CSNbbs
How about your bands? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: SunBeltbbs (/forum-317.html)
+---- Forum: Sun Belt Conference Talk (/forum-296.html)
+---- Thread: How about your bands? (/thread-1032027.html)

Pages: 1 2


How about your bands? - sdcritter - 08-26-2026 09:25 PM

Kinda having a discussion about our marching band over in the stAte forum. It's losing ground and my suggestion is to do away with a bunch of that game day programmed crap music and put that money into the band. So what do you like better? The PA system blasting or the kids playing in the band?


RE: How about your bands? - Usajags - 08-26-2026 09:47 PM

Give me the band, one of the things that make college gameday better than the NFL. Tradition is losing in college sports, and losing the band would just be another hit.


RE: How about your bands? - dawgonit - 08-26-2026 10:19 PM

(08-26-2026 09:47 PM)Usajags Wrote:  Give me the band, one of the things that make college gameday better than the NFL. Tradition is losing in college sports, and losing the band would just be another hit.

Agreed. College football games are also about the pageantry of it all, not just winning or losing. You want the spirit groups, the tailgating and the bands all on game day otherwise it just becomes NFL-lite.


RE: How about your bands? - chiefsfan - 08-26-2026 10:41 PM

This is what happens when everyone is bored before football season and someone starts a topic about how a SWAC school can charge more than we do for a football game.


RE: How about your bands? - We Are the Dukes of JMU - 08-26-2026 11:07 PM

So what's the question? JMU has one of the largest marching bands in the country. They're great and I want to keep them. Is there really debate around this?


RE: How about your bands? - WinstonTheWolf - 08-27-2026 12:59 AM

Can we not put the band budget toward NIL?


RE: How about your bands? - islandTROYtrojan - 08-27-2026 04:13 AM

I prefer a marching band to PA any day and any time. PA music is irritating especially when it plays when the band is playing too. Troy uses way too much PA music and some of it is absolutely dreadful.


RE: How about your bands? - GSUdpb - 08-27-2026 09:09 AM

Our marching band is the best thing we've ever put on a football field.


RE: How about your bands? - TTT - 08-27-2026 09:30 AM

Lol, relatively speaking, it doesn't cost nearly as much to play music over the loudspeakers as it does to have a marching band. There's a reason serious programs have a balance of marching band and house music throughout their games—you want to appeal to everyone in your fanbase. USM actually has a good mix of marching band and house music—hip-hop, rock, EDM, country, etc. A marching band can't realistically play every second of every empty space between game breaks, so you have to mix it up. Players get hyped to Travis Scott and YoungBoy, while boomers hate that stuff. Boomers might prefer Queen or Journey, but that isn't necessarily what's going to get the players and student section hyped during the game. You can't please everyone at all times so the best you can do is play a little bit of everything which is what most serious programs do.


RE: How about your bands? - HyperDuke - 08-27-2026 09:50 AM

(08-27-2026 09:09 AM)GSUdpb Wrote:  Our marching band is the best thing we've ever put on a football field.

Georgia State’s band is very very good. Confirmed. Adam Dalton is the real deal. Did great work at Marshall as well. He’s a JMU alum.


RE: How about your bands? - HyperDuke - 08-27-2026 09:52 AM

(08-27-2026 09:30 AM)TTT Wrote:  Lol, relatively speaking, it doesn't cost nearly as much to play music over the loudspeakers as it does to have a marching band. There's a reason serious programs have a balance of marching band and house music throughout their games—you want to appeal to everyone in your fanbase. USM actually has a good mix of marching band and house music—hip-hop, rock, EDM, country, etc. A marching band can't realistically play every second of every empty space between game breaks, so you have to mix it up. Players get hyped to Travis Scott and YoungBoy, while boomers hate that stuff. Boomers might prefer Queen or Journey, but that isn't necessarily what's going to get the players and student section hyped during the game. You can't please everyone at all times so the best you can do is play a little bit of everything which is what most serious programs do.

The best marching bands play all of those styles & genres. See: Jackson State U


RE: How about your bands? - Jag89 - 08-27-2026 10:14 AM

(08-26-2026 11:07 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  So what's the question? JMU has one of the largest marching bands in the country. They're great and I want to keep them. Is there really debate around this?

