CSNbbs
6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. (/thread-1029687.html)



6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Crayton - 06-17-2026 06:12 PM

NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - RUScarlets - 06-17-2026 06:50 PM

Can really only play Rds 1/2 the first two weekends and push Army Navy to the third weekend as far as unencumbered scheduling.

Give the players that are finishing a real degree an extension on FEs and suspend exams campus wide the ensuing Monday at the CFP hosting school. Extended semester a few days allows for the players/teams who played on the road catch up time prior to the third weekend.

16 teams is fine too, but I'm not a fan of seeds 12-9 who did not participate in a CCG getting a week off. The M2 would also lose when you remove their bye opp, so that Big 12 Friday night CCG slot and ACC noon slot does not whet the appetite of the casual sports fan. That weekend essentially becomes about only two games to decide a bye (and a marquee G6 game perhaps).

It should go to 24, but I don't think the third weekend works. The NFL reinforced their stick and blocked the CFP from maximizing it.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Garden_KC - 06-17-2026 07:17 PM

Doesn't sound like a split or superdivision situation is happening if they are still wanting to grow the playoff to 24.

If a decision came down to table expansion to 24 until afte the TV contract is done it would be more suitable for split after the existing contract.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Wahoowa84 - 06-17-2026 08:44 PM

Good to read that most of the discussion is about the 24 team proposal. The more questions the better…it’s the more complex proposal


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - GoBuckeyes1047 - 06-18-2026 07:42 AM

(06-17-2026 06:50 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Can really only play Rds 1/2 the first two weekends and push Army Navy to the third weekend as far as unencumbered scheduling.

Give the players that are finishing a real degree an extension on FEs and suspend exams campus wide the ensuing Monday at the CFP hosting school. Extended semester a few days allows for the players/teams who played on the road catch up time prior to the third weekend.

16 teams is fine too, but I'm not a fan of seeds 12-9 who did not participate in a CCG getting a week off. The M2 would also lose when you remove their bye opp, so that Big 12 Friday night CCG slot and ACC noon slot does not whet the appetite of the casual sports fan. That weekend essentially becomes about only two games to decide a bye (and a marquee G6 game perhaps).

It should go to 24, but I don't think the third weekend works. The NFL reinforced their stick and blocked the CFP from maximizing it.

2 Friday games and 2 early Saturday games could work with minimal crossover, but then it's a question of where would Army-Navy go, also trying to fit 8 games into the first 2 weekends. I think 20 teams with 9-14 hosting 15-20 playing the 1st weekend, the 6 winners playing 3-8 the 2nd weekend, and then the 6 winners joining the top 2 seeds or champs the 3rd weekend, but 20 teams is my cap personally depending on the regular season and CCG/WCG format.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - bryanw1995 - 06-18-2026 08:06 AM

(06-17-2026 06:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.

Are we still giving lip service to "student wellness" for rosters of paid athletes that collectively make $20-50m+ year? Come on. If this was Soccer or lacrosse, that might be true, but in the case of the CFP it's a waste of breath, or perhaps just the last gasp of a few clueless people who still think these paid mercenaries are amateurs.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Crayton - 06-18-2026 08:07 AM

(06-17-2026 06:50 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  16 teams is fine too, but I'm not a fan of seeds 12-9 who did not participate in a CCG getting a week off. The M2 would also lose when you remove their bye opp, so that Big 12 Friday night CCG slot and ACC noon slot does not whet the appetite of the casual sports fan. That weekend essentially becomes about only two games to decide a bye (and a marquee G6 game perhaps).

It should go to 24, but I don't think the third weekend works. The NFL reinforced their stick and blocked the CFP from maximizing it.

With 16 I think there is still enough collegiality that the byes will go to the “top” champs, not just the P2. And lower ranked CG teams will be in danger of elimination; there will still be something to play for in EVERY A4 CG.

I still feel my “Perfect” 16-team playoff balances the politics best. 3 byes means the P2 champs are all but guaranteed a bye while the M2 still have legit hope of a bye (though not necessarily a Top 3 seed). 6 play-in teams is also a great fit such that playoff teams need to accumulate ~12 wins to make the QFs.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Gitanole - 06-18-2026 08:16 AM

(06-18-2026 08:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 06:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.

Are we still giving lip service to "student wellness" for rosters of paid athletes that collectively make $20-50m+ year? Come on. If this was Soccer or lacrosse, that might be true, but in the case of the CFP it's a waste of breath, or perhaps just the last gasp of a few clueless people who still think these paid mercenaries are amateurs.

All the more, then.

When you bet a thousand on a horse, you like to know it’s healthy.

