CSNbbs
Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment (/thread-1024320.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - billybobby777 - 02-05-2026 09:12 AM

1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Big Frog II - 02-05-2026 09:14 AM

(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.
Yes


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - goofus - 02-05-2026 09:22 AM

My initial reaction was that UNLV and AFA were just as much losers as the Pac members that rejected the reverse merger. My thought was that UNLV and AFA could have got more media dollars with a reverse merger. But then it occurred to me I guess that is balanced out by the extra dollars they have been promised from the exit fees and poaching fees.

But wait a minute, the poaching fees and exit fees are still hung up in court. So until that is settled, it may be premature to call UNLV and AFA "winners" or even "break even". Maybe they can be declared winners in 2027 if the get a good settlement in court, but not yet. Until, then I am calling losers just like the Pac members that left them behind.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - TUowl06 - 02-05-2026 09:36 AM

Patriot League Football with the addition of Villanova and William & Mary.

Not only does it make the league stronger, there are reasons to believe it will help to increase interest in FCS football in the Northeast. The traditional nature of Ivy and Patriot League and the better CAA programs align with the senses of this region more so than the quasi-professional FBS ranks. Obviously, Penn State, Notre Dame, and a few others still have the pull in this region of the country.

The PL is now a MORE powerful collection of institutions when it comes to governance/policy development. Likewise, the Ivy League and NESCAC have tremendous influence, both directly and indirectly.

Naturally, this is all in context.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - billybobby777 - 02-05-2026 10:44 AM

(02-05-2026 09:22 AM)goofus Wrote:  My initial reaction was that UNLV and AFA were just as much losers as the Pac members that rejected the reverse merger. My thought was that UNLV and AFA could have got more media dollars with a reverse merger. But then it occurred to me I guess that is balanced out by the extra dollars they have been promised from the exit fees and poaching fees.

But wait a minute, the poaching fees and exit fees are still hung up in court. So until that is settled, it may be premature to call UNLV and AFA "winners" or even "break even". Maybe they can be declared winners in 2027 if the get a good settlement in court, but not yet. Until, then I am calling losers just like the Pac members that left them behind.

But do you think AF and UNLV were against a reverse merger? I think they would have gone for it. I think Air Force is in a decent position here overall though. Stay in MWC and make (potentially) more $, have an easier schedule in fb and basketball and have options to move to PAC or AC if they want to.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Memphis Yankee - 02-05-2026 10:45 AM

(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - DFW HOYA - 02-05-2026 10:49 AM

(02-05-2026 09:36 AM)TUowl06 Wrote:  Patriot League Football with the addition of Villanova and William & Mary. Not only does it make the league stronger, there are reasons to believe it will help to increase interest in FCS football in the Northeast.

Agreed. The PL now has five of the better FCS rivalry games of the year within its confines:

Lafayette-Lehigh
Richmond-William & Mary
Georgetown-Villanova
Fordham-Holy Cross
Bucknell-Colgate


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - billybobby777 - 02-05-2026 11:08 AM

(02-05-2026 10:45 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.

If what you described had happened then yes, that would have been a success. Gould fumbled repeatedly with this. The arrogance with the pac 12 leadership was in full display blowing an opportunity to take Memphis, Tulane and even USF who likely would have followed those two. What an absolute failure. There are things we can’t control in realignment but these were unforced errors.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Formerluerker_redbirdfan - 02-05-2026 11:20 AM

(02-05-2026 11:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 10:45 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.

If what you described had happened then yes, that would have been a success. Gould fumbled repeatedly with this. The arrogance with the pac 12 leadership was in full display blowing an opportunity to take Memphis, Tulane and even USF who likely would have followed those two. What an absolute failure. There are things we can’t control in realignment but these were unforced errors.

totally, I think they needed to be willing to just straight up pay someone in the Americans entire buy out, in order to destabilize the league. They should have just gone to north texas and been like "what do you need?" instead they wanted to spread the money out, tiny payments to tulane and memphis who are 1. making more money in the tv deal and 2. would incur much more travel costs (Dallas is closer and DFW is probably the best airport to be located near in overall realignment terms). I think at a minimum, even if Memphis and Tulane stay, you can probably snag Wichita St for olympics, and still take USU, who is actually a decent add anyway (basketball, growing Utah market, etc) even a UTSA is 100% in play here. you have 8/10 or 9/10 split and if USF goes to the ACC in a few years, Tulane and Memphis pretty much have to go to the PAC.

