CSNbbs
MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN (/thread-1029722.html)

Pages: 1 2


MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - bryanw1995 - 06-18-2026 06:29 PM

https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - SoCalBobcat78 - 06-18-2026 08:16 PM

(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Glenn360 - 06-18-2026 08:29 PM

I don't see the MLBPA agreeing to this without a major incentive because it removes money from the talent pool and pushes FA for American players by 2 years


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - jdgaucho - 06-18-2026 09:15 PM

(06-18-2026 08:29 PM)Glenn360 Wrote:  I don't see the MLBPA agreeing to this without a major incentive because it removes money from the talent pool and pushes FA for American players by 2 years

Here's the compromise. No salary cap 05-stirthepot


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - jdgaucho - 06-18-2026 09:17 PM

(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Comes a decade too late for Fernando Tatis Jr. He would have torn it up in college


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - bryanw1995 - 06-18-2026 11:11 PM

(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Lush - 06-18-2026 11:22 PM

(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

i'd argue that college is about the development of the player not to the otherwise detriment of the team. if that makes sense


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - FULL_MONTY - 06-18-2026 11:28 PM

(06-18-2026 11:11 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.

Yes indeed. And when the NCAA has been blasted for "taking advantage" of college athletes no one said, you know if the NFL, NBA, MLB, et al didn't limit the Draft and funded their own development league kids could monetize their NIL, Grift, or whatever without sullying college athletics. But here we sit. What makes this worse is that these leagues have taken their anti-trust exemptions and have used it to bilk Americans.

To follow the NFL, you will need access to CBS, FOX, NBC, Prime, Netflix, NFL Network, ESPN, andNFL Ticket.

To Follow MLB, you need ESPN, FS1, FOX, TBS, and MLB+.

To follow the NBA you need ABC, ESPN, TNT, and NBA TV

All of these billions of dollars from media rights doesn't come from ad revenue but the subscriber and carriage fees that consumers foot the bill.

We the people gave them a monopoly and then they used it to empty our pockets. Will that end up with this new bill? Maybe, but probably not. Too many disparate interests.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Scoochpooch1 - 06-18-2026 11:45 PM

(06-18-2026 09:17 PM)jdgaucho Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Comes a decade too late for Fernando Tatis Jr. He would have torn it up in college

Especially with the steroids.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Scoochpooch1 - 06-18-2026 11:47 PM

Isn't MLB going on strike after the season anyway? Seems increasingly likely if Dodgers back into another title.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Scoochpooch1 - 06-18-2026 11:50 PM

(06-18-2026 11:28 PM)FULL_MONTY Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 11:11 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.

Yes indeed. And when the NCAA has been blasted for "taking advantage" of college athletes no one said, you know if the NFL, NBA, MLB, et al didn't limit the Draft and funded their own development league kids could monetize their NIL, Grift, or whatever without sullying college athletics. But here we sit. What makes this worse is that these leagues have taken their anti-trust exemptions and have used it to bilk Americans.

To follow the NFL, you will need access to CBS, FOX, NBC, Prime, Netflix, NFL Network, ESPN, andNFL Ticket.

To Follow MLB, you need ESPN, FS1, FOX, TBS, and MLB+.

To follow the NBA you need ABC, ESPN, TNT, and NBA TV

All of these billions of dollars from media rights doesn't come from ad revenue but the subscriber and carriage fees that consumers foot the bill.

We the people gave them a monopoly and then they used it to empty our pockets. Will that end up with this new bill? Maybe, but probably not. Too many disparate interests.

Never understood why people need to watch every game available though. Please dont tell me people are watching anything other than football which has so few games relatively speaking. To watch MLB, NHL, and NBA is a literal waste of time since everyone makes the playoffs anyway. Missing a game here and there because its on a streaming service really should be no big deal. If people stopped subscribing the leagues would move it back to an easily digestible service.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Bill Marsh - 06-18-2026 11:52 PM

(06-18-2026 11:22 PM)Lush Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

i'd argue that college is about the development of the player not to the otherwise detriment of the team. if that makes sense

I disagree. Baseball being the topic of this thread, their minor league system has multiple levels of competition. If a player struggles at one level, he can be dropped down to a lower level where his skills at that stage of his development are a better match for the level of competition. The most important thing is that he can play every day. Equally true is that a player who is dominating the competition can be moved to a higher level of competition so that he will be challenged by better players with higher skill levels.

College does not offer this kind of flexibility. If a player is struggling and not producing, the only alternative is to sit him on the bench and let someone else play in his spot. The player sitting on the bench isn’t developing because you can’t improve if you don’t play. In the case of a superior player who is dominating his league, he too is locked into the level of completion at which his college competes. In contrast, a minor league baseball who is dominating his league can be moved up to a higher minor league level where he will face more challenging competition. In fact it’s not unusual to see a player compete at 3 different minor league levels in the same season. A dominating player can even be moved up to the major league team if that’s warranted.

None of that kind of flexibility is available in college sports. A player can change colleges to compete at a higher or lower level but not in the same season. Players are locked in with their team/school for any guven season. After all they are supposed to be students first, right?


