CSNbbs
CFP Format for 16 Schools - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: CFP Format for 16 Schools (/thread-1023210.html)



CFP Format for 16 Schools - orangefan - 01-10-2026 03:39 PM

With the push to expand the CFP to 16 schools, the question becomes when to play the addiitonal 4 games. There is resistance to adding these games to the second Saturday in December to avoid conflicts with the Army-Navy game. I have taken a look at using the Tuesdays and Wednesdays before and after the third Saturday in December to see what problems would come up.

Tuesdays and Wednesdays would be great days to schedule these games because they present no issue with going head to head with the NFL, and therefore would likely achieve very high TV ratings.

The biggest problem that I see with the Tuesday/Wednesday solution is that in years when the third Saturday comes on the 20th or 21st, one game will fall on Christmas Eve, and when it falls on the 21st, one game will fall on Christmas. These late days also present a concern because they fall only a week before New Years Day.

The following chart shows the dates on which these games would fall depending on when the third Saturday falls, as well as the years in which these occur.

Code:
3rd
Sat  T/W Befor T/W After                
21    17/18    24/25         2030            
20    16/17    23/24         2031  2036
19    15/16    22/23    2026       2037
18    14/15    21/22    2027 2032  2038
17    15/16    20/21         2033  2039
16    12/13    19/20    2028 2034      
15    11/12    18/19    2029 2035  2040

Obviously, the CFP will also want to keep the rest between games as close as possible for teams that will meet in the next round. To address this, game dates should be tied to particular seeds, for instance as follows.

Tu 6 v 11
W 3 v 14
Fr 8 v 9
Sa Noon 7 v 10
Sa 4 pm 1 v 16
Sa 8 pm 2 v 15
Tu 4 v 13
W 5 v 12

The potential scheduling of games on Christmas and Christmas Eve does present a real concern. However, the first year in which this happens is 2030. In those seasons, the CFP could look at other alternatives, but the value of playing on Tuesday and Wednesday could make it the preferred approach.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - GoBuckeyes1047 - 01-10-2026 04:12 PM

(01-10-2026 03:39 PM)orangefan Wrote:  With the push to expand the CFP to 16 schools, the question becomes when to play the addiitonal 4 games. There is resistance to adding these games to the second Saturday in December to avoid conflicts with the Army-Navy game. I have taken a look at using the Tuesdays and Wednesdays before and after the third Saturday in December to see what problems would come up.

Tuesdays and Wednesdays would be great days to schedule these games because they present no issue with going head to head with the NFL, and therefore would likely achieve very high TV ratings.

The biggest problem that I see with the Tuesday/Wednesday solution is that in years when the third Saturday comes on the 20th or 21st, one game will fall on Christmas Eve, and when it falls on the 21st, one game will fall on Christmas. These late days also present a concern because they fall only a week before New Years Day.

The following chart shows the dates on which these games would fall depending on when the third Saturday falls, as well as the years in which these occur.

Code:
3rd
Sat  T/W Befor T/W After                
21    17/18    24/25         2030            
20    16/17    23/24         2031  2036
19    15/16    22/23    2026       2037
18    14/15    21/22    2027 2032  2038
17    15/16    20/21         2033  2039
16    12/13    19/20    2028 2034      
15    11/12    18/19    2029 2035  2040

Obviously, the CFP will also want to keep the rest between games as close as possible for teams that will meet in the next round. To address this, game dates should be tied to particular seeds, for instance as follows.

Tu 6 v 11
W 3 v 14
Fr 8 v 9
Sa Noon 7 v 10
Sa 4 pm 1 v 16
Sa 8 pm 2 v 15
Tu 4 v 13
W 5 v 12

The potential scheduling of games on Christmas and Christmas Eve does present a real concern. However, the first year in which this happens is 2030. In those seasons, the CFP could look at other alternatives, but the value of playing on Tuesday and Wednesday could make it the preferred approach.

The current proposed CFP would be 13v16 and 14v15 playing the 2nd Saturday of December, then probably Tues., Wed., Fri., and 3 Sat. games for the main field. I did briefly look into what you suggested and seen the same issue with Christmas and figured that would be DOA. I wouldn't be opposed of up to 18 teams in the CFP with up to 4 games on the 2nd weekend of Dec. (11v18, 12v17, 13v16, 14v15), and then 6 games the 3rd week of Dec.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Crayton - 01-10-2026 05:20 PM

To address the Christmas problem you could push 2 games all the way to the following Saturday, and have their QF the Saturday after that, which some years like this is after NYD.

But I think they are going to get all they can out of the Second Saturday of December. If CBS wants viewers for Army-Navy they may have to find another slot (or not).


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Stugray2 - 01-10-2026 06:16 PM

Mid-week ratings for Bowls before Christmas are pretty dismal.

Probably there would be a 2nd Friday Night game and an early start Saturday game for round one. That gets you to 14.

