+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: MACbbs (/forum-513.html)
+---- Forum: Mid-American Conference Talk (/forum-472.html)
+---- Thread: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation (/thread-1028291.html)
Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - epasnoopy - 05-07-202606:22 AM
Quote:The NCAA MFRS reports don’t just tell us what schools spent money on, they also tell us what revenues they claim. But the “Total Revenues” figure can be a little misleading, since the NCAA forms include some items that laypeople probably wouldn’t consider to exactly count as revenue.
For example, many institutions use student fees to help balance their athletic department budget. If an athletic department generated funds via student fees, they’re allowed to count that figure as “revenue” even though students don’t really have an option of not paying, even if they never attend an athletic event. Schools can also claim “Direct Institutional Support”, or even “Direct State or Governmental Support”, as revenue.
That’s valuable information, sure. I’m not saying it doesn’t belong on these reports. But I suspect when Joe Fan is talking about athletic department revenue, they’re really trying to talk about Generated Revenue, or all the money that an athletic department produces via ticket sales, TV money, corporate sponsorships, concession stands, etc.
So I dug into all of those MFRS reports, found each school’s “total revenues” in FY25, and subtracted everything from student fees, direct institutional support, indirect institutional support revenue, Direct State or Other Government Support, and Indirect Institutional Support – Athletic Facilities Debt Service, Lease and Rental Fees.
The remainder? Let’s call that Generated Revenue. That figure includes everything an athletic department earned from:
- Ticket Sales
- Contributions (donations)
- Guarantees Revenue (buy games)
- Media Rights
- NCAA Distributions
- Conference Distributions
- Bowl Revenue
- Program, Novelty and Concession Sales
- Royalties, Licensing, Advertisement and Sponsorships
- Sports Camp Revenues
- Other Operating Revenue
Is this a completely perfect figure? No, because the MFRS data isn’t perfect. But I do think it’s close enough to be useful.
This data also comes from FY25, or July 1 2024-June 30 2025. It does not include data from the 2025 college football season or 2025 fall sports.
Average MAC share payout during this reporting year was $2.48 million.
Some of the MAC schools with lower enrollment such as EMU and CMU that are highly dependent on student fees/institutional support are going to be hurting more and more as they continue to lose students. They will have to raise student fees just to keep up. Don't forget, each school is also about to lose $300k-$500k in NCAA distributions due to NCAA-House settlement to pay former players. Buffalo and UMass should be dominating the MAC with how heavily they boost their athletics spending with student fees/institutional support. Sacramento St is already heavily subsidized and their new deal to join the MAC is going to make it much worse.
Some of the hockey playing MAC schools also earn more revenue from ticket sales, sponsorships, etc. from that sport (such as WMU, BG, Miami, and UMass). Other MAC schools may be getting more from naming rights deals (such as Akron) that other schools don't have. WMU is getting about $4 million more in donor contributions than the avg MAC school.
(From most revenue generation to least (aka least subsidized by students/institutional support to most))
MAC
1. University of Toledo - $14,688,347 (56.50%)
2. Western Michigan University - $20,015,018 (47.70%)
3. Northern Illinois University - $12,225,099 (39.10%)
4. Bowling Green State University - $12,968,900 (36.80%)
5. University of Akron - $11,444,338 (35.00%)
6. Miami University (Ohio) - $14,138,045 - (34.30%)
7. Kent State University - $10,899,362 (33.90%)
8. Ball State University - $10,931,636 (31.50%)
9. Ohio University - $10,994,788 (30.10%)
10. Eastern Michigan University - $11,338,192 (29.10%)
11. Central Michigan University - $10,254,187 (27.00%)
12. University at Buffalo - $11,216,338 (23.30%)
13. University of Massachusetts - $14,030,012 (18.90%)
California State University, Sacramento - $4,905,136 (10.40%)
RE: Matt Brown - MAC schools revenue generation - Steve1981 - 05-07-202608:37 AM
(05-07-2026 06:22 AM)epasnoopy Wrote: Average MAC share payout during this reporting year was $2.48 million.
