CSNbbs
[NEWS] Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: The Spin Room (/forum-540.html)
+---- Thread: [NEWS] Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals (/thread-1022741.html)



Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - CrimsonPhantom - 12-30-2025 02:25 PM

Quote:Well, this is certainly different – a federal court has actually ruled in favor of the Trump administration, handing down a decision Monday that will allow Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to use Medicaid data to track down and deport illegal aliens starting January 6.

The ruling comes after 22 blue states, led by California, sued the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) back in July, arguing that the administration's mass transfer of Medicaid data to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) illegally exposed confidential health information, including immigration status. The lawsuit was filed after HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., authorized a data transfer from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to DHS back in June.

In his decision, U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria, an Obama appointee, partially granted and partially denied a motion for preliminary injunction in the blue state lawsuit over the Trump administration’s policy of sharing Medicaid data with DHS and ICE. Judge Chhabria ruled that ICE officials would be able to obtain six specific categories of personal information on Medicaid recipients, including address, citizenship, immigration status, phone number, date of birth, and Medicaid ID.

“The sharing of such information is clearly authorized by law and the agencies have adequately explained their decisions,” Chhabria wrote in the seven-page order. “Beyond the basic information discussed above, the policies are totally unclear and do not appear to be the product of a coherent decision-making process."



However, the court also ruled that the Trump administration was using vague language when it came to other categories of information it wanted to access for deportation purposes. Judge Chhabria noted that the government had not adequately explained what additional information it might want to share with ICE, why it would be needed, or what safeguards might be used to ensure other data wasn't improperly accessed or utilized.

“Beyond the basic information discussed above, the policies are totally unclear and do not appear to be the product of a coherent decisionmaking process,” Chhabria wrote.

As a result, Judge Chhabria concluded that the vagueness of the policy could be seen as “arbitrary and capricious,” and preliminarily enjoined the administration from sharing or using any Medicaid data obtained from the blue states outside the stated six categories.

If you find yourself asking why illegals are able to enroll for Medicaid benefits, here's your answer:

California and other blue states — Illinois, Colorado, New York, Washington, Oregon, Minnesota, as well as Washington, D.C. — allow some people to receive state-funded benefits through their Medicaid implementation programs regardless of immigration status.

The big loser here is California's Democrat attorney general, Rob Bonta, who led the blue state effort to shield illegals from having their data shared with federal law enforcement officials. And the plaintiffs are not one bit pleased with Monday's ruling – a spokesperson for the California Department of Justice said the Trump administration was violating the trust illegals placed in the health system.

“The Trump Administration’s effort to use Medicaid data for immigration enforcement is a violation of their trust and will lead to fewer people seeking vital healthcare,” they said in a statement.

DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin, however, is celebrating the win, calling it “a victory for the rule of law and American taxpayers.”

Link


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - Eldonabe - 12-30-2025 02:45 PM

From above:


[The big loser here is California's Democrat attorney general, Rob Bonta, who led the blue state effort to shield illegals from having their data shared with federal law enforcement officials. And the plaintiffs are not one bit pleased with Monday's ruling – a spokesperson for the California Department of Justice said the Trump administration was violating the trust illegals placed in the health system.]


These people must use the same speech writer that Kamala used. Do they even hear the words they are speaking?


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - ECUGrad07 - 12-30-2025 02:51 PM

Wait, I thought illegals didn't get Medicaid?


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - rath v2.0 - 12-30-2025 02:54 PM

Print er' all up.

Start at the illegals whose last names start with Aa and go see them personally. While there check to see if that address is HUD supported housing. Might as well look to see if this is a food stamp or welfare recipient as well. lol. One stop shopping.

I have a feeling some folks are going to be moving ASAP.


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - VA49er - 12-30-2025 02:59 PM

(12-30-2025 02:45 PM)Eldonabe Wrote:  From above:


[The big loser here is California's Democrat attorney general, Rob Bonta, who led the blue state effort to shield illegals from having their data shared with federal law enforcement officials. And the plaintiffs are not one bit pleased with Monday's ruling – a spokesperson for the California Department of Justice said the Trump administration was violating the trust illegals placed in the health system.]


These people must use the same speech writer that Kamala used. Do they even hear the words they are speaking?

lol, you beat me to it. I read that and was like, "There's no way that person said that with a straight face!"


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - TripleA - 12-30-2025 03:02 PM

(12-30-2025 02:54 PM)rath v2.0 Wrote:  Print er' all up.

Start at the illegals whose last names start with Aa and go see them personally. While there check to see if that address is HUD supported housing. Might as well look to see if this is a food stamp or welfare recipient as well. lol. One stop shopping.

I have a feeling some folks are going to be moving ASAP.

Hey! Why you picking on us "A" folks? We're always the guinea pigs, lol.


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - VA49er - 12-30-2025 03:39 PM

(12-30-2025 03:02 PM)TripleA Wrote:  
(12-30-2025 02:54 PM)rath v2.0 Wrote:  Print er' all up.

Start at the illegals whose last names start with Aa and go see them personally. While there check to see if that address is HUD supported housing. Might as well look to see if this is a food stamp or welfare recipient as well. lol. One stop shopping.

I have a feeling some folks are going to be moving ASAP.

Hey! Why you picking on us "A" folks? We're always the guinea pigs, lol.

lol, quit ya bitchin! Always first in the phone book. That's something!! 02-13-banana

btw. do people even know what a phone book is these days??


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - Eldonabe - 12-30-2025 03:45 PM

How dare the government want to know who they are giving our tax payer money to.

The nerve of these people.


Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - maximus - 12-30-2025 03:55 PM

The treasonous effin lawyers and politicians should be required to have to pay for these retarded lawsuits when they lose.

Absolute effin nonsense.

Lawyers are are the scum of the earth.

About 3% are worth a ****, the rest are pieces of ****.

Sent from my SM-S928U using Tapatalk


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - GeminiCoog - 12-30-2025 05:06 PM

In before Ofer comes in and basically says he knows better than the ruling judge.


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - oruvoice - 12-30-2025 05:10 PM

Shall I just go ahead and make it 215-0?


RE: Court Rules Trump Admin Can Use Medicaid Data on Illegals - stinkfist - 12-30-2025 06:22 PM

(12-30-2025 05:10 PM)oruvoice Wrote:  Shall I just go ahead and make it 215-0?

https://csnbbs.com/thread-1022463-post-20492239.html#pid20492239
https://csnbbs.com/thread-1022493-post-20494034.html#pid20494034

you missed my posts a few days ago ... there's two with a personal foul +1 penalty ... make it so, o' tally master ... 03-lmfao03-drunk03-lmfao 04-cheers