That'd be two games on the Friday the 18th, still four on Saturday the 19th, knowing the last two are up against the NFL, but you start your first two early. I don't know where you put the other two to avoid the NFL as they have Thursday night and are wall to wall Sunday. Maybe you can get one in early start like 5:30pm eastern on Thursday the 17th, to beat the NFL, but I don't know where you can slip in the 8th first round game -- you are compromised no matter when you run it. I guess you just accept one game overlapping on Saturday morning, viewers just have to choose. NYD is on a Friday, so that's your quarterfinals, no NFL overlap.

That first Saturday the 13th is pretty much open for the G6 if they want a tournament. They can easily slot four games. Christmas eve is the logical date for round two, the semifinals have to fall either early start on New Years or Saturday the 2nd before the NFL starts, or one on each day, with exclusive early windows.

It can work next year to got to 14, 16 is harder because of the lack of windows. The Calendar is favorable for a G6 playoff; I suggest they implement it with the CFP access still in place as a way to test the waters and work out the kinks (selection process, games scheduling and media setup). It is also ideal because the Bowls are up for renewals.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Fighting Muskie - 01-10-2026 07:14 PM

Here’s a better plan:

2nd Fri in Dec & 2nd Sat in Dec: 8-9, 7-10, 6-11, & 5-12
3rd Fri in Dec & 3rd Sat in Dec: 1-16, 2-15, 3-14, 4-13

No one wants a bunch of weeknight games and they are pain for fans to travel to. Letting the top seeds rest a week between CCGs and their 1st round game will mean they are less rusty in their Bowl Games.

The better games also fall on a weekend where the NFL can’t air on Friday or Saturday


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - GoBuckeyes1047 - 01-10-2026 07:35 PM

(01-10-2026 06:16 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Mid-week ratings for Bowls before Christmas are pretty dismal.

Probably there would be a 2nd Friday Night game and an early start Saturday game for round one. That gets you to 14.

That'd be two games on the Friday the 18th, still four on Saturday the 19th, knowing the last two are up against the NFL, but you start your first two early. I don't know where you put the other two to avoid the NFL as they have Thursday night and are wall to wall Sunday. Maybe you can get one in early start like 5:30pm eastern on Thursday the 17th, to beat the NFL, but I don't know where you can slip in the 8th first round game -- you are compromised no matter when you run it. I guess you just accept one game overlapping on Saturday morning, viewers just have to choose. NYD is on a Friday, so that's your quarterfinals, no NFL overlap.

That first Saturday the 13th is pretty much open for the G6 if they want a tournament. They can easily slot four games. Christmas eve is the logical date for round two, the semifinals have to fall either early start on New Years or Saturday the 2nd before the NFL starts, or one on each day, with exclusive early windows.

It can work next year to got to 14, 16 is harder because of the lack of windows. The Calendar is favorable for a G6 playoff; I suggest they implement it with the CFP access still in place as a way to test the waters and work out the kinks (selection process, games scheduling and media setup). It is also ideal because the Bowls are up for renewals.

ESPN has a schedule they typically follow when they have 4 bowls on a Saturday. 11 AM, 2:15/2:30 PM, 5:45 PM, 9:15 PM. Maybe you shift the latter games by 15 minutes or the earlier games by 15-30 minutes to try to prevent overlap. I suspect the 2 Friday games would be 4:30-5 PM and 8-8:30 PM. ESPN has been using 4:30 and 8 PM. If you go 16 teams, you probably look at Tues. and Wed. games to avoid the NFL. Also can't rule out splitting the 1st round over 2 weekends with the champs playing the 3rd weekend and the at-large teams playing the 2nd weekend.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Crayton - 01-10-2026 08:32 PM

(01-10-2026 07:14 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Here’s a better plan:

2nd Fri in Dec & 2nd Sat in Dec: 8-9, 7-10, 6-11, & 5-12
3rd Fri in Dec & 3rd Sat in Dec: 1-16, 2-15, 3-14, 4-13

No one wants a bunch of weeknight games and they are pain for fans to travel to. Letting the top seeds rest a week between CCGs and their 1st round game will mean they are less rusty in their Bowl Games.

The better games also fall on a weekend where the NFL can’t air on Friday or Saturday

I think this works quite well. Good logic too.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - The Beaver - 01-10-2026 10:23 PM

How many of these threads are we gonna need/tolerate.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Stugray2 - 01-11-2026 12:48 PM

This one is just focused on logistics.

The thing many forget is that the schedule really is year to year, traying to get the best windows while avoiding the NFL. Hence the days of the week for given games will shift from year to year.

