CSNbbs
realignment prophecy??? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: realignment prophecy??? (/thread-1021156.html)



realignment prophecy??? - DawgNBama - 12-01-2025 04:37 PM




RE: realignment prophecy??? - Ned Low - 12-01-2025 05:26 PM

Without looking it up, my hunch is that this figure will be the total required over a number of years.

The American has a $10M total over a three year period, for example.

I think that revenue sharing will be a big part of realignment decisions in the coming years, particularly in the G ranks.[/i]


RE: realignment prophecy??? - nodak651 - 12-01-2025 06:28 PM

(12-01-2025 05:26 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Without looking it up, my hunch is that this figure will be the total required over a number of years.

The American has a $10M total over a three year period, for example.

I think that revenue sharing will be a big part of realignment decisions in the coming years, particularly in the G ranks.[/i]

I don't get this exactly, why would it suddenly be about revenue sharing rather than how many eyeballs or how much revenue a school can contribute to the conference?

Revenue sharing matters, I assume, because it helps to ensure programs are competitive. But a school like NDSU which is and would be competitive was passed over for NIU, because of "market". Is "market" no longer the number 1 priority? I find that hard to believe and doubt anything has actually changed in that regard.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - andybible1995 - 12-01-2025 07:35 PM

So, if teams don't share enough revenue, will they be kicked out of their current conference?


RE: realignment prophecy??? - bryanw1995 - 12-01-2025 07:41 PM

(12-01-2025 07:35 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  So, if teams don't share enough revenue, will they be kicked out of their current conference?

That would be a tough rule to pass b/c you'd have to get the revenue sharing laggards to vote to put themselves in jeopardy. However, a Conference like CUSA that has lots of turnover can require it for future members, and lean hard on current members to persuade them to voluntarily step up their rev share.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - andybible1995 - 12-01-2025 07:44 PM

(12-01-2025 07:41 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 07:35 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  So, if teams don't share enough revenue, will they be kicked out of their current conference?

That would be a tough rule to pass b/c you'd have to get the revenue sharing laggards to vote to put themselves in jeopardy. However, a Conference like CUSA that has lots of turnover can require it for future members, and lean hard on current members to persuade them to voluntarily step up their rev share.

That makes more sense.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - Ned Low - 12-01-2025 09:52 PM

(12-01-2025 06:28 PM)nodak651 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:26 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Without looking it up, my hunch is that this figure will be the total required over a number of years.

The American has a $10M total over a three year period, for example.

I think that revenue sharing will be a big part of realignment decisions in the coming years, particularly in the G ranks.[/i]

I don't get this exactly, why would it suddenly be about revenue sharing rather than how many eyeballs or how much revenue a school can contribute to the conference?

Revenue sharing matters, I assume, because it helps to ensure programs are competitive. But a school like NDSU which is and would be competitive was passed over for NIU, because of "market". Is "market" no longer the number 1 priority? I find that hard to believe and doubt anything has actually changed in that regard.

It makes sense that revenue sharing will be a part of the equation in addition to market, eyeballs, and competitiveness.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - Ned Low - 12-01-2025 09:53 PM

(12-01-2025 07:35 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  So, if teams don't share enough revenue, will they be kicked out of their current conference?

The American conference instituted such a rule for all of its members. I’m not sure what the penalty would be if a member failed to reach that minimum requirement.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - celldweller7 - 12-01-2025 11:31 PM

(12-01-2025 07:35 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  So, if teams don't share enough revenue, will they be kicked out of their current conference?

They could also withhold conference payouts.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - DFW HOYA - 12-01-2025 11:51 PM

(12-01-2025 09:53 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  The American conference instituted such a rule for all of its members. I’m not sure what the penalty would be if a member failed to reach that minimum requirement.

For example, the service academies.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - Garden_KC - 12-02-2025 12:08 AM

I don't think realignment will be based on revenue sharing as much as certain revenue levels will become pre-conditions of membership.

The SBC East if they split could require all members contribute 10 million dollars annually in revenue sharing for everyone joining it. That would cement their edge over the other G6 conferences.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - bryanw1995 - 12-02-2025 11:21 AM

(12-01-2025 11:51 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 09:53 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  The American conference instituted such a rule for all of its members. I’m not sure what the penalty would be if a member failed to reach that minimum requirement.

For example, the service academies.

The Service Academies have their own special exemption (from Congress!). They've been paying their players forever, it's only recently that others started officially paying our kids more. I'm sure that all 3 of them would be just fine if the American/MWC/everyone else suddenly decided that they didn't want them around any more. They could go independent in football, immediately fill their schedules without issue b/c of the enormous prestige most schools get from playing them, and they could park their Olympic sports in smaller regional conferences.

I'm reminded of that LSU-Army game a couple years ago, or ofc the Navy-ND yearly game. If schools like LSU and ND are excited to play an Academy, then just about anybody would be able to find a spot for them.

In October 2023, LSU painted its Tiger Stadium end zones with a camouflage pattern to honor the Army Black Knights football team when they played. The LSU logo was in the center of the camouflaged end zones, a tribute to the visiting service academy.

Purpose: The paint scheme was a way to show respect for the Army Black Knights and military service members.
Design: The end zones featured a camouflage pattern with the LSU logo in black in the center.
Significance: The gesture was a unique event, as LSU was hosting Army for the first time in 92 years. The tribute also included players wearing an American flag patch on their uniforms.
Post-game: After the game, both teams joined in the end zones to sing each other's alma maters


My distaste for LSU is well documented, but that was a classy move. I've never heard of them showing that kind of respect for ANYBODY, but it was Army and everyone understood.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - jacksfan29! - 12-02-2025 03:11 PM

(12-01-2025 11:51 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 09:53 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  The American conference instituted such a rule for all of its members. I’m not sure what the penalty would be if a member failed to reach that minimum requirement.

