![]() |
|
What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: ACCbbs (/forum-381.html) +---- Forum: ACC Conference Talk (/forum-351.html) +---- Thread: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? (/thread-1021834.html) |
What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Garrettabc - 12-11-2025 08:15 AM I’m not sure if the cable companies are going to renegotiate immediately, but somewhere down the line the ACCN will not be getting full rates in Indiana or Chicago. ESPN may be locked in at the current rate until 2036, but I don’t think they’ll do any pay increases so that might effect the 1 pro-rata owed. Lacrosse and other Olympic sports - The ACC might need to add 1 more just to reach the requirement to sponsor these sports. The good is less losses in OOC play, but it would be that much harder to find Power level OOC opponents. What am I missing? RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Hokie Mark - 12-11-2025 09:00 AM Less deep dish pizza. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - ken d - 12-12-2025 03:58 PM Instead of wondering about letting Notre Dame leave, might it not be better for everybody to modify the current scheduling deal in a way that helps both the Irish and the stronger ACC programs that have a realistic chance at CFP success? ND has already indicated it's willing to play Clemson annually, even if it's outside the current five game commitment. That helps both their SOS and Clemson's most of the time. I suggest the following deal. Notre Dame is eligible for the ACC championship if they play Clemson, Miami, and Florida State annually; alternate Stanford/Cal, Georgia Tech/SMU, UNC/Pitt (or some other combination); and play the other 8 ACC schools every four years instead of the current three year rotation. That's six games a year. They also play (or want to play) USC every year. Let them schedule two additional games suitable to the ACC against P2 teams which, along with USC, are designated ACC conference games to bring them to 9 P4 games. Require that they have four home "conference" games one year, and five the next, like every other ACC team. Notre Dame gets a national schdule with P2 strength. The top ACC programs' schedules are also upgraded. The league's chances for multiple CFP bids are improved. ESPN is happy. It's unorthodox, but so is the current arrangement. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - All-in - 12-12-2025 05:47 PM (12-12-2025 03:58 PM)ken d Wrote: Instead of wondering about letting Notre Dame leave, might it not be better for everybody to modify the current scheduling deal in a way that helps both the Irish and the stronger ACC programs that have a realistic chance at CFP success? Things like this is why Clemson and FSU want to get out of the ACC. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - LaBradfordsTWill - 12-12-2025 06:06 PM The fallout is more on ND than on the ACC. They would have to go to the Big East which is only a high profile basketball league. Their Olympic sports would suffer and I believe ND cares about them. Yes, ND football would go on as usual, but the rest of the Athletic Department would be taking a demotion in prestige. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Garrettabc - 12-12-2025 06:26 PM (12-12-2025 03:58 PM)ken d Wrote: Instead of wondering about letting Notre Dame leave, might it not be better for everybody to modify the current scheduling deal in a way that helps both the Irish and the stronger ACC programs that have a realistic chance at CFP success? All good suggestions, some of which I pondered, but… 1) I’d rather FSU play more SEC teams rather than stuck playing 9 ACC opponents, UF and ND, there is just no room for OOC variety. Miami should be annual and I think ND fans would rather play them than FSU if they had a choice. 2) Part of making peace with ND is getting them back down to 5 ACC games. 6 might be more tolerable if it was a hand picked 6, but that means half of the ACC won’t get to play them ever again. 3) If Terry truly has a pulse on what ND likes, then they are not going to have any part of the ACCCG. I do have an idea how ND can play a 13th game and the ACC can play their 6th annual game which I will reveal soon, but I’m sure I’ll get scorned by the ND faithful. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Schema - 12-12-2025 06:46 PM In basketball, each school has one permanent home and away, one rotating home and away, seven home only, and seven away only, leaving one conference opponent off the schedule. If Notre Dame leaves, each school would be able to face all other conference schools. What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Lenvillecards - 12-12-2025 09:30 PM (12-12-2025 05:47 PM)All-in Wrote:(12-12-2025 03:58 PM)ken d Wrote: Instead of wondering about letting Notre Dame leave, might it not be better for everybody to modify the current scheduling deal in a way that helps both the Irish and the stronger ACC programs that have a realistic chance at CFP success? Yeah, why give ND a chance to take the ACC auto bid when they already get special treatment for an at large & we could be stuck without anyone in the CFP? Horrible idea. ND has no business playing in the ACC CCG. Better one is to have more ACC brands play them more often. Go Cards & Kings! RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - GTFletch - 12-12-2025 09:56 PM (12-11-2025 08:15 AM)Garrettabc Wrote: I’m not sure if the cable companies are going to renegotiate immediately, but somewhere down the line the ACCN will not be getting full rates in Indiana or Chicago. Come on, you think ND is really leaving??? They get 50M from NBC and 20-25M from ACCN. How can the Big East get ND the 25M (they might get them 10M) So then the question is will BIG10 allow ND to come as all sports except FB... and share the BIGN monies like the ACC does... ND stays in the ACC as partial member as Stanford and Cal (who they wanted) just arrived! RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Wahoowa84 - 12-12-2025 10:48 PM (12-12-2025 03:58 PM)ken d Wrote: Instead of wondering about letting Notre Dame leave, might it not be better for everybody to modify the current scheduling deal in a way that helps both the Irish and the stronger ACC programs that have a realistic chance at CFP success? NO! Those are horrible ideas. When an ACC team is on the CFP bubble, the conference did right by advocating for Miami. Notre Dame is not a football member of the ACC. More importantly, aggressively favoring certain members is not right. The purpose of a conference is not to make competition easier for the biggest brands. What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - georgia_tech_swagger - 12-12-2025 11:33 PM Everybody gets a better bowl game. Sent from my SM-G766U1 using CSNbbs mobile app RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - ken d - 12-13-2025 08:55 AM (12-12-2025 10:48 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:(12-12-2025 03:58 PM)ken d Wrote: Instead of wondering about letting Notre Dame leave, might it not be better for everybody to modify the current scheduling deal in a way that helps both the Irish and the stronger ACC programs that have a realistic chance at CFP success? What I suggested is intended to make competition harder, not easier, for the ACC's biggest brands, and improve their SOS to make more of them able to qualify for the CFP, to the benefit of the entire conference. As for ND not being a football member of the ACC, this proposal would essentially make them a member, albeit one with a much more difficult path to an ACC championship than any other member. