(06-07-2026 09:36 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: (06-04-2026 03:58 PM)sigke Wrote: (06-03-2026 12:38 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: We need to stop the charade and pretending that all 10 FBS conferences are playing at the same level—the subdivision needs further subdivision
That doesn't fix anything. If you want a "third" something, have the P4 leave the NCAA & create a third governing body like the NAIA.
This problem doesn't just affect football, it affects all the other sports too. Look at the number of bids the A4 get in the Men's basketball tournament today. In the past, leagues like the A-10, Big East & CAA, each etc. received multiple bids each (with the Big East being similar to the Power schools). Today the A-10 is lucky if they get 2 bids and the CAA and many other leagues are 1 bid only. The Power 4 conferences all had at least 8 schools each, with B1G having 9 and SEC having 10.
The Big East was the conference with the 5th most, at a whopping 3 schools.
So let's not pretend this is a football only issue. Making a new subdivision doesn't solve the money problem at all.
The best way to fix things is pull media rights across ALL OF DIVISION 1 (not just the FBS), and then for the FBS - give all 10 conference champs an autobid, with remaining schools getting at large bids (based on CFP rankings closed as of last game of regular season but BEFORE conference championship games).
This would allow some schools to consider changing conferences. For example: maybe a Rutgers then moves to the MAC or CUSA for a chance at a national championship? Or maybe key players move to a CUSA or SunBelt school for a chance at a nati.
If the A4 doesn't like this, they should leave the NCAA and create their own system, just like there is the NAIA for schools with very poor athletic departments (where even NCAA D3 costs too much money), make one for the super rich athletic departments.
Brilliant solution—let’s fix the problem by stealing money from the schools who actually draw fans and viewers. That doesn’t fix diddily.
Enough with the bottom feeders. You’ve got a crap ton of D1 basketball programs that essentially rely on 3 things to fund being D1—student subsidies, buy games, and the NCAA tournament money. If they weren’t fleecing their own students and the big guys, they wouldn’t even be there. The same goes for FBS. If you can’t afford to be FBS without playing body bag games and your CFP check, you don’t belong in FBS.
I don't know what you are trying to argue. I'm saying having a 3rd football subdivision is stupid. The G6 are in the FBS because they WANT to compete with the big boys. I'm not arguing FOR the A4 to leave the NCAA. I'm really arguing that they should NOT break the FBS into two subdivisions. Some of the arguments people make regarding money for the 3rd subdivision is what doesn't make any sense.
I honestly fail to understand why some people defend the A4 making all this money compared to the rest of D1? Until recently, all that money was going to coaches. The 3 highest paid members of the US Defense Department are the 3 head football coaches for Army, Navy & Air Force. The highest employee at many of these A4 schools is the head football coach.
80-90 D1 football coaches make more than anyone else at their respective University. At USC and Clemson (for example) the head coach makes 4 times more than the University President. That's honestly ridiculous. How many companies have employees making more than the CEO?
I'm not saying revenue sharing needs to be 100% equal. I think the ACC's current model of where top TV rankings get more from the media deal makes sense. Why should Rutgers get the same media deal pay as Ohio State?
If revenue sharing existed among all 10 FBS leagues, then top TV earners can make the most. To me, it makes more sense for Army & Navy (who average far more per game than Rutgers or Maryland) get paid more than Rutgers and Maryland for media.
Creating a 3rd subdivision does nothing except say: "we're too good to play with you, so we are taking our ball and going over here"
If the playoffs go to 24 teams, I don't see why we can't have all 10 conference champs and remaining top 14 ranked teams play for a championship. With bowl games for everyone else. Who cares if the first round has a few blowouts? If you do this, even if the G6 teams always lose to the P4, you might have some very interesting games - esp if the schedule is set up so that in the first round, all 10 conference champs are playing an at large, then it could be very interesting.
Imagine a G6 champ playing a BYU or Notre Dame in the first round? And imaging the buzz if the G6 team wins that first round? I think that would be awesome.
My first round would look like this:
#1 Ranked A4 team Conference Champ vs #5 Ranked at large team
#2 Ranked A4 team Conference Champ vs #6 Ranked at large team
#3 Ranked A4 team Conference Champ vs #7 Ranked at large team
#4 Ranked A4 team Conference Champ vs #8 Ranked at large team
#1 Ranked at large team vs #4 Ranked at large team
#2 Ranked at large team vs #3 Ranked at large team
#1 Ranked G6 team Conference Champ vs #9 Ranked at large team
#2 Ranked G6 team Conference Champ vs #10 Ranked at large team
#3 Ranked G6 team Conference Champ vs #11 Ranked at large team
#4 Ranked G6 team Conference Champ vs #12 Ranked at large team
#5 Ranked G6 team Conference Champ vs #13 Ranked at large team
#6 Ranked G6 team Conference Champ vs #14 Ranked at large team
Anyway - I'm not asking for the A4 to leave the NCAA. I'm saying breaking the FBS doesn't solve anything.