(09-04-2013 02:58 PM)stever20 Wrote: I'm a Georgetown fan and I am a huge basketball fan. I am a fan of the old Big East. The new Big East as much as you guys want to paint it out to be just is not the same. You don't lose Syracuse, UConn, Pitt, Notre Dame, Louisville, or even Cincy recently, and just move on like nothing happened. I mean that's 5 championships in 15 years- I mean national championships. Forget Big East Championships, those teams had 11 championships in that time frame. WV and BC have as many titles in the last 15 years as current Big east schools do. I'm just not a lemming and think that all is perfect- that's just not the case.
Does the Big East have potential to be a very good conference? Yes, of course it does. You have teams in here that have been really great in the past. But, there's that word- the past. Of the 7 C7 schools, how many are riding on high right now? Marquette maybe, but other than that? I know the Hoya's aren't. St Johns and Nova aren't. Depaul and Seton Hall aren't. Providence seems to be on the uptick, but they aren't where they were back with Pitino, Barnes, and Gillen. Not yet at least. For the newbies, Xavier I like a lot even with last year. Butler you just don't know with a new coach what they're going to be like- especially at a whole new level.... Creighton, lets see them in 2 years after McDermott leaves.
If this was 1990, this collection of teams would have been amazing. But, it's not 1990. Also, the question of any non football league now in days- it's just not been done on the level we're trying to do it at. So, there's uncertainty.
What difference does/did it make?
Did you feel some kind of pride in being associated with all those championships when it wasn't your team winning them? Your team has been spitting the bit year after year since their high point in 2007. Was it a consolation for you to watch Louisville, and UConn win championships in the past few years?
And then there was the endless blame game played by the dysfunctional football group, constantly scapegoating the Catholic schools for the problems they created. Did you enjoy being their butt boy?
Some things are more important than championships. Like pride, self-respect, and showing some backbone.
Fact is that the Catholic schools are in a far better position now to realize their own potential than they were in the recent incarnation of the Big East. That's a good thing, a positive development.
Fact is that the Catholic schools gave the finger to the football schools, the old FU by deciding to leave them instead of the other way around. Take some pride in the fact that your administration and the others collectively decided not to be pushed around any more.
Fact is that we now have a viable basketball-first conference with a group of schools with a clear identity, which returns The Big East to its roots. This is a tremendous development for college basketball in general. In college athletics, the football conferences ate the local bullies. Finally someone has decided to fight back.
As for the long term future of The Big East, it is very bright. Regardless of any of the particulars at this moment, Villanova, Georgetown, and Marquette have demonstrated in the past decade or so that they can once again compete at the highest levels. That's reassuring because there had been doubt. Butler too has demonstrated that it is a place where a championship contender can be built
In terms of the immediate future - like right now - in addition to Georgetown, Villanova, and Marquette, Creighton, St. John's and Providence are loaded. All 6 of those teams are capable of deep runs in this year's tournament. That means that there's a lot to look forward to right now. I'm not in the business of making predictions, but I know that it's going to be fun watching this season play out.
If you can't enjoy all that, fine with me. I understand how you feel. I'm a UConn season ticket holder and I hate the thought of being in the AAC. I will root for UConn but I wll not follow the conference. My interest in a conference will be with the Big East. I'll even get to an occasional Big East game even though it is not convenient for me.
It sounds like your feelings toward the Big East are a lot like mine toward the AAC. So, my suggestion is that you root for your Hoyas, but follow the conference that you're interested in, which appears to be the ACC, judging by the schools you keep mentioning. Ignore the Big East. You'll be much happier.