CSNbbs
Very few TN players on TN college teams - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: Members (/forum-401.html)
+----- Forum: MemphisTigers.org (/forum-446.html)
+------ Forum: Dockery-Finch Memorial Tiger Sports Forum (/forum-499.html)
+------ Thread: Very few TN players on TN college teams (/thread-1022008.html)

Pages: 1 2


Very few TN players on TN college teams - Herff Tiger - 12-14-2025 12:45 PM

Looked at:
Tenn St
Tenn Tech
East Tenn
Middle Tenn
Tenn-Martin
Tenn-Chatt
Austin Peay
Belmont
Vanderbilt
Lipscomb
us
viles


Middle Tenn has the most, 4 or 5, and that's it. 2 or 3 at most on the others. A lot of foreign players.

Is the talent not there?
Is this an issue of low return on investment for state taxpayers (except for the 3 private colleges)?

I'm sure there are quite a few TN players on teams in other states but I don't like Austin Peay, Tenn Tech, East Tenn St, Tenn-Martin, etc. having such a low percentage. West Tenn St is too big of a program to limit itself on recruiting, I get that, and also maybe it is limited in who it can reasonably sign from other parts of the state and/or beat out other offers.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - memtiger1987 - 12-14-2025 12:58 PM

(12-14-2025 12:45 PM)Herff Tiger Wrote:  Looked at:
Tenn St
Tenn Tech
East Tenn
Middle Tenn
Tenn-Martin
Tenn-Chatt
Austin Peay
Belmont
Vanderbilt
Lipscomb
us
viles


Middle Tenn has the most, 4 or 5, and that's it. 2 or 3 at most on the others. A lot of foreign players.

Is the talent not there?
Is this an issue of low return on investment for state taxpayers (except for the 3 private colleges)?

I'm sure there are quite a few TN players on teams in other states but I don't like Austin Peay, Tenn Tech, East Tenn St, Tenn-Martin, etc. having such a low percentage. West Tenn St is too big of a program to limit itself on recruiting, I get that, and also maybe it is limited in who it can reasonably sign from other parts of the state and/or beat out other offers.

There just haven’t been a lot of talent that stays in Tenn. This could be true of most states, I’m not sure. But most of the better players leave for basketball academies.

Recruiting high school players is hardly worth it. The top players will go for huge NIL and most of the rest will go to lower schools and get seasoned. For schools like Memphis, the transfer portal is the way. But, that doesn’t mean we can’t retain a core of players. It’s common to lose players every year, even the top schools have this issue, but they don’t replace EVERY player EVERY year. It’s just ridiculous at Memphis. And it’s the same thing EVERY year, “ Penny is trying to find a starting rotation”; “Penny is trying to get his team to gel”, etc.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Atlanta - 12-14-2025 03:01 PM

(12-14-2025 12:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-14-2025 12:45 PM)Herff Tiger Wrote:  Looked at:
Tenn St
Tenn Tech
East Tenn
Middle Tenn
Tenn-Martin
Tenn-Chatt
Austin Peay
Belmont
Vanderbilt
Lipscomb
us
viles


Middle Tenn has the most, 4 or 5, and that's it. 2 or 3 at most on the others. A lot of foreign players.

Is the talent not there?
Is this an issue of low return on investment for state taxpayers (except for the 3 private colleges)?

I'm sure there are quite a few TN players on teams in other states but I don't like Austin Peay, Tenn Tech, East Tenn St, Tenn-Martin, etc. having such a low percentage. West Tenn St is too big of a program to limit itself on recruiting, I get that, and also maybe it is limited in who it can reasonably sign from other parts of the state and/or beat out other offers.

There just haven’t been a lot of talent that stays in Tenn. This could be true of most states, I’m not sure. But most of the better players leave for basketball academies.

