CSNbbs
Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Are big OOC games a dying breed? (/thread-1030115.html)



Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Fighting Muskie - 06-30-2026 01:33 PM

By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - GoBuckeyes1047 - 06-30-2026 01:43 PM

(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue

If we keep increasing the number of conference games without increasing the total number of regular season games, I think this trend does continue unfortunately. While I agree conferences should start looking at playing 10 conference games, I think there needs to be 13 regular season games along with a mandate for conferences to play 12 games against Power conference opponents (includes ND). It'd also ensure teams play 7 home games.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - BePcr07 - 06-30-2026 01:46 PM

When we have a formalized split, all OOC will be big, or - at least - just power schools.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Just Joe - 06-30-2026 02:11 PM

(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue

Not necessarily. The nonconference schedules were mostly set before Texas/OU and the Pac 12 implosion and haven't reset to a P2 dynamic. Maybe they won't as Big 12/ACC schools still present attractive or at least acceptable non conference opponents.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - CliftonAve - 07-01-2026 04:52 AM

Unless you are in a protected OOC series (ie GT v UGA, UK v Louisville. Etc) these type of match ups are virtually impossible to get. There are only so many slots on the schedule since teams will also schedule a formula of 1 P4+1G5+1FCS.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Hokie Mark - 07-01-2026 08:20 AM

B1G OOC games certainly seem to be.

The last P4 OOC that Indiana played during the regular season was a neutral site LOSS to Louisville in 2023. Their next P4 OOC will be the series with Notre Dame in 2030-31.

Penn State beat WVU in 2024, then no P4 OOC in 2025 or 2026 (though they do have a series with Syracuse in 2027-28).

If marquee P4 non-conference match-ups come to an end, you can lay the blame at the feet of the Big Ten - the only power conference that doesn't require teams to play a P4 OOC game.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Wahoowa84 - 07-01-2026 10:56 AM

(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue


The ACC is doing its best to keep big OOC games in their schedules. Seventeen ACC teams are playing 23 P4 OOC games this year...mainly against SEC teams and ND.

In addition, all programs in the ACC and SEC are playing a minimum of 10 games versus P4 opponents (guaranteeing at least one P4 OOC opponent).

B12 programs have multiple games versus each of Oregon State and Washington State...ex-P5 programs that were left without club membership in the last realignment dance. It'll be interesting to see whether the B12 formally transitions to a stricter interpretation of one P4 opponent each season.

It's the Big Ten that seems to be using OOC scheduling as leverage in CFP discussions. Easier OOC scheduling helps a few CFP contenders (e.g., Indiana and PSU). Enforcing one OOC P4 game may also be a chip in Petitti's negotiations with Sankey on a larger CFP format.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - USF_Bullsharks - 07-02-2026 08:47 AM

I'd be interested in what the potential $ is in OOC rivalry games vs in-conference. For instance, Oklahoma vs Oklahoma St. Would an annual game as an OOC feature/spotlight make more than if the SEC were to bring OKSt in as a member of the SEC? I think OOC rivalry games can be huge, especially on rivalry weekend. Mizzou/Kansas? UNC/NCSt if they were to split? FSU/Miami if they split? You'd have to guess there would be a premium on viewership for conference vs conference games.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Scoochpooch1 - 07-02-2026 10:36 AM

(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue

Hopefully with the exception of rivalry games since these games are pointless. There arent enough matchups either way to test strength. I can give you the strength each year:
1) SEC
2) B10
T3) ACC/B12; B12 may have the better teams but we know they will always lose when it matters. ACC at least wins often - Miami, Clemson, etc.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Fighting Muskie - 07-02-2026 10:36 AM

I did a deeper dive on this:

P2/ND vs P2/ND: 6
M2 vs M2: 5
P2/ND vs M2: 29

Big 10 plays: SEC 3, ND 3, ACC 5, Big 12 3
SEC plays: Big 10 3, ND 0, ACC 9 Big 12 4
ND plays: Big 10 3, SEC, 0, ACC 6, Big 12 1

ACC plays: Big 10 5, SEC 9, ND 6, Big 12 5
Big 12 plays: Big 10 3, SEC 3, ND 1, ACC 5

while it looks like there’s a lot of ACC-SEC interaction, only 5 ACC schools face SEC opponents: L’ville, Clemson, GT, Florida St, and NC St


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Scoochpooch1 - 07-02-2026 10:37 AM

(06-30-2026 01:46 PM)BePcr07 Wrote:  When we have a formalized split, all OOC will be big, or - at least - just power schools.

