The 2009 MAC football recruiting analysis has added the Northern Illinois, Ohio and Temple team reports at VanDelay Sports.

(02-12-2009 12:32 PM)IBleedMACGreen Wrote:  The 2009 MAC football recruiting analysis has added the Northern Illinois, Ohio and Temple team reports at VanDelay Sports.

8 MAC schools had excellent, or better, recruiting classes? I know that rank is as they compare to each other, but if over half the conference ranks Excellent or better as compared to each other I think that kind of implies your ratings are bunk.

...Yeah that sounds right.

And not to nitpick, but if you are going to post this on our board you should probably have the class right.

You say we had 3 juco players signed to this class. The real number is 5.

Kyle Jenkins DE is missing, and Charvo Lampton OL.

I'm not here to judge your website - but how do you rank the classes if you don't know who is in them?

The VanDelay stuff is useless. It's swell that somebody takes the time to be committed to MAC football and summarize data, but there is no objective or expert rating analysis here. It's just like the EdgyTim stuff.

(02-13-2009 10:02 AM)Nigel Incubator-Jones Wrote:  The VanDelay stuff is useless. It's swell that somebody takes the time to be committed to MAC football and summarize data, but there is no objective or expert rating analysis here. It's just like the EdgyTim stuff.

NIU received an Excellent rating. He must know his stuff!

(02-13-2009 12:30 PM)NIU17 Wrote:  

(02-13-2009 10:02 AM)Nigel Incubator-Jones Wrote:  The VanDelay stuff is useless. It's swell that somebody takes the time to be committed to MAC football and summarize data, but there is no objective or expert rating analysis here. It's just like the EdgyTim stuff.

NIU received an Excellent rating. He must know his stuff!

Anytime you and 7 of your closest friends receive an excellent rating...something sure isn't right.

(02-13-2009 01:47 PM)TheNEWguy Wrote:  

(02-13-2009 12:30 PM)NIU17 Wrote:  

(02-13-2009 10:02 AM)Nigel Incubator-Jones Wrote:  The VanDelay stuff is useless. It's swell that somebody takes the time to be committed to MAC football and summarize data, but there is no objective or expert rating analysis here. It's just like the EdgyTim stuff.

NIU received an Excellent rating. He must know his stuff!

Anytime you and 7 of your closest friends receive an excellent rating...something sure isn't right.

lol. But, if you look at it from the point of view that many of the teams addressed their needs and also got some above average (for the MAC) talent, there could be more than 1/2 the teams receiving above average grades. Maybe not excellent ratings, but it doesn't have to be 50 good-50 bad.

(02-13-2009 01:56 PM)NIU17 Wrote:  

(02-13-2009 01:47 PM)TheNEWguy Wrote:  

(02-13-2009 12:30 PM)NIU17 Wrote:  

(02-13-2009 10:02 AM)Nigel Incubator-Jones Wrote:  The VanDelay stuff is useless. It's swell that somebody takes the time to be committed to MAC football and summarize data, but there is no objective or expert rating analysis here. It's just like the EdgyTim stuff.

NIU received an Excellent rating. He must know his stuff!

Anytime you and 7 of your closest friends receive an excellent rating...something sure isn't right.

lol. But, if you look at it from the point of view that many of the teams addressed their needs and also got some above average (for the MAC) talent, there could be more than 1/2 the teams receiving above average grades. Maybe not excellent ratings, but it doesn't have to be 50 good-50 bad.

You are right, if he said average I would totally agree. I think the funny part of it all is that everyone was EXCELLENT!!! Everyone is a winner.

My 2nd problem with it all is that he doesn't even have our class correct, so how can he rank us?