CSNbbs
11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: SunBeltbbs (/forum-317.html)
+---- Forum: Sun Belt Conference Talk (/forum-296.html)
+---- Thread: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility (/thread-1030283.html)



11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - CoachMaclid - 07-07-2026 07:35 AM

https://wvmetronews.com/2026/07/06/11-marshall-student-athletes-suing-ncaa-over-new-rule/

These athletes are players who graduated high school in 2022 and played four seasons and are now being denied a fifth season and are suing the NCAA over its new eligibility rule.

Probably a long shot case, but I guess you miss 100% of the shots you don't take.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - PetroCajun - 07-07-2026 09:57 AM

Oh for f—- sake. This **** needs to stop.

Five years to play four seasons. If they’ve played four already, time to move on. Graduate if you haven’t already and get a job.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - Dukes_Royals - 07-07-2026 10:25 AM

(07-07-2026 09:57 AM)PetroCajun Wrote:  Oh for f—- sake. This **** needs to stop.

Five years to play four seasons. If they’ve played four already, time to move on. Graduate if you haven’t already and get a job.

Except the NCAA just changed it to 5 in 5. Its not a retroactive rule, but I could see the courts overturning that portion.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - wsherdfan - 07-07-2026 12:59 PM

(07-07-2026 10:25 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(07-07-2026 09:57 AM)PetroCajun Wrote:  Oh for f—- sake. This **** needs to stop.

Five years to play four seasons. If they’ve played four already, time to move on. Graduate if you haven’t already and get a job.

Except the NCAA just changed it to 5 in 5. Its not a retroactive rule, but I could see the courts overturning that portion.

04-cheers


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - Luckyshot - 07-07-2026 03:33 PM

Our Baseball team wouldn't mind bringing back a few guys.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - Purplehazed - 07-07-2026 06:34 PM

I thought under the new portal and NIL, players have 15 yrs of eligibility at 15 schools


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - Usajags - 07-07-2026 08:11 PM

(07-07-2026 06:34 PM)Purplehazed Wrote:  I thought under the new portal and NIL, players have 15 yrs of eligibility at 15 schools

I think the rule actually reads, “Your 4 years of eligibility restarts with each school you transfer to as long as you are only there for one season”. It’s referred to as the TJ Finley Clause.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - OsageJ - 07-08-2026 08:14 AM

I wonder which college running back will get 19,000 rushing yards to pass Emmett Smith's NFL record.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - GreenBison - 07-08-2026 11:20 AM

(07-07-2026 06:34 PM)Purplehazed Wrote:  I thought under the new portal and NIL, players have 15 yrs of eligibility at 15 schools

I think it’s 15 Bowl Games to sit out even though there’s no way they are getting drafted. But you know it makes them look cool.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - Trojanbybirth - 07-08-2026 07:49 PM

The job market for former football players is not great. Usually they major in a low or no wage degree. They would rather get NIL and live on campus than work for ups. It's got to be hard going from getting all your needs met, a salary, and thousands of fans to no job and no prospects. One time I recognized a former FSU and NFL player working as a security guard at the Destin Hilton.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - HarborPointe - 07-08-2026 10:09 PM

Colleges have got to get some legal/anti-trust coverage before every manner of eligibility rule eventually gets sued away. We’re only a few steps away from, “Who are you to say I have to be enrolled in order to play here?”


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - CoachMaclid - 07-31-2026 08:17 PM

The "Class of 2022" has won its class action lawsuit and all athletes that were 4th year seniors last year have been ruled immediately eligible to play this season, and prohibits the NCAA from punishing schools that allow them to play this season!

Boogie Trotter is back for the 2026 SBC Champion Marshall Thundering Herd! Also, our 2026 WNIT champions WBB team (which had 3 seniors as part of a suit) looks to be a HUGE benefactor!


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - MUsince96 - 07-31-2026 08:27 PM

The judge opened the portal for 7 days. I really hope someone doesn't throw a bag at him.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - BubWV - 08-01-2026 01:21 AM




RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - wsherdfan - 08-01-2026 06:32 AM

Do any of the other 13 member schools have student athletes impacted by this?


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - chiefsfan - 08-03-2026 07:59 PM

Some clarifications here. The NCAA has gotten a ruling on top that they do not have to open the transfer portal and that the player must fit all other eligibility requirements (i.e. they have 5 years from their 19th birthday to play)

In other words, for a player to play, they have to play for the school they graduated from, and that school must have an available spot for them on the roster.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - jmu98 - 08-04-2026 04:39 AM

(08-03-2026 07:59 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  Some clarifications here. The NCAA has gotten a ruling on top that they do not have to open the transfer portal and that the player must fit all other eligibility requirements (i.e. they have 5 years from their 19th birthday to play)

In other words, for a player to play, they have to play for the school they graduated from, and that school must have an available spot for them on the roster.

I have heard conflicting information on this part. From some sources I have heard that if you in fact graduated you are free to transfer but if you did not actually graduate you must return to your prior school. Makes sense as if you have graduated they should not be able to hold you back but who knows.


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - bcp_jmu - 08-04-2026 08:55 AM

(08-01-2026 06:32 AM)wsherdfan Wrote:  Do any of the other 13 member schools have student athletes impacted by this?

Trent Hendrick ….DPOY so we have hope on this


RE: 11 Marshall athletes suing NCAA for extra year of eligibility - wsherdfan - 08-04-2026 09:03 AM

(08-04-2026 08:55 AM)bcp_jmu Wrote:  
(08-01-2026 06:32 AM)wsherdfan Wrote:  Do any of the other 13 member schools have student athletes impacted by this?

Trent Hendrick ….DPOY so we have hope on this

04-cheers