![]() |
|
CFP and the G6 - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: MACbbs (/forum-513.html) +---- Forum: Mid-American Conference Talk (/forum-472.html) +---- Thread: CFP and the G6 (/thread-1022851.html) Pages: 1 2 |
CFP and the G6 - Rocket Man - 01-01-2026 10:26 PM Has anyone heard any media or sports commentators decry the injustice that teams like Alabama and Texas Tech were in major bowls today? What complete shellackings. The G6 gets roasted for our losses, but when a P4 also gets humbled in the CFP that is completly ignored. I loved seeing Indiana just pound Bama - especially after Saban’s comments on the G6 in the playoffs’ first round. Also love that there are many overachieving players on Indiana. I guess it is G6 against Everyone! Looking forward to a great 2026 with my MAC and G6 brothers! Happy New Year everyone!!! Go MAC and Go Rockets!!! RE: CFP and the G6 - Rocket Man - 01-01-2026 10:31 PM I thought JMU played Oregon well even on the road. Had they more time in that game and defended a little better earlier, they just might win that game. Oregon is a beast and might just win it all. That game with Indiana will be a doozie! RE: CFP and the G6 - Rocket Man - 01-01-2026 10:32 PM Hoping we have a great MAC candidate next year to challenge for the G6 spot - unless they change the rules again. RE: CFP and the G6 - Schadenfreude - 01-02-2026 08:06 AM (01-01-2026 10:26 PM)Rocket Man Wrote: Has anyone heard any media or sports commentators decry the injustice that teams like Alabama and Texas Tech were in major bowls today? What complete shellackings. The G6 gets roasted for our losses, but when a P4 also gets humbled in the CFP that is completly ignored. Yes, this. RE: CFP and the G6 - JHVMU19 - 01-02-2026 09:11 AM (01-01-2026 10:26 PM)Rocket Man Wrote: Has anyone heard any media or sports commentators decry the injustice that teams like Alabama and Texas Tech were in major bowls today? What complete shellackings. The G6 gets roasted for our losses, but when a P4 also gets humbled in the CFP that is completly ignored. I loved seeing Indiana just pound Bama - especially after Saban’s comments on the G6 in the playoffs’ first round. Also love that there are many overachieving players on Indiana. I guess it is G6 against Everyone! Looking forward to a great 2026 with my MAC and G6 brothers! Happy New Year everyone!!! Go MAC and Go Rockets!!! Totally agree… I would love to hear Texas Tech had “no business being there” in CFP. They did not even put up a point! The point differential was also larger for TT vs Oregon than JMU vs Oregon. It is such a joke and ESPN and the media drive this. There will definitely be some excuses this week for sure. I loved seeing Alabama gets destroyed by a non-football school.
RE: CFP and the G6 - JHVMU19 - 01-02-2026 09:11 AM (01-02-2026 09:11 AM)JHVMU19 Wrote:(01-01-2026 10:26 PM)Rocket Man Wrote: Has anyone heard any media or sports commentators decry the injustice that teams like Alabama and Texas Tech were in major bowls today? What complete shellackings. The G6 gets roasted for our losses, but when a P4 also gets humbled in the CFP that is completly ignored. I loved seeing Indiana just pound Bama - especially after Saban’s comments on the G6 in the playoffs’ first round. Also love that there are many overachieving players on Indiana. I guess it is G6 against Everyone! Looking forward to a great 2026 with my MAC and G6 brothers! Happy New Year everyone!!! Go MAC and Go Rockets!!! RE: CFP and the G6 - BruceMcF - 01-02-2026 01:16 PM This has been raised on the ex-Twitter ... "the SEC can only get into the semi-finals by organizing a game between two SEC schools -- and Alabama and Texas Tech really should not have been playing in the CFP. I mean, think of the safety of the players when they play against teams like Oregon or Indiana!" RE: CFP and the G6 - FMRocket - 01-02-2026 03:49 PM (01-01-2026 10:31 PM)Rocket Man Wrote: I thought JMU played Oregon well even on the road. Had they more time in that game and defended a little better earlier, they just might win that game. Oregon is a beast and might just win it all. That game with Indiana will be a doozie! JMU had even stats, first down/yardage etc… as Oregon, and also put up 3 hundred more yards of offense than Tech did !! One more thing, JMU & Tulane had to both go on the road into hostile environments !! RE: CFP and the G6 - Lux Interior - 01-02-2026 05:32 PM The G6 needs a playoff like the FCS has. Play twelve games, ditch the conference championship games, and the conference winners and next two highest-ranked teams have an 8-team playoff. Done. RE: CFP and the G6 - NIU05 - 01-02-2026 07:08 PM (01-02-2026 05:32 PM)Lux Interior Wrote: The G6 needs a playoff like the FCS has. Play twelve games, ditch the conference championship games, and the conference winners and next two highest-ranked teams have an 8-team playoff. Done. That is a automatic downgrade in class. IMO, if portal is not straighten out , but that I mean wild, wild west operating environment that exists now, there will be just P5 and everyone else D3. RE: CFP and the G6 - wmubroncopilot - 01-02-2026 08:05 PM If the G6 wants to put together a playoff, then whatever. I mean presumably it won’t be any less interesting than bowls (which I enjoy, fwiw). But it certainly shouldn’t come at the expense of true access to the CFP. If we’re going to have a 12 team (and probably more soon) CFP and there’s no real access for the G6 then we’ve basically already dropped down. RE: CFP and the G6 - mattresspolice - 01-03-2026 12:23 PM (01-02-2026 09:11 AM)JHVMU19 Wrote:(01-01-2026 10:26 PM)Rocket Man Wrote: Has anyone heard any media or sports commentators decry the injustice that teams like Alabama and Texas Tech were in major bowls today? What complete shellackings. The G6 gets roasted for our losses, but when a P4 also gets humbled in the CFP that is completly ignored. I loved seeing Indiana just pound Bama - especially after Saban’s comments on the G6 in the playoffs’ first round. Also love that there are many overachieving players on Indiana. I guess it is G6 against Everyone! Looking forward to a great 2026 with my MAC and G6 brothers! Happy New Year everyone!!! Go MAC and Go Rockets!!! So you think JMU is a better football team than Texas Tech? RE: CFP and the G6 - Rocket Man - 01-03-2026 02:43 PM (01-03-2026 12:23 PM)mattresspolice Wrote:Based on head to head metrics vs Oregon-I’d say yes. Also- JMU had to play in hostile environment and not at neutral site. Don’t they typically equate home field advantage to 7 points?(01-02-2026 09:11 AM)JHVMU19 Wrote:(01-01-2026 10:26 PM)Rocket Man Wrote: Has anyone heard any media or sports commentators decry the injustice that teams like Alabama and Texas Tech were in major bowls today? What complete shellackings. The G6 gets roasted for our losses, but when a P4 also gets humbled in the CFP that is completly ignored. I loved seeing Indiana just pound Bama - especially after Saban’s comments on the G6 in the playoffs’ first round. Also love that there are many overachieving players on Indiana. I guess it is G6 against Everyone! Looking forward to a great 2026 with my MAC and G6 brothers! Happy New Year everyone!!! Go MAC and Go Rockets!!! RE: CFP and the G6 - Schadenfreude - 01-04-2026 07:27 AM (01-02-2026 05:32 PM)Lux Interior Wrote: The G6 needs a playoff like the FCS has. No. We don't that. What we do need is for the NCAA to sponsor a playoff in our subdivision that is as fair and inclusive as the playoffs sponsored at every other level of college football. RE: CFP and the G6 - Motown Bronco - 01-09-2026 09:18 PM A bit OT but didn’t want to start a new thread. Can someone explain Indiana to me and how they look like a juggernaut after being a doormat for decades? Portal luck? (Coach brought a bunch of JMU guys but that can’t be it). Genius coach? NIL? RE: CFP and the G6 - Rocket Man - 01-09-2026 09:32 PM We are wondering the same thing. Cignetti must be one hell of a coach. I think he has a lot of over achievers. Many 3 star guys. Love it!!!! RE: CFP and the G6 - Polish Hammer - 01-14-2026 07:00 AM (01-09-2026 09:18 PM)Motown Bronco Wrote: A bit OT but didn’t want to start a new thread.One helluva coach with a great staff working for him. They identify under the radar talent and develop them. He took a pile of players and some recruits from JMU to IU, but took the right kids with the right attitude and rebuilt the culture. They parlayed that momentum into now making it a destination for higher ranked recruits. And just think, after he depleted JMU of their roster and staff, JMU made a good hire that went 9-4, won their first bowl game ever and then made it to the CFP this season pulling up 500+ yards and 34 points on the road at a hostile Oregon crowd, which is more than anyone else has done all year. Culture means everything, and now JMU will have to rely on that again to reload since they lost their head coach and staff to UCLA and any players with eligibility. PS: Many of those kids Cignetti took were FCS level recruits and/or recruited when JMU was transitioning and still not considered FBS. They took ballers and knew they could compete at that level. They've kind of changed the blueprint, bring your players with you when you get hired and also bring in kids from below (G6/FCS) that produced and are looking to move up instead of guys from power programs that never saw the field and were probably overrated recruits. RE: CFP and the G6 - george14 - 01-14-2026 09:39 AM This thread seems disingenuous because in the CFP era there have been 4 G5 teams to make the playoff, here are the results: - 2021 Cincy lost by 21 to Bama - 2024 Boise lost by 17 to Penn State - 2025 Tulane lost by 31 to Ole Miss - 2025 JMU lost by 17 to Oregon 100% of G5 teams have lost by 3+ scores. Sure you can point to P4 blowouts, but they are also the teams blowing out others. I'm as big of a G5 slappy as there is but this argument makes little sense because every time we make it to the dance, we lose badly. RE: CFP and the G6 - Steve1981 - 01-14-2026 01:20 PM (01-14-2026 09:39 AM)george14 Wrote: This thread seems disingenuous because in the CFP era there have been 4 G5 teams to make the playoff, here are the results: Still like my idea of 20 teams, 19 teams based on rank plus a G6 team To get down to 16 teams have a play in round of the last 8 teams. This way the G6 team is not facing the #1 team in the nation. RE: CFP and the G6 - george14 - 01-14-2026 02:31 PM (01-14-2026 01:20 PM)Steve1981 Wrote:(01-14-2026 09:39 AM)george14 Wrote: This thread seems disingenuous because in the CFP era there have been 4 G5 teams to make the playoff, here are the results: I'm all for all conference champs being included in the playoff but that requires expansion to make it make sense. There are MAC fans who believe the MAC champ should get the same value spot as the B10 champ which is absurd. P4 champs + G6 champs = 10 P4 runner ups = 4 Make the rest at large which will likely all be P4 = 6 |