When you bet a million on a horse, you really like to know it’s healthy.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Crayton - 06-18-2026 08:21 AM

(06-18-2026 08:16 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 06:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.

Are we still giving lip service to "student wellness" for rosters of paid athletes that collectively make $20-50m+ year? Come on. If this was Soccer or lacrosse, that might be true, but in the case of the CFP it's a waste of breath, or perhaps just the last gasp of a few clueless people who still think these paid mercenaries are amateurs.

All the more, then.

When you bet a thousand on a horse, you like to know it’s healthy.

When you bet a million on a horse, you really like to know it’s healthy.

The cynic in me imagines the consultants rolled out a schedule with midweek games and then the committee pulled out their hair wondering how many days of rest those teams would have before that game and the next.

I wasn’t in the room, but it sounds like they are still trying to squeeze 16 games into 2 weeks. Timeslots like the Thursday after the regular season were probably presented. I’d be concerned too.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Frank the Tank - 06-18-2026 09:36 AM

(06-18-2026 08:21 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 06:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.

Are we still giving lip service to "student wellness" for rosters of paid athletes that collectively make $20-50m+ year? Come on. If this was Soccer or lacrosse, that might be true, but in the case of the CFP it's a waste of breath, or perhaps just the last gasp of a few clueless people who still think these paid mercenaries are amateurs.

All the more, then.

When you bet a thousand on a horse, you like to know it’s healthy.

When you bet a million on a horse, you really like to know it’s healthy.

The cynic in me imagines the consultants rolled out a schedule with midweek games and then the committee pulled out their hair wondering how many days of rest those teams would have before that game and the next.

I wasn’t in the room, but it sounds like they are still trying to squeeze 16 games into 2 weeks. Timeslots like the Thursday after the regular season were probably presented. I’d be concerned too.

This is always a challenge. Even if you could have an infinite number of games in theory, there are still only a finite number of time slots, so there are diminishing financial returns or even no additional value created at all when there are two playoff games going on in the same time slot (not to mention other competing content like the NFL).

As a result, every TV interest is going to push midweek games. Optimally, they have no overlapping games at all and avoid the NFL as much as possible on top of it. Heck - having only Thursday and Friday as the only weeknight games for an expanded playoff (even at 16 teams, much less 24) would be wildly optimistic. I think the TV people are looking at Tuesday and Wednesday TV games on top of it all.

That inherently conflicts with a fair competitive objective of having at least a week between games for each playoff game. I believe that having a 2 week break between the regular season and the start of the playoff is anachronistic (especially if conference championship games are eliminated as some teams would play those even on 6 days rest), but ensuring that no one plays a game with less than 7 days between games is certainly fair for competitiveness and safety.

Throw in the Army-Navy Game needing to be integrated somewhere in an exclusive time slot and it becomes even more difficult.


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Crayton - 06-18-2026 10:42 AM

(06-18-2026 09:36 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:21 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 06:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.

Are we still giving lip service to "student wellness" for rosters of paid athletes that collectively make $20-50m+ year? Come on. If this was Soccer or lacrosse, that might be true, but in the case of the CFP it's a waste of breath, or perhaps just the last gasp of a few clueless people who still think these paid mercenaries are amateurs.

All the more, then.

When you bet a thousand on a horse, you like to know it’s healthy.

When you bet a million on a horse, you really like to know it’s healthy.

The cynic in me imagines the consultants rolled out a schedule with midweek games and then the committee pulled out their hair wondering how many days of rest those teams would have before that game and the next.

I wasn’t in the room, but it sounds like they are still trying to squeeze 16 games into 2 weeks. Timeslots like the Thursday after the regular season were probably presented. I’d be concerned too.

This is always a challenge. Even if you could have an infinite number of games in theory, there are still only a finite number of time slots, so there are diminishing financial returns or even no additional value created at all when there are two playoff games going on in the same time slot (not to mention other competing content like the NFL).

As a result, every TV interest is going to push midweek games. Optimally, they have no overlapping games at all and avoid the NFL as much as possible on top of it. Heck - having only Thursday and Friday as the only weeknight games for an expanded playoff (even at 16 teams, much less 24) would be wildly optimistic. I think the TV people are looking at Tuesday and Wednesday TV games on top of it all.

That inherently conflicts with a fair competitive objective of having at least a week between games for each playoff game. I believe that having a 2 week break between the regular season and the start of the playoff is anachronistic (especially if conference championship games are eliminated as some teams would play those even on 6 days rest), but ensuring that no one plays a game with less than 7 days between games is certainly fair for competitiveness and safety.

Throw in the Army-Navy Game needing to be integrated somewhere in an exclusive time slot and it becomes even more difficult.

