CSNbbs
The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 (/thread-1021081.html)



The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Fighting Muskie - 11-30-2025 12:45 PM

As you might be aware, I’m a strong proponent of a Big 10-style 4-4-3-3-1-1 playoff with play in games. Here’s what it would look like if implemented this year:

Autobids:
Ohio State, Indiana, Alabama, Georgia, BYU, Texas Tech, Virginia, Duke—all by virtue of making a P2/M2 CCG

I think it’s fair to say the Tulane/UNT winner clinches the G6 spot

Play in games:

Iowa @ Oregon
Michigan @ USC
Vandy @ Ole Miss
Oklahoma @ Texas A&M
GT @ Miami
Houston @ Utah
Texas @ ND


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - stever20 - 11-30-2025 12:50 PM

yeah sorry but no way in hell does the ACC deserve 3 bids this year. At all whatsoever. Duke doesn't belong.

And this year will make this garbage much tougher to push that narrative.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - bryanw1995 - 11-30-2025 12:54 PM

(11-30-2025 12:45 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As you might be aware, I’m a string proponent of a Big 10-style 4-4-3-3-1-1 playoff with play in games. Here’s what it would look like if implemented this year:

Autobids:
Ohio State, Indiana, Alabama, Georgia, BYU, Texas Tech, Virginia, Duke—all by virtue of making a P2/M2 CCG

I think it’s fair to say the Tulane/UNT winner clinches the G6 spot

Play in games:

Iowa @ Oregon
Michigan @ USC
Vandy @ Ole Miss
Oklahoma @ Texas A&M
GT @ Miami
Houston @ Utah
Texas @ ND

Someone needs to start an all-female institution and call it the Technical Academy of Central Ohio. Their sports teams should be called the Belles. Imagine the horror and shame their opponents would have losing to the TACO Belles.

I'm actually replying to your signature line:

I think of the TACO Belles as the dance team for TACO. It wouldn't be as shameful for another dance team to lose to them at a competition, but still, pretty funny!


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Fighting Muskie - 11-30-2025 01:08 PM

(11-30-2025 12:50 PM)stever20 Wrote:  yeah sorry but no way in hell does the ACC deserve 3 bids this year. At all whatsoever. Duke doesn't belong.

And this year will make this garbage much tougher to push that narrative.

Don’t blame me—blame the ACC for having dumb tie breaker procedures. My model was always autobids for the CCG participants, 2 play in games each for the P2 and 1 each for the M2, then the 2 highest ranked teams left to give Indy schools a path.

#13 is just going to luck out and get a very soft #16 at home.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - GoBuckeyes1047 - 11-30-2025 01:19 PM

So I don't know if you tried avoiding rematches for the SEC, but it should be Oklahoma-Ole Miss and Texas-Texas A&M based on SEC tiebreakers and then it would be Vandy-ND (assuming you did a play-in game for the at-large slot). I think I proposed similar to this, but it was for 14 teams (4/4/2/2/1+1) instead of 16 teams. The pushback was SEC would be screwed out of their bids and ND would complain after taking away being given their in top X and you're in, no questions asked rule. I think you'll need 3 at-larges at least to satisfy the SEC and leave ND out of WCGs, but wouldn't complain if this happened.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - andybible1995 - 11-30-2025 01:50 PM

FM,

Here's my version of the playoff, but I'm expanding the playoff to 24 teams, like the FCS, and I used the Coaches Poll with straight seeding since the AP Poll isn't out at the time of writing this.

First round bye:

#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma

First round games (on-campus)

#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC

#25 Navy is left out.

Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - stever20 - 11-30-2025 01:52 PM

(11-30-2025 01:50 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  FM,

Here's my version of the playoff, but I'm expanding the playoff to 24 teams, like the FCS, and I used the Coaches Poll with straight seeding since the AP Poll isn't out at the time of writing this.

First round bye:

#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma

First round games (on-campus)

#9 Notre Dame vs. #17 USC
#10 Alabama vs. #18 Michigan
#11 BYU vs. #19 James Madison
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #20 North Texas
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #21 Tulane
#14 Texas vs. #22 Arizona
#15 Utah vs. #23 Georgia Tech
#16 Virginia vs. #24 Tennessee

#25 Navy left out

Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army ve. Navy game the following Saturday.

uh it would be 9 vs 24 10 vs 23 etc.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - andybible1995 - 11-30-2025 01:55 PM

(11-30-2025 01:52 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-30-2025 01:50 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  FM,

Here's my version of the playoff, but I'm expanding the playoff to 24 teams, like the FCS, and I used the Coaches Poll with straight seeding since the AP Poll isn't out at the time of writing this.

First round bye:

#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma

First round games (on-campus)

#9 Notre Dame vs. #17 USC
#10 Alabama vs. #18 Michigan
#11 BYU vs. #19 James Madison
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #20 North Texas
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #21 Tulane
#14 Texas vs. #22 Arizona
#15 Utah vs. #23 Georgia Tech
#16 Virginia vs. #24 Tennessee

#25 Navy left out

Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army ve. Navy game the following Saturday.

uh it would be 9 vs 24 10 vs 23 etc.

Noted. Fixed the OP.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Fighting Muskie - 11-30-2025 06:30 PM

(11-30-2025 01:19 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So I don't know if you tried avoiding rematches for the SEC, but it should be Oklahoma-Ole Miss and Texas-Texas A&M based on SEC tiebreakers and then it would be Vandy-ND (assuming you did a play-in game for the at-large slot). I think I proposed similar to this, but it was for 14 teams (4/4/2/2/1+1) instead of 16 teams. The pushback was SEC would be screwed out of their bids and ND would complain after taking away being given their in top X and you're in, no questions asked rule. I think you'll need 3 at-larges at least to satisfy the SEC and leave ND out of WCGs, but wouldn't complain if this happened.

