CSNbbs
Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff (/thread-1021633.html)



Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Dr Dawgma III - 12-19-2025 02:25 PM

Seeds:

1-Indiana*
2-Ohio State
3-Georgia*
4-Texas Tech*
5-Oregon
6-Ole Miss
7-Texas A&M
8-Oklahoma
9-Alabama
10-Miami
11-Notre Dame
12-BYU
13-Texas
14-Vanderbilt
15-Utah
16-Southern Cal
17-Tulane*
18-James Madison*
19-Duke*
20-Boise State*
21-Kennesaw State*
22-Western Michigan*

Last two out: Arizona and Michigan

* Denotes conference champ

First Round (Current Army-Navy Weekend)
Tulane at Southern Cal
Boise State at Texas
Kennesaw State at BYU
JMU at Utah
Duke at Vanderbilt
W. Michigan at Notre Dame

Second Round (Current First Round Weekend)
Tulane/Southern Cal at Indiana
Alabama at Oklahoma

Boise State/Texas at Texas Tech
Kennesaw State/BYU at Oregon

JMU/Utah at Ohio State
Miami at Texas A&M

Duke/Vanderbilt at Georgia
W. Michigan/Notre Dame at Ole Miss

• • •

The rest remains the same and the CFP is easily expandable up to 24, although I find this superior.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Just Joe - 12-19-2025 02:37 PM

No thank you. I have no problem letting a G5 champ in as they have to both win their conference and do something to separate themselves from the other four G5 champs. And for that matter I didn't have an issue with JMU over Duke although that circumstance isn't likely to happen again. Once you're letting the Sun Belt and CUSA have the same autobid access as the SEC or Big Ten... yeah, no. Not all FBS conferences are created equal and you're guaranteed to see the Power 4 (or 2 or whatever) leave and let the others figure out whether they want to stay in the hollowed out husk of FBS or go back to FCS.

The basketball tournaments have 30 plus autobids to spread out over a field of 64 (plus however many first 4/play in games they have in any given year) leaving plenty of room for the best 30ish teams to be guaranteed a spot as at large bids. Football doesn't need to waste spots in a much smaller field on teams that objectively should be (and really already are) participating on a lower level.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - b2b - 12-19-2025 03:01 PM

What if you had the G6 in "play in" games? The 6 would play for the right to play the P4 #1, #2 and #3.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - U-C-FKnights - 12-19-2025 03:24 PM

I like it. I like getting all the conference champs involved. I was thinking of posting something similar, but with one change.

To avoid some of the complaints of adding all the low ranked G6 champs, I would suggest maybe adding a 2 play in games for the bottom 4 g5s on the weekend after championship week. So only 4 g6 teams in the main tournament.

You could even let them as a group sell those games and keep the money as a group if they don’t want to roll it all into the CFP.

You could stretch it to 3 play in games for the G6 to get only three into the main tournament . But I like keeping top 6 conference champs ( the p4 and 2 G6).

I would structure it as 22 teams (top 6 champs, 2 more AQ for each P4, 6 at large and 2 from G6 playing games. Top 10 seeds get 1st round bye. Tournament would be 5 rounds. The two play in g6 games would probably need to be Army Navy week, but being only two games could keep the 3:30 time slot exclusive.

This my attempt to compromise and make everyone happy lol.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Garden_KC - 12-19-2025 04:31 PM

(12-19-2025 03:01 PM)b2b Wrote:  What if you had the G6 in "play in" games? The 6 would play for the right to play the P4 #1, #2 and #3.

Make it a 3/3/3/3/3/ where the G6 have 3 slots but teams 1 vs 2, 3 vs 4, 5 vs 6 do the WCG thing. The G6 collectively has as many good teams as the XII or ACC do by themseles. Worth their own WCGs.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - bryanw1995 - 12-19-2025 04:35 PM

(12-19-2025 02:25 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Seeds:

1-Indiana*
2-Ohio State
3-Georgia*
4-Texas Tech*
5-Oregon
6-Ole Miss
7-Texas A&M
8-Oklahoma
9-Alabama
10-Miami
11-Notre Dame
12-BYU
13-Texas
14-Vanderbilt
15-Utah
16-Southern Cal
17-Tulane*
18-James Madison*
19-Duke*
20-Boise State*
21-Kennesaw State*
22-Western Michigan*

Last two out: Arizona and Michigan

* Denotes conference champ

First Round (Current Army-Navy Weekend)
Tulane at Southern Cal
Boise State at Texas
Kennesaw State at BYU
JMU at Utah
Duke at Vanderbilt
W. Michigan at Notre Dame

Second Round (Current First Round Weekend)
Tulane/Southern Cal at Indiana
Alabama at Oklahoma

Boise State/Texas at Texas Tech
Kennesaw State/BYU at Oregon

JMU/Utah at Ohio State
Miami at Texas A&M

Duke/Vanderbilt at Georgia
W. Michigan/Notre Dame at Ole Miss

• • •

The rest remains the same and the CFP is easily expandable up to 24, although I find this superior.