Now? I mean, even if Memphis got a big east invite, I think they would still be ok parking fb only in the American, which, unfortunately the american would probably have to accept. And Tulane is probably unpoachable too. I still think Wichita would go if offered though.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - AztecEmpire - 02-05-2026 11:27 AM

SDSU will play Gonzaga every year in hoops and eliminate the worst front-range schools from their travel schedule. Then there is all of the conference BB and FB games that will be aired over the air....hell we could breakeven on the media deal compared to what we were paid in the MW and it would still be a massive win.

I also think the MW won in that it is clear schools in the east that are not at the power level have a big problem in the form of always competing with bigger conferences for the same slots. The MW won't have the same linear exposure as the PAC, but MW FB and BB will be easier to watch than the AAC. The 4th window is saving the western conferences bacon.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Garden_KC - 02-05-2026 11:31 AM

Because of this PAC/MWC split CUSA lost both UTEP & Louisiana Tech putting them into a more unstable position.

Now CUSA only has WKU, MT & FIU leftover from CUSA 3.0.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - ken d - 02-05-2026 12:09 PM

(02-05-2026 11:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 10:45 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.

If what you described had happened then yes, that would have been a success. Gould fumbled repeatedly with this. The arrogance with the pac 12 leadership was in full display blowing an opportunity to take Memphis, Tulane and even USF who likely would have followed those two. What an absolute failure. There are things we can’t control in realignment but these were unforced errors.

Imagine if, as soon as the PAC was down to two schools, they had invited Boise State, Fresno State, SDSU, Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. That's 9 quality programs, and while it doesn't completely kill the MWC or AAC, it certainly relegates them to permanent G status well behind the new PAC, which would free up media money down the road with which to give the PAC a much better payout than they eventually got. Still not M2 money, but likely 3X what any other G conference would command.

But life is full of what ifs, isn't it?


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Dr Dawgma III - 02-05-2026 12:15 PM

UTEP and it's not even close.

Gonzaga stepped up significantly.

I like the PL additions as well.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - Dr Dawgma III - 02-05-2026 12:16 PM

(02-05-2026 09:36 AM)TUowl06 Wrote:  Patriot League Football with the addition of Villanova and William & Mary.

Not only does it make the league stronger, there are reasons to believe it will help to increase interest in FCS football in the Northeast. The traditional nature of Ivy and Patriot League and the better CAA programs align with the senses of this region more so than the quasi-professional FBS ranks. Obviously, Penn State, Notre Dame, and a few others still have the pull in this region of the country.

The PL is now a MORE powerful collection of institutions when it comes to governance/policy development. Likewise, the Ivy League and NESCAC have tremendous influence, both directly and indirectly.

Naturally, this is all in context.

100%. Excellent post.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - billybobby777 - 02-05-2026 12:18 PM

(02-05-2026 12:09 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 11:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 10:45 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.

If what you described had happened then yes, that would have been a success. Gould fumbled repeatedly with this. The arrogance with the pac 12 leadership was in full display blowing an opportunity to take Memphis, Tulane and even USF who likely would have followed those two. What an absolute failure. There are things we can’t control in realignment but these were unforced errors.

Imagine if, as soon as the PAC was down to two schools, they had invited Boise State, Fresno State, SDSU, Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. That's 9 quality programs, and while it doesn't completely kill the MWC or AAC, it certainly relegates them to permanent G status well behind the new PAC, which would free up media money down the road with which to give the PAC a much better payout than they eventually got. Still not M2 money, but likely 3X what any other G conference would command.

But life is full of what ifs, isn't it?

As the singer in Fuel says “it was in my hands” (again). It was all there for the taking for the PAC. Memphis wanted out of the AC badly and were ready to join. Tulane and others would have followed. They fumbled on the 1 yard line and the other team picked up the football and ran it back for a game winning TD.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - AztecEmpire - 02-05-2026 12:29 PM

(02-05-2026 12:18 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 12:09 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 11:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 10:45 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.

If what you described had happened then yes, that would have been a success. Gould fumbled repeatedly with this. The arrogance with the pac 12 leadership was in full display blowing an opportunity to take Memphis, Tulane and even USF who likely would have followed those two. What an absolute failure. There are things we can’t control in realignment but these were unforced errors.