Recruiting high school players is hardly worth it. The top players will go for huge NIL and most of the rest will go to lower schools and get seasoned. For schools like Memphis, the transfer portal is the way. But, that doesn’t mean we can’t retain a core of players. It’s common to lose players every year, even the top schools have this issue, but they don’t replace EVERY player EVERY year. It’s just ridiculous at Memphis. And it’s the same thing EVERY year, “ Penny is trying to find a starting rotation”; “Penny is trying to get his team to gel”, etc.

Can't see how we stack up better exclusively in the portal than we might by recruiting some high level local high school talent to grow & then supplement with portal players that we might get 2-3 yrs out of. Didn't we have a high level freshman that never saw the floor last season. Don't want to debate it really, I'm probably wrong but I'd think it worth a try, current approach isn't working.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - memtiger1987 - 12-14-2025 04:30 PM

(12-14-2025 03:01 PM)Atlanta Wrote:  
(12-14-2025 12:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-14-2025 12:45 PM)Herff Tiger Wrote:  Looked at:
Tenn St
Tenn Tech
East Tenn
Middle Tenn
Tenn-Martin
Tenn-Chatt
Austin Peay
Belmont
Vanderbilt
Lipscomb
us
viles


Middle Tenn has the most, 4 or 5, and that's it. 2 or 3 at most on the others. A lot of foreign players.

Is the talent not there?
Is this an issue of low return on investment for state taxpayers (except for the 3 private colleges)?

I'm sure there are quite a few TN players on teams in other states but I don't like Austin Peay, Tenn Tech, East Tenn St, Tenn-Martin, etc. having such a low percentage. West Tenn St is too big of a program to limit itself on recruiting, I get that, and also maybe it is limited in who it can reasonably sign from other parts of the state and/or beat out other offers.

There just haven’t been a lot of talent that stays in Tenn. This could be true of most states, I’m not sure. But most of the better players leave for basketball academies.

Recruiting high school players is hardly worth it. The top players will go for huge NIL and most of the rest will go to lower schools and get seasoned. For schools like Memphis, the transfer portal is the way. But, that doesn’t mean we can’t retain a core of players. It’s common to lose players every year, even the top schools have this issue, but they don’t replace EVERY player EVERY year. It’s just ridiculous at Memphis. And it’s the same thing EVERY year, “ Penny is trying to find a starting rotation”; “Penny is trying to get his team to gel”, etc.

Can't see how we stack up better exclusively in the portal than we might by recruiting some high level local high school talent to grow & then supplement with portal players that we might get 2-3 yrs out of. Didn't we have a high level freshman that never saw the floor last season. Don't want to debate it really, I'm probably wrong but I'd think it worth a try, current approach isn't working.

Memphis just hasn’t put out incredible talent lately. And the idea of signing a decent prospect (but not ready to play) just doesn’t seem to work. Our retention rate is probably as bad as any team in the country. So, most don’t stick around (and less likely if they don’t play). We signed Givens and Thedford this year, formally Memphis players that signed elsewhere. So it seems that it’s better to let them season and try to sign them later.

Anyway, you’re right, the current approach isn’t working. But with NIL/transfer portal, it’s hard to grow players. And, you’ll still have to pay them if they have other options. I would like to see us keep a core of players for continuity. They don’t have to be all stars, but strong rotation players. Use the bigger NIL funds to sign a couple of scorers.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - GoDownSwinging - 12-14-2025 06:00 PM

Just don't think there high school prospects that are high caliber prospects. If you take Shelby County away from West Tennessee, the last few West Tennessee high school players to get into an SEC school in basketball was Casey Prather (North Side, played at Florida) and Robert Hubbs (Dyer County, played at Tennessee), and Jaylen Barford (South Side, played JUCO ball, then went to Arkansas). They all graduated High School over 10 years ago.
The talent just isn't there. Even the Gillespie player that is now at Tennessee, went to Belmont, then transferred to Maryland, and is now at Tennessee.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Eagleonpar - 12-15-2025 04:02 PM

(12-14-2025 06:00 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  Just don't think there high school prospects that are high caliber prospects. If you take Shelby County away from West Tennessee, the last few West Tennessee high school players to get into an SEC school in basketball was Casey Prather (North Side, played at Florida) and Robert Hubbs (Dyer County, played at Tennessee), and Jaylen Barford (South Side, played JUCO ball, then went to Arkansas). They all graduated High School over 10 years ago.
The talent just isn't there. Even the Gillespie player that is now at Tennessee, went to Belmont, then transferred to Maryland, and is now at Tennessee.

