![]() |
|
football only FBS conferences - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: football only FBS conferences (/thread-1005975.html) Pages: 1 2 |
football only FBS conferences - ballantyneapp - 02-05-2025 11:43 AM When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports? IMO all the FBS conferences can align as football only versions of themselves and allow all other sports to align differently (or not on M/W BBall). Does UCLA really care if their womens bowling team is Big 10 affiliated? WCC or similar is really fine. Since the TV deals are 70%+ FB all the media companies are fine. Its 95%+ if M/W basketball are included. chartering a jet 1-4 times a year for FB players for a 4 hour game is a lot better than 10-12 times for bball or more and more for baseball all the way down to volleyball. IMO P4 conference teams would probably pay a small fee (maybe $2MM) to be a member of a regional conference for the minor sports where there was millions to be saved on travel. Call it part of the environmental carbon cutting progress or whatever. It just makes sense, will save $$ and bring us more competitive football overall. RE: football only FBS conferences - bullet - 02-05-2025 12:02 PM (02-05-2025 11:43 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote: When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports?They do care who they are affiliated with and they do want competitive conferences. Now, the Pac 12 was plenty good enough for all the non-rev for USC & UCLA. But they would have no interest in the Big West, Big Sky or MWC schools. RE: football only FBS conferences - stever20 - 02-05-2025 12:04 PM And it wouldn't change football at all. App St would still be in the Sun Belt and not associated with the ACC.... RE: football only FBS conferences - bullet - 02-05-2025 12:16 PM But you bring up a thought. What if the rule was changed so that groups of conferences could qualify? For example: The Big 10/SEC/ACC/Big 12 group stays the same for football and men's and women's basketball but for non-rev: ACC-ND, BC, SU, Pitt, UVA, VT, Duke, WF, UNC, NCSU, GT, FSU, Miami, UL, Clemson, UC, WVU, UCF (trades 3 schools with Big 12) Big 10-MD, Rutgers, PSU, tOSU, UM, MSU, IU, Purdue, NW, IL, WI, MN, IA, NE, KU, KSU, ISU, OK St. (trades 4 schools with Big 12) SEC-USCe, FL, UGA, UK, TN, Vandy, AL, Auburn, MS, MSU, LSU, A&M, UT, Ark, MO, OU Big 12-BYU, UU, Arizona, ASU, CU, Baylor, TCU, Texas Tech, UH, Stanford, Cal, SMU, UCLA, USC, UW, OR A similar setup could be worked out with the G5/6. RE: football only FBS conferences - ballantyneapp - 02-05-2025 12:42 PM (02-05-2025 12:02 PM)bullet Wrote:(02-05-2025 11:43 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote: When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports?They do care who they are affiliated with and they do want competitive conferences. I think you'd be surprised and I think college administrators of even the most hoity toity schools are starting to come around. Stanford in the not too distant past affiliated with App State in MAC field hockey. RE: football only FBS conferences - ballantyneapp - 02-05-2025 12:42 PM (02-05-2025 12:04 PM)stever20 Wrote: And it wouldn't change football at all. App St would still be in the Sun Belt and not associated with the ACC.... I never advocated for any football teams to move conferences.... RE: football only FBS conferences - IWokeUpLikeThis - 02-05-2025 12:44 PM I bet it happens one day, but probably not until we see a split of FBS. RE: football only FBS conferences - Dr Dawgma III - 02-05-2025 01:05 PM I’d like to see them go full anarcho-capitalist and everyone in FBS become an Independent and bundle with whomever you want for however long you want. Schedule whomever you want etc. Sort of the Chip Kelly philosophy. Leave Olympic sports out of it and let us have more appropriate basketball conferences featuring double round-robins. RE: football only FBS conferences - solohawks - 02-05-2025 01:35 PM Ideally non revenue sports would be in regional leagues...but if the power conferences wanted it would have already happened RE: football only FBS conferences - DawgNBama - 02-05-2025 01:45 PM (02-05-2025 11:43 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote: When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports? Some schools have more value in m/w basketball