CSNbbs
Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: Members (/forum-401.html)
+----- Forum: MemphisTigers.org (/forum-446.html)
+------ Forum: Dockery-Finch Memorial Tiger Sports Forum (/forum-499.html)
+------ Thread: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. (/thread-1022828.html)

Pages: 1 2


Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - mapdude - 01-01-2026 11:33 AM

It's time to just let the power boys go have their circle jerk playoffs and the rest of the world try to move back to a different reality...

link


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Herff Tiger - 01-01-2026 12:00 PM

Or we give up on this media manufactured and sports culture pursued demand to find out the "true #1" and accept the fact that "OK, 14-0 Ohio State won the Rose Bowl and 14-0 Alerbammer won the Sugar Bowl and 13-1 Florida State won the Orange Bowl, oh well, see you next season".

There are too many teams and it is too complicated to worry about the "true #1". Remember the saying regarding the NFL, "any given Sunday"? Well "any given Saturday" applies as well. The RB has a tweaked ankle, the QB has a bruised shoulder causing a hitch in his throw, the best cover corner has a cold . . . there are any number of reasons one team will beat another on whatever day they happen to meet. It's foolish to worry about it.

The NFL is kind of screwed up too, because of the divisions versus the # of games played. A sub-500 team can win its division and make the playoffs with much better 3-loss teams getting left out. That situation doesn't get the air play that college FB rankings does, so it's a non-issue in sports pop culture.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - hammer595 - 01-01-2026 02:24 PM

How much of a budget does Huff have to work with?


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - AlonsoWDC - 01-01-2026 04:08 PM

(01-01-2026 02:24 PM)hammer595 Wrote:  How much of a budget does Huff have to work with?

Being discussed.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - MemphisTigerPawr - 01-01-2026 05:41 PM

They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - DDrum1961 - 01-01-2026 06:36 PM

(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - RCM1029 - 01-01-2026 09:37 PM

(01-01-2026 06:36 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …

So you’re saying Manning has a true NIL deal, meaning he’s getting paid for allowing businesses to use his name, image, or likeness for promotional purposes. Unlike 95% of players who have neither their name, image, nor likeness being used by anyone…so they are basically being paid to wear a uniform and play football.

Let’s stop calling it NIL and call it what it is: pay for play. Make them employees, give them a W-2, and let them pay taxes like the rest of us.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - TigerBlue4Ever - 01-01-2026 10:00 PM

(01-01-2026 09:37 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 06:36 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …

So you’re saying Manning has a true NIL deal, meaning he’s getting paid for allowing businesses to use his name, image, or likeness for promotional purposes. Unlike 95% of players who have neither their name, image, nor likeness being used by anyone…so they are basically being paid to wear a uniform and play football.

Let’s stop calling it NIL and call it what it is: pay for play. Make them employees, give them a W-2, and let them pay taxes like the rest of us.

04-rock


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - roundhouse74 - 01-01-2026 10:24 PM

(01-01-2026 09:37 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 06:36 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …

So you’re saying Manning has a true NIL deal, meaning he’s getting paid for allowing businesses to use his name, image, or likeness for promotional purposes. Unlike 95% of players who have neither their name, image, nor likeness being used by anyone…so they are basically being paid to wear a uniform and play football.

Let’s stop calling it NIL and call it what it is: pay for play. Make them employees, give them a W-2, and let them pay taxes like the rest of us.

They are taxed on NIL.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Eagleonpar - 01-02-2026 08:14 AM

It’s easier to pay 8-10 than it is to pay 50

I’ll just leave that there


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - DDrum1961 - 01-02-2026 10:20 AM

(01-01-2026 10:24 PM)roundhouse74 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 09:37 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 06:36 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …

So you’re saying Manning has a true NIL deal, meaning he’s getting paid for allowing businesses to use his name, image, or likeness for promotional purposes. Unlike 95% of players who have neither their name, image, nor likeness being used by anyone…so they are basically being paid to wear a uniform and play football.

Let’s stop calling it NIL and call it what it is: pay for play. Make them employees, give them a W-2, and let them pay taxes like the rest of us.

They are taxed on NIL.

Sorry, it was Warby Parker not Oakley ... See below .. All appear to be national brands ....

Arch Manning signs first NIL deal with Panini America | kvue.comArch Manning has numerous high-profile Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals, making him one of the most valuable college athletes, with partners including Red Bull, Uber, Vuori, Panini, EA Sports, Raising Cane's, and Warby Parker, leveraging his famous football lineage and role as Texas Longhorns quarterback, despite fluctuations in his NIL valuation. His deals, managed by Excel Sports Management, range from trading cards (Panini) and energy drinks (Red Bull) to apparel (Vuori) and rideshares (Uber), with his value estimated to be in the millions.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - SeñorTiger - 01-05-2026 10:41 AM

(01-01-2026 10:24 PM)roundhouse74 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 09:37 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 06:36 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …

So you’re saying Manning has a true NIL deal, meaning he’s getting paid for allowing businesses to use his name, image, or likeness for promotional purposes. Unlike 95% of players who have neither their name, image, nor likeness being used by anyone…so they are basically being paid to wear a uniform and play football.

Let’s stop calling it NIL and call it what it is: pay for play. Make them employees, give them a W-2, and let them pay taxes like the rest of us.

They are taxed on NIL.

