![]() |
|
Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html) +---- Forum: Members (/forum-401.html) +----- Forum: MemphisTigers.org (/forum-446.html) +------ Forum: Dockery-Finch Memorial Tiger Sports Forum (/forum-499.html) +------ Thread: Top college football coach hires rated per espn (/thread-1022447.html) Pages: 1 2 |
Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Southaven - 12-23-2025 12:19 AM 8. Charles Huff, Memphis. Huff was an assistant for Nick Saban and James Franklin, he went to four bowls and won a Sun Belt title in four years at Marshall, and he inspired enough loyalty with his players that, when the Thundering Herd let him leave for Southern Miss a year ago, more than 20 followed him to Hattiesburg and helped the Golden Eagles surge from 1-11 to 7-5. He has built teams around potent offenses and strong defenses. Another hire who checks lots of boxes. 24. Ryan Silverfield, Arkansas. Like Candle, Silverfield was able to build an excellent base of talent and score some big wins over teams such as Arkansas, Florida State, West Virginia, Iowa State and Mississippi State. But that made the letdown losses that followed -- like a ghastly defeat against UAB this season -- even more disappointing. Silverfield is clearly solid, but he won't have many athleticism advantages in the SEC. https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47380536/2025-college-football-coaching-carousel-ranking-every-fbs-hire RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - EarthBoundMisfit - 12-23-2025 10:35 AM they put us behind Kent State pn the grading scale...strongly disagree RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Tiger87 - 12-23-2025 03:34 PM (12-23-2025 10:35 AM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: they put us behind Kent State pn the grading scale...strongly disagree Does seem odd to have Kent so high, but whatever. Bottom line is that this is a very well-regarded hire. Now just win, baby. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - AlonsoWDC - 12-23-2025 04:01 PM I dunno, winning even five games at Kent is a minor miracle. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - presskh - 12-23-2025 06:09 PM I’m actually feeling pretty good about this hire, given our second-tier conference limitations. He at least seems to be a good communicator; I also don’t see him becoming the player’s “buddy” instead of their coach. I certainly think there could have been worse choices. I guess we won’t know until the season kicks off. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - TigerBlue4Ever - 12-23-2025 08:16 PM (12-23-2025 06:09 PM)presskh Wrote: I’m actually feeling pretty good about this hire, given our second-tier conference limitations. He at least seems to be a good communicator; I also don’t see him becoming the player’s “buddy” instead of their coach. I certainly think there could have been worse choices. I guess we won’t know until the season kicks off. Yeah, he doesnt seem like he'd be into that kind of nonsense. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - holyterror - 12-26-2025 10:09 AM Coach Huff has a reputation for being a good recruiter. We will start seeing that side of his ability very soon. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Eagleonpar - 12-28-2025 11:29 AM Don’t have a dog in this pissing contest but with our resources compared to the rest of the AAC we should be in the championship game NEXT year. If we don’t get there the season is a failure. Don’t care who the coach is PERIOD RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - ImaTiger - 12-28-2025 11:49 AM So when you look at their resumes at the time of hiring; and focusing on experience as a leader; you'd probably say resume rankings are based on: Ranking by 1. HC experiences (D1, D2, HS) 2. Wins minus losses as HC 3. Years as an Asst then ranked by program strength 4. National Awards and Conference Awards So our hires since Rex ranked by the above 4... #1 Stobart, HC at 2 places (Utah Toledo) and asst for several major power houses. #2 Rex; because at Texas Tech he handled a tough situation when Sloan left and was the SWC coach of the year. Asst jobs at nice schools (not quite power houses). That award is maybe what make some place him as our #1 hc hire. #3 Huff; because of turn arounds at 2 D1 programs and a winning record and high profile asst jobs. Huff was also national recruiter of the year... which I think is the basis of him being our 2nd most 'decorated' HC hire... #4 Tommy; Tommy was HC for 5.1 years at 1 school (ran the program into the ground) and was an asst coach for 6 diff programs. His win loss record was abysmal. I think you'd have to discount his HC time due to poor performance. #5 RIP; turned JMU around 2x's, so he was a D2 HC, 7 or so good asst jobs at power programs. So same resume as Bailey but had HC exp. #6 Bailey; Asst at 8-9 places before here but no HC experience. #7 Rey; 2 D2 HC jobs, but only 1 asst job, more of a high school coach (and it showed). #8 Silverfield; 10+ Asst jobs over a broad array of private colleges, pro and power schools. #9 Porter; asst at 4 places, National recruiter of the year. #10 Norvell; asst at 4 places, no HC experience. #11 Feunte; asst at 2 places, no HC experience. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - shere khan - 12-28-2025 12:49 PM (12-28-2025 11:29 AM)Eagleonpar Wrote: Don’t have a dog in this pissing contest but with our resources compared to the rest of the AAC we should be in the championship game NEXT year. If we don’t get there the season is a failure. Don’t care who the coach is PERIOD How could we not be? A great coach Huff following a great coach Silverfield. This board has told us Looking forward to a championship next year! RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Slack A Lack - 12-28-2025 01:07 PM I got to meet Coach Huff over the weekend. Really nice guy, very polite and he’s excited to get this thing rolling. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Old Tiger - 12-28-2025 04:05 PM Based on his resume, Coach Huff is a good hire. However, until the portal opens on January 2, we will have little or no idea what type of team we will have next year as we are going to have to reload once again through the portal. With 34 guys apparently in the portal (both high quality QBs and our best 2 remaining RBs) and another 33 or so seniors out of eligibility, we will have to get a haul better than last year to compete for a conference championship. Our recruiting class is rated around 75th and I doubt there are any starters there. If Coach Huff brings in a haul from the portal we can reload. If we don't get at least 20 high quality transfers, we will certainly be in rebuild mode next year. Coach Huff has shown that he can turn around a program quickly and the first test of this will be his success in the portal. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - TIGERCITY - 12-28-2025 04:08 PM South Florida hire? I guess he doesn't read this board. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Atlanta - 12-28-2025 04:46 PM (12-28-2025 04:05 PM)Old Tiger Wrote: Based on his resume, Coach Huff is a good hire. However, until the portal opens on January 2, we will have little or no idea what type of team we will have next year as we are going to have to reload once again through the portal. With 34 guys apparently in the portal (both high quality QBs and our best 2 remaining RBs) and another 33 or so seniors out of eligibility, we will have to get a haul better than last year to compete for a conference championship. Our recruiting class is rated around 75th and I doubt there are any starters there. If Coach Huff brings in a haul from the portal we can reload. If we don't get at least 20 high quality transfers, we will certainly be in rebuild mode next year. Coach Huff has shown that he can turn around a program quickly and the first test of this will be his success in the portal. Actually until we have games played, we can applaud ratings & reviews that really meaning nothing. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - shere khan - 12-28-2025 06:10 PM (12-28-2025 04:46 PM)Atlanta Wrote:(12-28-2025 04:05 PM)Old Tiger Wrote: Based on his resume, Coach Huff is a good hire. However, until the portal opens on January 2, we will have little or no idea what type of team we will have next year as we are going to have to reload once again through the portal. With 34 guys apparently in the portal (both high quality QBs and our best 2 remaining RBs) and another 33 or so seniors out of eligibility, we will have to get a haul better than last year to compete for a conference championship. Our recruiting class is rated around 75th and I doubt there are any starters there. If Coach Huff brings in a haul from the portal we can reload. If we don't get at least 20 high quality transfers, we will certainly be in rebuild mode next year. Coach Huff has shown that he can turn around a program quickly and the first test of this will be his success in the portal. Preseason #1 RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Tiger87 - 12-28-2025 09:42 PM (12-28-2025 11:29 AM)Eagleonpar Wrote: Don’t have a dog in this pissing contest but with our resources compared to the rest of the AAC we should be in the championship game NEXT year. If we don’t get there the season is a failure. Don’t care who the coach is PERIOD According to the experts, USF leads us in fb funding, and we are right there with Tulane for #2. Then there are always upstarts with the unbalanced scheduling (Navy, Army, UNT, etc.). We aren't going to make the CCG every year. While over a 6-year period, it's very fair to make it pass/fail on conference championships - it's silly to do that based solely on the first year. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - Tiger87 - 12-28-2025 09:57 PM (12-28-2025 11:49 AM)ImaTiger Wrote: So when you look at their resumes at the time of hiring; and focusing on experience as a leader; you'd probably say resume rankings are based on: Interesting. A few counterpoints: All assistants are not created equally. OC/DC/STC greatly outweighs positions coach. And there's a certain point where longevity as an assistant might become a negative (never got the HC call). Finally, getting fired has to be a negative on the resume. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - AlonsoWDC - 12-29-2025 12:09 PM (12-28-2025 06:10 PM)shere khan Wrote:(12-28-2025 04:46 PM)Atlanta Wrote:(12-28-2025 04:05 PM)Old Tiger Wrote: Based on his resume, Coach Huff is a good hire. However, until the portal opens on January 2, we will have little or no idea what type of team we will have next year as we are going to have to reload once again through the portal. With 34 guys apparently in the portal (both high quality QBs and our best 2 remaining RBs) and another 33 or so seniors out of eligibility, we will have to get a haul better than last year to compete for a conference championship. Our recruiting class is rated around 75th and I doubt there are any starters there. If Coach Huff brings in a haul from the portal we can reload. If we don't get at least 20 high quality transfers, we will certainly be in rebuild mode next year. Coach Huff has shown that he can turn around a program quickly and the first test of this will be his success in the portal. You can't have it both ways. If we made a poor HC hire, you and your kind would have filled this board until September with RUIN and RUE THE DAY posts But we have slammed a homer and you continue to be negative. Tell your wife I said hi. RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - k2tigers - 12-29-2025 12:58 PM and the final carousel ranking from USA Today after the Notre Dame hire https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/ncaaf/2025/12/29/college-football-coaching-hire-rankings/87794567007/ RE: Top college football coach hires rated per espn - shere khan - 12-29-2025 02:31 PM (12-29-2025 12:58 PM)k2tigers Wrote: and the final carousel ranking from USA Today after the Notre Dame hire Heck. No reason we dont go undefeated. Tulane hired the worst, maybe we can beat them. Bookmarking this thread to see how it shakes out
|