Imagine if, as soon as the PAC was down to two schools, they had invited Boise State, Fresno State, SDSU, Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. That's 9 quality programs, and while it doesn't completely kill the MWC or AAC, it certainly relegates them to permanent G status well behind the new PAC, which would free up media money down the road with which to give the PAC a much better payout than they eventually got. Still not M2 money, but likely 3X what any other G conference would command.

But life is full of what ifs, isn't it?

As the singer in Fuel says “it was in my hands” (again). It was all there for the taking for the PAC. Memphis wanted out of the AC badly and were ready to join. Tulane and others would have followed. They fumbled on the 1 yard line and the other team picked up the football and ran it back for a game winning TD.

Or, the AAC and ESPN made sure they didnt lose Memphis by changing the way distrbutions are done(AAC) and then altering the ACC terms so a date certain for the poaching of the ACC became known. Memphis is a decent AD, but they arent better than Boise in FB, or BB than the Zags or the Aztecs. If they dont get that ACC invite they will have made a mistake if the PAC poaches UNM and UNLV creating the 6th best BB conference without Memphis and friends.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - ken d - 02-05-2026 12:30 PM

(02-05-2026 12:18 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 12:09 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 11:08 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 10:45 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(02-05-2026 09:12 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  1. Northern Illinois-Better conf, more $. Better exposure. No more Tuesday night games.
2. UTEP- back with longtime western rivals. More $.
3. Grand Canyon- good western competition, more $.
4. UC Davis-better competition, more $, in position for FBS conference membership.
5. Hawaii-Olympic sports in MWC, no travel subsidies, national tv.
6. Texas St-More $, better competition.
7. Louisiana Tech-in conf with regional rivals and better competition.

Break evens: UNLV, Air Force, Gonzaga: more $ in sweetheart deal.

Losers: everybody else in PAC & MWC because $ was left in the table by not doing a reverse merger.

I disagree. Imagine you're in a conference with USC/Oregon/Washington etc. Then you have to drop down to the G5. That had to be a tough pill to swallow. At the very least you want to be with the best of the G5. Not with a bunch of bottom feeders in the MWC.

Even Memphis and Tulane wouldn't have done that. They'd have to take a pay cut with increased expenses. No way would two P teams do it, even if they are at the lower end of the P spectrum.

The Pac has a much better pool to select from than the MWC going forward. Merging with the MWC would have benefited the Mountain West, but not the P2 teams.

Their goal was to re-imagine/rebuild the PAC. They failed. They couldn't get the top of the AAC because they couldn't get a media deal ironed out. Gould was arrogant in her approach towards those teams, like it was a privilege. She couldn't get UNLV either.

After she screwed that up, she panicked by taking Utah State and Texas State trying to get to eight teams. If she would have played her cards right, which she didn't, she could have had this for a conference.

Boise State
Colorado State
Fresno State
Memphis
Oregon State
San Diego State
Tulane
UNLV
UTSA
Washington State

Gonzaga
Wichita State or St. Mary's

That would have been close to an M conference.

If what you described had happened then yes, that would have been a success. Gould fumbled repeatedly with this. The arrogance with the pac 12 leadership was in full display blowing an opportunity to take Memphis, Tulane and even USF who likely would have followed those two. What an absolute failure. There are things we can’t control in realignment but these were unforced errors.

Imagine if, as soon as the PAC was down to two schools, they had invited Boise State, Fresno State, SDSU, Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. That's 9 quality programs, and while it doesn't completely kill the MWC or AAC, it certainly relegates them to permanent G status well behind the new PAC, which would free up media money down the road with which to give the PAC a much better payout than they eventually got. Still not M2 money, but likely 3X what any other G conference would command.

But life is full of what ifs, isn't it?

As the singer in Fuel says “it was in my hands” (again). It was all there for the taking for the PAC. Memphis wanted out of the AC badly and were ready to join. Tulane and others would have followed. They fumbled on the 1 yard line and the other team picked up the football and ran it back for a game winning TD.

That 9 team conference would have left the MWC with 9 members and the AC with 10. Looking at every conference's 5 year average Sagarin strength rating, the following picture is striking.