Adding 4 games to the current calendar (ie expanding to 16) while avoiding overlap, short weeks, Tues+Wed, Army-Navy, and NFL broadcasts is easy enough: 3 games to Army-Navy weekend, 1 to either Thursday.

Add 8 more games and you can still do it BUT only if you use Tuesday+Wednesdays AND all 3 weekends. The fact that they are still concerned about (and spent much of 3 hours talking about) “student wellness” tells me they either want a fallow Saturday or are unwilling to play Tuesdays and Wednesdays. :/


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - bullet - 06-18-2026 10:56 AM

(06-18-2026 09:36 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:21 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:16 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 08:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 06:12 PM)Crayton Wrote:  NYTimes: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7370023/2026/06/17/college-football-playoff-expansion-questions-2/

ESPN: https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/49099713/cfp-leaders-face-serious-questions-expanded-24-team-field

The focus on 24 was ‘mostly’ because 16 is more well known. Not sure what the health concerns were around 24. Perhaps it is ensuring no short weeks.

No revenue discussions at this time. Sounds like they want to finalize the schedule before they go shopping. Both article indicate that there is no guarantee the money will be there.

Are we still giving lip service to "student wellness" for rosters of paid athletes that collectively make $20-50m+ year? Come on. If this was Soccer or lacrosse, that might be true, but in the case of the CFP it's a waste of breath, or perhaps just the last gasp of a few clueless people who still think these paid mercenaries are amateurs.

All the more, then.

When you bet a thousand on a horse, you like to know it’s healthy.

When you bet a million on a horse, you really like to know it’s healthy.

The cynic in me imagines the consultants rolled out a schedule with midweek games and then the committee pulled out their hair wondering how many days of rest those teams would have before that game and the next.

I wasn’t in the room, but it sounds like they are still trying to squeeze 16 games into 2 weeks. Timeslots like the Thursday after the regular season were probably presented. I’d be concerned too.

This is always a challenge. Even if you could have an infinite number of games in theory, there are still only a finite number of time slots, so there are diminishing financial returns or even no additional value created at all when there are two playoff games going on in the same time slot (not to mention other competing content like the NFL).

As a result, every TV interest is going to push midweek games. Optimally, they have no overlapping games at all and avoid the NFL as much as possible on top of it. Heck - having only Thursday and Friday as the only weeknight games for an expanded playoff (even at 16 teams, much less 24) would be wildly optimistic. I think the TV people are looking at Tuesday and Wednesday TV games on top of it all.

That inherently conflicts with a fair competitive objective of having at least a week between games for each playoff game. I believe that having a 2 week break between the regular season and the start of the playoff is anachronistic (especially if conference championship games are eliminated as some teams would play those even on 6 days rest), but ensuring that no one plays a game with less than 7 days between games is certainly fair for competitiveness and safety.

Throw in the Army-Navy Game needing to be integrated somewhere in an exclusive time slot and it becomes even more difficult.

Army-Navy really complicates it. Because you really have to have 2 first round games the 2nd week in case they both make it.

One possibility:
1st week:
Two on Friday
Three on Saturday plus Army-Navy
One on Wednesday
2nd week:
Two on Friday-end of 1st round
Four on Saturday
One on Wednesday
3rd week:
Two on Friday (winners from previous Friday)
One on Saturday (only one to avoid NFL)

If you insist on a week before the first game and between games:
First week:
Three on Saturday plus Army-Navy
One on Tuesday
One on Wednesday
2nd week:
One on Friday
Two first round on Saturday (could be Army and Navy)
Two second round on Saturday (from 3 Saturday winners and byes)
One on Tuesday (from 3 Saturday winners and Tuesday winner and byes)
One on Wednesday (from 3 Saturday winners and T/W winners and byes)
3rd week:
Two on Friday (from any Sat-Friday winners and byes)
Two on Saturday (from two 2nd Saturday winners and byes-one game faces NFL)


RE: 6/17 CFP Discussion focused on 24. Student Wellness top priority. - Crayton - 06-20-2026 11:36 AM

(06-17-2026 08:44 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Good to read that most of the discussion is about the 24 team proposal. The more questions the better…it’s the more complex proposal

Agreed. When 24 was first trotted out I thought it was too big and I didn’t want to lose regional (“conference”, now that divisions are gone) championships. “Sure Florida will make the playoff at 9-3, but they’ll host Syracuse and then go on the road to Lubbock; yawn.”

But I realize that conferences aren’t really regional now anyways and 24 isn’t really worse than 12 when it comes to rewarding regular season performance. I just hope there is some geographical considerations when building the bracket.