BeatNavy
1st String

Posts: 1,702
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 285
I Root For: Army
Location: NH
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-07-2026 07:48 AM)Ourland Wrote: (09-07-2026 07:20 AM)BeatNavy Wrote: (09-06-2026 11:18 PM)Ourland Wrote: (09-06-2026 09:02 PM)BeatNavy Wrote: (09-06-2026 07:39 PM)Ourland Wrote: Oh, okay. That makes it easier. If no one gets a scholarship, then the roster can be as large as Army and Navy like. Players are promoted as the injured fall.
NCAA football roster size is not limited to the number of football scholarships awarded.
Scholarship limits are waived for the academies. It's the reason that Army, Navy, and Air Force typically sign between 30-40 cadets every single season for football. If you do the math, it gives the academies about 140-150 players at any time, so a distinct advantage in depth that other like-minded institutions don't enjoy at the 105 limit.
Most freshmen play on a JV team that has its own schedule. They play regional junior colleges and/or D3 opponents. I don't know if Navy still does this, but Air Force still has a JV team.
So yes, there's no such thing as athletic scholarships since everyone is on a academic scholarship. This is the loophole that enables the academies to sign as many players as they want who can qualify academically.
No one is on academic scholarship either. There is no tuition, thus no scholarships. Also, double your 30-40 new players each year estimate, it's 60-80.
Regarding roster size, how much value do players "ranked" 106 through whatever bring to a football team's on-field performance? Let's not pretend that 106-whatever have much, if any, chance of making an appearance in a game, regardless of injuries to players 1 through 105.
JV schedules are very very limited because of lack of competition. Yes, they get more game experience than non-playing members in a program that doesn't have JV.
But not having JV is A CHOICE. If it was more advantageous than not, wouldn't more programs field a JV team?
What the academies have is a much larger pool of athletes. No, many of those guys don't work out, for whatever the reasons, but the same is true of athletes from schools that must stay at the 105 limit, meaning that attrition hurts the academies much less.
Most freshmen at the academies never play. They're typically coming right out of basic training, and don't have the size to step right in. All of them get a full year to "develop" physically before joining the team, which is also a very big advantage. They're lifting weights and learning the option.
If other schools, like Rice, had the numbers for a freshman program/JV, they'd surely do it. Just like the academies, the kids that come to Rice aren't typically ready to play as freshmen.
More schools could have JV, they choose not to do it. Other than buyout blowouts, what is the average number of players per FBS team who appear in games? I'd be very surprised if it was as many as 60.
PART of why JV died out is that JV games against "outside competition" burned redshirts. With redshirts now preserved as long as players don't appear in "too many" games, that concern is lessened. If a 5-year cap ends up happening, that would further open up things.
(This post was last modified: 09-09-2026 07:41 AM by BeatNavy.)
|
|
| 09-09-2026 07:36 AM |
|
WTXOwl
Bench Warmer

Posts: 206
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 73
I Root For: Rice University
Location: West Texas
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
(09-09-2026 06:31 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
3 quarters.
Based upon Owl at the Moon's definition - 100%
Based upon Side.Show.Joe's definition - 0%
I believe these percentages would be consistent with most voters in the Coaches Poll with the exception of the team which employs said coach and current opponent of that team.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 08:07 AM |
|
Cubanbull1
Heisman

Posts: 6,595
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 672
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
Too early to rank. Memphis so far looks best having played best competition and won. Tulsa beat OKST but we know how that went last year.
This week we have more matchups that will make it more clear.
1. Memphis vs Boise will be a big step towards best in CFP right now.
2. USF vs Army and Navy vs FAU- who gets a leg up in Conference Play
3. ECU vs AppState, Tulane vs So.Ala, UTSA vs Texas St, North Texas vs UNLV, UAB vs LaMo, Tulsa vs Sam Houston- games vs conferences we are in competition for CFP
4. Temple vs Penn st, Charlotte vs Ole Miss. games vs P teams most likely losses
|
|
| 09-09-2026 08:24 AM |
|
goliath74
5318008

Posts: 10,090
Joined: Nov 2013
Reputation: 759
I Root For: FAU, FSU
Location: Boca Raton, Florida
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
Or 60:00 to 60:01?
|
|
| 09-09-2026 12:51 PM |
|
BeatNavy
1st String

Posts: 1,702
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 285
I Root For: Army
Location: NH
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 08:07 AM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
(09-09-2026 06:31 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
3 quarters.
Based upon Owl at the Moon's definition - 100%
Based upon Side.Show.Joe's definition - 0%
I believe these percentages would be consistent with most voters in the Coaches Poll with the exception of the team which employs said coach and current opponent of that team.
Raise your hand if you think a significant portion of the coaches who vote in the coaches poll actually fill out their own ballots.
What we need to know is what is the most common job title among those who DO fill out those ballots?
I suspect that "social media" and/or "intern" is in the job title.
(This post was last modified: 09-09-2026 01:34 PM by BeatNavy.)
|
|
| 09-09-2026 01:32 PM |
|
Side.Show.Joe
Heisman

