CSNbbs
CFP locks - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: CFP locks (/thread-1021290.html)

Pages: 1 2


CFP locks - Fighting Muskie - 12-03-2025 01:16 PM

Going into the CCGs, I think these 8 teams are locks:

Ohio State, Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, TAMU, Oklahoma

Win and in:
BYU, UNT/Tulane, UVA

Vulnerable:
Alabama & ND— Bama does t necessarily need to win but they certainly can’t afford to lose bad. BYU is in a position to play bid thief with a win and ND would currently be the team knocked out. However, that team could become Alabama if their performance is bad enough in the CCG that the committee elects to slide them down.

Needs a Duke Upset:
JMU

Things look bad:
Miami, Vanderbilt, & Texas— they are all idle, so they can’t win and improve their rank.

Needs total chaos:
UNLV, Boise State, Duke, Kenn St, Troy — It’s been pointed out that if both UVA and JMU lose, the committee would need to select a 5th CCG winner for an autobid. 11-2 UNLV would be an attractive selection if they defeat Boise. If they lose too, the committee would have to choose between 8-5 Duke, 9-4 Boise St, 9-4 Troy, or 10-3 Kenn St. (I guess theoretically a 9-4 Jacksonville St or the MAC champ could be in play.)

One side note—I’m interested to see how the committee reacts to Ole Miss’s loss of Kiffin and the potential of players jumping to the portal to go with him. It might drop them some in the seeding but I’d be shocked if it takes them all the way out of the top 10.


RE: CFP locks - domer1978 - 12-03-2025 01:19 PM

I expect to be left out. Can't start 0-2 and leave it up to a bunch of dorks in a room. I believe we can compete and beat anyone in the country now, but we started the way we started.


RE: CFP locks - mlb - 12-03-2025 01:20 PM

(12-03-2025 01:19 PM)domer1978 Wrote:  I expect to be left out. Can't start 0-2 and leave it up to a bunch of dorks in a room. I believe we can compete and beat anyone in the country now, but we started the way we started.

I believe that too, but at the end of the day you have to win the games you play... based on that ND shouldn't be in.


RE: CFP locks - AuzGrams - 12-03-2025 01:21 PM

Why is Texas Tech a lock?

What does 11-2 Texas Tech do that other teams do?


RE: CFP locks - bryanw1995 - 12-03-2025 01:21 PM

(12-03-2025 01:16 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Going into the CCGs, I think these 8 teams are locks:

Ohio State, Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, TAMU, Oklahoma

Win and in:
BYU, UNT/Tulane, UVA

Vulnerable:
Alabama & ND— Bama does t necessarily need to win but they certainly can’t afford to lose bad. BYU is in a position to play bid thief with a win and ND would currently be the team knocked out. However, that team could become Alabama if their performance is bad enough in the CCG that the committee elects to slide them down.

Needs a Duke Upset:
JMU

Things look bad:
Miami, Vanderbilt, & Texas— they are all idle, so they can’t win and improve their rank.

One side note—I’m interested to see how the committee reacts to Ole Miss’s loss of Kiffin and the potential of players jumping to the portal to go with him. It might drop them some in the seeding but I’d be shocked if it takes them all the way out of the top 10.

If the committee was going to drop Ole Miss, yesterday was the time to do it. They've obviously decided to completely ignore Kiffin leaving. Instead, they vaulted them over my Aggies despite a much easier schedule. Why? Recency bias. Ole Miss lost over a month ago, Aggies lost 3 days ago, so recency bias trumps much stronger SOS. Recency bias and especially eye test seem to be the only 2 things that the Committee cares about these days. The only reason I'm not howling about it is that we're still hosting a CFP game in any of the 5-8 spots, so I'm happy with any of them.


RE: CFP locks - solohawks - 12-03-2025 01:22 PM

If BYU wins and Alabama wins, you gotta think BYU takes Notre Dame's slot, or else the committee would have put ND ahead of Oklahoma

If BYU wins and Alabama loses, does BYU take Alabama's slot or Notre Dame's?


RE: CFP locks - mlb - 12-03-2025 01:23 PM

(12-03-2025 01:21 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  Why is Texas Tech a lock?

