GSUdpb
Special Teams

Posts: 613
Joined: Feb 2012
Reputation: 52
I Root For: Georgia State
Location: ATL
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
Why am I not surprised the Jimmy Mads fans are still whining about that transition thing?
|
|
| 09-22-2026 01:37 PM |
|
We Are the Dukes of JMU
1st String

Posts: 1,374
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 110
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-22-2026 11:18 AM)GSUALUM17 Wrote: As I browse this thread, I do think there is a disconnect between JMU fans and the rest.
In the past decade or so, many SBC fans were genuinely pulling for what's best for the conference's interest. Their programs built this conference together from the gutter.
JMU came along very late post-covid when SBC was already pretty darn good. Before JMU arrived, SBC was taking P4 scalps regularly. Multiple teams made top 25 rankings or came close. Received the attention of national media as the G5 conference that's consistently punching above its weight (G5 is the right term here as G6 wasn't a thing yet). In fact, SBC's built-in success is what attracted JMU here.
I literally read JMU fans stating "I care most about what can SBC do for JMU" and "if you dont want JMU to leave, you better do x." That's something new we've never encountered before. Appreciately the blunt honesty, but I guess that camaraderie just isn't there for the newcomer.
I think that's a fraction of JMU fans, but they do exist. Notice though that you see other JMU fans on this thread taking the opposite position.
On the JMU board, I get the impression that most of our fans are happy with our SBC conference affiliation. Like any other school, we would obviously considering moving if the right athletic and financial opportunity presented itself. That's not unique to JMU.
|
|
| 09-22-2026 01:40 PM |
|
High Country Student
1st String

Posts: 1,416
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 66
I Root For: App. State
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-22-2026 01:35 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (09-22-2026 09:41 AM)High Country Student Wrote: (09-22-2026 09:33 AM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (09-22-2026 08:34 AM)High Country Student Wrote: (09-22-2026 08:06 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote: SBC policy dictates who plays in the CCG and the NY6 bid at that time required a conference championship. The SBC's policy was only bowl-eligible teams could play in the CCG, which there were questions if JMU was going to be with transition rules.
But once JMU got slotted into a bowl game with Air Force and not just the last available bowl, it was clear once there were not enough bowl eligible teams JMU was treated the same as everyone else. If JMU had a conference championship, it could have been slotted into a NY6 bowl.
You’re salty that no one changed the rules to give you hope of a better outcome. You can’t rely on that and holding a grudge over that not happening is childish. Truth is, if you beat us, something probably happens but when the undefeated record went out the door, so did your chances of making the playoff. After having the loss, they probably put Liberty and SMU in the playoff ahead of JMU that year.
Regarding teams wanting to kick ULM out that haven’t been here a long time, maybe the folks complaining about them wanting to do that are part of the problem. It shouldn’t matter how long a team has or hasn’t been here. If someone is not performing over a long period of time, why should anyone want them here. You wouldn’t want them working for you if you were their boss. It sounds like feelings are causing you to be comfortable with the thoughts of mediocrity rather than wanting to see the conference continue to rise. If someone is underperforming over a long period of time and not doing anything to fix it over a long period of time (meaning not doing anything that has actually worked) why should we care to keep them?
The rules at the time allowed a team to request a waiver, which JMU did. We followed the rules. Many JMU fans hoped Gill would publicly support our waiver request but he remained silent.
Again, I don't think it would have changed the outcome, but there are some JMU fans who feel he should have done more. But let's dispense with the "JMU tried to change the rules" narrative. The rules allowed our waiver request and we followed them precisely.
A waiver is within the rules but a waiver is literally an attempt to change the rules. Keith Gill not speaking up isn’t anything new. He’s good at what he’s good at but being vocal is not one of those things. He’s never been a vocal advocate of anything. He has more of the conservative trying not to ruffle any feathers approach for better or worse.
Nope, a waiver is not a rule change. JMU's request would not have changed the NCAA reclassification rule. It would have literally remained word for word the same. The rules allowed the NCAA to issue waivers at its discretion.
The NCAA has the power to change the rules via waiver.
|
|
| 09-22-2026 02:02 PM |
|
debragga
All American