Posts: 7,127
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 1344
I Root For: North Texas
Location:
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 08:07 AM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
(09-09-2026 06:31 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
3 quarters.
Based upon Owl at the Moon's definition - 100%
Based upon Side.Show.Joe's definition - 0%
I believe these percentages would be consistent with most voters in the Coaches Poll with the exception of the team which employs said coach and current opponent of that team.
My Youtube TV account automatically records all televised games, which allows me to enjoy significant amounts of our conference games over the long weekend. I was just interested in how much of your assessment was based on what you observed from actual games and how much might have been gleaned from highlights.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 05:02 PM |
|
WTXOwl
Bench Warmer

Posts: 206
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 73
I Root For: Rice University
Location: West Texas
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 05:02 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-09-2026 08:07 AM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
(09-09-2026 06:31 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
3 quarters.
Based upon Owl at the Moon's definition - 100%
Based upon Side.Show.Joe's definition - 0%
I believe these percentages would be consistent with most voters in the Coaches Poll with the exception of the team which employs said coach and current opponent of that team.
My Youtube TV account automatically records all televised games, which allows me to enjoy significant amounts of our conference games over the long weekend. I was just interested in how much of your assessment was based on what you observed from actual games and how much might have been gleaned from highlights.
Three observations:
1. Recording the games is a very useful tool to have when trying to catch games in a conference of 14.
2. As an old soul, I rely heavily upon box scores and local reporting.
3. I rarely let the facts get in the way of a good ranking.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 06:08 PM |
|
WTXOwl
Bench Warmer

Posts: 206
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 73
I Root For: Rice University
Location: West Texas
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 01:32 PM)BeatNavy Wrote: (09-09-2026 08:07 AM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
(09-09-2026 06:31 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
3 quarters.
Based upon Owl at the Moon's definition - 100%
Based upon Side.Show.Joe's definition - 0%
I believe these percentages would be consistent with most voters in the Coaches Poll with the exception of the team which employs said coach and current opponent of that team.
Raise your hand if you think a significant portion of the coaches who vote in the coaches poll actually fill out their own ballots.
What we need to know is what is the most common job title among those who DO fill out those ballots?
I suspect that "social media" and/or "intern" is in the job title.
Director of Football Operations
|
|
| 09-09-2026 06:10 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 08:24 AM)Cubanbull1 Wrote: Too early to rank. Memphis so far looks best having played best competition and won. Tulsa beat OKST but we know how that went last year.
This week we have more matchups that will make it more clear.
1. Memphis vs Boise will be a big step towards best in CFP right now.
2. USF vs Army and Navy vs FAU- who gets a leg up in Conference Play
3. ECU vs AppState, Tulane vs So.Ala, UTSA vs Texas St, North Texas vs UNLV, UAB vs LaMo, Tulsa vs Sam Houston- games vs conferences we are in competition for CFP
4. Temple vs Penn st, Charlotte vs Ole Miss. games vs P teams most likely losses
If Memphis beats Boise along with the UNLV win, the CFP is going to the American champ. We will have plowed the road.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 10:46 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 01:32 PM)BeatNavy Wrote: (09-09-2026 08:07 AM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 11:06 PM)owl at the moon Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
Long enough for the game clock to have gone from 0:00 to 0:01?
(09-09-2026 06:31 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:12 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: (09-08-2026 06:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: How many of these games did you watch for a significant amount of time?
Define significant . . .
3 quarters.
Based upon Owl at the Moon's definition - 100%
Based upon Side.Show.Joe's definition - 0%
I believe these percentages would be consistent with most voters in the Coaches Poll with the exception of the team which employs said coach and current opponent of that team.
Raise your hand if you think a significant portion of the coaches who vote in the coaches poll actually fill out their own ballots.
What we need to know is what is the most common job title among those who DO fill out those ballots?
I suspect that "social media" and/or "intern" is in the job title.
Who cares? If the coach is a good leader he leaves bull**** like that to the ones he trusts. Isn't that how you guys operate? Delegate!
|
|
| 09-09-2026 11:06 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-08-2026 12:49 PM)WTXOwl Wrote: Top Tier:
Memphis RiverCats - As the only team at 2-0, they get to stay for now. This week will either set them apart from the Conference or set the Conference quest for the playoffs back.
UTSA Meep Meep - The beat up on their mini me in UTRGV, but the Rivalry on I-35 is of utmost importance to keeping the PAC12(?) a step down the rung.
Army Cadets - Didn't repeat their FCS disaster from one year ago, and 1st in the country in rushing yards. "Those caissons go rolling along."
Navy Middies - Also had no problem with an FCS opponent, but 2nd in the country in rushing yards.
We're Green:
South Florida Greenies- Defeating a much improved International Gilded Kitty isn't great, but it isn't bad.
Tulane Greenies - The Egg Heads of Lusiana laid an egg vs. the Egg Heads of Tobacky Road.
Bama Greenies - The Blazing Lizards showed some signs of life, but is how good is Illinois?
Texas Greenies - The Not so Mean Green flew into Indiana and it went as expected for a brand new coach against a defending National Champion.
Too Soon to Panic?:
Carolina Pirates - ECU were capsized on the Crimson wave, but maybe Bama will be that good?
Too Soon to Celebrate!:
Tulsa Gold Plated Tornados - A win over an in-state power school is a big deal (according to Former President Biden), but taking down the No-Pokes with a New Coach, maybe this is the start of something or just another round of hope to be smashed. (Also, I feel like Dan Quayle: Tornadoes or Tornados?)
The Parliament:
H-Town R-Owls - Rolled over the Christians formerly known as Baptists, and 3rd in the country in rushing. Congrats the Catholics are your prize.
Philly T-Owls - Beat up on the smallest state in the Union; let freedom ring! Congrats the Naughty Lions are your prize
Atlantic F-Owls - The newest Owls on the Block were in fact Gator Bait.
D'oh:
L'Eastern Miners - So you lost to a senior military college, ok was it Texas A&M? Virginia Tech? Oh, the Citadel. Well you were on the road right?! No? D-oh. Ok looking for a green lining . . the offense did score more points than 9 American teams this week . . . oh, you needed three overtimes? I got nothing.
We get to stay for now? OMG what an honor. Thank you almighty Rice. Your support is immeasurable.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 11:25 PM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-07-2026 01:59 PM)ECUGrad07 Wrote: I think Alabama might win the whole thing this year.
Holy moly that offense is ridiculous. Matchup nightmares at every position - I don't care who they play.
Very much disagree. They are talented but I've seen ECU play a number of more talented teams.
|
|
| 09-10-2026 12:20 PM |
|
surrealpirate
GDP

