The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,389
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-15-2026 10:32 AM)Blust3 Wrote: (09-15-2026 07:43 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (09-15-2026 04:45 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote: (09-14-2026 12:02 PM)Blust3 Wrote: (09-14-2026 11:42 AM)darkdragon99 Wrote: I think Syracuse has more value than Pitt. Pitt has very little value. They are in the middle of Steelers and Penn State country so interest for Pitt football is low. Syracuse at least has a entire market to themselves and their own stadium and its better academically so they bring a lot more to the table than Pitt.
Pitt would have more value if Pennsylvania and West Pennsylvania were two states like Virginia and West Virginia are. Same applies to Cal if California and South California were two states. South Carolina and Clemson would have less value if two universities were in the one single state of Carolina. In another Earth, the fifty states include California, South California, Pennsylvania, West Pennsylvania, Carolina and Dakota, and conference realignment would be totally different due to this factor. For starter, when B1G adds Penn State, she has to add Pitt at the same time, otherwise Penn State would be an island.
It's an unfortunate byproduct of the cable carriage models that made states into singular blocs rather than regional pieces. If that was even the real deciding factor. Politics look to be more tangible, and "markets" a scapegoat for some situations. Funny how the Big Ten couldn't possibly have a need for two Iowa, Ohio, or Pennsylvania schools, but two in LA?
I don't think he's talking about cable carriage markets, so much as local pride. As it is, to someone in rural western PA, a few million people, the University of Pittsburgh is just the Pittsburgh city school. If the borders were different, and Pittsburgh were the capital of the State of West Pennsylvania or the Allegheny Commonwealth, then the Pitt Panthers would be "our team" for more of what's in reality western Pennsylvania.
Would that overcome the cultural gulf between "Pittsburgh, Philadelphia and Pennsyltucky"? I don't know.
Nope. The majority of Western Pennsylvania roots for Pitt and East PA roots for Penn State. And Pitt has better academics than Penn State so people valuing academics prefer Pitt when finding school for their kids.
Pitt has a plurality of the city of Pittsburgh (despite it having more PSU grads than Pitt grads) and the collar counties and thats it. I say that not because of familiarity with the area, which is so wide that I'd scoff at anyone who proports to, but because polling has consistently shown it to be so. There's a reason whenever anyone tries to make a map using data, as opposed to geographic proximity, it ends up looking like this or this.
Bear in mind that "western" and "eastern" PA usually boils down to Philly versus Pittsburgh. That isn't what this is, its State College vs Pittsburgh. State College is west of the Susquehanna and north of the state's middle dividing line, such that any such line exists. I guess if "Western Pennsylvania" ends at Westmoreland County then sure, Pitt wins western Pennsylvania, but nobody else defines it like that. I see that Cutter is missing that too. His "Berlin Wall" would have both schools in west Berlin.
edit: That first image of mine, at it's main source, actually drills down county by county with top five results. You can see that, for example, Bedford County (deep in western PA, for those who don't know,) is 59% Penn State, 9% Pitt, 9% WV. Fulton County, to its east, is evenly divided between PSU and... WV. Pitt doesn't even chart with none of the county's 12 accounts following Pitt Football. Up north Venango is 34% PSU, 23% Pitt, Erie is 40% Penn State, 11% Pitt, 8% OSU. If you can't even be competitive in Erie, let alone carry it, you don't own Western PA. Pitt's best result is in Allegheny County (home to Pittsburgh, for those who don't know), where they get 43% of the total, the only county where they break 40.
And then out east, just for the sake of completeness, you have places like Schuylkill County (PSU 56%, ND 7%, Pitt 4%), York (PSU 54%, nobody else crosses 4%), Northhampton (PSU 32%, Lehigh 15%, Lafayette 12%, Pitt fails to make top five), Montgomery -the most important, though not largest, county in Pennsylvania- (PSU 30%, Temple 15%, Pitt didn't place), and finally Philly (Temple 22%, PSU 19%, Pitt once again not rated.)
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2026 07:40 AM by The Beaver.)
|
|