Some of the MAC schools with lower enrollment such as EMU and CMU that are highly dependent on student fees/institutional support are going to be hurting more and more as they continue to lose students. They will have to raise student fees just to keep up. Don't forget, each school is also about to lose $300k-$500k in NCAA distributions due to NCAA-House settlement to pay former players. Buffalo and UMass should be dominating the MAC with how heavily they boost their athletics spending with student fees/institutional support. Sacramento St is already heavily subsidized and their new deal to join the MAC is going to make it much worse.
Some of the hockey playing MAC schools also earn more revenue from ticket sales, sponsorships, etc. from that sport (such as WMU, BG, Miami, and UMass). Other MAC schools may be getting more from naming rights deals (such as Akron) that other schools don't have. WMU is getting about $4 million more in donor contributions than the avg MAC school.
(From most revenue generation to least (aka least subsidized by students/institutional support to most))
MAC
1. University of Toledo - $14,688,347 (56.50%)
2. Western Michigan University - $20,015,018 (47.70%)
3. Northern Illinois University - $12,225,099 (39.10%)
4. Bowling Green State University - $12,968,900 (36.80%)
5. University of Akron - $11,444,338 (35.00%)
6. Miami University (Ohio) - $14,138,045 - (34.30%)
7. Kent State University - $10,899,362 (33.90%)
8. Ball State University - $10,931,636 (31.50%)
9. Ohio University - $10,994,788 (30.10%)
10. Eastern Michigan University - $11,338,192 (29.10%)
11. Central Michigan University - $10,254,187 (27.00%)
12. University at Buffalo - $11,216,338 (23.30%)
13. University of Massachusetts - $14,030,012 (18.90%)
California State University, Sacramento - $4,905,136 (10.40%)
Agree with your comment that universities with hockey have more total revenue. But draw a different conclusions with the bolded area. New York, Buffalo and Massachusetts, UMass only have 1 FBS university, so while probably a less drain on tax payers as a percentage than other MAC states that have so many FBS public universities to support that those universities each reach less from the state. I have not looked at student fees, but think they are in line with other universitates and we have lots of intramural sports and the students do have a nice 50M sports facility in addition to the old Boyden, 3 floor gym.
It was tagged as 52M in 2011 dollars.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC schools revenue generation - epasnoopy - 05-07-202609:46 AM
(05-07-2026 08:37 AM)Steve1981 Wrote:
(05-07-2026 06:22 AM)epasnoopy Wrote: Average MAC share payout during this reporting year was $2.48 million.
Some of the MAC schools with lower enrollment such as EMU and CMU that are highly dependent on student fees/institutional support are going to be hurting more and more as they continue to lose students. They will have to raise student fees just to keep up. Don't forget, each school is also about to lose $300k-$500k in NCAA distributions due to NCAA-House settlement to pay former players. Buffalo and UMass should be dominating the MAC with how heavily they boost their athletics spending with student fees/institutional support. Sacramento St is already heavily subsidized and their new deal to join the MAC is going to make it much worse.
Some of the hockey playing MAC schools also earn more revenue from ticket sales, sponsorships, etc. from that sport (such as WMU, BG, Miami, and UMass). Other MAC schools may be getting more from naming rights deals (such as Akron) that other schools don't have. WMU is getting about $4 million more in donor contributions than the avg MAC school.
Agree with your comment that universities with hockey have more total revenue. But draw a different conclusions with the bolded area. New York, Buffalo and Massachusetts, UMass only have 1 FBS university, so while probably a less drain on tax payers as a percentage than other MAC states that have so many FBS public universities to support that those universities each reach less from the state. I have not looked at student fees, but think they are in line with other universitates and we have lots of intramural sports and the students do have a nice 50M sports facility in addition to the old Boyden, 3 floor gym.
It was tagged as 52M in 2011 dollars.