Willie Kemp and his teammate from Bolivar (forgot his name) went to UT


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - RCM1029 - 12-15-2025 04:17 PM

There was a time kids in west Tennessee grew up wanting to play for the Memphis Tigers. There was a time when kids in east Tennessee grew up wanting to play for Tennessee. Where I grew up in middle Tennessee, we all wanted to play for MTSU or even Vanderbilt. It used to be the dream to play for the school you grew up rooting for. Now, players play wherever they can get paid.

The game has changed.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Unionman76 - 12-15-2025 04:30 PM

(12-15-2025 04:02 PM)Eagleonpar Wrote:  
(12-14-2025 06:00 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  Just don't think there high school prospects that are high caliber prospects. If you take Shelby County away from West Tennessee, the last few West Tennessee high school players to get into an SEC school in basketball was Casey Prather (North Side, played at Florida) and Robert Hubbs (Dyer County, played at Tennessee), and Jaylen Barford (South Side, played JUCO ball, then went to Arkansas). They all graduated High School over 10 years ago.
The talent just isn't there. Even the Gillespie player that is now at Tennessee, went to Belmont, then transferred to Maryland, and is now at Tennessee.

Willie Kemp and his teammate from Bolivar (forgot his name) went to UT

wayne chism, also won state at jackson southside


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - memtiger1987 - 12-15-2025 07:05 PM

(12-15-2025 04:17 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  There was a time kids in west Tennessee grew up wanting to play for the Memphis Tigers. There was a time when kids in east Tennessee grew up wanting to play for Tennessee. Where I grew up in middle Tennessee, we all wanted to play for MTSU or even Vanderbilt. It used to be the dream to play for the school you grew up rooting for. Now, players play wherever they can get paid.

The game has changed.

It’s about the $$$. I don’t blame the players. They’re looking out for themselves, and if they don’t, no one will. But the unlimited transfers needs to be looked at. Could you imagine the NBA/NFL/MLB without contracts? Contracts provide some stability to the league, franchise, fans, and players. I’m not sure the best way to handle this, but the current system is nuts.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Unionman76 - 12-15-2025 07:27 PM

What we need is some unknown school go
Out and buy a championship

Like New Orleans in basketball with master p money

Then the rules would change


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - GermantownTiger - 12-15-2025 08:39 PM

(12-14-2025 06:00 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  Just don't think there high school prospects that are high caliber prospects. If you take Shelby County away from West Tennessee, the last few West Tennessee high school players to get into an SEC school in basketball was Casey Prather (North Side, played at Florida) and Robert Hubbs (Dyer County, played at Tennessee), and Jaylen Barford (South Side, played JUCO ball, then went to Arkansas). They all graduated High School over 10 years ago.
The talent just isn't there. Even the Gillespie player that is now at Tennessee, went to Belmont, then transferred to Maryland, and is now at Tennessee.

Across the country (Memphis area, too), much of the top high school talent has already been moving out of town to play for the "basketball academies" for several years by the time college rolls around if they're not covered up with the AAU circuits.

High school basketball in and of itself barely exists anymore like it did a few decades ago.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - GermantownTiger - 12-15-2025 08:46 PM

(12-15-2025 07:05 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  It’s about the $$$. I don’t blame the players. They’re looking out for themselves, and if they don’t, no one will. But the unlimited transfers needs to be looked at. Could you imagine the NBA/NFL/MLB without contracts? Contracts provide some stability to the league, franchise, fans, and players. I’m not sure the best way to handle this, but the current system is nuts.

100% agree.

The current system is unsustainable with the exception of the Power conference schools who get shitetons of broadcast revenues for football (and to a lesser degree basketball).

