![]() |
|
NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? (/thread-1024930.html) |
NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - johnbragg - 02-15-2026 09:42 AM Chatter has been for a while that the blue bloods weren't happy with the endless expansion of FBS. Mountain West Commissioner Nevarez pretty much confirmed this, when she said that they didn't bring up any FCS programs in the rebuild because they were afraid that the rules would change midstream and they'd be stuck. North Dakota State is debateable on its own. On the one hand, they're in the middle of nowhere. On the other hand, they have 10 FCS titles in 15 years, 5 in a row etc etc. Sacramento State flat out bought their way into FBS, with the MAC splitting the bribe. As a first step, do the SEC and Big Ten push to raise that entry fee to $25M? If schools are stroking that check to move up, shouldn't it go to the NCAA rather than the conference? If the school can afford to bribe the conference on top of that, maybe revisit. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - GoBuckeyes1047 - 02-15-2026 09:52 AM My preferred option is the P4 either form a new subdivision for football or football breakaway from the NCAA further than they already have while the G6 maintains FBS, but I don't think I'll get my way. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - EOU93 - 02-15-2026 09:59 AM (02-15-2026 09:42 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Chatter has been for a while that the blue bloods weren't happy with the endless expansion of FBS. Mountain West Commissioner Nevarez pretty much confirmed this, when she said that they didn't bring up any FCS programs in the rebuild because they were afraid that the rules would change midstream and they'd be stuck. What is it to the P4 if G6 schools elevate FCS schools? They are not taking any part of their pie. The G6 conferences are sharing their piece of the pie with the FCS schools they elevate. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Gemofthehills - 02-15-2026 10:04 AM Schools should be able to play at whatever level they desire. It is a shame one public institution is raping another. Public universities should be limited on the amount of funds provided to athletics. These funds should be used to reduce tutition. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - andybible1995 - 02-15-2026 10:07 AM (02-15-2026 09:59 AM)EOU93 Wrote:(02-15-2026 09:42 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Chatter has been for a while that the blue bloods weren't happy with the endless expansion of FBS. Mountain West Commissioner Nevarez pretty much confirmed this, when she said that they didn't bring up any FCS programs in the rebuild because they were afraid that the rules would change midstream and they'd be stuck. People have been led to believe that the Big Ten and the SEC have forbidden FCS schools from moving up to Group conferences, which is false. I discovered that after doing my own research on the claim. The real concentration is the CFP financial distribution, which trickles down to the Group conferences. But, even in a expanded playoff, the Group conferences would be sending only one representative. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Glenn360 - 02-15-2026 10:16 AM I feel the composition of G6 conferences is way down the line of priorities for Sankey and Petiti RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - andybible1995 - 02-15-2026 10:19 AM (02-15-2026 10:16 AM)Glenn360 Wrote: I feel the composition of G6 conferences is way down the line of priorities for Sankey and Petiti Exactly. Besides, (and I hate to pull a David here) the Big Ten and the SEC cannot tell the FCS what to do, nor have they told the FCS that they cannot allow any more call ups to join the Group conferences. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - quo vadis - 02-15-2026 10:27 AM IMO, the only time the Power conferences really cared about the expansion of FBS was 12+ years ago, when they feared that soon G schools would outnumber P schools, and thus under the rules of that time, be able to out-vote them on key NCAA issues. That problem was solved by the creation of "Autonomy" conferences. So I don't think the SEC and B1G care much if the bottom rung of the G6 keep brining up FCS schools. The only thing that could IMO bother them about that is if the expanded Gs want more CFP money so as to not dilute their share of that money. But IIRC the P2 are well aware of that and have made it clear that the G-share of CFP money isn't going up, so if a the MW or MAC or CUSA or whoever wants to bring up an FCS, they have to finance that out of their fixed share of CFP money. That's my understanding, at least. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Xavier Cage - 02-15-2026 10:50 AM The B1G & SEC force a new middle tier in FBS. They are the P2 (Premier 2) and kings of FBS. A new A4 (Autonomous 4?) tier of ACC, Big XII, American & PAC is created. Then the G4 (Group of 4) of MWC, SBC, MAC & SBC at the entry level. CFP money will be divided based on these 3 tiers. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - andybible1995 - 02-15-2026 10:51 AM (02-15-2026 10:50 AM)Xavier Cage Wrote: The B1G & SEC force a new middle tier in FBS. They are the P2 (Premier 2) and kings of FBS. A new A4 (Autonomous 4?) tier of ACC, Big XII, American & PAC is created. Then the G4 (Group of 4) of MWC, SBC, MAC & SBC at the entry level. Sir, this isn't European soccer. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Frank the Tank - 02-15-2026 11:16 AM There’s rarely just one thing that drives decisions, but rather a spectrum. I believe that the P4 and especially Big Ten and SEC very much do not want dilution of any of their revenue and voting power due to the addition of more FBS teams. For all of the squabbling between the Big Ten and SEC lately, the one thing that they agree on is that they should be the two conferences that run college football (if either one of them can’t be the only single conference running college football). It’s classic Cold War geopolitics akin to the US vs. USSR - they may not agree on much and either one *could* blow everything up, but they do agree that nothing should be done unless both of them agree on an action. The Big Ten and SEC would rather have total inaction than allow for the ACC and Big 12 to gain back power or heaven forbid any of the G6 conferences.on that sense, it doesn’t matter whether there are 140 FBS schools or 1400 FBS schools as long as the control continues to rest with the P2. Tangential to that point, the P4 have been clear that the G6 is getting a fixed amount of dollars from the CFP regardless of how many schools that they have, so they need to subsidize whoever they add in expansion. That’s likely why we’re seeing such huge entry fee payments from North Dakota State to the MWC and Sacramento State to the MAC - they all need to make those conferences financially whole for diluting their individual school CFP shares more. So, the P4 might be annoyed by more FBS schools, but they’ve mitigated the two biggest issues where more FBS schools would directly have a negative impact on them. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - johnbragg - 02-15-2026 11:45 AM (02-15-2026 09:59 AM)EOU93 Wrote: What is it to the P4 if G6 schools elevate FCS schools? They are not taking any part of their pie. The G6 conferences are sharing their piece of the pie with the FCS schools they elevate. (02-15-2026 11:16 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: There’s rarely just one thing that drives decisions, but rather a spectrum. Let me try to phrase my point another way. The Mountain West and the MAC just got a pile of money The Big Ten and SEC didn't get any of it. I don't think the Big Ten and SEC think that's how things should work. Money in the FBS ecosystem is the rightful property of the blue-blood programs who create the value and generate that money. If FBS membership is valuable, and we've established a market price of $17-$20M, ($5M fee to the NCAA, the rest to the conferences). I expect they'll rebalance that fee so that the lions share goes to the NCAA and the conference gets much less. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - IWokeUpLikeThis - 02-15-2026 11:50 AM FBS fee is moving to 8 figures. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Frank the Tank - 02-15-2026 12:06 PM (02-15-2026 11:45 AM)johnbragg Wrote:(02-15-2026 09:59 AM)EOU93 Wrote: What is it to the P4 if G6 schools elevate FCS schools? They are not taking any part of their pie. The G6 conferences are sharing their piece of the pie with the FCS schools they elevate. But the P4 just clawed most/all of the power in college football *from* the NCAA. They *want* the conferences to have control as opposed to the NCAA. So, in that sense, it’s a “What’s good for the goose is good for the gander.” It’s not that the Big Ten and SEC necessarily love the addition of FBS schools, but having the entry fee/move-up money going to the NCAA to then get split among thousands of schools at all levels definitely isn’t what they want, either. Having the conferences being able to dictate the value in their leagues is exactly what the Big Ten and SEC want - any free market argument (as opposed to the top down governance structure of the NCAA) helps the Big Ten and SEC more than anyone else. If anything, it’s like when a pro sports franchise gets sold for a huge price. There are few things that that NFL and especially