Why only 9 Champs? No love for the 2Pac??


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Dr Dawgma III - 12-19-2025 05:03 PM

(12-19-2025 04:35 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-19-2025 02:25 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Seeds:

1-Indiana*
2-Ohio State
3-Georgia*
4-Texas Tech*
5-Oregon
6-Ole Miss
7-Texas A&M
8-Oklahoma
9-Alabama
10-Miami
11-Notre Dame
12-BYU
13-Texas
14-Vanderbilt
15-Utah
16-Southern Cal
17-Tulane*
18-James Madison*
19-Duke*
20-Boise State*
21-Kennesaw State*
22-Western Michigan*

Last two out: Arizona and Michigan

* Denotes conference champ

First Round (Current Army-Navy Weekend)
Tulane at Southern Cal
Boise State at Texas
Kennesaw State at BYU
JMU at Utah
Duke at Vanderbilt
W. Michigan at Notre Dame

Second Round (Current First Round Weekend)
Tulane/Southern Cal at Indiana
Alabama at Oklahoma

Boise State/Texas at Texas Tech
Kennesaw State/BYU at Oregon

JMU/Utah at Ohio State
Miami at Texas A&M

Duke/Vanderbilt at Georgia
W. Michigan/Notre Dame at Ole Miss

• • •

The rest remains the same and the CFP is easily expandable up to 24, although I find this superior.

Why only 9 Champs? No love for the 2Pac??

Good catch. I’m honestly unaware if they declared a champ this season!


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Dr Dawgma III - 12-20-2025 08:17 AM

(12-19-2025 03:24 PM)U-C-FKnights Wrote:  I like it. I like getting all the conference champs involved. I was thinking of posting something similar, but with one change.

To avoid some of the complaints of adding all the low ranked G6 champs, I would suggest maybe adding a 2 play in games for the bottom 4 g5s on the weekend after championship week. So only 4 g6 teams in the main tournament.

You could even let them as a group sell those games and keep the money as a group if they don’t want to roll it all into the CFP.

You could stretch it to 3 play in games for the G6 to get only three into the main tournament . But I like keeping top 6 conference champs ( the p4 and 2 G6).

I would structure it as 22 teams (top 6 champs, 2 more AQ for each P4, 6 at large and 2 from G6 playing games. Top 10 seeds get 1st round bye. Tournament would be 5 rounds. The two play in g6 games would probably need to be Army Navy week, but being only two games could keep the 3:30 time slot exclusive.

This my attempt to compromise and make everyone happy lol.

The only way to have a fair CFP for all of FBS is to include every conference champ. The concession would be to offer more at-larges than currently available.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Garden_KC - 12-20-2025 12:55 PM

(12-20-2025 08:17 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(12-19-2025 03:24 PM)U-C-FKnights Wrote:  I like it. I like getting all the conference champs involved. I was thinking of posting something similar, but with one change.

To avoid some of the complaints of adding all the low ranked G6 champs, I would suggest maybe adding a 2 play in games for the bottom 4 g5s on the weekend after championship week. So only 4 g6 teams in the main tournament.

You could even let them as a group sell those games and keep the money as a group if they don’t want to roll it all into the CFP.

You could stretch it to 3 play in games for the G6 to get only three into the main tournament . But I like keeping top 6 conference champs ( the p4 and 2 G6).

I would structure it as 22 teams (top 6 champs, 2 more AQ for each P4, 6 at large and 2 from G6 playing games. Top 10 seeds get 1st round bye. Tournament would be 5 rounds. The two play in g6 games would probably need to be Army Navy week, but being only two games could keep the 3:30 time slot exclusive.

This my attempt to compromise and make everyone happy lol.

The only way to have a fair CFP for all of FBS is to include every conference champ. The concession would be to offer more at-larges than currently available.

If you had a WCG format and then the G6 had 1 vs 2, 3 vs 4, 5 vs 6 representing the best G6 to determine 3 bids that would be fair enough and more attractive for the playoff system than every conference champ.