What does 11-2 Texas Tech do that other teams do?

The committee has them 4th. It would take a big loss to knock them out of an at large.


RE: CFP locks - bryanw1995 - 12-03-2025 01:30 PM

(12-03-2025 01:21 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  Why is Texas Tech a lock?

What does 11-2 Texas Tech do that other teams do?

11-2 Texas Tech has 1 more win that other 2 loss teams
11-2 Texas Tech went 1-1 against BYU, the Big 12 champs
11-2 Texas Tech also blew out Utah and BYU the first time they played, too, so they're 2-1 against the top 15
11-2 Texas Tech lost a game in the last minute with their (now healthy) QB out hurt - I don't agree with this guideline, but it is one of the few things that Committee consistently cares about, and a close loss to a good team when you have a hurt QB who comes back and starts dominating again doesn't hurt as much as any other loss

On average, if the higher ranked team loses the CCG, they drop 3.4 spots, and the lower ranked team typically drops 1.6 spots. If Texas Tech loses, due to the 3 1 loss teams right behind them, I think they'd fall below A&M and be in the mix at #8 with OU. BYU SHOULD leap up to take the #4 slot if they beat Texas Tech, but they'd probably be more like 6 or 7 b/c the committee has zero respect for them for some reason.


RE: CFP locks - GoBuckeyes1047 - 12-03-2025 01:38 PM

(12-03-2025 01:16 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Going into the CCGs, I think these 8 teams are locks:

Ohio State, Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, TAMU, Oklahoma

Win and in:
BYU, UNT/Tulane, UVA

Vulnerable:
Alabama & ND— Bama does t necessarily need to win but they certainly can’t afford to lose bad. BYU is in a position to play bid thief with a win and ND would currently be the team knocked out. However, that team could become Alabama if their performance is bad enough in the CCG that the committee elects to slide them down.

Needs a Duke Upset:
JMU

Things look bad:
Miami, Vanderbilt, & Texas— they are all idle, so they can’t win and improve their rank.

One side note—I’m interested to see how the committee reacts to Ole Miss’s loss of Kiffin and the potential of players jumping to the portal to go with him. It might drop them some in the seeding but I’d be shocked if it takes them all the way out of the top 10.

I wouldn't completely rule out the MWC CCG winner and Duke if JMU and Virginia both lose. Miami also could potentially sneak in depending on if BYU loses bad and gets a more direct comparison to ND.


RE: CFP locks - Fighting Muskie - 12-03-2025 01:39 PM

BYU would really have to pummel Texas Tech to make them fall from 4 to 11. Historically, the committee hasn’t punished teams too harshly for losing CCGs, especially when comparing them to teams who didn’t play in one.


RE: CFP locks - GoldenWarrior11 - 12-03-2025 01:42 PM

I actually think Alabama is a near-lock. They already beat Georgia once. If favorites (Ohio State, Georgia, Texas Tech, Virginia) all win this weekend, this is what I believe is being set-up:

1. Ohio State (AQ)
2. Georgia (AQ)
3. Indiana
4. Texas Tech (AQ)
5. Oregon
6. Ole Miss
7. Texas A&M
8. Oklahoma
9. Alabama
10. BYU/Miami/ND
11. Virginia (AQ)
12. North Texas/Tulane (AQ)
*JMU is #12 if Duke beats Virginia; American Champion would then be #11

For the Big 12 - If BYU wins, they are in. I don't think they get in with a loss, as matchup #1 with Tech wasn't close. Tech is in regardless.
For the ACC - Virginia is in if they win, but the ACC is shut out if Duke loses. James Madison gets AQ #5. Essentially the #5 AQ spot is for either JMU/Virginia.

The million dollar question is whether the committee will then (after all the CCGs being played) determine if they view ND and Miami on the same line for the same spot, in which case the head-to-head would come into play (I presume it is). Despite any metrics, SOS, margin of victory and "look", Miami owns the head to head win over them. That's all that is needed. It's funny, but neither Miami or Notre Dame played Duke or Virginia this year, so that game has really zero impact on their resume.