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - GTFletch - 12-13-2025 09:25 AM Notre Dame stepping away from a deeper ACC football commitment isn’t necessarily the disaster it’s often framed to be—especially when you look at it through a long-term, strategic lens for both ND and the league. For Notre Dame, independence (or semi-independence) actually reopens doors that ACC scheduling constraints partially closed. Without being locked into a heavy ACC slate, ND gains far more flexibility to schedule premium, Power 4 matchups—particularly against the SEC. Those games carry real value: national visibility, playoff-strength résumés, and television appeal. A future schedule that regularly features SEC opponents, plus Big Ten rivals and the occasional Big 12 matchup, does more for Notre Dame’s brand and postseason positioning than a rigid conference model ever could. From the ACC’s perspective, Notre Dame’s reduced football footprint doesn’t cripple the league either. The ACC has already been operating in a world where ND football was only a partial member. Losing guaranteed ND games forces ACC programs to do what they should already be doing: seek competitive, high-profile non-conference matchups that strengthen résumés and fan interest. In an expanded playoff era, quality wins matter more than conference logos. There’s also a competitive upside. Without Notre Dame’s unique scheduling advantages inside the ACC framework, the league gains clarity. The ACC can fully focus on schools that are all-in on football membership, scheduling balance, and long-term revenue alignment. That cohesion matters more than propping up a hybrid member whose priorities will always be national rather than conference-driven. Finally, this shift reflects the reality of modern college football. The sport is no longer about geographic alignment—it’s about inventory, matchups, and media value. Notre Dame scheduling more SEC and Big Ten opponents creates marquee games that benefit the entire ecosystem, while the ACC recalibrates around committed members and strategic scheduling. In short, ND leaving deeper ACC football ties isn’t fatal—it’s an adjustment. One that gives Notre Dame more scheduling freedom, pushes ACC programs to be more aggressive, and aligns both sides with where college football is clearly heading. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - TerryD - 12-13-2025 11:47 AM (12-13-2025 09:25 AM)GTFletch Wrote: Notre Dame stepping away from a deeper ACC football commitment isn’t necessarily the disaster it’s often framed to be—especially when you look at it through a long-term, strategic lens for both ND and the league. Plus, there would be a whole lot less ACC losses to ND. The Irish are 37-4 vs. ACC teams since the beginning of 2018. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Shannon Panther - 12-13-2025 01:44 PM Notre Dame may not be happy with the ACC right now, but what other options do they have? Maybe the Big 12 would give them a similar deal to the ACC. The Big 10 and SEC would gladly accept them as a full member, but they will never give them the sweetheart deal they have with the ACC. I'm sure the Big East would give them an Olympic sports membership, but the media deal with them would be half or less of what they receive from the ACC. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Wahoowa84 - 12-13-2025 04:34 PM (12-13-2025 09:25 AM)GTFletch Wrote: Notre Dame stepping away from a deeper ACC football commitment isn’t necessarily the disaster it’s often framed to be—especially when you look at it through a long-term, strategic lens for both ND and the league. Disagree. ND admissions to the ACC was largely a financial deal (that’s what makes ND AD and fans comments recently so egregious…they’re arguing that we’re the bad partner when we support Miami football). The 5-game football contract is the quid-pro-quo for all 14 members having a partial member who doesn’t really support the conference. UVa was willing to allow SMU take its place versus ND football…creating a win-win-win negotiation for ND, SMU and UVa. A few writers have suggested that other legacy members may be looking for similar arrangements. Whatever solution comes about has to significantly improve the finances of the ACC. ND still has complete flexibility in scheduling 7 games per year. While ACC football members, and all other P4 programs, will only have similar flexibility for 3 games per year (actually, 2 games per year for teams with historic OOC rivals). The ACC didn’t schedule ND’s games versus the SEC and Big Ten cellar dwellers (e.g., 0-8 Arkansas and 0-9 Purdue)…those decisions and lack of accountability is what ND is conveniently downplaying in its criticisms of the ACC. FWIW - there is a compromise where ND gets a reliably much stronger SOS via the ACC…it’s a simple extension of the ND-UVa-SMU model. Replace weaker football team’s visiting South Bend with stronger football brands, while also adding games at their sites (e.g., in Clemson, Miami, Tallahassee, etc.). Everyone wins something. RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Wolfman - 12-13-2025 05:21 PM What about a Stanford style arrangement? ND takes football, leaves Olympic sports, gets zero dollars from ACC. What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - Lenvillecards - 12-14-2025 12:35 AM With the B1G, SEC & B12 playing 9 conference games & only 1 P4 opponent, will ND be able to schedule 12 quality opponents without the ACC? The top brands availability will be extremely limited, especially with the established OOC rivalries. Would they be happy with a schedule full of G5 teams? Go Cards & Kings! RE: What is the fallout if ND left the ACC? - ChrisLords - 12-14-2025 05:39 AM (12-13-2025 05:21 PM)Wolfman Wrote: What about a Stanford style arrangement? ND takes football, leaves Olympic sports, gets zero dollars from ACC. Stanford and Cal aren't getting nothing forever. They're waiting their way up to a full membership share. |