![]() |
|
Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities (/thread-1029748.html) |
Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - Garden_KC - 06-19-2026 05:55 PM I like the idea of a 5 star ranking for public universities based around the AAU/Carnegie classifications. Some exception given to endowment size but not the full research requirement. Five Star 1a. AAU Membership 1b. Endowment 2.25 billion+ Four Star 1a. Carnegie R1 1b. Enowment 750 million+ Three Star 1a. Carnegie R2 1b. Endowment 250 million+ Two Star 1. Anything below both R2 and 250 mill. Are there any 2 star publics playing in FBS? CUSA: Jacksonville St. SBC: Coastal Carolina, Troy, Louisana Monroe
RE: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - JxGx78 - 06-19-2026 09:15 PM A rough break down by conference. I used GenAI but the AAU/Carnegie ratings were pulled directly from an excel file and appear to be right. The endowment numbers are squishier. I asked chatGPT to pull from wikipedia. I've spotted checked and they appear reasonable. But, if I'm wrong let me know and I'll edit it. Also, sorry for the formatting. AMERICAN CONFERENCE 5 Stars Rice * AAU, R1 * Endowment: $8.5B Tulane * AAU, R1 * Endowment: $2.47B South Florida * AAU, R1 * Endowment: $890M 4 Stars UAB * R1 * Endowment: $710M Charlotte * R1 * Endowment: $440M East Carolina * R1 * Endowment: $310M Florida Atlantic * R1 * Endowment: $280M Memphis * R1 * Endowment: $250M North Texas * R1 * Endowment: $320M Temple * R1 * Endowment: $1.05B UTSA * R1 * Endowment: $1.21B Tulsa * R2 * Endowment: $1.34B 3 Stars Wichita State * R2 * Endowment: $360M Army * Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $450M Navy * Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $550M AC TOTALS * 5 Stars: 3 * 4 Stars: 9 * 3 Stars: 3 * 2 Stars: 0 ⸻ PAC-12 4 Stars Oregon State * R1 * Endowment: $1.01B Washington State * R1 * Endowment: $1.13B Colorado State * R1 * Endowment: $590M San Diego State * R1 * Endowment: $500M Utah State * R1 * Endowment: $510M 3 Stars Boise State * R2 * Endowment: $200M Fresno State * R2 * Endowment: $230M Texas State * R2 * Endowment: $410M Gonzaga * R2 * Endowment: $400M PAC-12 TOTALS * 5 Stars: 0 * 4 Stars: 5 * 3 Stars: 4 * 2 Stars: 0 ⸻ MOUNTAIN WEST 5 Stars UC Davis * AAU, R1 * Endowment: $2.3B 4 Stars Hawaii * R1 * Endowment: $400M Nevada * R1 * Endowment: $440M New Mexico * R1 * Endowment: $570M UNLV * R1 * Endowment: $370M UTEP * R1 * Endowment: $240M Wyoming * R1 * Endowment: $720M North Dakota State * R1 * Endowment: $330M 3 Stars San Jose State * R2 * Endowment: $190M Northern Illinois * R2 * Endowment: $100M 2 Stars Air Force * Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $100M Grand Canyon * No Carnegie research classification MWC TOTALS * 5 Stars: 1 * 4 Stars: 7 * 3 Stars: 2 * 2 Stars: 2 SUN BELT 4 Stars Georgia State * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $300M Louisiana * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $230M Old Dominion * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $310M Southern Miss * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $160M South Alabama * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $770M 3 Stars Appalachian State * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $200M Arkansas State * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $100M Georgia Southern * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $100M James Madison * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $160M Louisiana Tech * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $120M Marshall * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $220M 2 Stars Coastal Carolina * Carnegie: Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $60M Troy * Carnegie: Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $190M ULM * Carnegie: Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $70M Sun Belt Total * 5 Stars: 0 * 4 Stars: 5 * 3 Stars: 6 * 2 Stars: 3 CONFERENCE USA 4 Stars Delaware * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $2.06B FIU * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $280M New Mexico State * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $320M Liberty * Carnegie: No research designation * Endowment: $2.00B 3 Stars Kennesaw State * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $130M Middle Tennessee * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $130M Sam Houston * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $160M 2 Stars Western Kentucky * Carnegie: Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $210M Jacksonville State * Carnegie: No research designation * Endowment: $50M Missouri State * Carnegie: Research Colleges & Universities * Endowment: $190M CUSA Total * 5 Stars: 0 * 4 Stars: 4 * 3 Stars: 3 * 2 Stars: 3 MAC 5 Stars Buffalo * Carnegie: R1 / AAU * Endowment: $1.17B 4 Stars UMass * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $1.80B Kent State * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $180M Ohio * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $700M Toledo * Carnegie: R1 * Endowment: $520M Miami Ohio * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $1.09B 3 Stars Akron * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $320M Ball State * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $350M Bowling Green * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $160M Central Michigan * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $240M Eastern Michigan * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $90M Northern Illinois * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $100M Western Michigan * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $550M Sacramento State * Carnegie: R2 * Endowment: $90M 2 Stars None. MAC Total * 5 Stars: 1 * 4 Stars: 5 * 3 Stars: 8 * 2 Stars: 0 RE: Categorizing Public Universities - Gitanole - 06-19-2026 09:41 PM Accreditation bodies have this covered, actually. Anyone can create lists of schools that wants to, of course, sorting them by any criteria desired, and publish the lists. Editors of the US News lists approach the task as a matter of consumer information. ___ RE: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - SFLFB - 06-20-2026 10:55 AM I think USF's endowment net position will be over $1B when the next financial statements are released. Over the last two years we have grown our endowment almost $180MM - as long as the market doesn't tank over the next ten days, I think we're in a good spot to add that next comma. $890MM was 2024, 6/30 2025 it improved to $977MM. RE: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - Garden_KC - 06-20-2026 01:14 PM I would exclude all private schools from this. For one endowments relative to enrollments are much higher. AFA/NAVY/ARMY are elite schools that don't play by the standard rules. Comparing the publics of the AAC, MAC & SBC AAC 5 Stars (1): USF 4 Stars (8): UAB, Charlotte, ECU, FAU, Memphis, North Texas, Temple, UTSA 3 Stars (1): Wichita St. MAC 5 Stars (1): Buffalo 4 Stars (6): UMass, Ohio, Miami, Kent St, WMU, Toledo 3 Stars (6): CMU, BGSU, EMU, Ball St, Akron, Sac St. SBC 5 Stars (0): 4 Stars (4): Georgia St, Louisiana, So. Miss, Old Dominion 3 Stars (6): USA, Appalachian, Ark St, JMU, LaTech, Marshall 2 Stars (3): Coastal, Troy, ULM This has the AAC a little higher in research than the MAC. SBC has low 4, 3 and 2 stars for the most part IMO. RE: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - LatahCounty - 06-20-2026 02:41 PM (06-19-2026 09:41 PM)Gitanole Wrote: Accreditation bodies have this covered, actually. Or ARWU. Or Forbes. Or the Wall Street Journal. Or the Manhattan Institute. Or Princeton Review. Or QS. Or College Raptor. Or Washington Monthly. Or etc. But it's possible the world is crying out for yet another ranking system, this one developed by some guys on a college sports message board. It's got stars, which are irresistible. Although I prefer the Siskel & Ebert thumbs up/thumbs down ratings, so I'll be watching for a simpler method. RE: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - Gitanole - 06-21-2026 07:57 PM (06-20-2026 02:41 PM)LatahCounty Wrote:(06-19-2026 09:41 PM)Gitanole Wrote: Accreditation bodies have this covered, actually. The great thing about the thumb system is you can get so much nuance if you use both hands. Sure, you can show two thumbs up or two thumbs down and everybody gets the message. But maybe not! Maybe you show one thumb up and one thumb down, or one thumb down and one thumb up. Now you’re doing something more thought provoking, reflecting academic life in its rich complexity. Like, maybe the right thumb can be arts and the left thumb can be sciences. Or maybe the left thumb can be education and the right thumb can be research—or the right thumb can be grad school and the left thumb can be undergrad. The possibilities are endless. RE: Creating a More Objective Way to Categorize Public Universities - Garden_KC - 06-23-2026 12:13 AM (06-20-2026 10:55 AM)SFLFB Wrote: I think USF's endowment net position will be over $1B when the next financial statements are released. Over the last two years we have grown our endowment almost $180MM - as long as the market doesn't tank over the next ten days, I think we're in a good spot to add that next comma. $890MM was 2024, 6/30 2025 it improved to $977MM. Going over 1 Billion is sweet. Especially after tapping $250 million from endowment on a new medical/engineering campus. Quote:The Board also received an update from Vice President for University Advancement Greg Simmons, reporting that OHIO has secured $41.5 million in gifts and grants this fiscal year and highlighted how the University’s endowment exceeded $1 billion for the first time as of April 30. I think the number for this year is about 1.2 bil narrowly defined. Including working capital partnerships that number is closer to 1.8 billion. Also due for a 10% raise next year from the state due to metrics (at the expense of the other publics). |