![]() |
|
FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams (/thread-1024578.html) |
FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-09-2026 01:04 PM I thought it would be interesting looking back at the last 10 FCS playoffs to see how many schools left have an acceptable stadium (15,000 for this example) and the playoff success to say they belong. Also no Patriot, Ivy, Pioneer League, SWAC or MEAC as those schools are peferctly happy where they are. Listed by playoff appearances and best & most recent success: SDSU 10 (2025,2024,2023,2022,2021,2020,2019,2018,201,2016)-Champ '23 Montana St 7 (2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2019, 2018)-Champ 25' Montana 6 (2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2019)-Runner Up 23' Weber St 6 (2022, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016)-Semifinal 19' Illinois St 4 (2025, 2024, 2019, 2016)-Runner Up 25' Sacramento St 4 (2023, 2022, 2021, 2019)-Quarterinfinal 23' Furman 4 (2023, 2022, 2019, 2017)-Quarterfinal 23' Northern Iowa 4 (2021, 2019, 2018, 2017)-Quarterfinal 19' Idaho 3 (2024, 2023, 2022)-Quarterfinal 24' Southern Ill. 3 (2023, 2021, 2020)-Quarterfinal 20' Tarleton St 2 (2025, 2024)-Quarterfinal 25' Stephen F. Austin 2 (2025, 2021)-Quarterfinal 25' Eastern Kentucky 2 (2024, 2022)-First Round 24' Chattanooga 2 (2023, 2016)- 16 Round 23' Youngstown St 2 (2025, 2023)- 16 Round 23' Western Illinois 1 (2017)-First Round 17' RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Bobcat2013 - 02-09-2026 01:18 PM History has shown that neither playoff success (TXST) nor stadium size (SHSU, KSU, Missouri St) matter. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-09-2026 01:20 PM (02-09-2026 01:18 PM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: History has shown that neither playoff success (TXST) nor stadium size (SHSU, KSU, Missouri St) matter. Yeah for random FCS success. But if you look at the sustained success its SDSU, Montana, Montana at the top of the list with G6 level stadiums. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - goofus - 02-09-2026 01:43 PM I find it interesting that the directional Illinois schools (western and southern) are mentioned, only because many of us know that the directional schools in Illinois have been in enrollment free fall. About the only public schools that are growing in Illinois are UIUC, UIC and ILL St. Even NIU has been struggling with enrollment numbers. If Western ILL does anything, they should think of downgrading athletics to Div II, or maybe consider merging with another directional school. Ok, maybe thats an over-resction. WIU will probably be fine staying in FCS, but upgrading to FBS would be ridiculous at this time. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - goofus - 02-09-2026 01:48 PM I think that Northern Iowa has expressed no interest in the past in upgrading to FBS and thinks its in the perfect division for them right now. And I agree with that. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - goofus - 02-09-2026 01:52 PM (02-09-2026 01:43 PM)goofus Wrote: I find it interesting that the directional Illinois schools (western and southern) are mentioned, only because many of us know that the directional schools in Illinois have been in enrollment free fall. About the only public schools that are growing in Illinois are UIUC, UIC and ILL St. Even NIU has been struggling with enrollment numbers. Just to add some numbers to this Western Illinois University (WIU) has experienced a steady, significant decline in total enrollment over the past decade, dropping from over 11,000 in 2015 to roughly 5,337 in Fall 2025. The student body has decreased by over 4,700 in the last 10 years, with 71% of the 2024-25 population being undergraduate students. Key Historical Enrollment Trends (Fall Headcounts) Fall 2015: 11,094 Fall 2016: 10,373 Fall 2017: 9,441 Fall 2018: 8,502 Fall 2019: 7,624 Fall 2024: 6,332 Fall 2025: 5,337 RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-09-2026 01:53 PM (02-09-2026 01:43 PM)goofus Wrote: I find it interesting that the directional Illinois schools (western and southern) are mentioned, only because many of us know that the directional schools in Illinois have been in enrollment free fall. About the only public schools that are growing in Illinois are UIUC, UIC and ILL St. Even NIU has been struggling with enrollment numbers. If the very top of FCS (SDSU, Montana's) leave it will open up the FCS playoffs for the schools sitting below. Open it up for the ones that really belong in FCS not just those stuck there. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - solohawks - 02-09-2026 03:18 PM NC A&T should be on that list...they have also suggested they would be interested in upgrading RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - DFW HOYA - 02-09-2026 03:26 PM (02-09-2026 01:04 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Listed by playoff appearances and best & most recent success: These schools also share three things in common: 1) almost no flagships ; 2) no Eastern schools, and 3) only one private university listed. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-09-2026 03:53 PM (02-09-2026 03:18 PM)solohawks Wrote: NC A&T should be on that list...they have also suggested they would be interested in upgrading They made the playoffs 1 time in 2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCAA_Division_I_Football_Championship RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-09-2026 03:59 PM (02-09-2026 03:26 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-09-2026 01:04 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Listed by playoff appearances and best & most recent success: I did not include Patriot/Pioneer/Ivy/MEAC/SWAC. Lamar I was thinking about but forgot to put in. 16,000 seats and they made the playoff in 2025 & 2018 though didn't advance. Tarleton obviously is on the rise and in a few years will probably have more playoff appearances under their belt. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - solohawks - 02-09-2026 04:07 PM (02-09-2026 03:53 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:(02-09-2026 03:18 PM)solohawks Wrote: NC A&T should be on that list...they have also suggested they would be interested in upgrading And the Celebration Bowl 4 times 2015, and 2017-2019. They were rocking and rolling before COVID RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Scoochpooch1 - 02-09-2026 09:46 PM (02-09-2026 01:18 PM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: History has shown that neither playoff success (TXST) nor stadium size (SHSU, KSU, Missouri St) matter. And none of those 4 should be in FBS. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Outsider - 02-11-2026 10:07 AM (02-09-2026 03:59 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:(02-09-2026 03:26 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:(02-09-2026 01:04 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Listed by playoff appearances and best & most recent success: ACU could easily be on this list being in the playoffs, and advancing, the last two years. Their stadium can easily have a second level added to the visitor's side for expansion. The problem is that they aren't any type of flagship school being private, and they are in a small, non-market, area. I don't think ACU wants to move up, or necessarily should, but wouldn't leave them off of any list. ACU isn't busting at any enrollment seems either but that isn't necessarily a requirement to play FBS football. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Outsider - 02-11-2026 10:08 AM I also feel "moving up" has no real meaning anymore in todays FBS/FCS landscape. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - ken d - 02-11-2026 11:02 AM (02-09-2026 01:04 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: I thought it would be interesting looking back at the last 10 FCS playoffs to see how many schools left have an acceptable stadium (15,000 for this example) and the playoff success to say they belong. Also no Patriot, Ivy, Pioneer League, SWAC or MEAC as those schools are peferctly happy where they are. I'd say they all belong in FCS, but then I realized you meant "belong in FBS". I'd have a hard time saying any of those schools "belong" in FBS, but I'm sure some aspire to it nevertheless. By the time they get there, there's a good chance that FBS will be the second of three tiers in D-I football. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Max Power - 02-11-2026 11:03 AM (02-09-2026 01:04 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: to see how many schools left have an acceptable stadium (15,000 for this example) Illinois St's stadium is 13,391. RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-11-2026 01:57 PM (02-11-2026 11:03 AM)Max Power Wrote:(02-09-2026 01:04 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: to see how many schools left have an acceptable stadium (15,000 for this example) Close enough when you factor in SRO. Illinois State is already part of a handful of teams that have made a Semifinal or better the past 10 years in the FCS playoffs with a credible FBS stadium that haven't yet moved up. SDSU 10 (2025,2024,2023,2022,2021,2020,2019,2018,201,2016)-Champ '23 Montana St 7 (2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2019, 2018)-Champ 25' Montana 6 (2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2019)-Runner Up 23' Weber St 6 (2022, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016)-Semifinal 19' Illinois St 4 (2025, 2024, 2019, 2016)-Runner Up 25' RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - Garden_KC - 02-16-2026 02:41 AM Scratch Sacramento State off the list with the invite to the MAC. Illinois St is actually #2 playoff success wise the past 10 years out of remaining MVC FB teams. Tarleton definitely looks on the way up with two recent playoff appearances. SDSU 10 (2025,2024,2023,2022,2021,2020,2019,2018,201,2016)-Champ '23 Montana St 7 (2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2019, 2018)-Champ 25' Montana 6 (2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2019)-Runner Up 23' Weber St 6 (2022, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016)-Semifinal 19' Illinois St 4 (2025, 2024, 2019, 2016)-Runner Up 25' Furman 4 (2023, 2022, 2019, 2017)-Quarterfinal 23' Northern Iowa 4 (2021, 2019, 2018, 2017)-Quarterfinal 19' Idaho 3 (2024, 2023, 2022)-Quarterfinal 24' Southern Ill. 3 (2023, 2021, 2020)-Quarterfinal 20' Tarleton St 2 (2025, 2024)-Quarterfinal 25' Stephen F. Austin 2 (2025, 2021)-Quarterfinal 25'' Chattanooga 2 (2023, 2016)- 16 Round 23' Youngstown St 2 (2025, 2023)- 16 Round 23' Lamar 2 (2025, 2017)-First Round 25' Eastern Kentucky 2 (2024, 2022)-First Round 24' Western Illinois 1 (2017)-First Round 17' North Carolina A&T 1 (2016)-First Round 16' RE: FCS Schools Still Busting at the Seams - The Sicatoka - 02-16-2026 08:45 AM The 15k rule is dead. And I'd rather play in a full house. |