I think the G6 works for 12 next year, the big CFP works for 14 to give all games favorable windows. Expanding beyond those numbers you run into a low price for added games, reducing the payouts per team. That is why I think the numbers are what I said.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Just Joe - 01-11-2026 03:02 PM

Army/Navy is great but it having its own weekend is a recent thing not an ancient tradition. I’m not convinced the CFP needs that weekend but if the PTB decide it is just tell them to either play another weekend or opt out of the playoff same as the SWAC/MEAC do in FCS.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - goofus - 01-11-2026 03:56 PM

This is not an original idea, but for a variety of reasons, I do prefer a schedule begins in mid-August and finishes the regular season the week before Thanksgiving. Then if you have a 24-team CFP, you could play the 8 first round games on Black Friday and Saturday. Then the 16-team 2nd round the first week of December. The 8-team 4-game quarterfinals the 2nd week of Dec and the 4-team 2-game semifinals the 3rd sat. Then the NCG on NYD.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Just Joe - 01-11-2026 05:46 PM

(01-11-2026 03:56 PM)goofus Wrote:  This is not an original idea, but for a variety of reasons, I do prefer a schedule begins in mid-August and finishes the regular season the week before Thanksgiving. Then if you have a 24-team CFP, you could play the 8 first round games on Black Friday and Saturday. Then the 16-team 2nd round the first week of December. The 8-team 4-game quarterfinals the 2nd week of Dec and the 4-team 2-game semifinals the 3rd sat. Then the NCG on NYD.

One of the arguments against a playoff was “the season can’t go into a second semester” even though various other sports manage to do this with no problem. Personally I like NYD being wall to wall playoffs in bowls which is one of the few ways CFP has successfully paired progress with tradition.

And I love CFB far more than the NFL but I recognize I’m in the minority. Going head to head with the NFL in late December is a sure way to get slaughtered in the ratings. I’m not even sure networks would bid on those games with as many broadcast partners as the NFL has. MLB was once king of sports in America and they conceded playing World Series games on Sunday because they were getting killed by midseason NFL games.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - BruceMcF - 01-11-2026 07:59 PM

(01-10-2026 06:16 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Mid-week ratings for Bowls before Christmas are pretty dismal.

Probably there would be a 2nd Friday Night game and an early start Saturday game for round one. That gets you to 14.

That'd be two games on the Friday the 18th, still four on Saturday the 19th, knowing the last two are up against the NFL, but you start your first two early. ...

Yes, so the #3 host #14 and #4 host #13 are against the NFL, #5 host #12 and #6 host #11 are early games, and #7 host #10, #8 host #9 are the second games on Friday and Saturday.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - cowboysrule - 02-10-2026 01:19 PM

just do this...your welcome

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1PG53bwd_jSULLtEU2LO0sU09Dd54coY1S1asvrPuvk0/edit?usp=sharing


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - bullet - 02-10-2026 01:40 PM

(01-10-2026 05:20 PM)Crayton Wrote:  To address the Christmas problem you could push 2 games all the way to the following Saturday, and have their QF the Saturday after that, which some years like this is after NYD.

But I think they are going to get all they can out of the Second Saturday of December. If CBS wants viewers for Army-Navy they may have to find another slot (or not).

They do sometimes put 4 games on a day with a little earlier start for the first game, so its easy to work around Army-Navy and put 3 games that first weekend.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - YNot - 02-10-2026 05:32 PM

Do you need exclusive windows for Round 1 with 16+ teams?

Wouldn't be hard to stage 8 games on a Friday night and Saturday, with the likely lopsided matchups overlapping the likely more competitive matchups on a couple of networks.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - YNot - 02-10-2026 05:34 PM

(02-10-2026 01:19 PM)cowboysrule Wrote:  just do this...your welcome

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1PG53bwd_jSULLtEU2LO0sU09Dd54coY1S1asvrPuvk0/edit?usp=sharing

03-puke


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - Crayton - 02-10-2026 05:52 PM

(02-10-2026 05:32 PM)YNot Wrote:  Do you need exclusive windows for Round 1 with 16+ teams?

Wouldn't be hard to stage 8 games on a Friday night and Saturday, with the likely lopsided matchups overlapping the likely more competitive matchups on a couple of networks.

I suppose not. But you wouldn’t get more money for those games. ESPN agreed to pay the same for 4 or 6 games on the current First Round weekend. The contract doesn’t consider 8 probably because CFP didn’t consider it viable or ESPN’s margin overhead was going to exceed revenue.

If the CFP wants money the play is to add 2-4 games to the current Army-Navy weekend.


RE: CFP Format for 16 Schools - cowboysrule - 02-10-2026 06:56 PM

(01-11-2026 07:59 PM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(01-10-2026 06:16 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Mid-week ratings for Bowls before Christmas are pretty dismal.

Probably there would be a 2nd Friday Night game and an early start Saturday game for round one. That gets you to 14.

That'd be two games on the Friday the 18th, still four on Saturday the 19th, knowing the last two are up against the NFL, but you start your first two early. ...

Yes, so the #3 host #14 and #4 host #13 are against the NFL, #5 host #12 and #6 host #11 are early games, and #7 host #10, #8 host #9 are the second games on Friday and Saturday.

(02-10-2026 05:34 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(02-10-2026 01:19 PM)cowboysrule Wrote:  just do this...your welcome

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1PG53bwd_jSULLtEU2LO0sU09Dd54coY1S1asvrPuvk0/edit?usp=sharing

03-puke

04-jawdrop