CSNbbs
Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? (/thread-1023539.html)

Pages: 1 2


Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - LeeNobody - 01-19-2026 11:36 AM

With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - UpStreamRedTeam - 01-19-2026 11:39 AM

(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

What acrimony? Please show your work.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - LeeNobody - 01-19-2026 11:48 AM

(01-19-2026 11:39 AM)UpStreamRedTeam Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

What acrimony? Please show your work.
1. The entire Saga of Private Financing, including ultimatums against conference members, appeals by the national university board members trade group to stop the deal, and finally failing to launch entirely

2. Multiple teams angry at the league office for kickoff times and network selection. Beliefs that certain teams were entitled to not have night kickoffs late into the year

3. Teams cancelling cross.country league games mid week rather than trying to reschedule. This is not a normal occurrence


These are the just off the top of my head


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Stugray2 - 01-19-2026 12:38 PM

Not likely.

More likely the B1G and SEC pull football out of the NCAA and go internal scheduling and oversight, set up their own CFP against each other. The ACC and Big 12 would be forced to follow suit, sign on as juniors in whatever playoff these two scheme.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Garden_KC - 01-19-2026 01:18 PM

Once the SEC expands I think their attitude toward 24 will change. Also their attitude toward autobids once the push up to 20 teams.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Frank the Tank - 01-19-2026 01:41 PM

(01-19-2026 11:48 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:39 AM)UpStreamRedTeam Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

What acrimony? Please show your work.
1. The entire Saga of Private Financing, including ultimatums against conference members, appeals by the national university board members trade group to stop the deal, and finally failing to launch entirely

2. Multiple teams angry at the league office for kickoff times and network selection. Beliefs that certain teams were entitled to not have night kickoffs late into the year

3. Teams cancelling cross.country league games mid week rather than trying to reschedule. This is not a normal occurrence


These are the just off the top of my head

NO.

There is only one thing that will split up the Big Ten: a true elite 20-team Super League.

There is no backdoor to where, “Maybe Big Ten ‘acrimony’ will lead some schools to go to the ACC or Big 12.” That belief should be fired into the sun as pure unadulterated delusion. Even with a hypothetical of Big Ten teams going to the SEC, there is no universe where Ohio State and Michigan somehow get *more* control over scheduling night games or time slots when Texas and Alabama fully follow whatever ESPN tells them to do.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Garden_KC - 01-19-2026 02:34 PM

(01-19-2026 01:41 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:48 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:39 AM)UpStreamRedTeam Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

What acrimony? Please show your work.
1. The entire Saga of Private Financing, including ultimatums against conference members, appeals by the national university board members trade group to stop the deal, and finally failing to launch entirely

2. Multiple teams angry at the league office for kickoff times and network selection. Beliefs that certain teams were entitled to not have night kickoffs late into the year

3. Teams cancelling cross.country league games mid week rather than trying to reschedule. This is not a normal occurrence


These are the just off the top of my head

NO.

There is only one thing that will split up the Big Ten: a true elite 20-team Super League.

There is no backdoor to where, “Maybe Big Ten ‘acrimony’ will lead some schools to go to the ACC or Big 12.” That belief should be fired into the sun as pure unadulterated delusion. Even with a hypothetical of Big Ten teams going to the SEC, there is no universe where Ohio State and Michigan somehow get *more* control over scheduling night games or time slots when Texas and Alabama fully follow whatever ESPN tells them to do.

Northwestern to the MAC..

05-stirthepot


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - UpStreamRedTeam - 01-19-2026 06:22 PM

(01-19-2026 11:48 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:39 AM)UpStreamRedTeam Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

What acrimony? Please show your work.
1. The entire Saga of Private Financing, including ultimatums against conference members, appeals by the national university board members trade group to stop the deal, and finally failing to launch entirely

2. Multiple teams angry at the league office for kickoff times and network selection. Beliefs that certain teams were entitled to not have night kickoffs late into the year

3. Teams cancelling cross.country league games mid week rather than trying to reschedule. This is not a normal occurrence


These are the just off the top of my head

Two teams not thinking they are getting a big enough cut, thinking they are the Big Nooner to often and canceling a late season mid week game that’s not football or men’s basketball is not acrimony. Two teams suing the conference so that they can leave is acrimony.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - The Beaver - 01-19-2026 06:26 PM

A lot of the top heavy acrimony in the Big Ten will go away if the rest of the league starts performing more in line with them and kills off the old Big 2/Little 8 dichotomy. In that sense, the past two years have been a good step forward for the league and hopefully it continues.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - IWokeUpLikeThis - 01-19-2026 06:35 PM

If something splits the B1G, it’s not going to be CFP non-expansion. If CFP non-expansion leads to anything, it would just be the B1G/SEC leading the charge to break off and form their own playoff (TBD if they allow the ACC/XII to come with). CFP non-expansion isn’t going to cause a superpower to split when superpowers have the power to exit the system and start a new one.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Crayton - 01-19-2026 07:16 PM

(01-19-2026 12:38 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Not likely.

More likely the B1G and SEC pull football out of the NCAA and go internal scheduling and oversight, set up their own CFP against each other. The ACC and Big 12 would be forced to follow suit, sign on as juniors in whatever playoff these two scheme.

That is a lot of work to not solve the problem. How big will that P2 playoff be?


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - 46566 - 01-19-2026 07:36 PM

I think Money keeps e everyone in the Big Ten. Unless the media deal collapses on everyone but then I think all of college sports is screwed at that point. We're would they move to? Would USC and UCLA go back to the PAC the same with Oregon and Washington? All 4 to the Big 12? Would it be feasible for a Big 12 with USC, Oregon, Washington and UCLA to move to the Big 12 to try to increase revenue for that conference? With tv networks kinda dying would a Big 12 tv network make sense for that conference? Have it tied to ESPN or fox like the ACC or Big Ten are.


Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - owl at the moon - 01-19-2026 07:37 PM

(01-19-2026 07:16 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 12:38 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Not likely.

More likely the B1G and SEC pull football out of the NCAA and go internal scheduling and oversight, set up their own CFP against each other. The ACC and Big 12 would be forced to follow suit, sign on as juniors in whatever playoff these two scheme.

That is a lot of work to not solve the problem. How big will that P2 playoff be?


Either 16 or 24 03-wink


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - OdinFrigg - 01-23-2026 02:07 PM

Oh my, potty mouth podcasters:


https://youtu.be/uV-caMLEbic?si=TlpC9Q624TIKnOUL


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Redwood86 - 01-23-2026 02:20 PM

(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

It appears that the CFP is remaining at 12 only because the B1G will not accept 16 without strings attached. If the B1G is supporting 12 v. 16 for now, where/what is the problem?

And what do the ACC and Big-12 have to do with a squabble between the B1G and the SEC?


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - bryanw1995 - 01-23-2026 02:21 PM

(01-19-2026 01:41 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:48 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:39 AM)UpStreamRedTeam Wrote:  
(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

What acrimony? Please show your work.
1. The entire Saga of Private Financing, including ultimatums against conference members, appeals by the national university board members trade group to stop the deal, and finally failing to launch entirely

2. Multiple teams angry at the league office for kickoff times and network selection. Beliefs that certain teams were entitled to not have night kickoffs late into the year

3. Teams cancelling cross.country league games mid week rather than trying to reschedule. This is not a normal occurrence


These are the just off the top of my head

NO.

There is only one thing that will split up the Big Ten: a true elite 20-team Super League.

There is no backdoor to where, “Maybe Big Ten ‘acrimony’ will lead some schools to go to the ACC or Big 12.” That belief should be fired into the sun as pure unadulterated delusion. Even with a hypothetical of Big Ten teams going to the SEC, there is no universe where Ohio State and Michigan somehow get *more* control over scheduling night games or time slots when Texas and Alabama fully follow whatever ESPN tells them to do.

I have to agree with Frank on this one. The larger B1G programs have far more say in B1G matters than Alabama or Georgia do in SEC matters. What’s Michigan gonna do, leave the B1G for less money, less influence, tougher games, and more travel in the SEC? If the SEC offers more money, and I mean a lot more than a $10m delta, they might consider it, but I think that the B1G is just too good of a home for them. Kinda like with all these hypothetical “Utah to the ACC” rumors that we tend to laugh off, the only way a B1G school to the SEC makes sense is something more akin to a merger or near-merger. Michigan isn’t joining the SEC, not by themselves. But they might with 5-10 of their closest friends. And that goes both ways btw, Texas might have preferred the B1G in 2021, but there’s no way they were going there with A&M in the SEC and OU determined to join us. If some seismic shift happened and SEC schools were talking to the B1G far in the future, we’d bring a bunch of friends, too, else it wouldn’t be worth moving. I find that hard to fathom, but I have to admit it’s at least plausible.

A 20 school super league seems unlikely, especially in our current climate where billionaires buy CFP-caliber teams on a whim at random Technical schools. 3 or possibly all 4 of our semifinalists this year would miss a 20 school cut, and the whole point of a hypothetical 20 school league is that team #20 would usually be superior to the best non top 20 school.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - Outsider6 - 01-23-2026 03:18 PM

(01-19-2026 11:36 AM)LeeNobody Wrote:  With 18 full members, different tiers of payouts and many historic blue bloods expecting to play for championships, playoff expansion seems to be a two-fold play to assist in keeping the league together. First playoff expansion re-opens the CFP contract allowing B1G TV partners access to lucrative playoff games, and will compensate the B1G accordingly for their efforts and potentially for play-in games. Secondly expanding the playoff allows former contenders a second chance after failing to make the Conference Championship game. Both serve to assuage top teams from leaving or splintering the league.

So if the playoff remains at 12, does momentum grow in the second tier of the upper class (USC, Penn State, Oregon, Washington, Nebraska) to seek other leagues or split the B1G itself? Does the B1G split with the top of the league forming a smaller higher revenue league and a separate wholly owned post season. The acrimony in the B1G seems much more public than anything in the SEC.
Thoughts?

Nebraska still being considered upper tier in Big Ten is cute.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - The Sicatoka - 01-23-2026 03:22 PM

The only thing that'll break up the B1G (or SEC) is money.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - bryanw1995 - 01-23-2026 03:34 PM

(01-19-2026 06:26 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  A lot of the top heavy acrimony in the Big Ten will go away if the rest of the league starts performing more in line with them and kills off the old Big 2/Little 8 dichotomy. In that sense, the past two years have been a good step forward for the league and hopefully it continues.

Yep. Did anybody here have Oregon and Indiana winning the B1G the past 2 years on your bingo card? I know I sure didn’t.


RE: Could CFP non expansion splinter the B1G? - dbackjon - 01-23-2026 04:31 PM

(01-19-2026 06:26 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  A lot of the top heavy acrimony in the Big Ten will go away if the rest of the league starts performing more in line with them and kills off the old Big 2/Little 8 dichotomy. In that sense, the past two years have been a good step forward for the league and hopefully it continues.

Pretty much already there with 6 different current B1G teams in the final four over the last three years and three different champions.