Short of a school like Memphis having a couple of "super boosters" willing to pony up millions every year for NIL payroll levels that compete with the big boys, it's gonna get tougher every year to put a consistently Top 20 team on the court.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - TigerBlue4Ever - 12-15-2025 08:59 PM

(12-15-2025 08:46 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote:  
(12-15-2025 07:05 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  It’s about the $$$. I don’t blame the players. They’re looking out for themselves, and if they don’t, no one will. But the unlimited transfers needs to be looked at. Could you imagine the NBA/NFL/MLB without contracts? Contracts provide some stability to the league, franchise, fans, and players. I’m not sure the best way to handle this, but the current system is nuts.

100% agree.

The current system is unsustainable with the exception of the Power conference schools who get shitetons of broadcast revenues for football (and to a lesser degree basketball).

Short of a school like Memphis having a couple of "super boosters" willing to pony up millions every year for NIL payroll levels that compete with the big boys, it's gonna get tougher every year to put a consistently Top 20 team on the court.

Those boosters will almost certainly at some point start wanting to see an ROI. What form that takes is probably tied to conference championships and at least consistent runs in the NCAA tournament.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - GermantownTiger - 12-15-2025 09:01 PM

(12-15-2025 08:59 PM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote:  Those boosters will almost certainly at some point start wanting to see an ROI. What form that takes is probably tied to conference championships and at least consistent runs in the NCAA tournament.

No doubt about it.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - 2021 Tiger Football!! - 12-15-2025 09:21 PM

I’ve asked this question many times. The answer usually given by those that know is usually that the top talent leaves the area during high school to play for top prep teams and once they’re out of this area they realize they don’t want to return. Just what I’ve been told.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - micman - 12-15-2025 09:28 PM

(12-14-2025 06:00 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  Just don't think there high school prospects that are high caliber prospects. If you take Shelby County away from West Tennessee, the last few West Tennessee high school players to get into an SEC school in basketball was Casey Prather (North Side, played at Florida) and Robert Hubbs (Dyer County, played at Tennessee), and Jaylen Barford (South Side, played JUCO ball, then went to Arkansas). They all graduated High School over 10 years ago.
The talent just isn't there. Even the Gillespie player that is now at Tennessee, went to Belmont, then transferred to Maryland, and is now at Tennessee.

Likely best player in ncaa from Germantown. Plays for Texas. Booker.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - micman - 12-15-2025 09:32 PM

1986 team on YouTube lately against Louisville and LSU (unfortunately). Entire starting 5 from Memphis. Turner, Boyd, Askew, Batman, and Bedford. Pretty awesome watching the intros.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Herff Tiger - 12-15-2025 10:12 PM

(12-15-2025 09:21 PM)2021 Tiger Football!! Wrote:  I’ve asked this question many times. The answer usually given by those that know is usually that the top talent leaves the area during high school to play for top prep teams and once they’re out of this area they realize they don’t want to return. Just what I’ve been told.

I can see that. When I went to Florida for Spring Break my freshman year, the first time I had been south of Memphis and in a state besides TN & KY, I didn't want to come back.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Herff Tiger - 12-15-2025 10:15 PM

(12-15-2025 04:17 PM)RCM1029 Wrote:  There was a time kids in west Tennessee grew up wanting to play for the Memphis Tigers.

Nah. Some in Memphis and a few in the surrounding counties, but most would have gone to the viles in a second.


RE: Very few TN players on TN college teams - Alcalde2 - 12-16-2025 02:39 AM

Arent most of the very best high school kids going to prep schools made almost entirely of top 200 recruits these days?

Teams like Montverde in Florida for instance... when Penny was coaching at East he was scheduling those kind of high school teams. I remember he played Findlay Prep with Manute Bols kid, and he went to Florida to play University School and James Wiseman played against a front court of Vernon Carey and Scottie Barnes. I remember Barnes was a sophomore that year and I thought he looked like the best player on the court then. He proved to be obviously