Posts: 2,516
Joined: Nov 2017
Reputation: 212
I Root For: ULM
Location: Ruston, LA
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-22-2026 02:02 PM)High Country Student Wrote: The NCAA has the power to change the rules via waiver.
It’s time to stop.
|
|
| 09-22-2026 04:21 PM |
|
BamaCajun
2nd String

Posts: 488
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 55
I Root For: Leggy Red Heads
Location: Richmond, VA
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-22-2026 09:44 AM)High Country Student Wrote: (09-22-2026 09:41 AM)geaux.cajuns Wrote: (09-21-2026 07:07 PM)debragga Wrote: (09-21-2026 06:24 PM)Big Buds Wrote: It’s not just football. It’s atrocious in every sport they sponsor. Somehow, Louisiana and LaTech can contribute more years than not on a wide range of athletes, let alone football. Something is fundamentally wrong in Monroe.
Not every sport. We were regular season champs in 3 sports last year. And of course there’s water skiing consistently being top 2 nationally if you want to count that.
Just want to point out that the Cajuns are 6x defending national champs 
When you’re skiing for your life to avoid alligators, you probably are darn good skiiers lol. You Cajuns and your swamps are a different breed!
Actually, growing up in Iberia and Vermilion Parishes, I did water ski in several bayous with gators. Simple rules to follow. Stay in the middle of the bayou/river, have a damn good spotter, and the driver had to immediately pick up a downed skier.
|
|
| 09-22-2026 06:24 PM |
|
HouCat
2nd String

Posts: 388
Joined: Nov 2023
Reputation: 41
I Root For: Texas State
Location: Bayou City
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 12:53 PM |
|
High Country Student
1st String

Posts: 1,416
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 66
I Root For: App. State
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 12:53 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
Still wouldn’t fix the ULM problem
|
|
| 09-23-2026 01:29 PM |
|
MUther
Heisman

Posts: 9,914
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 729
I Root For: Marshall
Location:

|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 12:53 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
You’ve used that argument before while creating zero revenue or exposure for the conference. It’s ok. You’re no longer our problem. Nothing going on in the PAC worth reading?
|
|
| 09-23-2026 02:18 PM |
|
Dukes_Royals
All American

Posts: 2,998
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 84
I Root For: James Madison University
Location: Harrisonburg, VA
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 01:29 PM)High Country Student Wrote: (09-23-2026 12:53 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
Still wouldn’t fix the ULM problem
I don't know. $1-2 million a year would be a 5-10% increase their budget. Not insignificant
|
|
| 09-23-2026 02:57 PM |
|
OregonIndian
Water Engineer

Posts: 8
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 0
I Root For: ULM
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
This will probably not be real popular on this board but the ultimate solution to the issue is for ULM and LaTech to merge. there is only 30 miles between the 2 schools and frankly North Louisiana would be better served with one large institution (20,000 +) students than continuing to try and support 2 smaller institutions. The graduate programs could be housed at ULM along with building up the medical school and strengthening the health sciences, Construction management could move to LaTech and join the Engineering / Architecture program. You could even add a Law School which North Louisiana could surely use.
Call it whatever you want, UNL (university of North Louisiana), Louisiana Tech, or Louisiana A & M.
It just makes too much sense from a financial and demographic point, and that is why the university system will never let it happen.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 04:17 PM |
|
HouCat
2nd String

Posts: 388
Joined: Nov 2023
Reputation: 41
I Root For: Texas State
Location: Bayou City
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 02:18 PM)MUther Wrote: (09-23-2026 12:53 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
You’ve used that argument before while creating zero revenue or exposure for the conference. It’s ok. You’re no longer our problem. Nothing going on in the PAC worth reading?
Zero revenue and conference exposure is what happens when Marshall opts out of bowl games.
We were happy to share our winnings from three bowl games with the conference as well as the exposure and goodwill that comes with it.
You're welcome.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 04:23 PM |
|
Troy_Fan_15
Sun Belt Apologist

Posts: 6,522
Joined: Dec 2016
Reputation: 467
I Root For: Troy Trojans
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
At the end of the day I doubt there have been any serious discussions about ULM dropping to FCS or athletics at all in regard to that single result. They haven't dropped yet and so I don't see them doing it now. Especially if the SBC begins any type of renegotiations soon with ESPN over media rights in the next 2 seasons and they can get an uptick in money from that.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 05:46 PM |
|
MUther
Heisman