Thats the hope. They can then format it in an NFL style manner.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - Scoochpooch1 - 07-02-2026 10:40 AM

(06-30-2026 01:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue

If we keep increasing the number of conference games without increasing the total number of regular season games, I think this trend does continue unfortunately. While I agree conferences should start looking at playing 10 conference games, I think there needs to be 13 regular season games along with a mandate for conferences to play 12 games against Power conference opponents (includes ND). It'd also ensure teams play 7 home games.

Theres room for 14 games on the schedule. All G5 and FCS games should be banned with 10 conference games minimum. Thats leaves 4 Power games - Rivalry, old rivalry, etc.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - XOVERX - 07-04-2026 10:47 AM

“Big” OOC games will thrive in a 24-school playoff structure.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - 46566 - 07-04-2026 12:29 PM

For football yes. There's no incentive to schedule hard in non conference. The biggest decision is 3 G6 games I'd have 2 G6 and a FCS team on the schedule. The 3 easy games (assuming 9 game conference schedule) just means you need 3 wins in conference for a bowl game. For basketball at least early season tournaments have quality opponents. In basketball either a tournament or 1 neutral site game is enough.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - goodknightfl - 07-05-2026 07:02 AM

(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue

SOS matters biggley in playoffs. plus, bigglier games = bigger money. yes, the trend continurs.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - mikeinsec127 - 07-06-2026 07:42 PM

(06-30-2026 01:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  By my count, this season there are only 6 P2/ND vs P2/ND games. There are 5 M2 vs M2 match ups. There’s 28 P2/ND vs M2 games.

Here’s the breakdown:

Big 10: P2/ND 6 M2 8
SEC: P2/ND 3 M2 13
ND: P2 3 M2 7

ACC: P2/ND 18 M2 5
Big 12: P2/ND 7 M2 5

With so few data points between conferences, it’s going to be difficult to adequately compare relative strengths of teams.

I have to wonder if this trend is going to continue

The twelve game season was sold to the fans on the basis that the extra game would allow for more big matchup OOC games. Instead most P/M schools began to actively avoid such games. So we got charged premium prices for extra bodybag games.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - schmolik - 07-07-2026 05:10 AM

It will depend on if the CFP is expanded and they will also see if the CFP gives the benefit of the doubt to a school like a 2025 Texas who loses a big OOC game and still gets in.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - quo vadis - 07-07-2026 06:11 AM

More conference games means a squeeze on big OOC games.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - ccbfan - 07-07-2026 04:01 PM

(07-04-2026 12:29 PM)46566 Wrote:  For football yes. There's no incentive to schedule hard in non conference. The biggest decision is 3 G6 games I'd have 2 G6 and a FCS team on the schedule. The 3 easy games (assuming 9 game conference schedule) just means you need 3 wins in conference for a bowl game. For basketball at least early season tournaments have quality opponents. In basketball either a tournament or 1 neutral site game is enough.

The main difference is that the NCAA tournament rewards hard OOC. Either through the bubble or high seeds. Uconn and Duke schedules elite OOC because their conferences are weaker than the other P5 ones.

CFB only cares about record if you're P2+ND. A win is a win regardless if its Texas or Texas school of the blind. A loss is a loss regardless if its Ohio State or Ohio school of the blind. They all mean exactly the same thing to the committee.


RE: Are big OOC games a dying breed? - BirdHawkEagle - 07-07-2026 04:02 PM

Unless the regular season is expanded to 13 games to accommodate more conference games, especially at the Power 4 level, they will be a thing of the past.