How many band members in JMU's band? South Alabama just finished the new Marching Band Complex and band size has grown from 250 to now over 300.

https://www.southalabama.edu/colleges/music/marchingband/


RE: How about your bands? - TTT - 08-27-2026 11:07 AM

(08-27-2026 09:52 AM)HyperDuke Wrote:  
(08-27-2026 09:30 AM)TTT Wrote:  Lol, relatively speaking, it doesn't cost nearly as much to play music over the loudspeakers as it does to have a marching band. There's a reason serious programs have a balance of marching band and house music throughout their games—you want to appeal to everyone in your fanbase. USM actually has a good mix of marching band and house music—hip-hop, rock, EDM, country, etc. A marching band can't realistically play every second of every empty space between game breaks, so you have to mix it up. Players get hyped to Travis Scott and YoungBoy, while boomers hate that stuff. Boomers might prefer Queen or Journey, but that isn't necessarily what's going to get the players and student section hyped during the game. You can't please everyone at all times so the best you can do is play a little bit of everything which is what most serious programs do.

The best marching bands play all of those styles & genres. See: Jackson State U

I've always thought Jackson State's band was a little overrated. People rave about them, but every time they've played in Hattiesburg, I've never been that impressed. They have a million members, so yeah, they're loud as h*ll, but I don't think they're all that precise. To me, JSU is more quantity than quality, with a lot of the appeal coming from playing current popular music that younger people are naturally going to gravitate toward. If we're talking specifically drumline stuff...Jackson State is awesome. But as a whole, just kinda eh. Loud, but eh.


RE: How about your bands? - boozeNammo - 08-27-2026 11:30 AM

(08-27-2026 10:14 AM)Jag89 Wrote:  
(08-26-2026 11:07 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  So what's the question? JMU has one of the largest marching bands in the country. They're great and I want to keep them. Is there really debate around this?

How many band members in JMU's band? South Alabama just finished the new Marching Band Complex and band size has grown from 250 to now over 300.

https://www.southalabama.edu/colleges/music/marchingband/

I believe, currently, 500+ active members. Does fluctuate a bit.


RE: How about your bands? - TrueBlueDrew - 08-27-2026 12:08 PM

Southern Pride Marching Band Alum here. A lot of people don’t realize, but the band was here first, well before someone blew air up a pig’s @$$ and kicked it around. It was one of the original student organizations on most college campuses and most of the musicians in the band went on to join the military after college. Thats how it became so intertwined with college sports from the very beginning thanks to the service academies and ROTC programs at the big state colleges.


RE: How about your bands? - OsageJ - 08-27-2026 01:22 PM

My 7th grade grandson plays football. He is pretty athletic and looks like he should be pretty good. He also wants to be in the band. So he is starting that too. Football and band work together if they have a student who wants to do both. I think its great. My oldest daughter was in her high school band. So I have some idea how much work they do even at the high school level.


RE: How about your bands? - stinkfist - 08-27-2026 04:08 PM

@cheekyFeller 03-lmfao03-drunk03-lmfao






RE: How about your bands? - Trojanbybirth - 08-29-2026 10:06 PM

Troy's band went woke and changed the fanfare. They suck now.


RE: How about your bands? - islandTROYtrojan - 08-30-2026 05:12 AM

Dropping a line from the song, Dixie, from the fanfare was an overdue necessity which was requested by students and was also a factor in Troy losing a potential deal for sponsorship rights of the stadium. Playing a song from 1859 which was designed for minstrel singers in blackface depicting a freed slave in the North longing for a return to the South was simply inappropriate. The song probably would have never become the unofficial anthem of the Confederacy had it not included the line, "In Dixieland I'll make my stand to live and die in Dixie". The University of Miami stopped playing it in 1968, Arkansas and ECU in 1969, Georgia in 1971, and Ole Miss in 2016. Young people today do not have the same level of generational transmission of a fondness for the Confederacy that their parents might have had since their parents' parents and grandparents were closer to the time of the Civil War and lived through the Civil Rights struggles and prejudices. It was past time for the fanfare to go.


RE: How about your bands? - TrojansOneandAll - 08-30-2026 06:43 AM

The fanfare doesn't have anything to do with why the band sucks.

The director creates a show by randomly selecting a different decade from the '60s to the present. Then they randomly select some top 40 from that decade. They break the monotony by occasionally doing a tribute show to a single artist.

Apart from starting and stopping at certain sections of the music, the drill has nothing to do with the music and does nothing to enhance it, they just move into random formations using the same baby step.

In short, the band plays to people who think it's good because they recognize the song, and even if they can't, the announcer will tell them - that's very important... now.