MLB/NBA/NHL owners love more than when an MLS franchise gets sold for a huge number (the equivalent of a G6 pro league compared to the Big 4 pro sports leagues). If people are paying huge amounts for an MLS team, then that’s raising the value of every team in the Big 4 pro sports league that have even more value dramatically. The same thing is happening now in college sports: if a spot in the G6 is worth close to $20 million in entry fees, then think of what the P4 leagues can charge if/when they expand again. Heck, we essentially saw what the price of going from G5 to P4 is in today’s market with SMU foregoing ACC conference TV revenue for years. See how Memphis was having to offer an equivalent financial deal to try to get a Big 12 invite. I think this is great for every FBS school - these high entry fees are establishing how much even the lowest schools in the FBS totem pole are worth if they were sold as a “franchise” in a pro sports sense. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - The Beaver - 02-15-2026 12:14 PM With the scholarship limits eliminated post-House and the attendance minimum eliminated shortly before it there really is nothing more than cultural stigma and a one-time entry fee separating FCS and FBS. I'm not necessarily a fan of the mandatory power team OOC schedules that Jrsec has repeatedly proposed but they certainly would go a long way towards solving "the problem." Split teams so they never/hardly ever play, after which point it is very easy to justify excluding them from your playoffs and then you've practically created the third DI subdivision. It wouldn't be hard to re-instate minimums around, say, spending and/or attendance to restore a floor to "new FBS" either but there seems to be opposition towards that coming from within the P4, and not just from the very bottom of the Big 12 and ACC either. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - bryanw1995 - 02-15-2026 12:57 PM (02-15-2026 10:19 AM)andybible1995 Wrote:(02-15-2026 10:16 AM)Glenn360 Wrote: I feel the composition of G6 conferences is way down the line of priorities for Sankey and Petiti Yeah, I think that we all might have read a bit too much into Sankey's comments last year about that. Or was it in 2024? Whatever, he sure gave the impression that more FCS callups weren't welcome. However, the way it was implemented was the way it was always implemented. ie: 5 g5 conferences that get to split the 10% g5 pie (soon to be 6 with the nuPac). If the pie doesn't get any larger with callups, and they can assume that they'll never get more than 10% of the CFP pie, then there is a natural reluctance for any g6 school to want to help any FCS move up and, eventually, further dilute their CFP money. Having said that, NDSU and Sac St are 2 very different animals: NDSU: paid $12m, but they get a full football membership in a strong MWC Sac St: paid $18m, and they get a temporary fb membership (and no conference money at all) in a very weak looking MAC NDSU will get CFP shares and full media rights payouts. However, Sac St will never dilute Toledo's shares unless Toledo and the rest decide that they want Sac St to permanently join the conference down the road. If anything, Sac St will probably end up diluting some other conference's CFP shares in the 2030s. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Yosef181 - 02-15-2026 12:59 PM Propagate a system that rewards those who pay a lot, and then complain about those who can afford to pay a lot. RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - bryanw1995 - 02-15-2026 12:59 PM (02-15-2026 10:50 AM)Xavier Cage Wrote: The B1G & SEC force a new middle tier in FBS. They are the P2 (Premier 2) and kings of FBS. A new A4 (Autonomous 4?) tier of ACC, Big XII, American & PAC is created. Then the G4 (Group of 4) of MWC, SBC, MAC & SBC at the entry level. Odd that an SDSU fan would think that his new conference, which can't seem to get paid very much, will ever be considered comparable to the ACC or Big 12. I wonder what TCU or GT fans would think about this comment? RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - Stay Cool - 02-15-2026 01:05 PM (02-15-2026 12:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(02-15-2026 10:50 AM)Xavier Cage Wrote: The B1G & SEC force a new middle tier in FBS. They are the P2 (Premier 2) and kings of FBS. A new A4 (Autonomous 4?) tier of ACC, Big XII, American & PAC is created. Then the G4 (Group of 4) of MWC, SBC, MAC & SBC at the entry level. It's almost typical of SDSU fans at this point, super weird RE: NSDU, Sac State buy their way into FBS. What's Sankey/Petiti's next move? - CFBLurker - 02-15-2026 01:14 PM I think the P2 opposition to move ups was tied to the House settlement. At this point it no longer matters |