76 Big 12
73 ACC
71 PAC
63 SBC
62 MWC
61 AAC
58 MAC
56 USA

Would the media narrative have been that the new PAC is an M conference or a G conference?


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - UTEPDallas - 02-05-2026 01:12 PM

What most people forget is no matter how desperate you are in leaving a conference, it all comes down to a financial decision that makes sense. Memphis wasn’t going to leave a guaranteed $7 million a year from the American tv contract for an unknown amount in the Pac-12. The only advantage the Pac-12 had over the American was the basketball credits of the departing schools, the last two years of the Rose Bowl contact and the conference name.

When Memphis announced in late 2011 or early 2012 they were leaving C-USA for the Big East, the conference still had the BCS AQ, the C7, better tv exposure and money, and a reunion with Louisville and Cincinnati. The Pac-12 didn’t come close to match any of that. OTOH, Boise State, San Diego State, Fresno State, Colorado State and Utah State made the decision without knowing what tv partners were on board and how much they were going to be paid (we now know the former but not the latter).

That’s the main difference between Memphis, Tulane, USF and UTSA and the MWC defectors. The first three might desperate to leave the American but not that desperate to take an offer without any financial details that can justify the move. The only way American schools can move to the Pac-12 is if ESPN dramatically decreases the new tv contract and most games get relegated to ESPNU and ESPN+. ESPN might need more tv slots if they want to get the Big Ten again. That doesn’t look good for any G6 conference that will renew with ESPN once the current Big Ten contract comes for renegotiations.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - bryanw1995 - 02-05-2026 01:18 PM

(02-05-2026 09:22 AM)goofus Wrote:  My initial reaction was that UNLV and AFA were just as much losers as the Pac members that rejected the reverse merger. My thought was that UNLV and AFA could have got more media dollars with a reverse merger. But then it occurred to me I guess that is balanced out by the extra dollars they have been promised from the exit fees and poaching fees.

But wait a minute, the poaching fees and exit fees are still hung up in court. So until that is settled, it may be premature to call UNLV and AFA "winners" or even "break even". Maybe they can be declared winners in 2027 if the get a good settlement in court, but not yet. Until, then I am calling losers just like the Pac members that left them behind.

The very fact of the (assumed) low Pac media rights agreement certainly doesn't help the MWC's legal case. How does "we lost a few schools and gained a few schools but our payouts remained the same" justify $100m worth of exit fees? Boise was the only departure worth big $$, and they had their own separate carveout already.


RE: Biggest winners in 2026 conference realignment - AztecEmpire - 02-05-2026 01:39 PM

(02-05-2026 01:12 PM)UTEPDallas Wrote:  What most people forget is no matter how desperate you are in leaving a conference, it all comes down to a financial decision that makes sense. Memphis wasn’t going to leave a guaranteed $7 million a year from the American tv contract for an unknown amount in the Pac-12. The only advantage the Pac-12 had over the American was the basketball credits of the departing schools, the last two years of the Rose Bowl contact and the conference name.

When Memphis announced in late 2011 or early 2012 they were leaving C-USA for the Big East, the conference still had the BCS AQ, the C7, better tv exposure and money, and a reunion with Louisville and Cincinnati. The Pac-12 didn’t come close to match any of that. OTOH, Boise State, San Diego State, Fresno State, Colorado State and Utah State made the decision without knowing what tv partners were on board and how much they were going to be paid (we now know the former but not the latter).

That’s the main difference between Memphis, Tulane, USF and UTSA and the MWC defectors. The first three might desperate to leave the American but not that desperate to take an offer without any financial details that can justify the move. The only way American schools can move to the Pac-12 is if ESPN dramatically decreases the new tv contract and most games get relegated to ESPNU and ESPN+. ESPN might need more tv slots if they want to get the Big Ten again. That doesn’t look good for any G6 conference that will renew with ESPN once the current Big Ten contract comes for renegotiations.

This just points to outsiders not affiliated with the MW not really understanding the dynamics that led to the schools that left. Remember, Boise walked away from a special media rights deal. Sometimes the cost of who you associate with is equal to or greater than the value you collectively can attain. I guess we will find out how long schools like Memphis, Tulane, USF, and ECU will stay with the Charlotte's and Temple's of the world the moment they realize the ACC leftovers are more likely to merge with the B12 leftover than make any call ups.