I just think the playoff would be better if it wasn't 75% from SEC & B1G. Sure the other leagues don't have the 5 stars but often have really good defenses that can keep it interesting.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Stugray2 - 12-20-2025 01:47 PM

No. The last thing we need is more G6 teams in the playoff. Starting next year, per Dellenger's reporting, the MOU of the autonomous conferences who control the CFP format, the G6 access will be limited to one entry only, with auto-bids to the four CCG winners from the autonomous conferences replacing the vague "top 5 conferences." The Autonomous schools are long-term (as in within 3 years) looking for ways to incentivize a G6 CFP to not have to deal with the access issue in order to avoid anti-trust lawsuits.

I suspect the eventual compromise will be a 14-team playoff, with a separate 12-team G6 playoff which increases the money G6 schools get from the CFP system. The CFP will be open to all, allowing non-autonomous school ranked in the top 12 can get in, but the G6 playoff championship will not be open to autonomous schools. (For the G6 this replaces the great season reward of playing in a meaningless low value bowl against a random opponent which nobody will remember next year.) The key to this is coming to fruition will be securing the payout for the G6 to make it financially appealing.

Now, were I the tsar of CFB, I'd cull the non-playoff bowl games to the few with a high minimum payout guarantee required, stripping of conference tie-ins to give top 25 schools not in a playoff an opportunity to have a reward game if they desire (I imagine half a dozen passed over schools will want to "prove" they should have been in the playoff, while half a dozen just want to shut it down). But mostly I'd replace the bowls with an exhibition game window in mid-December to allow schools to schedule any opponent they want in a non-counting game/scrimmage to evaluate returning players (on the bench) before the portal opens, giving schools who choose to use that say four practices, one with contact. I also see this as a chance for "practice squad" walk-ons including seniors to get some actual game action.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - andy98 - 12-22-2025 03:03 AM

So basically the committee would choose the top 16 teams from the P4 conferences, but the bottom 6 would first have to do a play-in game versus the G6 champions. If all of the P4 teams manage to beat all of the G6 teams, then you would be left with a 16 team playoff with all P4 teams. But at least the G6 champs were all given a chance to play their way in.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Dr Dawgma III - 12-22-2025 07:29 AM

(12-20-2025 01:47 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  No. The last thing we need is more G6 teams in the playoff. Starting next year, per Dellenger's reporting, the MOU of the autonomous conferences who control the CFP format, the G6 access will be limited to one entry only, with auto-bids to the four CCG winners from the autonomous conferences replacing the vague "top 5 conferences." The Autonomous schools are long-term (as in within 3 years) looking for ways to incentivize a G6 CFP to not have to deal with the access issue in order to avoid anti-trust lawsuits.

I suspect the eventual compromise will be a 14-team playoff, with a separate 12-team G6 playoff which increases the money G6 schools get from the CFP system. The CFP will be open to all, allowing non-autonomous school ranked in the top 12 can get in, but the G6 playoff championship will not be open to autonomous schools. (For the G6 this replaces the great season reward of playing in a meaningless low value bowl against a random opponent which nobody will remember next year.) The key to this is coming to fruition will be securing the payout for the G6 to make it financially appealing.

Now, were I the tsar of CFB, I'd cull the non-playoff bowl games to the few with a high minimum payout guarantee required, stripping of conference tie-ins to give top 25 schools not in a playoff an opportunity to have a reward game if they desire (I imagine half a dozen passed over schools will want to "prove" they should have been in the playoff, while half a dozen just want to shut it down). But mostly I'd replace the bowls with an exhibition game window in mid-December to allow schools to schedule any opponent they want in a non-counting game/scrimmage to evaluate returning players (on the bench) before the portal opens, giving schools who choose to use that say four practices, one with contact. I also see this as a chance for "practice squad" walk-ons including seniors to get some actual game action.


Thank the lawd you are tsar of nothing!

DAWGMA would strip any record requirements concerning bowls, because they already are exhibition games. The bowl system is already in place, and believe it or not, a lot of players enjoy them. Also, there should absolutely be player incentive$ to play in them.

DAWGMA = more football with equal opportunity for ALL FBS programs

Stugray2 = less football and a convoluted exhibition window with no logistics in place




Under the patented DAWGMA CFP, the viewership of ALL CCG's would skyrocket.


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Crayton - 02-25-2026 03:38 PM

You just mentioned this on another thread and I never responded.

Better than what you have, I suggest replacing G6 CCGs with G6-owned play ins. So instead of JMU playing Troy, they play an at large team.

Benefits:
G6 game is now more likely to feature a national brand ($$)
P4 get up to 6 additional play-in spots
Top 25 all get in, meaning strong G6 runner-ups get access


RE: Patented DAWGMA 22-Team Playoff - Dr Dawgma III - 02-25-2026 06:59 PM

Well, the G6 isn’t getting more than one auto-bid so it won’t matter. Shame on everyone for shutting down the NCAA in the 80’s