Correct. I do many of the UofA player tax returns for them. They are not only being taxed at ordinary income rates but also on self-employment taxes... Unfortunately, most are completely uneducated on this and get hammered.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - SeñorTiger - 01-05-2026 10:43 AM

What they are not being taxed on is their scholarships. If deemed W2 employees, it is possible the IRS could make the claim that their scholarship are a component of their pay and try to tax that which could get very interesting.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Tiger87 - 01-06-2026 09:16 AM

As I've seen business "contract" employee laws and tax regulations evolve over the years, I'm surprised the IRS hasn't actually gone after this - taxing scholarships and universities for payroll taxes.

The "behavioral control" rule clearly puts players in employee status. Their work is controlled and supervised by the university.
"Financial control" and "relationship" remain a bit more of a gray area.

But I've seen businesses dinged by the IRS on the "behavioral control" rule alone.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - SeñorTiger - 01-06-2026 09:21 AM

(01-06-2026 09:16 AM)Tiger87 Wrote:  As I've seen business "contract" employee laws and tax regulations evolve over the years, I'm surprised the IRS hasn't actually gone after this - taxing scholarships and universities for payroll taxes.

The "behavioral control" rule clearly puts players in employee status. Their work is controlled and supervised by the university.
"Financial control" and "relationship" remain a bit more of a gray area.

But I've seen businesses dinged by the IRS on the "behavioral control" rule alone.

The schools are not paying them and scholarships that cover tuition are specifically nontaxable so at this point there really is nothing for the IRS to step in on. If schools get involved in directly paying players then it will be interesting to see where it goes.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Tiger87 - 01-07-2026 09:00 AM

(01-06-2026 09:21 AM)SeñorTiger Wrote:  
(01-06-2026 09:16 AM)Tiger87 Wrote:  As I've seen business "contract" employee laws and tax regulations evolve over the years, I'm surprised the IRS hasn't actually gone after this - taxing scholarships and universities for payroll taxes.

The "behavioral control" rule clearly puts players in employee status. Their work is controlled and supervised by the university.
"Financial control" and "relationship" remain a bit more of a gray area.

But I've seen businesses dinged by the IRS on the "behavioral control" rule alone.

The schools are not paying them and scholarships that cover tuition are specifically nontaxable so at this point there really is nothing for the IRS to step in on. If schools get involved in directly paying players then it will be interesting to see where it goes.

I thought Revenue Sharing started this academic year - along with bringing most of the collectives "in house"?


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - memtigbb - 01-07-2026 09:37 AM

(01-02-2026 08:14 AM)Eagleonpar Wrote:  It’s easier to pay 8-10 than it is to pay 50

I’ll just leave that there

ding ding ding we have a winner. I would even say pay 3-4 and then coach up some role players.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Tiger87 - 01-07-2026 10:17 AM

(01-07-2026 09:37 AM)memtigbb Wrote:  
(01-02-2026 08:14 AM)Eagleonpar Wrote:  It’s easier to pay 8-10 than it is to pay 50

I’ll just leave that there

ding ding ding we have a winner. I would even say pay 3-4 and then coach up some role players.

Most of us love football too, though. Even with Ryan, we had 25k coming to games. That's at least 3x the number who come to basketball games.


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - Gusrob2.0 - 01-07-2026 01:41 PM

(01-05-2026 10:41 AM)SeñorTiger Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 10:24 PM)roundhouse74 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 09:37 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 06:36 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote:  
(01-01-2026 05:41 PM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote:  They tried to say last night that Arch Manning cost 3 million

I would venture to say that much of the NIL money Arch receives has NOTHING to do with Texas and more to the fact that his last name is Manning … He has national level endorsements (Oakley, etc) that would follow him wherever he goes …. He could probably (and likely) take a minimum amount from Texas to allow for better roster construction …

So you’re saying Manning has a true NIL deal, meaning he’s getting paid for allowing businesses to use his name, image, or likeness for promotional purposes. Unlike 95% of players who have neither their name, image, nor likeness being used by anyone…so they are basically being paid to wear a uniform and play football.

Let’s stop calling it NIL and call it what it is: pay for play. Make them employees, give them a W-2, and let them pay taxes like the rest of us.

They are taxed on NIL.

Correct. I do many of the UofA player tax returns for them. They are not only being taxed at ordinary income rates but also on self-employment taxes... Unfortunately, most are completely uneducated on this and get hammered.

I was trying to remember who it was....it was you...that mentioned this previously. 04-cheers


RE: Interesting take on what it costs to get an athlete in todays college sports. - SeñorTiger - 01-08-2026 10:43 AM

(01-07-2026 09:00 AM)Tiger87 Wrote:  
(01-06-2026 09:21 AM)SeñorTiger Wrote:  
(01-06-2026 09:16 AM)Tiger87 Wrote:  As I've seen business "contract" employee laws and tax regulations evolve over the years, I'm surprised the IRS hasn't actually gone after this - taxing scholarships and universities for payroll taxes.

The "behavioral control" rule clearly puts players in employee status. Their work is controlled and supervised by the university.
"Financial control" and "relationship" remain a bit more of a gray area.

But I've seen businesses dinged by the IRS on the "behavioral control" rule alone.

The schools are not paying them and scholarships that cover tuition are specifically nontaxable so at this point there really is nothing for the IRS to step in on. If schools get involved in directly paying players then it will be interesting to see where it goes.

I thought Revenue Sharing started this academic year - along with bringing most of the collectives "in house"?

Correct, I forgot about revenue sharing beginning. NIL is still all over the place with new reporting requirements. There significant amounts of NIL lump sum payments and even multi-year payments to avoid having to report under the new rules. It just continue to be a complete 01-rivals show.

If challenged the players would almost certainly be ruled as employees of the University unless the IRS granted some sort of special exception.