CSNbbs
My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) (/thread-1030223.html)



My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - celldweller7 - 07-04-2026 11:25 AM

8 4 team regions

West
- California
- Oregon State
- Stanford
- Washington State

Mountain
- Colorado
- BYU
- Utah
- Boise State

Southwest
- Arizona
- Arizona State
- San Diego State
- Texas Tech

Plains
- TCU
- Kansas
- Kansas State
- Oklahoma State

Midlands
- Iowa State
- Louisville
- Cincinnati
- SMU

East
- NC State
- Virginia Tech
- West Virginia
- Wake Forest

South
- Georgia Tech
- UCF
- Houston
- Baylor

Northeast
- Boston College
- Pittsburgh
- Syracuse
- UConn

Football schedule
3 division games / 1 game from each division = 10 conference games

Men's & Women's Basketball schedules
6 division games (h/a) and 14 games from other division (2 from each division, h/a) = 20 conference games

Other sports focus on division and a sister division to decrease travel costs. The top 2 from each division advance to the Conference tournament. The number of outside sister division games is to be determined by each sport's usual number of conference games.

Required sports
Football
Men's & Women's Basketball
Baseball
Softball
Men's Wrestling
Men's & Women's Cross Country
Men's & Women's Track & Field
Men's & Women's Golf
Men's & Women's Tennis
Men's & Women's Soccer
Women's Volleyball
Women's Rowing


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - LaBradfordsTWill - 07-04-2026 11:49 AM

I like it. Anything to avoid the SEC, B1G, or a Tobacco Road dominated ACC. Don't care about the money or the politics, just want a stable home with peer universities and traditional rivals.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - Lurker Above - 07-04-2026 11:51 AM

(07-04-2026 11:25 AM)celldweller7 Wrote:  8 4 team regions

West
- California
- Oregon State
- Stanford
- Washington State

Mountain
- Colorado
- BYU
- Utah
- Boise State

Southwest
- Arizona
- Arizona State
- San Diego State
- Texas Tech

Plains
- TCU
- Kansas
- Kansas State
- Oklahoma State

Midlands
- Iowa State
- Louisville
- Cincinnati
- SMU

East
- NC State
- Virginia Tech
- West Virginia
- Wake Forest

South
- Georgia Tech
- UCF
- Houston
- Baylor

Northeast
- Boston College
- Pittsburgh
- Syracuse
- UConn

Football schedule
3 division games / 1 game from each division = 10 conference games

Men's & Women's Basketball schedules
6 division games (h/a) and 14 games from other division (2 from each division, h/a) = 20 conference games

Other sports focus on division and a sister division to decrease travel costs. The top 2 from each division advance to the Conference tournament. The number of outside sister division games is to be determined by each sport's usual number of conference games.

Required sports
Football
Men's & Women's Basketball
Baseball
Softball
Men's Wrestling
Men's & Women's Cross Country
Men's & Women's Track & Field
Men's & Women's Golf
Men's & Women's Tennis
Men's & Women's Soccer
Women's Volleyball
Women's Rowing

Switch Iowa State and TCU, and if these are the teams that get left out of the P2 then that is not bad.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - tf8693 - 07-06-2026 05:35 PM

(07-04-2026 11:25 AM)celldweller7 Wrote:  8 4 team regions

West
- California
- Oregon State
- Stanford
- Washington State

Mountain
- Colorado
- BYU
- Utah
- Boise State

Southwest
- Arizona
- Arizona State
- San Diego State
- Texas Tech

Plains
- TCU
- Kansas
- Kansas State
- Oklahoma State

Midlands
- Iowa State
- Louisville
- Cincinnati
- SMU

East
- NC State
- Virginia Tech
- West Virginia
- Wake Forest

South
- Georgia Tech
- UCF
- Houston
- Baylor

Northeast
- Boston College
- Pittsburgh
- Syracuse
- UConn

Football schedule
3 division games / 1 game from each division = 10 conference games

Men's & Women's Basketball schedules
6 division games (h/a) and 14 games from other division (2 from each division, h/a) = 20 conference games

Other sports focus on division and a sister division to decrease travel costs. The top 2 from each division advance to the Conference tournament. The number of outside sister division games is to be determined by each sport's usual number of conference games.