than they do football. Remember how the AAC booted UConn's football team once UConn moved its M/W basketball teams along with its other olympic sports to the Big East?? Find a system, ballantyneapp, that removes football and M/W basketball from the equation, and maybe then we can talk. RE: football only FBS conferences - DawgNBama - 02-05-2025 01:50 PM (02-05-2025 01:05 PM)esayem Wrote: I’d like to see them go full anarcho-capitalist and everyone in FBS become an Independent and bundle with whomever you want for however long you want. Schedule whomever you want etc. Sort of the Chip Kelly philosophy. It doesn't surprise me that an UNC fan would say that. Basketball is a religion for you guys!! RE: football only FBS conferences - bill dazzle - 02-05-2025 01:54 PM (02-05-2025 01:50 PM)DawgNBama Wrote:(02-05-2025 01:05 PM)esayem Wrote: I’d like to see them go full anarcho-capitalist and everyone in FBS become an Independent and bundle with whomever you want for however long you want. Schedule whomever you want etc. Sort of the Chip Kelly philosophy. And the UNC congregational offering plate is suffering as Tar Heel faithful sour on Bert Davis. RE: football only FBS conferences - bryanw1995 - 02-05-2025 07:51 PM (02-05-2025 12:16 PM)bullet Wrote: But you bring up a thought. I can see a few edge cases where schools might choose to affiliate with a much closer conference in secondary or tertiary sports, but nobody in the P4 would want to do it. Thing about how the UT swimming and diving team would feel if the money sports got to join the SEC but they had to stay back in the old Big 12 with Baylor, Tech, etc etc? Or UCLA and USC's Olympic Sports? The Big 12 doesn't sponsor half the stuff they offer, anyway. Texas, OU, A&M, LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Arkansas, Missouri, Georgia, Florida, Miss, etc etc, we all want to go after each other in every sport, all the time, and I think it's awesome. Ditto for the B1G, including their 4 new schools. The concept of having the option to cleave specific sports off is a good one, however. The NCAA has so many rules that make little or no sense for D1 and especially FBS, it's been dominated for too long by a critical mass of little bitty schools that just want to see that big check every month. RE: football only FBS conferences - The Beaver - 02-05-2025 09:17 PM (02-05-2025 07:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(02-05-2025 12:16 PM)bullet Wrote: But you bring up a thought. For the Big, I think the four new schools' programs would all love to be allowed to affiliate regionally in things other than football. But thats not how it is set up right now and that won't be changing any time soon, unfortunately. RE: football only FBS conferences - jimrtex - 02-05-2025 11:59 PM (02-05-2025 11:43 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote: When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports?Require land travel (train, bus, bicycle, foot) only for all sports. RE: football only FBS conferences - Fresno Fanatic - 02-06-2025 02:51 AM (02-05-2025 11:43 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote: When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports? NewPac Football *no “divisions” per se, but regions… West 10: Hawaii Air Force Fresno San Diego UNLV WaSU Beavs Boise USU Colorado St East 14: Army Navy ECU App USF UAB Memphis Tulane UTSA UNT Texas State JMU Georgia St CCU A ‘4 X 6 scheduling matrix’ would work well with 24 teams for a 3ooc-8matrix-1semis/flex-CCG RE: football only FBS conferences - ballantyneapp - 02-06-2025 08:23 AM (02-05-2025 07:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(02-05-2025 12:16 PM)bullet Wrote: But you bring up a thought. nobody in the P4 would want to save millions in travel costs for non revenue sports? I doubt that. I think the athletes who are getting full or partial scholarships to attend mostly prestigious universities in the P4 could get over it. Also where is that big check the itty bitty schools get? The autonomous conferences just signed up the G6 ot pay a big chunk of the house settlement even though they received 95% of the benefit. Sounds like the welfare goes both ways. RE: football only FBS conferences - GoBuckeyes1047 - 02-06-2025 08:52 AM I could see something where if the B1G and SEC go to 20 teams each, and for non-rev sports, they could split