Fair point on the state of Massachusetts having less FBS schools to support, where Ohio has eight and Michigan has five.
Quote:Akron, Toledo, UMass, and Miami average subsidy per student is $1,529.
NIU average is $1,123.
If NIU charged the same average as those four MAC schools we would bring in another $6,258,490 annually. Plenty more money to spend on basketball.
I got this info from a Google search of each university's 2024 total fall enrollment and compared it to Knight Commission reporting for 2024.
EMU appears to have the highest student subsidy in the MAC at $2,092 per student.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - Garden_KC - 05-08-202608:23 AM
You can't derive student fees from looking at "budget" numbers and dividing by enrollment.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - epasnoopy - 05-08-202610:07 AM
(05-08-2026 08:23 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: You can't derive student fees from looking at "budget" numbers and dividing by enrollment.
Not sure by what you mean "budget". The numbers came from adding student fees and institutional support numbers from Knight Commission and dividing by enrollment. All students pay student athletic fees (and tuition), even if they are online, part-time, or graduate students.
Institutional funding and student fees are basically the same thing. In both cases, students are paying the largest burden. Some schools combine the two categories in their athletic financial reporting (for example, EMU). Most institutional funding comes from students paying tuition (and fees). If you want to get a more accurate look, then you need to figure out how much of the "institutional support" athletics departments are receiving from tuition, state funding, and other university revenue sources. But schools are never going to break it down in that far of detail.
If you have a better source for figuring out the true cost to students then please post it.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - Garden_KC - 05-08-202602:37 PM
(05-08-2026 10:07 AM)epasnoopy Wrote:
(05-08-2026 08:23 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: You can't derive student fees from looking at "budget" numbers and dividing by enrollment.
Not sure by what you mean "budget". The numbers came from adding student fees and institutional support numbers from Knight Commission and dividing by enrollment. All students pay student athletic fees (and tuition), even if they are online, part-time, or graduate students.
Institutional funding and student fees are basically the same thing. In both cases, students are paying the largest burden. Some schools combine the two categories in their athletic financial reporting (for example, EMU). Most institutional funding comes from students paying tuition (and fees). If you want to get a more accurate look, then you need to figure out how much of the "institutional support" athletics departments are receiving from tuition, state funding, and other university revenue sources. But schools are never going to break it down in that far of detail.
If you have a better source for figuring out the true cost to students then please post it.
You would have to get the fee schedule at every MAC university to see what they are paying in student or academic support fees.
The problem even there is the fees will vary as to their composition. Student fees go to campus service and wellness and then from there can even spend academic components into it.
I think the best source to see what a program is spending might be the equity in athletics website.
But even there the spending doesn't tell you the whole story as to all the spending line items. I think it does however clearly show the MAC spends less money on FB than the AC.
Wins and losses are the best metric you have because the financials are apples to oranges school to school IMO.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - epasnoopy - 05-08-202603:22 PM
(05-08-2026 02:37 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:
(05-08-2026 10:07 AM)epasnoopy Wrote:
(05-08-2026 08:23 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: You can't derive student fees from looking at "budget" numbers and dividing by enrollment.
Not sure by what you mean "budget". The numbers came from adding student fees and institutional support numbers from Knight Commission and dividing by enrollment. All students pay student athletic fees (and tuition), even if they are online, part-time, or graduate students.
Institutional funding and student fees are basically the same thing. In both cases, students are paying the largest burden. Some schools combine the two categories in their athletic financial reporting (for example, EMU). Most institutional funding comes from students paying tuition (and fees). If you want to get a more accurate look, then you need to figure out how much of the "institutional support" athletics departments are receiving from tuition, state funding, and other university revenue sources. But schools are never going to break it down in that far of detail.
If you have a better source for figuring out the true cost to students then please post it.
You would have to get the fee schedule at every MAC university to see what they are paying in student or academic support fees.
The problem even there is the fees will vary as to their composition. Student fees go to campus service and wellness and then from there can even spend academic components into it.