Posts: 9,914
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 729
I Root For: Marshall
Location:

|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 04:23 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-23-2026 02:18 PM)MUther Wrote: (09-23-2026 12:53 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
You’ve used that argument before while creating zero revenue or exposure for the conference. It’s ok. You’re no longer our problem. Nothing going on in the PAC worth reading?
Zero revenue and conference exposure is what happens when Marshall opts out of bowl games.
We were happy to share our winnings from three bowl games with the conference as well as the exposure and goodwill that comes with it.
You're welcome.
And the other years? Like all of them. Would you like to compare bowl records? See we believe you succeed at “other” sports and revenue sports, like national runner up in soccer AND conference champ in football. And the only reason you can’t proclaim yourself a mouth breather is because it always has a dih in it.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 06:18 PM |
|
HouCat
2nd String

Posts: 388
Joined: Nov 2023
Reputation: 41
I Root For: Texas State
Location: Bayou City
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 06:18 PM)MUther Wrote: (09-23-2026 04:23 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-23-2026 02:18 PM)MUther Wrote: (09-23-2026 12:53 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-19-2026 11:52 PM)MUther Wrote: I think TxSt was more like Charlotte. Only won stuff that didn’t pay the bills or garner any recognition but bragged about Director Cup rankings. ULM is <
The rankings exist for a reason, do they not?
Some of us aren't mouth breathers and appreciate other sports.
Back to the topic at hand--Keith Gill needed to negotiate a better media deal yesterday--and that would give everybody more $.
You’ve used that argument before while creating zero revenue or exposure for the conference. It’s ok. You’re no longer our problem. Nothing going on in the PAC worth reading?
Zero revenue and conference exposure is what happens when Marshall opts out of bowl games.
We were happy to share our winnings from three bowl games with the conference as well as the exposure and goodwill that comes with it.
You're welcome.
And the other years? Like all of them. Would you like to compare bowl records? See we believe you succeed at “other” sports and revenue sports, like national runner up in soccer AND conference champ in football. And the only reason you can’t proclaim yourself a mouth breather is because it always has a dih in it.
Changing the subject doesn’t change the facts.
You might want to get off that high horse patna.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 06:57 PM |
|
MUther
Heisman

Posts: 9,914
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 729
I Root For: Marshall
Location:

|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
29 years in FBS. Only not eligible 9 times. Once eligible but couldn’t play. In some 19 bowls played in 29 years we’ve only lost 6. We held the record for most consecutive bowl wins over a decade. Had the biggest comeback in a bowl win, and had the most combined points in a bowl (same bowl vs ECU). TxSt would kill for our history in football. You’re not even in the same conversation
Teams beat: Louisville x2, BYU (ranked), Cincy, ECU, Ohio, FIU, Maryland, NIU (MAC Champs) x2, Colorado St, UCONN, USF
Teams lost to: Ole Miss, Cincy, Buffalo, UTSA, UCF, Louisiana (ranked Sunday Belt champs, I think)
You brought up bowls and changed the subject.
(This post was last modified: 09-23-2026 07:03 PM by MUther.)
|
|
| 09-23-2026 06:59 PM |
|
EaglesFly
Water Engineer

Posts: 98
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 16
I Root For: Georgia Souther
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-22-2026 01:40 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (09-22-2026 11:18 AM)GSUALUM17 Wrote: As I browse this thread, I do think there is a disconnect between JMU fans and the rest.
In the past decade or so, many SBC fans were genuinely pulling for what's best for the conference's interest. Their programs built this conference together from the gutter.
JMU came along very late post-covid when SBC was already pretty darn good. Before JMU arrived, SBC was taking P4 scalps regularly. Multiple teams made top 25 rankings or came close. Received the attention of national media as the G5 conference that's consistently punching above its weight (G5 is the right term here as G6 wasn't a thing yet). In fact, SBC's built-in success is what attracted JMU here.
I literally read JMU fans stating "I care most about what can SBC do for JMU" and "if you dont want JMU to leave, you better do x." That's something new we've never encountered before. Appreciately the blunt honesty, but I guess that camaraderie just isn't there for the newcomer.
Quote:I think that's a fraction of JMU fans
, but they do exist. Notice though that you see other JMU fans on this thread taking the opposite position.
On the JMU board, I get the impression that most of our fans are happy with our SBC conference affiliation. Like any other school, we would obviously considering moving if the right athletic and financial opportunity presented itself. That's not unique to JMU.
BCP-JMU and JMU2004. These two are special.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 07:05 PM |
|
olddawg
Hall of Famer