As an ND fan, while disheartening that this is likely where it goes, on-field results matter. It is an easier pill to swallow that ND gets bumped strictly on now competing for the same spot with Miami (which may not have been the case in previous weeks).


RE: CFP locks - AuzGrams - 12-03-2025 01:42 PM

(12-03-2025 01:23 PM)mlb Wrote:  
(12-03-2025 01:21 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  Why is Texas Tech a lock?

What does 11-2 Texas Tech do that other teams do?

The committee has them 4th. It would take a big loss to knock them out of an at large.

I just don’t personally see why Vanderbilt is getting the cold shoulder.


RE: CFP locks - Fighting Muskie - 12-03-2025 01:44 PM

(12-03-2025 01:38 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-03-2025 01:16 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Going into the CCGs, I think these 8 teams are locks:

Ohio State, Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, TAMU, Oklahoma

Win and in:
BYU, UNT/Tulane, UVA

Vulnerable:
Alabama & ND— Bama does t necessarily need to win but they certainly can’t afford to lose bad. BYU is in a position to play bid thief with a win and ND would currently be the team knocked out. However, that team could become Alabama if their performance is bad enough in the CCG that the committee elects to slide them down.

Needs a Duke Upset:
JMU

Things look bad:
Miami, Vanderbilt, & Texas— they are all idle, so they can’t win and improve their rank.

One side note—I’m interested to see how the committee reacts to Ole Miss’s loss of Kiffin and the potential of players jumping to the portal to go with him. It might drop them some in the seeding but I’d be shocked if it takes them all the way out of the top 10.

I wouldn't completely rule out the MWC CCG winner and Duke if JMU and Virginia both lose. Miami also could potentially sneak in depending on if BYU loses bad and gets a more direct comparison to ND.

That’s definitely a possibility if things fell just right. I’m not too confident in Duke to pull the upset needed to make that happen.


RE: CFP locks - Wahoowa84 - 12-03-2025 01:45 PM

(12-03-2025 01:16 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Going into the CCGs, I think these 8 teams are locks:

Ohio State, Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, TAMU, Oklahoma

Win and in:
BYU, UNT/Tulane, UVA

Vulnerable:
Alabama & ND— Bama does t necessarily need to win but they certainly can’t afford to lose bad. BYU is in a position to play bid thief with a win and ND would currently be the team knocked out. However, that team could become Alabama if their performance is bad enough in the CCG that the committee elects to slide them down.

Needs a Duke Upset:
JMU

Things look bad:
Miami, Vanderbilt, & Texas— they are all idle, so they can’t win and improve their rank.

One side note—I’m interested to see how the committee reacts to Ole Miss’s loss of Kiffin and the potential of players jumping to the portal to go with him. It might drop them some in the seeding but I’d be shocked if it takes them all the way out of the top 10.

One issue and one-knit with your categories.

The bigger issue: by flipping Alabama and ND, the CFP Committee may have exposed ND to a direct comparison with Miami. Depending on the CCG outcomes, the Committee may have to re-evaluate ND & Miami with the head-to-head criteria. Although Miami and ND are both idle, the ranking protocol may be impacted by what happens in the CCGs. Miami's chances of making the CFP are small, but not insignificant (ESPN analytics has them at 11%). By contrast, Vanderbilt and Texas have no viable paths to the CFP.

The knit: If JMU loses and Duke wins, the committee will still have to chose a 5th conference champion. The MWC or Duke may actually have paths.


RE: CFP locks - Fighting Muskie - 12-03-2025 02:01 PM

Wahoowa— you make a good point. I wonder if part of the committee’s thinking is, should Duke win, they could admit JMU as the 5th CCG winner, and have Miami leapfrog ND, keeping the ACC in the field.


RE: CFP locks - DavidSt - 12-03-2025 02:42 PM

Ole Miss may not be there as half the coaching staff left with Lane Kiffin. It would affect the team where they could get blown out. It is in the rules as they could become the FSU rule. The portal opens on the second and any players including starters will jump to LSU which would leave the Ole Miss team in a bad place.