For example, the service academies.

Pretty sure when the AAC mandated the $10 million it included an exemption for Army and Navy.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - jimrtex - 12-03-2025 01:52 PM

(12-01-2025 05:26 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Without looking it up, my hunch is that this figure will be the total required over a number of years.

The American has a $10M total over a three year period, for example.

I think that revenue sharing will be a big part of realignment decisions in the coming years, particularly in the G ranks.[/i]
$8.25 million is 3 x $2.75. (I don't know that is what CUSA is doing, but it fits). All I could find with a search was that CUSA would be paying $2 million, which was 22% of $9 million in revenue. I kind of interpret that as being anticipation based on the House settlement.

Under the House settlement, some of the "revenue sharing" can be in form of additional scholarships and Allston grants which are cash payments for academic achievements. I suspect at the heavily subsidized programs, more payments will be in that form since it would be more palatable to students paying student fees to have more baseball and volleyball players getting a full ride.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - ballantyneapp - 12-03-2025 02:39 PM

(12-01-2025 06:28 PM)nodak651 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:26 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Without looking it up, my hunch is that this figure will be the total required over a number of years.

The American has a $10M total over a three year period, for example.

I think that revenue sharing will be a big part of realignment decisions in the coming years, particularly in the G ranks.[/i]

I don't get this exactly, why would it suddenly be about revenue sharing rather than how many eyeballs or how much revenue a school can contribute to the conference?

Revenue sharing matters, I assume, because it helps to ensure programs are competitive. But a school like NDSU which is and would be competitive was passed over for NIU, because of "market". Is "market" no longer the number 1 priority? I find that hard to believe and doubt anything has actually changed in that regard.

IMO going forward conferences will be taking a more holistic approach to realignment.

10-15 years ago, when replacing SMU, the AAC would have first looked to someone like Georgia State (urban R1 metro pop 6.3MM). Instead they engaged lil ole App State (rural, R2 metro pop 15,000) and eventually settled on Army.

"market" as a driver of AD revenue is losing out as the industry gets more and more data. Now anyone selling advertising knows almost exactly how many eyeballs are watching games. Hell YTTV they can tell people how many people are watching the commercials. Exactly how old the people are who watch, how much $$ they make everything. Brands to a greater or lesser extent will eventually trump markets in alignment.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - Ned Low - 12-03-2025 03:21 PM

(12-03-2025 02:39 PM)ballantyneapp Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 06:28 PM)nodak651 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 05:26 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Without looking it up, my hunch is that this figure will be the total required over a number of years.

The American has a $10M total over a three year period, for example.

I think that revenue sharing will be a big part of realignment decisions in the coming years, particularly in the G ranks.[/i]

I don't get this exactly, why would it suddenly be about revenue sharing rather than how many eyeballs or how much revenue a school can contribute to the conference?

Revenue sharing matters, I assume, because it helps to ensure programs are competitive. But a school like NDSU which is and would be competitive was passed over for NIU, because of "market". Is "market" no longer the number 1 priority? I find that hard to believe and doubt anything has actually changed in that regard.

IMO going forward conferences will be taking a more holistic approach to realignment.

10-15 years ago, when replacing SMU, the AAC would have first looked to someone like Georgia State (urban R1 metro pop 6.3MM). Instead they engaged lil ole App State (rural, R2 metro pop 15,000) and eventually settled on Army.

"market" as a driver of AD revenue is losing out as the industry gets more and more data. Now anyone selling advertising knows almost exactly how many eyeballs are watching games. Hell YTTV they can tell people how many people are watching the commercials. Exactly how old the people are who watch, how much $$ they make everything. Brands to a greater or lesser extent will eventually trump markets in alignment.


I agree with this prediction 100%.


RE: realignment prophecy??? - billybobby777 - 12-03-2025 06:09 PM

(12-02-2025 11:21 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 11:51 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(12-01-2025 09:53 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  The American conference instituted such a rule for all of its members. I’m not sure what the penalty would be if a member failed to reach that minimum requirement.

For example, the service academies.

The Service Academies have their own special exemption (from Congress!). They've been paying their players forever, it's only recently that others started officially paying our kids more. I'm sure that all 3 of them would be just fine if the American/MWC/everyone else suddenly decided that they didn't want them around any more. They could go independent in football, immediately fill their schedules without issue b/c of the enormous prestige most schools get from playing them, and they could park their Olympic sports in smaller regional conferences.

I'm reminded of that LSU-Army game a couple years ago, or ofc the Navy-ND yearly game. If schools like LSU and ND are excited to play an Academy, then just about anybody would be able to find a spot for them.

In October 2023, LSU painted its Tiger Stadium end zones with a camouflage pattern to honor the Army Black Knights football team when they played. The LSU logo was in the center of the camouflaged end zones, a tribute to the visiting service academy.

Purpose: The paint scheme was a way to show respect for the Army Black Knights and military service members.
Design: The end zones featured a camouflage pattern with the LSU logo in black in the center.
Significance: The gesture was a unique event, as LSU was hosting Army for the first time in 92 years. The tribute also included players wearing an American flag patch on their uniforms.
Post-game: After the game, both teams joined in the end zones to sing each other's alma maters


My distaste for LSU is well documented, but that was a classy move. I've never heard of them showing that kind of respect for ANYBODY, but it was Army and everyone understood.

Good post. I’ve seen that happen with games between all the service academies opponents. I think one reason Air Force is loyal to the MWC is because of the conference members tributes and respect shown at conference events.