Posts: 1,338
Joined: Dec 2003
Reputation: 199
I Root For: ECU
Location: The Western Front
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-10-2026 12:20 PM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (09-07-2026 01:59 PM)ECUGrad07 Wrote: I think Alabama might win the whole thing this year.
Holy moly that offense is ridiculous. Matchup nightmares at every position - I don't care who they play.
Very much disagree. They are talented but I've seen ECU play a number of more talented teams.
Alabama made plenty of mistakes that we largely didn't capitalize on. Their QB has the tools to be something special but he's still got plenty to clean up too.
|
|
| 09-10-2026 03:54 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-10-2026 03:54 PM)surrealpirate Wrote: (09-10-2026 12:20 PM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (09-07-2026 01:59 PM)ECUGrad07 Wrote: I think Alabama might win the whole thing this year.
Holy moly that offense is ridiculous. Matchup nightmares at every position - I don't care who they play.
Very much disagree. They are talented but I've seen ECU play a number of more talented teams.
Alabama made plenty of mistakes that we largely didn't capitalize on. Their QB has the tools to be something special but he's still got plenty to clean up too.
Everyone looks a little disjointed right now. The monster turnover of players every year is taking a toll I believe. I've seen very few teams look like they're in any kind of a rhythm.
|
|
| 09-10-2026 06:09 PM |
|
ultraviolet
Heisman

Posts: 7,435
Joined: Jan 2004
Reputation: 519
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-09-2026 10:46 PM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: [quote='Cubanbull1' pid='20754433' dateline='1788960290']
If Memphis beats Boise along with the UNLV win, the CFP is going to the American champ. We will have plowed the road.
Go Frednecks!
|
|
| 09-11-2026 09:26 AM |
|
AAC.TV.Talk
Bench Warmer

Posts: 117
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 66
I Root For: A-A-C! A-A-C!
Location:
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
(09-11-2026 09:08 AM)ATTALLABLAZE Wrote: I think we are going to be pretty good, but I would rank us low until we show something. We need to blow out ULM, go on the road, and beat Louisiana. If we struggle against ULM to win and drop LU, then there is concern. I want to see our big revamped lines control the LOS and our backs pound our next two opponents like hookers in Thailand.
Are you vague posting about Navy (alumni and rest-of-Navy, not football)?
|
|
| 09-12-2026 08:42 AM |
|
jvllepirate
2nd String

Posts: 254
Joined: Jan 2011
Reputation: 10
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
13A-uncc
13B-ecu
|
|
| 09-12-2026 10:04 PM |
|
Cubanbull1
Heisman

Posts: 6,595
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 672
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
USF and FAU 1-0
The other 10 are 0-0
Navy and Army 0-1
The race has just begun
|
|
| 09-13-2026 12:09 PM |
|
panicstricken
Heisman

Posts: 6,467
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 315
I Root For: Tulsa
Location: Folly Beach
|
RE: Rank The American Thread
1: UNT
13: Tulsa
14: UC
|
|
| 09-14-2026 08:45 AM |
|