RE: CFP locks - quo vadis - 12-03-2025 02:47 PM

(12-03-2025 01:19 PM)domer1978 Wrote:  I expect to be left out. Can't start 0-2 and leave it up to a bunch of dorks in a room. I believe we can compete and beat anyone in the country now, but we started the way we started.

I think we will make it, but if we don't, I really won't have a complaint.

The moment we blew the game against TAMU, giving up the 4th down TD pass, I said "that's it, it's the start of September and our playoff chances are gone". So everything since has been gravy.

Hopefully there is one more ladle of gravy waiting for us Sunday.


RE: CFP locks - bullet - 12-03-2025 02:49 PM

(12-03-2025 01:21 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  Why is Texas Tech a lock?

What does 11-2 Texas Tech do that other teams do?

The committee loves Texas Tech and their losses would be one to a team they previously beat who is in the playoff and another to a team when Tech's QB was injured.


RE: CFP locks - bullet - 12-03-2025 02:53 PM

(12-03-2025 01:21 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-03-2025 01:16 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Going into the CCGs, I think these 8 teams are locks:

Ohio State, Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, TAMU, Oklahoma

Win and in:
BYU, UNT/Tulane, UVA

Vulnerable:
Alabama & ND— Bama does t necessarily need to win but they certainly can’t afford to lose bad. BYU is in a position to play bid thief with a win and ND would currently be the team knocked out. However, that team could become Alabama if their performance is bad enough in the CCG that the committee elects to slide them down.

Needs a Duke Upset:
JMU

Things look bad:
Miami, Vanderbilt, & Texas— they are all idle, so they can’t win and improve their rank.

One side note—I’m interested to see how the committee reacts to Ole Miss’s loss of Kiffin and the potential of players jumping to the portal to go with him. It might drop them some in the seeding but I’d be shocked if it takes them all the way out of the top 10.

If the committee was going to drop Ole Miss, yesterday was the time to do it. They've obviously decided to completely ignore Kiffin leaving. Instead, they vaulted them over my Aggies despite a much easier schedule. Why? Recency bias. Ole Miss lost over a month ago, Aggies lost 3 days ago, so recency bias trumps much stronger SOS. Recency bias and especially eye test seem to be the only 2 things that the Committee cares about these days. The only reason I'm not howling about it is that we're still hosting a CFP game in any of the 5-8 spots, so I'm happy with any of them.

And good losses. Ole Miss lost by 8 to #3 in a game they lead in the 4th quarter. A&M lost by 10 to #13.


RE: CFP locks - bullet - 12-03-2025 02:57 PM

(12-03-2025 01:42 PM)GoldenWarrior11 Wrote:  I actually think Alabama is a near-lock. They already beat Georgia once. If favorites (Ohio State, Georgia, Texas Tech, Virginia) all win this weekend, this is what I believe is being set-up:

1. Ohio State (AQ)
2. Georgia (AQ)
3. Indiana
4. Texas Tech (AQ)
5. Oregon
6. Ole Miss
7. Texas A&M
8. Oklahoma
9. Alabama
10. BYU/Miami/ND
11. Virginia (AQ)
12. North Texas/Tulane (AQ)
*JMU is #12 if Duke beats Virginia; American Champion would then be #11

For the Big 12 - If BYU wins, they are in. I don't think they get in with a loss, as matchup #1 with Tech wasn't close. Tech is in regardless.
For the ACC - Virginia is in if they win, but the ACC is shut out if Duke loses. James Madison gets AQ #5. Essentially the #5 AQ spot is for either JMU/Virginia.

The million dollar question is whether the committee will then (after all the CCGs being played) determine if they view ND and Miami on the same line for the same spot, in which case the head-to-head would come into play (I presume it is). Despite any metrics, SOS, margin of victory and "look", Miami owns the head to head win over them. That's all that is needed. It's funny, but neither Miami or Notre Dame played Duke or Virginia this year, so that game has really zero impact on their resume.

As an ND fan, while disheartening that this is likely where it goes, on-field results matter. It is an easier pill to swallow that ND gets bumped strictly on now competing for the same spot with Miami (which may not have been the case in previous weeks).

Interestingly, few of the top teams who are idle have played teams in CCGs.