Posts: 11,896
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 115
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-21-2026 11:00 AM)dawgonit Wrote: Great idea that we can all get behind.
Don't we all want to them become Northeastern Louisiana University again and join Northwestern, Southeastern and Southwestern in the Southland? I think I can speak on everyone's behalf that it is just satisfying to put all four together again in the FCS.
I still find it amusing that Southwestern Louisiana (Lafayette) is farther east than Northeast Louisiana (Monroe).
(This post was last modified: 09-23-2026 07:39 PM by olddawg.)
|
|
| 09-23-2026 07:32 PM |
|
seaking4steel
1st String

Posts: 1,561
Joined: May 2018
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Penn St, App St
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 04:17 PM)OregonIndian Wrote: This will probably not be real popular on this board but the ultimate solution to the issue is for ULM and LaTech to merge. there is only 30 miles between the 2 schools and frankly North Louisiana would be better served with one large institution (20,000 +) students than continuing to try and support 2 smaller institutions. The graduate programs could be housed at ULM along with building up the medical school and strengthening the health sciences, Construction management could move to LaTech and join the Engineering / Architecture program. You could even add a Law School which North Louisiana could surely use.
Call it whatever you want, UNL (university of North Louisiana), Louisiana Tech, or Louisiana A & M.
It just makes too much sense from a financial and demographic point, and that is why the university system will never let it happen.
That's a smart idea. Louisiana has too many public schools for a state of its size. Most of that is due to the old school feudal-style politics that dominated the state when most of these schools were founded.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 08:24 PM |
|
HouCat
2nd String

Posts: 388
Joined: Nov 2023
Reputation: 41
I Root For: Texas State
Location: Bayou City
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 06:59 PM)MUther Wrote: 29 years in FBS. Only not eligible 9 times. Once eligible but couldn’t play. In some 19 bowls played in 29 years we’ve only lost 6. We held the record for most consecutive bowl wins over a decade. Had the biggest comeback in a bowl win, and had the most combined points in a bowl (same bowl vs ECU). TxSt would kill for our history in football. You’re not even in the same conversation 
Teams beat: Louisville x2, BYU (ranked), Cincy, ECU, Ohio, FIU, Maryland, NIU (MAC Champs) x2, Colorado St, UCONN, USF
Teams lost to: Ole Miss, Cincy, Buffalo, UTSA, UCF, Louisiana (ranked Sunday Belt champs, I think)
You brought up bowls and changed the subject.
SBC Bowls are relevant because they provide proof you're FOS and directly contradict your assertion that we never provided any conference revenue or exposure.
The irony is Marshall hasn't had either since joining the SBC and has no business lecturing a member (current or former) about the same.
|
|
| 09-23-2026 09:43 PM |
|
Tech80
1st String

Posts: 1,772
Joined: Dec 2016
Reputation: 253
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
|
RE: Can the SBC drop ULM?
(09-23-2026 09:43 PM)HouCat Wrote: (09-23-2026 06:59 PM)MUther Wrote: 29 years in FBS. Only not eligible 9 times. Once eligible but couldn’t play. In some 19 bowls played in 29 years we’ve only lost 6. We held the record for most consecutive bowl wins over a decade. Had the biggest comeback in a bowl win, and had the most combined points in a bowl (same bowl vs ECU). TxSt would kill for our history in football. You’re not even in the same conversation 
Teams beat: Louisville x2, BYU (ranked), Cincy, ECU, Ohio, FIU, Maryland, NIU (MAC Champs) x2, Colorado St, UCONN, USF
Teams lost to: Ole Miss, Cincy, Buffalo, UTSA, UCF, Louisiana (ranked Sunday Belt champs, I think)
You brought up bowls and changed the subject.
SBC Bowls are relevant because they provide proof you're FOS and directly contradict your assertion that we never provided any conference revenue or exposure.
The irony is Marshall hasn't had either since joining the SBC and has no business lecturing a member (current or former) about the same.
Speaking of bowls, what are the bowl records for current SBC schools?
Tech is 8-4-1 (if I didn't miss 1 or 2).
|
|
| 09-24-2026 08:10 AM |
|