The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,374
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: Embarrassing attendance at USC
(08-30-2026 04:47 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (08-30-2026 04:18 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (08-30-2026 04:09 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (08-30-2026 12:48 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-30-2026 09:14 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: My goodness. So much judgment and I wouldn’t even personally cheer for USC against almost anyone.
Here’s some judgment:
(1) Unless you live in NYC, LA is a more important global city than wherever you live. The fact that a game against San Jose State in the middle of the day in blazing heat in Week 0 doesn’t mean as much in the global entertainment capital of the world compared to some college town with nothing else going on speaks more about how much more valuable anything that breaks through in LA is compared to some place with nothing else to do.
(2) Further to that point, unless you’re a fan a school in the Ohio State/Michigan/Notre Dame/Alabama/Texas tier, it doesn’t matter whether USC draws 90,000, 50,000, or 30,000. USC is far more valuable to the college sports world than whatever school that you cheer for. Each USC fan is literally worth more than you - they’re wealthier (both in terms of alums and market overall) and live in one of the key global markets that every advertiser that sells to people with high incomes wants to reach. The fact that USC is even competitive with the Dodgers (the biggest spending MLB team with the biggest global superstar that the sport has had this generation) and Lakers (the biggest marquee brand of the NBA) is a feature as opposed to a bug! If you moved anyone other than that elite of the elite tier of brands names like UVA or NC State to LA, they would do FAR worse in drawing attention and coverage than USC.
TLDR: LA is more important than where you live, each USC fan in the marketplace is worth more than you, and outside of the top 5 brands, USC is more important than your school.
There’s some judgment!
You significantly overestimate the importance of USC and LA in the CFB ecosystem. Just look at their TV numbers in recent years. 35-18 in the past 4 years, including 9-4 last season, and Miami more than doubles their ND ratings? Heck, A&M did 50% more and we got dumped on NBC h2h against a huge LSU-Florida game (that directly followed a 12.5m SEC game no less).
If I’m the B1G, I’d rather have Miami than USC today. Or half the SEC for that matter.
Think of it this way. The Big 12 lost Texas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Nebraska, and Missouri. It lost every flagship besides small market Kansas and West Virginia. This is a league that should have been dead yet somehow didn’t die.
The Pac-12 lost USC and UCLA and it essentially unraveled instantly. It was dead (at least for power conference status) within a year despite it having bigger brand names left like Oregon and Washington along with multiple flagships with strong fan bases.
Why? Because the LA market is simply uniquely important. NBC wasn’t going to go after Big Ten rights, but then came in over the top when the league expanded because the Big Ten footprint plus LA specifically is an entirely unique value proposition. Like the SEC maxim of it just means more, the LA market is straight up *worth* more. Every person of importance in the media industry and all of the ad buyers either live in or spends a huge amount of their time in LA, so owning LA is an entirely different value proposition for them. This is true elite global cultural power beyond more insular college football interest (and why so many SEC fans have continuously underrated how much the Big Ten ends up getting paid in every media deal over the past 20 years because the Big Ten is in the elite cultural power centers of this country in a way that the SEC simply isn’t).
Even looking at the insular college football viewpoint, USC was the *single* biggest TV draw in all of college football for most of the first decade of the 2000s. More than Texas. More than Ohio State. More than Alabama. I would not conflate a relatively fallow period for USC with the inability to not reach that status again. This the long game - if you just looked at Miami’s TV ratings a couple of years ago (and I’m someone that is VERY bullish on the value of Miami), there were plenty of people that nonsensically and wrongly declared them dead for national interest purposes, too.
You’re basically looking at near the floor for USC interest today. This isn’t a school with structural fan issues or a bad recruiting area or undesirable location or poor NIL funding. They have all of the resources and simply are not executing on-the-field. Frankly, Miami was similar before. Heck, even a school like Tennessee spent a decade in that manner. That poor execution is frustrating, but USC is without question one of those handful of programs where the problem is truly hiring the right coach. That is a more direct (albeit not necessarily easy) issue to address compared to deep structural problems with recruiting or NIL funding.
Outside of getting Notre Dame, there legitimately isn’t a single expansion candidate for the Big Ten outside of trying to poach the SEC that would be worth more than USC and it’s not even close. Once again, I love Miami in terms of value, but they definitely aren’t as valuable as USC.
Where, in your opinion, does USC rank in terms of value to the Big 10? 2nd? 3rd? 4th? (1st!??) Because they were only offered a middle tier valuation in the scuttled PI deal.
If we were to have a realignment draft where if you put all of the teams in college football together and defined the order of how they would be picked, I would rank it this way:
(1) Ohio State
(2) Michigan
(3) USC
(4) Penn State
Penn State probably has better figures on a pure financial income basis with its attendance, size, generally more consistent performance prior to last year, etc., so I wouldn’t dispute anyone that would argue that PSU would have a higher current “franchise value” than USC if they were sold like a pro sports team. However, if you’re looking at who you would want to draft from a clean slate, USC simply has the higher ceiling. Like I’ve said, when USC is at their peak, they can be the biggest TV draw in all of college football and they’re drawing in super valuable and affluent LA viewers as opposed to lower value small market and rural viewers on top of it (albeit Penn State does have major markets like Philly and Pittsburgh in its footprint, so it’s not as acute of a difference compared to USC as it would be with some other schools).
It’s not a perfect analogy, but compare the value of Clemson and Miami to the ACC. Clemson has been much more reliable both performance-wise and their fan base always shows up even in down years. However, Miami at their peak likely does more for ACC viewership than any single other school. As a result, Clemson might technically have the higher “franchise value” today, but in a realignment draft, I firmly believe Miami gets taken before Clemson because the upside is on a different level.
Actually, believe it or not, when I ranked Big 10 teams a few months ago my top 4 was exactly the same as yours. But for me the difference maker was that USC had the somewhat unique late-night timeslot. PSU would have edged them otherwise.
|
|