CSNbbs
What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? (/thread-1025358.html)



What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - thw0223 - 02-22-2026 07:47 PM

Good list below but you have to also factor in players like JaMarcus Russell, Peter Warrick and Lawrence Phillips.

https://mikefarrellsports.com/college/top-5-college-football-stars-who-vanished-in-the-nfl/


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - Scoochpooch1 - 02-22-2026 08:06 PM

Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - The Beaver - 02-22-2026 09:45 PM

(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

Yeah, all OSU and PSU qbs. And the obligatory Tebow reference too.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - AssKickingChicken - 02-22-2026 10:45 PM

A list like this that leaves off Ryan Leaf?

I’ll say this for Mandatich. After he left the NFL following three subpar seasons in 1992, he sobered up and returned to the league in 1996 and played three more years.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - bryanw1995 - 02-22-2026 10:59 PM

(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

CJ Stroud would like a word, he seems to be doing ok:

https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id/4432577/cj-stroud


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - tf8693 - 02-22-2026 11:15 PM

Looking at my own, I'd have to include Rocket in this category, if for no other reason than his dominance at the college level. Arguably the best college player never to win a Heisman, almost certainly on the short list in that category. Literally a threat to score from anywhere in the field once he had the ball in his hands.

In the NFL, he had a decently lengthy career, but he bounced around among several teams and never became a true star.

What I think happened: in the NFL, he no longer was the fastest guy on the field. And his lack of size finally caught up with him at the NFL level.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - celldweller7 - 02-22-2026 11:59 PM

(02-22-2026 07:47 PM)thw0223 Wrote:  Good list below but you have to also factor in players like JaMarcus Russell, Peter Warrick and Lawrence Phillips.

https://mikefarrellsports.com/college/top-5-college-football-stars-who-vanished-in-the-nfl/

Blackmon nearly drank himself to death. I think our receiver, Rashaun Woods, who was a 2-time All-American in 2002 & 2003, was the bigger bust. Blackmon actually performed well in his limited time in the NFL, Woods was a complete no-show.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - thw0223 - 02-23-2026 12:08 AM

(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

Good call, seemed like Stroud was going to break that streak but who knows now.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - thw0223 - 02-23-2026 12:10 AM

(02-22-2026 10:45 PM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  A list like this that leaves off Ryan Leaf?

I’ll say this for Mandatich. After he left the NFL following three subpar seasons in 1992, he sobered up and returned to the league in 1996 and played three more years.

Leaf is a good one to bring up but was he that dominant in college?

As for Mandarich, I think he gets unfairly punished for the guys drafted around him. The other four picks in the top 5 of the 1989 draft are Hall of Famers: Aikman, Barry Sanders, Deion and Derrick Thomas.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - thw0223 - 02-23-2026 12:14 AM

(02-22-2026 11:15 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  Looking at my own, I'd have to include Rocket in this category, if for no other reason than his dominance at the college level. Arguably the best college player never to win a Heisman, almost certainly on the short list in that category. Literally a threat to score from anywhere in the field once he had the ball in his hands.

In the NFL, he had a decently lengthy career, but he bounced around among several teams and never became a true star.

What I think happened: in the NFL, he no longer was the fastest guy on the field. And his lack of size finally caught up with him at the NFL level.

Looked up his stats and definitely played longer then I expected with nine seasons.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - Scoochpooch1 - 02-23-2026 12:29 AM

(02-22-2026 10:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

CJ Stroud would like a word, he seems to be doing ok:

https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id/4432577/cj-stroud

Based on expectations, hes doing poorly.
The league average QB rating is around 91-92. So after a stellar rookie season (defenses with zero film apparently), he was below average the next season and at average this year (below avg counting playoffs). All the while playing in the terrible AFC South, so he was below avg.

It was only a month ago too, look at these putrid playoff performances:

21-32 250 1-1 and 5 fumbles.
20-47 212 1-4 (Below 50% in today's no defense allowed NFL)

Hes already the best OSU QB in NFL history with merely avg numbers. Tomczak is #2.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - The Cutter of Bish - 02-23-2026 07:52 AM

(02-22-2026 11:15 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  Looking at my own, I'd have to include Rocket in this category, if for no other reason than his dominance at the college level. Arguably the best college player never to win a Heisman, almost certainly on the short list in that category. Literally a threat to score from anywhere in the field once he had the ball in his hands.

In the NFL, he had a decently lengthy career, but he bounced around among several teams and never became a true star.

What I think happened: in the NFL, he no longer was the fastest guy on the field. And his lack of size finally caught up with him at the NFL level.

I applaud what he did for himself with the CFL stint. Go and get yourself paid. Screw that whole "pay your dues."

But, doing so put the target on his back. I think the speed caught up with him, but so did some of the years he lost in Canada, and some politics in the NFL when he did decide to play in it, too.

I don't look at him "disappearing" the same way as others. There, I look to RB's like Salaam, Carter, and Phillips. QB's like Frazier, and the FSU QB's in the mid-90's (Kannell and Busby).


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - quo vadis - 02-23-2026 08:11 AM

(02-22-2026 09:45 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

Yeah, all OSU and PSU qbs. And the obligatory Tebow reference too.

Tebow didn't disappear though. He caused a sensation when he debuted in the NFL. It didn't last, it quickly became clear he couldn't play NFL QB, but his profile remained high and does to this day.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - tf8693 - 02-23-2026 10:27 AM

(02-23-2026 07:52 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 11:15 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  Looking at my own, I'd have to include Rocket in this category, if for no other reason than his dominance at the college level. Arguably the best college player never to win a Heisman, almost certainly on the short list in that category. Literally a threat to score from anywhere in the field once he had the ball in his hands.