up into 4 divisions of 10 with 1 whole B1G, 1 whole SEC, a split western division, and a split eastern division. Something like the remaining 10 SEC original members, and 10 B1G original, then the PAC 4 + Nebraska and the western 5 SEC teams formerly SWC or Big 8, followed by PSU, Rut, MD, SC, and 6 ACC schools that join the B1G and SEC. My best guess is UVA, UNC, Duke, Clem, FSU, and Miami. Then allow some crossover games with their FB/BB conference members. I wouldn't rule out Stanford, ND, NC State, VT, Louisville, and Kansas. Maybe 22 each for B1G & SEC (can still play everyone H&H in 6 years with 3 protected rivals playing 9 conf. games), and non-rev sports split into 4 divisions of 11 like suggested above, but that will be up to conferences, their media network partners, and maybe ND on if there is an appetite for 22 teams each. ACC/B12 remaining teams could follow suit amongst their teams for non-rev sports, and then the same thing potentially among the G6 conferences. RE: football only FBS conferences - Frank the Tank - 02-06-2025 08:53 AM (02-05-2025 12:42 PM)ballantyneapp Wrote:(02-05-2025 12:02 PM)bullet Wrote:(02-05-2025 11:43 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote: When is the NCAA going to come to its senses and remove the FBS requirement for all sports?They do care who they are affiliated with and they do want competitive conferences. Are they really coming around at the P4 level? (The G5/6 is a totally different story.) Your point about Stanford field hockey ignores the point that the school had few choices there due to a total lack of field hockey programs in the West. Even while in the Pac-12, Stanford was sending its field hockey team to the freaking America East. The ACC is actually more accessible by comparison considering they’re not having to go to places like Vermont and New Hampshire. Stanford and Cal couldn’t run away from the Oregon State/Washington State proposal for the rebuilt Pac-12 fast enough. I don’t think you’re getting what the P4 is doing here. Tying football to all of the non-revenue sports and forcing large spending on them is arguably the most effective way to protect their elite status in a non-crass manner (e.g. advancing all athletics, including women’s sports, as opposed to just making the most money on football and basketball). They *don’t* want Boise State or (with apologies) App State to simply be able to take their football program alone and easily move anywhere for that sport alone. The non-revenue sports are effectively the super high country club entry fee to keep the “riff raff” out of the football and basketball ranks. I don’t see that changing. Now, the G5/6 may have very different incentives. We just saw NIU move to the MWC for football-only. It wouldn’t shock me if we saw more of those types of moves at the G5/6 level or having football-only leagues introduced there. *That* is where it makes some sense. At the P4 level, though, betting on eiitism is a pretty good bet in realignment (once you get past the pure money aspect of it). RE: football only FBS conferences - Frank the Tank - 02-06-2025 09:00 AM (02-06-2025 08:23 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote:(02-05-2025 07:51 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(02-05-2025 12:16 PM)bullet Wrote: But you bring up a thought. The P4 don’t want to play the riff raff even in non-revenue sports. Stanford would have been in the top 10 of the overall medal count and gold medal count in the last Olympics if they were their own country. This one school produces more Olympians than all but a small handful of the wealthiest industrialized nations in the world. And yes, that’s an institutional priority for Stanford as much as finding future Nobel Prize winners or Silicon Valley titans, so they want to play the elite of the elite in every sport regardless of cost. The old Pac-12 served those needs, but the new Pac-12 doesn’t, so that’s why they offered financial concessions simply for the right to send everyone across the country to the ACC. If you understood the mentality of academia, this is actually NORMAL because elite status is the ultimate goal. Never underestimate the power of elitism in academia. Elitism IS their currency more than even money itself. The whole point of money in academia is to enhance elite status as opposed to the other way around. |