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Frank the Tank - 06-19-2026 12:20 AM

(06-18-2026 11:47 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Isn't MLB going on strike after the season anyway? Seems increasingly likely if Dodgers back into another title.

This proposal from the MLB owners is their latest way of saying that they don’t plan to play baseball in 2027. (Of course, the argument over a salary cap is issue #1.) I don’t see how anything in this proposal is anywhere close to what the MLBPA would ever agree to (and we’re just talking about the minor leagues here).


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - SoCalBobcat78 - 06-19-2026 12:51 AM

(06-18-2026 11:11 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.

The minor league system is strong and is not going anywhere. MLB wants to cut the domestic draft from 20 rounds to 12 and reduce amateur signing bonuses by more than $150 million annually. Eliminating high school players from the draft reduces the MLB financial and development risk. You basically get to see how they play against better competition and how they mature before they invest millions of dollars in a player.

Almost every player that gets drafted ends up in the minor leagues. There have only been 24 players in the last 60 years that have skipped the minor leagues. As an example, Paul Skenes was the No. 1 pick in the 2023 draft, after spending one year at LSU and two years at Air Force. In 2023, after he was drafted, Skenes went from the Rookie league; to the Single A league for one game and finished the season in the Double A league. In 2024, He started the season in Triple A before getting sent up to the Pirates in May and becoming an All-Star in 2024.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Frank the Tank - 06-19-2026 01:06 AM

(06-19-2026 12:51 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 11:11 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.

The minor league system is strong and is not going anywhere. MLB wants to cut the domestic draft from 20 rounds to 12 and reduce amateur signing bonuses by more than $150 million annually. Eliminating high school players from the draft reduces the MLB financial and development risk. You basically get to see how they play against better competition and how they mature before they invest millions of dollars in a player.

Almost every player that gets drafted ends up in the minor leagues. There have only been 24 players in the last 60 years that have skipped the minor leagues. As an example, Paul Skenes was the No. 1 pick in the 2023 draft, after spending one year at LSU and two years at Air Force. In 2023, after he was drafted, Skenes went from the Rookie league; to the Single A league for one game and finished the season in the Double A league. In 2024, He started the season in Triple A before getting sent up to the Pirates in May and becoming an All-Star in 2024.

Not that MLB owners care, but recall the hatchet job that MLB did in reorganizing the minor league system a couple of years ago with kicking out swaths of teams from MLB affiliations (causing them to either go to independent leagues or close down completely).

This proposal would likely be an even worse full-on massacre of the minor leagues by comparison. It’s easy to say “no big deal” in the way that a lot of people here seem to think that colleges getting downgraded from Division I status is no big deal, but there are a heck of a lot of cities and municipalities that invested in minor league stadiums relying upon those MLB affiliations. This isn’t like the G-League or attempted spring football leagues - there’s a whole massive level of public money invested in minor league baseball facilities.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - XLance - 06-19-2026 06:51 AM

Most people forget that bonuses are paid to high school players to keep them from going to college because the MLB owners want to get those kids into development quickly.

If the colleges are providing good development and MLB can eliminate all of that bonus expense, it's just less expense and more profit.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - EOU93 - 06-19-2026 07:26 AM

(06-18-2026 11:22 PM)Lush Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

i'd argue that college is about the development of the player not to the otherwise detriment of the team. if that makes sense

I’ll disagree. You get more development playing in the minors than college. Minors are full time job. They play over 100 games a season vs college players who go to class and play way less games.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Bill Marsh - 06-19-2026 08:03 AM

(06-19-2026 07:26 AM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 11:22 PM)Lush Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

i'd argue that college is about the development of the player not to the otherwise detriment of the team. if that makes sense

I’ll disagree. You get more development playing in the minors than college. Minors are full time job. They play over 100 games a season vs college players who go to class and play way less games.

Yes, and many of them then go and play in the Latin America winter leagues. If they’re in college, they can’t do that because they’re going to class in the fall and winter.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Bill Marsh - 06-19-2026 08:23 AM

(06-19-2026 01:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 12:51 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 11:11 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 06:29 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/49109814/sources-mlb-proposes-overhaul-amateur-entry-system

In a statement, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips touted the league's proposal as a benefit to college baseball.

"It's been remarkable to watch the upward trajectory of college baseball. The considerable and recent growth we've seen in the quality of facilities, access to advanced technologies, player development resources, and benefits through both increased scholarships and revenue sharing, has been significant," Phillips said. "These investments are creating more opportunities for student-athletes and providing additional pathways to develop at the collegiate level before taking the next step to the professional ranks. The collective improvements are not only a positive for college baseball but help strengthen the game for the betterment of all levels."


There's so much money in college baseball these days. I almost wonder if a lot of international prospects won't try to attend college for a year or 2 instead of getting dumped in the minors in the future?

Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.

The minor league system is strong and is not going anywhere. MLB wants to cut the domestic draft from 20 rounds to 12 and reduce amateur signing bonuses by more than $150 million annually. Eliminating high school players from the draft reduces the MLB financial and development risk. You basically get to see how they play against better competition and how they mature before they invest millions of dollars in a player.