In the NFL, he had a decently lengthy career, but he bounced around among several teams and never became a true star.

What I think happened: in the NFL, he no longer was the fastest guy on the field. And his lack of size finally caught up with him at the NFL level.

I applaud what he did for himself with the CFL stint. Go and get yourself paid. Screw that whole "pay your dues."

But, doing so put the target on his back. I think the speed caught up with him, but so did some of the years he lost in Canada, and some politics in the NFL when he did decide to play in it, too.

I don't look at him "disappearing" the same way as others. There, I look to RB's like Salaam, Carter, and Phillips. QB's like Frazier, and the FSU QB's in the mid-90's (Kannell and Busby).

I think what happened to Phillips was pretty obvious to anyone who was paying attention, although full disclosure: I listened to Jim Rome a lot in those days, and he talked about Phillips on practically a daily basis, so perhaps my perspective was slightly skewed. Frazier was a great college quarterback whose game didn't really translate to the next level.

As for Rocket, a few close comparisons are at least somewhat illustrative. He had a similar pro career to his brother Qadry despite a far more spectacular college career. And in college, he overshadowed his college teammate, Ricky Watters, but Ricky had the better pro career of the two. Tim Brown, to whom Rocket drew a lot of comparison in college, had a Hall of Fame NFL career. Tbf, both Watters and Brown were a little bit bigger than Ismail, which may have helped them in the NFL. And IIRC, Rocket only played two seasons in Canada, so I'm not sure that had a huge adverse impact on his pro career.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - ken d - 02-23-2026 10:49 AM

Before reading the article, the first name that popped into my mind was Johnny Manziel, so I was glad to see he made the list. But, to be honest, I really didn't recognize the names of the other four players.


What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - thw0223 - 02-23-2026 11:53 AM

(02-23-2026 10:49 AM)ken d Wrote:  Before reading the article, the first name that popped into my mind was Johnny Manziel, so I was glad to see he made the list. But, to be honest, I really didn't recognize the names of the other four players.


That probably speaks well to how quickly they disappeared I guess.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - SoCalBobcat78 - 02-23-2026 01:36 PM

(02-23-2026 12:29 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 10:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

CJ Stroud would like a word, he seems to be doing ok:

https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id/4432577/cj-stroud

Based on expectations, hes doing poorly.
The league average QB rating is around 91-92. So after a stellar rookie season (defenses with zero film apparently), he was below average the next season and at average this year (below avg counting playoffs). All the while playing in the terrible AFC South, so he was below avg.

It was only a month ago too, look at these putrid playoff performances:

21-32 250 1-1 and 5 fumbles.
20-47 212 1-4 (Below 50% in today's no defense allowed NFL)

Hes already the best OSU QB in NFL history with merely avg numbers. Tomczak is #2.

Stroud was the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year in 2023, threw for over 4,000 yards in 15 games, and was named to the Pro Bowl. That season alone tells you how good he is. He has led his team to the playoffs every season and won a playoff game every season. In his second season he was sacked 52 times, which was second highest among NFL quarterbacks in 2024. The offensive line has been a problem.

The Texans need to get better around Stoud on offense. The Texans have salary cap issues, but they will have six draft picks in the first 4 rounds of the 2026 NFL Draft. They are going to pay Stroud a huge contract extension in the spring or summer (ESPN estimates a $224 million, four-year deal). You just don't do that for an average QB.

Ohio State is the "three yards and a cloud of dust" football program. Developing great quarterbacks is not in their history. But they have been getting better at that position in the past decade. Justin Fields was a first-round pick, and while he has not done much in the NFL, he does own the NFL regular season single game record for most rushing yards at 178. Julian Sayin, their current starting QB, is a first-round pick in the 2027 NFL draft.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - Just Joe - 02-23-2026 04:53 PM

(02-22-2026 09:45 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

Yeah, all OSU and PSU qbs. And the obligatory Tebow reference too.

Tebow went, IIRC, 7-4 as a starter one season and won a playoff game. Then he never started again, because NFL coaches like to get credit for being geniuses and don't want to "win ugly" every week with the wrong kind of QB.

For the record, I had no problem with Denver dropping him to get a couple of years of Peyton in or near his prime. But there weren't 31 QBs better than Tebow the following year, just guys that weren't going to cause coaches headaches.


RE: What College Football Stars Disappeared in the NFL? - RUScarlets - 02-24-2026 08:09 AM

(02-23-2026 12:29 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 10:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-22-2026 08:06 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  Could probably list a million guys, starting with every Ohio State QB.

CJ Stroud would like a word, he seems to be doing ok:

https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id/4432577/cj-stroud

Based on expectations, hes doing poorly.
The league average QB rating is around 91-92. So after a stellar rookie season (defenses with zero film apparently), he was below average the next season and at average this year (below avg counting playoffs). All the while playing in the terrible AFC South, so he was below avg.

It was only a month ago too, look at these putrid playoff performances:

21-32 250 1-1 and 5 fumbles.
20-47 212 1-4 (Below 50% in today's no defense allowed NFL)

Hes already the best OSU QB in NFL history with merely avg numbers. Tomczak is #2.

Yeah... Texans will probably get rid of Stroud after this year if he doesn't make a run in the playoffs. He had a brutal game, but it was hardly a one game anomaly.