I think the best source to see what a program is spending might be the equity in athletics website.
But even there the spending doesn't tell you the whole story as to all the spending line items. I think it does however clearly show the MAC spends less money on FB than the AC.
Wins and losses are the best metric you have because the financials are apples to oranges school to school IMO.
I wouldn't rely on a department of education website as a good source. That department has been gutted by the current presidential administration. I doubt the few remaining employees are worried about making sure that website is accurate.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - Garden_KC - 05-08-202603:57 PM
(05-08-2026 03:22 PM)epasnoopy Wrote:
(05-08-2026 02:37 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:
(05-08-2026 10:07 AM)epasnoopy Wrote:
(05-08-2026 08:23 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: You can't derive student fees from looking at "budget" numbers and dividing by enrollment.
Not sure by what you mean "budget". The numbers came from adding student fees and institutional support numbers from Knight Commission and dividing by enrollment. All students pay student athletic fees (and tuition), even if they are online, part-time, or graduate students.
Institutional funding and student fees are basically the same thing. In both cases, students are paying the largest burden. Some schools combine the two categories in their athletic financial reporting (for example, EMU). Most institutional funding comes from students paying tuition (and fees). If you want to get a more accurate look, then you need to figure out how much of the "institutional support" athletics departments are receiving from tuition, state funding, and other university revenue sources. But schools are never going to break it down in that far of detail.
If you have a better source for figuring out the true cost to students then please post it.
You would have to get the fee schedule at every MAC university to see what they are paying in student or academic support fees.
The problem even there is the fees will vary as to their composition. Student fees go to campus service and wellness and then from there can even spend academic components into it.
I think the best source to see what a program is spending might be the equity in athletics website.
But even there the spending doesn't tell you the whole story as to all the spending line items. I think it does however clearly show the MAC spends less money on FB than the AC.
Wins and losses are the best metric you have because the financials are apples to oranges school to school IMO.
I wouldn't rely on a department of education website as a good source. That department has been gutted by the current presidential administration. I doubt the few remaining employees are worried about making sure that website is accurate.
Well its self reporting not Department of Education people putting in the numbers.
FB spening according to the website.
Toledo 12.03 m
UMass 11.53 m
Ohio 11.44 m
EMU 11.29 m
Miami 10.60 m
BGSU 10.1 m
Kent 9.87 m
WMU 9.23 m
Akron 7.85 m
Ball St. 7.71 m
Sacramento St. 7.2 m
Buffalo N/A
CMU N/A
If I'm looking at this date this is what I can conclude.
-The typical MAC FB program is spending about 10 million.
-UMass is spending more than average but they also have higher travel costs.
-Sacramento St will probably be a lot higher if they aren't aleady.
-Its really Akron & Ball St that stand out because their programs stink and they lag behind the MAC in spending.
-Toledo leads in FB expenses but also has some of the cheapest travel in the MAC. Thus they must be one of the biggest spenders.
RE: Matt Brown - MAC revenue generation - epasnoopy - 05-08-202608:48 PM
(05-08-2026 03:57 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:
(05-08-2026 03:22 PM)epasnoopy Wrote: I wouldn't rely on a department of education website as a good source. That department has been gutted by the current presidential administration. I doubt the few remaining employees are worried about making sure that website is accurate.
Well its self reporting not Department of Education people putting in the numbers.
FB spening according to the website.
Toledo 12.03 m
UMass 11.53 m
Ohio 11.44 m
EMU 11.29 m
Miami 10.60 m
BGSU 10.1 m
Kent 9.87 m
WMU 9.23 m
Akron 7.85 m
Ball St. 7.71 m
Sacramento St. 7.2 m
Buffalo N/A
CMU N/A
I looked at the website earlier and its bad. The data is either old or incorrect. I just posted a google drive link to every MAC school's official FRS report to the NCAA. Definitely a better source.
For example, WMU reported it spent $11,795,493 on football in 2024-25 in its NCAA FRS submission. Ball State reported $9,485,095.