CSNbbs
Should the NCAA Men's Basketball Selection Committee - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: MACbbs (/forum-513.html)
+---- Forum: Mid-American Conference Talk (/forum-472.html)
+---- Thread: Should the NCAA Men's Basketball Selection Committee (/thread-1023201.html)



Should the NCAA Men's Basketball Selection Committee - emu steve - 01-10-2026 12:00 PM

Give TWO automatic bids to the power conferences and the next say 5 - 7 conferences?

What I'm thinking:

For the 'one-bid' leagues, the OOC and even regular conference season aren't all that important.

What is important are say 5 days in March.

If the highest ranked mid-major conferences were guaranteed 2 bids (e.g., American, A-10, MAC, MWC, MVC, West Coast).

A case can be made that each of these conferences have two worthy teams, regardless of who wins the conference tourney. I want say 4 A-10 teams all fighting for the 2nd bid, regardless if they don't win the conf. tourney.

Yes, I'd be 'stealing' a bid from ACC, BE, B1G, etc. but like eating pizza, too much is not a good thing and has diminishing marginal benefit. A 2nd bid this year for the MAC does more for hoops than the Nth B1G team.

I would CAP the number of teams from any given conference. NCAA has the power give an added boost to the next tier of conferences.


RE: Should the NCAA Men's Basketball Selection Committee - Schadenfreude - 01-10-2026 03:02 PM

I would get rid of the selection committee. Replace it with a fair, even-handed computer ranking system and just use it the way is already done in college hockey. Once each conference champion gets an automatic bid, pass out at-large bids to the strongest remaining teams until you are out of at-large bids.

As far as conference champions: Conference tournaments are annoying. They sap the regular season of any meaning at all for most conferences. If the MAC wants to preserve a big showcase in Cleveland, split the conference into divisions and have the division winners play in Cleveland. The winner is the champion.

Bada bing. Bada boom. Done.