Required sports
Football
Men's & Women's Basketball
Baseball
Softball
Men's Wrestling
Men's & Women's Cross Country
Men's & Women's Track & Field
Men's & Women's Golf
Men's & Women's Tennis
Men's & Women's Soccer
Women's Volleyball
Women's Rowing

Leaving aside the obvious issue of the loss of a NCAAT AQ bid, the fact that you split the Texas schools among four divisions all but guarantees this has zero chance of passing. And if *required sports* means that every member must sponsor the sport, Colorado, SMU and Syracuse (at a minimum, there may be others) don't field baseball teams.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - Fighting Muskie - 07-06-2026 06:05 PM

Things don’t necessarily have to be so neat and tidy, and by extension, yield non-sensical divisions.

Take the schools left over from the merger under one umbrella.

Let them form pods of varying sizes based on geography and old rivalries.

Fill out the rest of the rotating schedule from among the consortium.


You might have a 6 team pod of Cal, Stanford, Utah, BYU, Arizona, & Arizona State while the Texas pod is only 5 teams: SMU, Baylor, TCU, Texas Tech, and Houston.

The plains pod might happen to also be 5–Colorado, Okla St, K St, Kansas, Iowa St while your East pod ends up at 6: BC, Cuse, Pitt, WVU, Cincinnati, & Louisville. (Or maybe even 7 or 8 if you toss in a UCF and/or USF)

Naturally, there’s a Tobacco Road pod that has WF, Duke, and some combination that includes a few of UVA/VT/NC St/GT.

Not everything has to fit in a perfect cookie cutter.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - goofus - 07-06-2026 06:08 PM

(07-04-2026 11:25 AM)celldweller7 Wrote:  8 4 team regions

West
- California
- Oregon State
- Stanford
- Washington State

Mountain
- Colorado
- BYU
- Utah
- Boise State

Southwest
- Arizona
- Arizona State
- San Diego State
- Texas Tech

Plains
- TCU
- Kansas
- Kansas State
- Oklahoma State

Midlands
- Iowa State
- Louisville
- Cincinnati
- SMU

East
- NC State
- Virginia Tech
- West Virginia
- Wake Forest

South
- Georgia Tech
- UCF
- Houston
- Baylor

Northeast
- Boston College
- Pittsburgh
- Syracuse
- UConn

Football schedule
3 division games / 1 game from each division = 10 conference games

No need to add any teams. Its big enough without adding anybody.

I give you the Big 27(28)

West Division-6
Cal, Stan, Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col

Central-5
BYU, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St

South-5
TT, TCU, SMU, Bay, Hou

East-6
Lou, Cincy, WV, Pitt, Cuse, BC

Atlantic-5
GT, Wake, NCSU, VT, UCF

Non-football
ND


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - goofus - 07-07-2026 02:53 PM

I got a new idea for power conference restructuring

UNC, VA, ND, Miami, GT --> Big Ten
Cal, Stan, USC, UCLA, Wash, Ore, Neb, Lou ---> Big 12
USF, UCF, Cincy, WV, UConn, Hou ---> ACC
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT ---> SEC

Big 12 (20)
USC, UCLA, Ore, Wash, Cal, Stan,
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, BYU, Col,
Neb, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St,
TT, TCU, Bay, Lou

Big Ten (18)
UNC, Va, Miami, GT, ND,
Rut, MD, Penn St,
Ohio St, Mich, Mich St,
Ind, Pur, ILL, NW,
Wisc, Minn, Iowa

SEC (20)
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT,
Ga, Flor, S. Car, Tenn, Ky, Vandy,
Bama, Aub, Ole Miss, Miss St, LSU
Ok, Tex, Tex A&M, Mizzou, Ark

ACC (12)
Cuse, Pitt, BC, UConn,
Wake, Duke, SMU,
WV, Cincy, Hou, UCF, USF


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - BirdHawkEagle - 07-07-2026 04:42 PM

If the Protect College Sports Act passes, there will be no Power 2 expansion, nor will there be any Group conference call ups moving up.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - ken d - 07-08-2026 08:56 AM

The OP essentially kills the PAC. To leave every conference viable (at least 8 members) and maintain or promote rivalries, this is my alternative.