Almost every player that gets drafted ends up in the minor leagues. There have only been 24 players in the last 60 years that have skipped the minor leagues. As an example, Paul Skenes was the No. 1 pick in the 2023 draft, after spending one year at LSU and two years at Air Force. In 2023, after he was drafted, Skenes went from the Rookie league; to the Single A league for one game and finished the season in the Double A league. In 2024, He started the season in Triple A before getting sent up to the Pirates in May and becoming an All-Star in 2024.

Not that MLB owners care, but recall the hatchet job that MLB did in reorganizing the minor league system a couple of years ago with kicking out swaths of teams from MLB affiliations (causing them to either go to independent leagues or close down completely).

This proposal would likely be an even worse full-on massacre of the minor leagues by comparison. It’s easy to say “no big deal” in the way that a lot of people here seem to think that colleges getting downgraded from Division I status is no big deal, but there are a heck of a lot of cities and municipalities that invested in minor league stadiums relying upon those MLB affiliations. This isn’t like the G-League or attempted spring football leagues - there’s a whole massive level of public money invested in minor league baseball facilities.

Frank, you’re absolutely right about this. I live in Connecticut where you can’t drive through downtown Hartford without passing the Connecticut Yard Goats Stadium, a minor league affiliate of the Colorado Rockies for the past dozen years. This enterprise has ultimately cost the city of Hartford and the state of Connecticut almost $700 million of investment combined. Connecticut used to have 4 minor league teams. The Yard Goats are the only ones left due to minor league reorganization. Two of the former minor league stadiums have been repurposed as futures league sites, which are essentially new business ventures, not supported by major league franchises.


RE: MLB plan would ban preps from draft, slash bonuses - ESPN - Captain Bearcat - 06-19-2026 11:00 AM

(06-19-2026 08:23 AM)Bill Marsh Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 01:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 12:51 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 11:11 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:  Of the top 32 draft picks in 2025, 16 of them were high school players. The Baseball Scouts and the MLBPA oppose it. Basically, this is about MLB teams saving money, baseball players losing money, and some scouts losing their jobs.

Scouts argue the pro baseball (minor league) develops skills to succeed at the MLB level; college baseball is more concerned about winning games rather than the development of players. Scouts will also argue that elite talent can be identified and developed much earlier.

MLB just wants to slash their costs and do what the NFL does, rely upon colleges to foot all the costs for training their next generation of studs. The NBA was like the NFL, then they started the g league, but their heart isn’t in it. Almost none of the top NBA prospects skip college (or Europe) for the g league, it’s turned into, I dunno, something akin to a very inexpensive AAA feeder league for marginal but talented kids that have aged out of college? Certainly it’s far, far cheaper for the NBA than the minor leagues are for MLB.

The minor league system is strong and is not going anywhere. MLB wants to cut the domestic draft from 20 rounds to 12 and reduce amateur signing bonuses by more than $150 million annually. Eliminating high school players from the draft reduces the MLB financial and development risk. You basically get to see how they play against better competition and how they mature before they invest millions of dollars in a player.

Almost every player that gets drafted ends up in the minor leagues. There have only been 24 players in the last 60 years that have skipped the minor leagues. As an example, Paul Skenes was the No. 1 pick in the 2023 draft, after spending one year at LSU and two years at Air Force. In 2023, after he was drafted, Skenes went from the Rookie league; to the Single A league for one game and finished the season in the Double A league. In 2024, He started the season in Triple A before getting sent up to the Pirates in May and becoming an All-Star in 2024.

Not that MLB owners care, but recall the hatchet job that MLB did in reorganizing the minor league system a couple of years ago with kicking out swaths of teams from MLB affiliations (causing them to either go to independent leagues or close down completely).

This proposal would likely be an even worse full-on massacre of the minor leagues by comparison. It’s easy to say “no big deal” in the way that a lot of people here seem to think that colleges getting downgraded from Division I status is no big deal, but there are a heck of a lot of cities and municipalities that invested in minor league stadiums relying upon those MLB affiliations. This isn’t like the G-League or attempted spring football leagues - there’s a whole massive level of public money invested in minor league baseball facilities.

Frank, you’re absolutely right about this. I live in Connecticut where you can’t drive through downtown Hartford without passing the Connecticut Yard Goats Stadium, a minor league affiliate of the Colorado Rockies for the past dozen years. This enterprise has ultimately cost the city of Hartford and the state of Connecticut almost $700 million of investment combined. Connecticut used to have 4 minor league teams. The Yard Goats are the only ones left due to minor league reorganization. Two of the former minor league stadiums have been repurposed as futures league sites, which are essentially new business ventures, not supported by major league franchises.

I don't think this affects minor league teams negatively because they don't rely on top prospects for financial success. They rely on two things: wins, and fan favorites sticking around.

Top prospects rarely translate to wins. That 19-year old's salary means he HAS to play, regardless of the game situation or roster needs. He's taking playing time away from a 26 year old whose game is more complete, body is more developed, and is focused on winning.

My kids got to be fans of a AA-level hockey team this year. But 2 months into the season, their favorite player got promoted to AAA. And the kids lost interest.

Overall, top prospects who are on an MILB roster for half a season probably decrease profitability.