![]() |
|
Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility (/thread-1025431.html) Pages: 1 2 |
Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - bryanw1995 - 02-24-2026 07:13 PM https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/48026183/virginia-qb-chandler-morris-files-lawsuit-seeking-7th-year This one is UVA's starting QB from this past year. His reasoning is highly suspect: Morris sought a medical redshirt for his 2022 season at TCU after he dealt with a knee injury that significantly impacted his mental health. Morris was injured in the season opener against Colorado and lost his starting job to Max Duggan, who went on to lead the Horned Frogs to the College Football Playoff championship game and a 13-2 season. Morris returned from the injury to play in three more games as a backup during 2022 season, including the national title game. Since he had already redshirted in 2021, the injury-shortened season counted as a full year of eligibility by NCAA standards. His attorneys contend the 26 snaps Morris played over the three appearances were part of a medically prescribed mental health treatment plan and that the NCAA disregarded mental health documentation submitted by Virginia on Morris' behalf in denying his eligibility waiver. Ofc, I'm sure that the State Judge hearing the case is a UVA grad, so there's still a chance. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - quo vadis - 02-24-2026 07:37 PM Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. And I think they will win. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - DFW HOYA - 02-25-2026 09:38 AM (02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. Unless the school enforces a degree-in-progress requirement. Do you see a judge telling Notre Dame they have to admit a 7th year recruit? No. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - AssKickingChicken - 02-25-2026 10:25 AM (02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. Someone could get a degree in four years and then decide to pursue a degree in a different major. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Dr Dawgma III - 02-25-2026 10:27 AM (02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. Exactly. I keep saying this and I thought Quo was in academia and understood how student-exclusive activities work and are supported by law. There are activities exclusive to specifically undergrads as well, and I wouldn’t mind seeing athletics fall under that umbrella. No more grad students. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Dr Dawgma III - 02-25-2026 10:28 AM (02-25-2026 10:25 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:(02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. That’s post-baccalaureate studies and can be classified as such. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Big Frog II - 02-25-2026 10:31 AM This is out of hand. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - HP-TBDPITL - 02-25-2026 10:45 AM How does all of this affect APR's? If the academic progress rate is that slow, then the school applying for the waiver should have to take a massive APR hit. If that happened, then less waivers would be submitted. I have to assume a 25 year old already has a bachelors and a masters at this point....so lets cap it at that. If the student doesnt, then applying for year 7 results in an APR blow to the program applying. I mean federal student loans would cut them off at some point, why not athletic scholarships. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Troy_Fan_15 - 02-25-2026 11:16 AM This is why I think expanding eligibility to 5 years and getting rid of redshirts as a whole is best. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - SoCalBobcat78 - 02-25-2026 12:01 PM (02-25-2026 10:27 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:(02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. That is not going to work. For example, Fernando Mendoza was a grad student last season at Indiana. He got his degree from Cal in three years. David Bailey, a unanimous All-American this past season, was a grad student at Texas Tech. He got his degree from Stanford in three years. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - ken d - 02-25-2026 12:14 PM (02-25-2026 12:01 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:(02-25-2026 10:27 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:(02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. I'm curious. How does a grad student on the roster figure in the calculation of his school's APR? RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Erictelevision - 02-25-2026 12:15 PM This is another step toward decoupling “college” sports from academics. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Just Joe - 02-25-2026 12:18 PM (02-25-2026 11:16 AM)Troy_Fan_15 Wrote: This is why I think expanding eligibility to 5 years and getting rid of redshirts as a whole is best. And then that'll be challenged once someone wants a 6th year. Without congressional action enacting a standard, there won't be one. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Outsider - 02-25-2026 12:23 PM To heck with all the high school grads wanting to play. Now all the players in school already will just never leave. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Troy_Fan_15 - 02-25-2026 12:50 PM (02-25-2026 12:18 PM)Just Joe Wrote:(02-25-2026 11:16 AM)Troy_Fan_15 Wrote: This is why I think expanding eligibility to 5 years and getting rid of redshirts as a whole is best. Maybe. By getting rid of redshirts (even medical redshirts) it helps remove the barrier that created these extra seasons kids are applying for. Miss a year due to injury? Welp you got 4 other years total. It's your senior year? That sucks but life goes on. I wouldn't expect congress to be much help on the issue because they can't unify to pass anything these days.. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - DFW HOYA - 02-25-2026 12:55 PM Have schools simply enforce four seasons of play within 10 semesters. No waivers, no hardship cases, no medical redshirts. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - bryanw1995 - 02-25-2026 05:30 PM (02-25-2026 10:27 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:(02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. While a traditional bachelor's degree in the US is designed to take four years, the actual average time to completion is closer to 5.1 to 5.7 years for many students. Although officially cited as a "four-year degree," only about 44% of students graduate within 48 months. Factors such as part-time enrollment, switching majors, and working while in school often extend the timeline to five or six years Fits in nicely with a blanket 5 or 6 year eligibility window. Start it when they graduate high school or turn 18, whichever comes first. If they play the sport professionally anywhere in the world they lose eligibility, but only for that sport. Ie, you can’t graduate at 16 and get 2 extra years, but you could play bball for Real Madrid from 16-19 and then play college FB or VB in the US until you’re 22. If you break something your first 3 years, or Covid happens, or you go on a sabbatical to find yourself, whatever, the clock never stops ticking, and no more 25 yo kids trying to follow in Pavia’s footsteps. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Dr Dawgma III - 02-25-2026 05:39 PM The problem with the “unlimited eligibility” angle is it totally destroys the original intent of college athletics which is an integral part of the college experience. Athletes would be pushed out of a chance to partake in a time honored tradition, and equity would be lost. RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Dr Dawgma III - 02-25-2026 05:39 PM (02-25-2026 12:01 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:(02-25-2026 10:27 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:(02-25-2026 09:38 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-24-2026 07:37 PM)quo vadis Wrote: Pretty soon all pretense will be dropped and "kids" will be suing to play CFB for as long as they want (and for as long as the NIL offers are good) on "just because it's the easiest way for me to make a living" grounds. Sorry? RE: Another 25 year old wants an extra year of eligibility - Stugray2 - 02-25-2026 07:11 PM Another case pushing us closer to the day the A4 enter into conference silos, separating football from the NCAA. |