West: Arizona St, Arizona, Cal, Stanford
Mountain: Utah, BYU, Air Force, Colorado
Plains: Kansas St, Iowa St, Oklahoma St, Kansas
Lone Star: Baylor, UTSA, Houston, Texas Tech

Gulf: UCF, Tulane, Memphis, USF
Metro: TCU, Louisville, SMU, Cincinnati
Southeast: NC State, Wake Forest, Georgia Tech, Virginia Tech
Northeast: Pitt, West Virginia, Syracuse, Boston College

Of these 32 teams, 9 would have an annual OOC rivalry game:

Cal - UCLA
Stanford - USC
Iowa St - Iowa
Louisville - Kentucky
Kansas - Missouri
NC State - UNC*
Georgia Tech - Georgia
Virginia Tech - Virginia
Pitt - Penn State

* UNC would have 2 OOC rivals: Duke and NC State

This assumes that FSU, Clemson, UNC, and Virginia go to the SEC and Miami and Duke join the B1G,


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - BirdHawkEagle - 07-08-2026 10:01 AM

(07-07-2026 02:53 PM)goofus Wrote:  I got a new idea for power conference restructuring

UNC, VA, ND, Miami, GT --> Big Ten
Cal, Stan, USC, UCLA, Wash, Ore, Neb, Lou ---> Big 12
USF, UCF, Cincy, WV, UConn, Hou ---> ACC
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT ---> SEC

Big 12 (20)
USC, UCLA, Ore, Wash, Cal, Stan,
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, BYU, Col,
Neb, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St,
TT, TCU, Bay, Lou

Big Ten (18)
UNC, Va, Miami, GT, ND,
Rut, MD, Penn St,
Ohio St, Mich, Mich St,
Ind, Pur, ILL, NW,
Wisc, Minn, Iowa

SEC (20)
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT,
Ga, Flor, S. Car, Tenn, Ky, Vandy,
Bama, Aub, Ole Miss, Miss St, LSU
Ok, Tex, Tex A&M, Mizzou, Ark

ACC (12)
Cuse, Pitt, BC, UConn,
Wake, Duke, SMU,
WV, Cincy, Hou, UCF, USF

Interesting.

Here's mine:

ACC

Boston College
Clemson
Duke
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Louisville
Maryland
Miami (FL)
NC State
North Carolina
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
Virginia
Virginia Tech
Wake Forest

Big Ten

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oregon
Penn State
Purdue
Stanford
UCLA
USC
Washington
Wisconsin

Big XII

Baylor
BYU
Colorado
Cincinnati
Houston
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Nebraska
Oklahoma State
SMU
TCU
Texas Tech
UCF
Utah
West Virginia

SEC

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
LSU
Mississippi State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Ole Miss
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
Texas A&M
Vanderbilt


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - goofus - 07-08-2026 12:05 PM

(07-08-2026 10:01 AM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  
(07-07-2026 02:53 PM)goofus Wrote:  I got a new idea for power conference restructuring

UNC, VA, ND, Miami, GT --> Big Ten
Cal, Stan, USC, UCLA, Wash, Ore, Neb, Lou ---> Big 12
USF, UCF, Cincy, WV, UConn, Hou ---> ACC
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT ---> SEC

Big 12 (20)
USC, UCLA, Ore, Wash, Cal, Stan,
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, BYU, Col,
Neb, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St,
TT, TCU, Bay, Lou

Big Ten (18)
UNC, Va, Miami, GT, ND,
Rut, MD, Penn St,
Ohio St, Mich, Mich St,
Ind, Pur, ILL, NW,
Wisc, Minn, Iowa

SEC (20)
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT,
Ga, Flor, S. Car, Tenn, Ky, Vandy,
Bama, Aub, Ole Miss, Miss St, LSU
Ok, Tex, Tex A&M, Mizzou, Ark

ACC (12)
Cuse, Pitt, BC, UConn,
Wake, Duke, SMU,
WV, Cincy, Hou, UCF, USF

Interesting.

