![]() |
|
***Rank the American after week three*** - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html) +---- Forum: American Conference Talk (/forum-409.html) +---- Thread: ***Rank the American after week three*** (/thread-1015538.html) |
***Rank the American after week three*** - Tiger1983 - 09-14-2025 11:40 AM My ranking is based on elevation of the league: Good Tulane ECU North Texas UAB Memphis Bad FAU (a terrible loss to a terrible team) Temple (could arguably be neutral, but margin was significant) Neutral UTSA USF Charlotte Rice NA Navy Tulsa RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - CrownRoyal - 09-14-2025 11:59 AM Where do you put Army in that? RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Tiger1983 - 09-14-2025 12:16 PM (09-14-2025 11:59 AM)CrownRoyal Wrote: Where do you put Army in that? Army was off this week. My post is intended to show how game results in week three helps, hurts, or has no effect on the American’s resume. I think it is too early to rank schools season to date so I will leave that to others. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - steves - 09-14-2025 12:41 PM Tulane So Fla No Texas Navy Memphis Err body else ... RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Side.Show.Joe - 09-14-2025 05:14 PM 1. Tulane 2. South Florida 3. Memphis 4. North Texas 5. Navy 6. ECU 7. UTSA 8. Army 9. Rice 10. UAB 11. Tulsa 12. Temple 13. Charlotte 14. FAU Personally, I think the top 6 are among the best teams outside of the P2 & M2. 7 through 10 seem dangerous, like they could play spoilers in conference play. 11 through 14, just don't pass the eyeball test. Overall, I feel the 2025 American has a very strong top and a respectable middle. Clearly, the American is among the top 5 FBS conferences this year. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - DowdyPirate - 09-14-2025 05:36 PM We will find out just how good the top of the conference is this week with Tulane @ Ole Miss, Arkansas @ Memphis, and BYU @ ECU. For now I will go with Memphis USF Tulane Navy ECU UNT Army Temple UTSA Rice UAB Tulsa FAU Charlotte Looking at Navy's schedule, they could start 7-0 without being very good at all. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - B easy - 09-14-2025 07:05 PM Taken off the Sunbelt board (AAC domination): Based on the full ESPN FBS list: G6 power index with actual FBS rank on the right. 1. Memphis 36 2. Tulane 47 3. East Carolina 52 4. South Florida 54 5. Old Dominion 56 6. Boise State 61 7. UNLV 65 8. Toledo 66 9. North Texas 67 10. Navy 68 11. Texas State 71 12. Ohio 72 13. Fresno State 75 14. James Madison 77 15. UTSA 78 16. South Alabama 80 17. Army 81 18. Utah State 83 19. Connecticut 84 20. New Mexico 85 21. Louisiana Tech 86 22. Jacksonville State 87 23. Bowling Green 88 24. Miami Ohio 90 25. Troy 91 RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Ned Low - 09-14-2025 07:05 PM Memphis Tulane USF ECU UNT Navy Army Temple UTSA Rice UAB Tulsa FAU Charlotte RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - TheBigEastSucks - 09-14-2025 07:12 PM (09-14-2025 07:05 PM)Ned Low Wrote: Memphis Tulane ECU USF Memphis Navy RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Memphis Yankee - 09-14-2025 10:35 PM Tulane/Memphis/USF Navy/North Texas/ECU Army/UAB/Temple RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - MeanGreenStebo - 09-15-2025 12:52 AM Solid: 1. Tulane (3-0)- I think 1 and 2 are both strong and are interchangeable but Tulane is undefeated so they get the edge 2. South Florida (2-1) 3. Memphis (3-0) - Memphis looks solid 4. North Texas (3-0) - we finally have both a defense and a QB 5. Navy (3-0) - look to be extremely solid again 6. Army (2-1) - Army hasn’t done anything to make me think they are suddenly out of the top tier. Tarleton played a perfect game and squeaked by in OT, this could happen to any of us. With a better kicker, Army wins that game. Army responded by beating a Big 12 team on the road. They could even be higher than this, but we only have two games to look at. We will see this week when they play UNT! 7. ECU (2-1, should probably be higher but who do I put them above? With a close loss to NC State, they could easily be contenders) To Be Determined: 8. Rice (2-1, beat ULL on the road, destroyed by Houston at home, struggled to dominate SWAC Prairie View aTm, all signs point to questionable) 9. Temple (2-1, OU beat the crap out of them, but they are essentially a pro team with a ridiculous payroll. Wins over Howard and UMass make this team an unknown, but they beat them both decidedly) 10. UTSA (1-2, losses to TX State and aTm are explainable, great coach - they will likely be higher than this by end of year, let’s see if they beat Colorado State this week) 11. Tulsa (1-2, losses to NMSU and Navy, tough to argue these as quality losses, I still think Tulsa is better this year and still a TBD team) Need help: 12. FAU (this could change, I don’t think FIU is as bad as everyone thinks they are) 13. UAB (I have watched parts of all 3 of their games, questionable coaching decisions throughout, almost lost to Alabama State, almost lost to Akron, the fans seem to have given up - that stadium against Akron was really empty, Dilfer has destroyed this once proud program and erased everything good the previous coach did) 14. Charlotte (rebuilding year for Charlotte, FCS caliber team, I watched their win against Monmouth and have never seen an FBS coach and fans so excited about beating an FCS team) ***Rank the American after week three*** - owl at the moon - 09-15-2025 06:26 AM National Convo: 1. Tulane Memphis Navy USF UNT Contenders: 6. ECU Rice UAB UTSA Temple Army Not Hot 100: 12. Tulsa FAU Charlotte RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Tiger1983 - 09-15-2025 07:26 AM Power rankings per one of the Tiger FB beat writers - Jonah Dylan 1. Tulane 2. USF 3. Navy 4. Memphis 5. North Texas 6. ECU 7. Army 8. UTSA 9. Temple 10. Rice 11. FAU 12. Tulsa 13. UAB 14. Charlotte https://www.commercialappeal.com/story/sports/college/memphis-tigers/2025/09/15/american-conference-power-rankings-tulane-south-florida/85991153007/ RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Tiger1983 - 09-15-2025 08:46 AM I think the Composite will be more meaningful after most of the OOC games are finished, but here are the early results per Massey Composite with 31 sources. I may update it later in the week. American total average (83) American legacy average (70) American Former CUSA6 (102) SBC total average (99) MWC total average (93) Future PAC total average (88) To date, nothing has changed since the former CUSA6 joined. The American's position is thanks collectively to legacy schools. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Cubanbull1 - 09-15-2025 09:19 AM So far it looks like the American Champion will be in CFP. It will be interesting to see if two teams emerge and finish with zero or one conference loss at the end or do having so many strong teams they end up beating each other up and our champ with 2-3 loses gets by passed by a weaker conference champions with less losses. Right now I would rank 1. Tulane 3-0, big test this week vs their first ranked opponent, Mississippi 2. USF 2-1 after three ranked opponents we get an FCS SCState. SC had problems with them 3. Memphis 3-0, their biggest opponent yet vs Arkansas 4. Navy 3-0 , off this week, already 2-0 in conference 5. North Texas 3-0, after their biggest win they get a big test in Army 6. ECU 2-1 has looked good, big test vs BYU 7. Army 2-1 has bounced back now big test vs NTexas Those 7 I see as the strongest contenders 8. UTSA 1-2, got a win, Colorado St this week 9. Rice. 2-1 vs Charlotte this week 10. Temple 2-1, loss to ranked team now runs into another one vs GTech These three have shown some life and could be trouble for the big 7 11. UAB 2-1, big trouble this week vs Tennessee 12. FAU 1-2, bad loss to FIU. Off this week 13. Charlotte 1-2, struggled vs FCS, plays Rice 14. Tulsa 1-2, vs OKState chance vs a bad Big12 squad The bottom four really haven’t shown much so far. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Side.Show.Joe - 09-15-2025 09:44 AM (09-15-2025 08:46 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: I think the Composite will be more meaningful after most of the OOC games are finished, but here are the early results per Massey Composite with 31 sources. I may update it later in the week. North Texas is getting it done on the field.
RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - msu35 - 09-15-2025 09:47 AM (09-15-2025 09:44 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:(09-15-2025 08:46 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: I think the Composite will be more meaningful after most of the OOC games are finished, but here are the early results per Massey Composite with 31 sources. I may update it later in the week. UNT has been solid in both revenue sports. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Side.Show.Joe - 09-15-2025 09:54 AM (09-15-2025 09:47 AM)msu35 Wrote:(09-15-2025 09:44 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:(09-15-2025 08:46 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: I think the Composite will be more meaningful after most of the OOC games are finished, but here are the early results per Massey Composite with 31 sources. I may update it later in the week. Thank you. North Texas never intended to join the American simple to be a member. Our goal was always to build and compete at this level. I truly believe the American can grow and challenge the Big12 and AAC for M2 status. We just need a few more committed programs to rise up. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - msu35 - 09-15-2025 10:02 AM (09-15-2025 09:54 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: Thank you. North Texas never intended to join the American simple to be a member. Our goal was always to build and compete at this level. I truly believe the American can grow and challenge the Big12 and [ACC] for M2 status. We just need a few more committed programs to rise up. I appreciate that line of thinking and genuinely believe there is a chance we could give the B12 and ACC a run for their money one of these years, but I don't believe the cartel is inclined to allow any other conferences to receive autonomy. Perhaps future legislation can help to unstack the deck, but I'm not optimistic. RE: ***Rank the American after week three*** - Tiger1983 - 09-15-2025 10:18 AM (09-15-2025 09:44 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:(09-15-2025 08:46 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: I think the Composite will be more meaningful after most of the OOC games are finished, but here are the early results per Massey Composite with 31 sources. I may update it later in the week. To date, NT has increased by 16 spots which is among the top five in FBS. Nevertheless, their overall ranking does not crack the top four of the American and cannot overcome the weight of the former CUSA6. It is still early so maybe the figures will improve. |