I presumed that Wikipedia had taken the tie breakers into consideration when they listed the SEC teams in their league standings.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - tf8693 - 11-30-2025 09:22 PM

Not a proponent of multiple autobids for conferences, or of play-in games for playoff berths. Sorry.

And Duke definitely doesn't deserve an autobid. Lose to Virginia and they're 7-6. How is that worthy of the CFP?


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Fighting Muskie - 11-30-2025 09:30 PM

Duke being in the mix is not a flaw of this playoff model—it’s a flaw of the ACC’s tie breaker procedures. Fix the tie breakers and instead of a lock, they are in a play in game or maybe not in the running at all.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - tf8693 - 11-30-2025 10:20 PM

(11-30-2025 09:30 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Duke being in the mix is not a flaw of this playoff model—it’s a flaw of the ACC’s tie breaker procedures. Fix the tie breakers and instead of a lock, they are in a play in game or maybe not in the running at all.

One of the few things you've posted here that I agree with. I've mentioned on at least two other threads that the ACC should have CFP ranking in its tiebreaker format, perhaps as high as second after head-to-head. Had they done that, it's Virginia vs. Miami in the ACC championship, and nobody is talking about their conference champion possibly being left out of the CFP.

Btw, Duke is hardly a "lock" in the current model. They still have to beat UVa AND possibly receive some help in the form of a Troy win over JMU in the Sun Belt championship game to get into the CFP. But the mere fact that a 5-loss team is in the running for a CFP bid is a bit of a travesty, especially given that the field is only 12 teams.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Crayton - 12-01-2025 06:04 AM

(11-30-2025 10:20 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-30-2025 09:30 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Duke being in the mix is not a flaw of this playoff model—it’s a flaw of the ACC’s tie breaker procedures. Fix the tie breakers and instead of a lock, they are in a play in game or maybe not in the running at all.

One of the few things you've posted here that I agree with. I've mentioned on at least two other threads that the ACC should have CFP ranking in its tiebreaker format, perhaps as high as second after head-to-head. Had they done that, it's Virginia vs. Miami in the ACC championship, and nobody is talking about their conference champion possibly being left out of the CFP.

Btw, Duke is hardly a "lock" in the current model. They still have to beat UVa AND possibly receive some help in the form of a Troy win over JMU in the Sun Belt championship game to get into the CFP. But the mere fact that a 5-loss team is in the running for a CFP bid is a bit of a travesty, especially given that the field is only 12 teams.

In Muskie’s “current” model, Duke can lose to Virginia next week and STILL make the playoff. That IS a flaw in the model; who would build a model where the ACCCG means diddly squat?


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - billybobby777 - 12-01-2025 07:41 AM

(11-30-2025 12:54 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-30-2025 12:45 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  As you might be aware, I’m a string proponent of a Big 10-style 4-4-3-3-1-1 playoff with play in games. Here’s what it would look like if implemented this year:

Autobids:
Ohio State, Indiana, Alabama, Georgia, BYU, Texas Tech, Virginia, Duke—all by virtue of making a P2/M2 CCG

I think it’s fair to say the Tulane/UNT winner clinches the G6 spot

Play in games:

Iowa @ Oregon
Michigan @ USC
Vandy @ Ole Miss
Oklahoma @ Texas A&M
GT @ Miami
Houston @ Utah
Texas @ ND

Someone needs to start an all-female institution and call it the Technical Academy of Central Ohio. Their sports teams should be called the Belles. Imagine the horror and shame their opponents would have losing to the TACO Belles.

I'm actually replying to your signature line:

I think of the TACO Belles as the dance team for TACO. It wouldn't be as shameful for another dance team to lose to them at a competition, but still, pretty funny!

Taco had at least one hit in the 80’s. I like this Taco Belles idea.


RE: The Big Muskie Playoff 2025 - Fighting Muskie - 12-01-2025 08:33 AM

(12-01-2025 06:04 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-30-2025 10:20 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-30-2025 09:30 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Duke being in the mix is not a flaw of this playoff model—it’s a flaw of the ACC’s tie breaker procedures. Fix the tie breakers and instead of a lock, they are in a play in game or maybe not in the running at all.

One of the few things you've posted here that I agree with. I've mentioned on at least two other threads that the ACC should have CFP ranking in its tiebreaker format, perhaps as high as second after head-to-head. Had they done that, it's Virginia vs. Miami in the ACC championship, and nobody is talking about their conference champion possibly being left out of the CFP.

Btw, Duke is hardly a "lock" in the current model. They still have to beat UVa AND possibly receive some help in the form of a Troy win over JMU in the Sun Belt championship game to get into the CFP. But the mere fact that a 5-loss team is in the running for a CFP bid is a bit of a travesty, especially given that the field is only 12 teams.

In Muskie’s “current” model, Duke can lose to Virginia next week and STILL make the playoff. That IS a flaw in the model; who would build a model where the ACCCG means diddly squat?

The whole point of autobids is that each league gets a set number with the idea that they are given to best teams or put up for grabs in a revenue generating play in game. In a world where the ACC has sensible tie breaking rules, it seems like an unjust punishment to kick out your CCG loser from the play off if #3 is getting to play #4 for an autobid.

It’s no different than leaving basketball autobids up the conference tournament—occasionally you’re going to get a dud. Good tie breaker procedures fixes a lot of this.