Here's mine:

ACC

Boston College
Clemson
Duke
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Louisville
Maryland
Miami (FL)
NC State
North Carolina
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
Virginia
Virginia Tech
Wake Forest

Big Ten

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oregon
Penn State
Purdue
Stanford
UCLA
USC
Washington
Wisconsin

Big XII

Baylor
BYU
Colorado
Cincinnati
Houston
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Nebraska
Oklahoma State
SMU
TCU
Texas Tech
UCF
Utah
West Virginia

SEC

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
LSU
Mississippi State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Ole Miss
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
Texas A&M
Vanderbilt

Interesting. I can work with that. I would tweak it to send all the 4 corners schools and cal/stan to the Big Ten. You can still send Neb to Big 12 and Rut/MD to the ACC.

But I think you would still need to upgrade Flor St, Clem , UNC and VA to the SEC.
Then add ND and Miami to the Big Ten.
Then add USF and UConn to the ACC.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - BirdHawkEagle - 07-08-2026 12:29 PM

(07-08-2026 12:05 PM)goofus Wrote:  
(07-08-2026 10:01 AM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  
(07-07-2026 02:53 PM)goofus Wrote:  I got a new idea for power conference restructuring

UNC, VA, ND, Miami, GT --> Big Ten
Cal, Stan, USC, UCLA, Wash, Ore, Neb, Lou ---> Big 12
USF, UCF, Cincy, WV, UConn, Hou ---> ACC
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT ---> SEC

Big 12 (20)
USC, UCLA, Ore, Wash, Cal, Stan,
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, BYU, Col,
Neb, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St,
TT, TCU, Bay, Lou

Big Ten (18)
UNC, Va, Miami, GT, ND,
Rut, MD, Penn St,
Ohio St, Mich, Mich St,
Ind, Pur, ILL, NW,
Wisc, Minn, Iowa

SEC (20)
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT,
Ga, Flor, S. Car, Tenn, Ky, Vandy,
Bama, Aub, Ole Miss, Miss St, LSU
Ok, Tex, Tex A&M, Mizzou, Ark

ACC (12)
Cuse, Pitt, BC, UConn,
Wake, Duke, SMU,
WV, Cincy, Hou, UCF, USF

Interesting.

Here's mine:

ACC

Boston College
Clemson
Duke
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Louisville
Maryland
Miami (FL)
NC State
North Carolina
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
Virginia
Virginia Tech
Wake Forest

Big Ten

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oregon
Penn State
Purdue
Stanford
UCLA
USC
Washington
Wisconsin

Big XII

Baylor
BYU
Colorado
Cincinnati
Houston
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Nebraska
Oklahoma State
SMU
TCU
Texas Tech
UCF
Utah
West Virginia

SEC

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
LSU
Mississippi State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Ole Miss
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
Texas A&M
Vanderbilt

Interesting. I can work with that. I would tweak it to send all the 4 corners schools and cal/stan to the Big Ten. You can still send Neb to Big 12 and Rut/MD to the ACC.

But I think you would still need to upgrade Flor St, Clem , UNC and VA to the SEC.
Then add ND and Miami to the Big Ten.
Then add USF and UConn to the ACC.

I see your point.

I was trying to keep most of the Power 4 conferences at 16 teams.

I agree that Colorado and Kansas should be in the Big Ten, but I didn't want to expand the conference past 20 teams.


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - realignmentreport9239 - 07-08-2026 06:47 PM

(07-08-2026 10:01 AM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  [quote='goofus' pid='20696684' dateline='1783453991']
I got a new idea for power conference restructuring

UNC, VA, ND, Miami, GT --> Big Ten
Cal, Stan, USC, UCLA, Wash, Ore, Neb, Lou ---> Big 12
USF, UCF, Cincy, WV, UConn, Hou ---> ACC
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT ---> SEC

Big 12 (20)
USC, UCLA, Ore, Wash, Cal, Stan,
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, BYU, Col,
Neb, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St,
TT, TCU, Bay, Lou

Big Ten (18)
UNC, Va, Miami, GT, ND,
Rut, MD, Penn St,
Ohio St, Mich, Mich St,
Ind, Pur, ILL, NW,
Wisc, Minn, Iowa

SEC (20)
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT,
Ga, Flor, S. Car, Tenn, Ky, Vandy,
Bama, Aub, Ole Miss, Miss St, LSU
Ok, Tex, Tex A&M, Mizzou, Ark

ACC (12)
Cuse, Pitt, BC, UConn,
Wake, Duke, SMU,
WV, Cincy, Hou, UCF, USF

Interesting.

Here's mine:

ACC

Boston College
Clemson
Duke
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Louisville
Maryland
Miami (FL)
NC State
North Carolina
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
Virginia
Virginia Tech
Wake Forest

Big Ten

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oregon
Penn State
Purdue
Stanford
UCLA
USC
Washington
Wisconsin

Big XII

Baylor
BYU
Colorado
Cincinnati
Houston
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Nebraska
Oklahoma State
SMU
TCU
Texas Tech
UCF
Utah
West Virginia

SEC

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
LSU
Mississippi State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Ole Miss
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
Texas A&M
Vanderbilt
[/quote
The main question is has Cal and Stanford gotten over their aversion to being part of the Big 12?


RE: My Ridiculous Proposal for a Post-P2 Expansion ACC-Big 12 Merger (and others too) - BirdHawkEagle - 07-08-2026 06:49 PM

(07-08-2026 06:47 PM)realignmentreport9239 Wrote:  
(07-08-2026 10:01 AM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  [quote='goofus' pid='20696684' dateline='1783453991']
I got a new idea for power conference restructuring

UNC, VA, ND, Miami, GT --> Big Ten
Cal, Stan, USC, UCLA, Wash, Ore, Neb, Lou ---> Big 12
USF, UCF, Cincy, WV, UConn, Hou ---> ACC
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT ---> SEC

Big 12 (20)
USC, UCLA, Ore, Wash, Cal, Stan,
Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, BYU, Col,
Neb, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St, Ok St,
TT, TCU, Bay, Lou

Big Ten (18)
UNC, Va, Miami, GT, ND,
Rut, MD, Penn St,
Ohio St, Mich, Mich St,
Ind, Pur, ILL, NW,
Wisc, Minn, Iowa

SEC (20)
Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT,
Ga, Flor, S. Car, Tenn, Ky, Vandy,
Bama, Aub, Ole Miss, Miss St, LSU
Ok, Tex, Tex A&M, Mizzou, Ark

ACC (12)
Cuse, Pitt, BC, UConn,
Wake, Duke, SMU,
WV, Cincy, Hou, UCF, USF

Interesting.

Here's mine:

ACC

Boston College
Clemson
Duke
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Louisville
Maryland
Miami (FL)
NC State
North Carolina
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Syracuse
Virginia
Virginia Tech
Wake Forest

Big Ten

Arizona
Arizona State
California
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oregon
Penn State
Purdue
Stanford
UCLA
USC
Washington
Wisconsin

Big XII

Baylor
BYU
Colorado
Cincinnati
Houston
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Nebraska
Oklahoma State
SMU
TCU
Texas Tech
UCF
Utah
West Virginia

SEC

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
LSU
Mississippi State
Missouri
Oklahoma
Ole Miss
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
Texas A&M
Vanderbilt
[/quote
The main question is has Cal and Stanford gotten over their aversion to being part of the Big 12?

I doubt they ever will. California and Stanford are Ivy League minded schools that look down upon middle America state schools.