Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Thread Closed 
Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Author Message
FAU Connoisseur! Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,735
Joined: May 2019
Reputation: 2000
I Root For: #CometotheFAU
Location:
Post: #41
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Asking for a friend...FAU has $20.6 mil of the original $44.5 million borrowed on their stadium remaining...could USF just send us 1 year of their debt service to us so we can close out our loan?
06-03-2026 09:50 AM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #42
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 08:22 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:46 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:29 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:25 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:22 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  Correct. Which would mean they would want to retain a Florida to replace FSU fortis media deal and ACC network.

but he said it expires in 6 years not 10

and who knows what will happen with conference networks or media contracts in general in 10 years

True. So all a school can do its improve its position in the pecking order.

I am not arguing that a school should not do all they can to improve....I said before I would prefer USF in The Big 12 over uH especially now that USF is in the AAU and USF is investing in facilities......it would have been better for UCF and for WVU and Cincy recruiting wise and for exposure overall and for overall recruiting and it would have removed the over representation in Texas

I was just pointing out that 10 years is a meaningful longer period of time than 6 years especially when all, but the SEC will have a chance to go to market for a media deal possibly even 2 times relative to the ACC (or really even 3 if you are looking at the Big 10 and The Big 12 though I doubt the next Big 12 deal would be only 4 years or so)

You're right the ACC contract is to 2036. I think he misspoke but the fact remains the same - 6 years from now the ACC may be a member or two or even more less than they are now.

And to CB1 - all the facts and truth in the world will not fix envy. Not even the Memphis fans buy his post. He's in a league of his own.

I am not sure the ACC will be adding any teams mid contract there are a number of issues there

1. if the SEC is taking teams then ESPN is most likely involved.....if ESPN is involved there is an issue with ESPN acting in a way that harms the ACC that is also a business partner with the ACC and ESPN will at least need to keep the ACC contract the same even with fewer teams.....I am not sure it would put ESPN into a position of wanting the ACC to add teams especially when the answer from the ACC would be "pay full shares for new members plus make sure that Cal, Stanford, and SMU become full share"......if the ACC was to make any attempts at a demand I think it would be "pay full shares for the partial share three and then pay us all more". With 17 full members plus ND the ACC can be just fine losing 3 members or even 3 members and ND....hell they could lose 5 and ND and still be a 12 team conference

2. if the Big 10 acts then ESPN might not be involved, but I am not sure the answer for ESPN even if not involved would be to add teams vs. telling the ACC they can stay with the remaining teams and keep the same overall dollar amount of the contract thus freeing money to make Cal, Stanford, and SMU full share members

3. there is an issue that has been discussed by a FSU reporter that really looked into the numbers where the ACCn payout dropping as subscriber counts drop to the point where the growth of their payouts becomes very small and in about 5 years could be less than the Big 12 and if the Big 12 gets a good deal on the next one then the ACC would be below the Big 12 for a number of years. And that was using some conservative losses of subscriber numbers as overall cable subscriptions decline

again none of this is to say that USF should not act to place themselves in the best position possible or that I think what USF is doing is a bad idea (I wish they had done it a lot sooner so they would have caught the eye of The Big 12)......but there is a lot at play in future expansion as cable numbers shrink, as the cost of adding members to some conferences becomes very very large, and as some conferences have gone to unequal payments, partial shares, and other things that would be best to resolve prior to considering new members
06-03-2026 09:59 AM
Find all posts by this user
USF_Bullsharks Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #43
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 09:59 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 08:22 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:46 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:29 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:25 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  but he said it expires in 6 years not 10

and who knows what will happen with conference networks or media contracts in general in 10 years

True. So all a school can do its improve its position in the pecking order.

I am not arguing that a school should not do all they can to improve....I said before I would prefer USF in The Big 12 over uH especially now that USF is in the AAU and USF is investing in facilities......it would have been better for UCF and for WVU and Cincy recruiting wise and for exposure overall and for overall recruiting and it would have removed the over representation in Texas

I was just pointing out that 10 years is a meaningful longer period of time than 6 years especially when all, but the SEC will have a chance to go to market for a media deal possibly even 2 times relative to the ACC (or really even 3 if you are looking at the Big 10 and The Big 12 though I doubt the next Big 12 deal would be only 4 years or so)

You're right the ACC contract is to 2036. I think he misspoke but the fact remains the same - 6 years from now the ACC may be a member or two or even more less than they are now.

And to CB1 - all the facts and truth in the world will not fix envy. Not even the Memphis fans buy his post. He's in a league of his own.

I am not sure the ACC will be adding any teams mid contract there are a number of issues there

1. if the SEC is taking teams then ESPN is most likely involved.....if ESPN is involved there is an issue with ESPN acting in a way that harms the ACC that is also a business partner with the ACC and ESPN will at least need to keep the ACC contract the same even with fewer teams.....I am not sure it would put ESPN into a position of wanting the ACC to add teams especially when the answer from the ACC would be "pay full shares for new members plus make sure that Cal, Stanford, and SMU become full share"......if the ACC was to make any attempts at a demand I think it would be "pay full shares for the partial share three and then pay us all more". With 17 full members plus ND the ACC can be just fine losing 3 members or even 3 members and ND....hell they could lose 5 and ND and still be a 12 team conference

2. if the Big 10 acts then ESPN might not be involved, but I am not sure the answer for ESPN even if not involved would be to add teams vs. telling the ACC they can stay with the remaining teams and keep the same overall dollar amount of the contract thus freeing money to make Cal, Stanford, and SMU full share members

3. there is an issue that has been discussed by a FSU reporter that really looked into the numbers where the ACCn payout dropping as subscriber counts drop to the point where the growth of their payouts becomes very small and in about 5 years could be less than the Big 12 and if the Big 12 gets a good deal on the next one then the ACC would be below the Big 12 for a number of years. And that was using some conservative losses of subscriber numbers as overall cable subscriptions decline

again none of this is to say that USF should not act to place themselves in the best position possible or that I think what USF is doing is a bad idea (I wish they had done it a lot sooner so they would have caught the eye of The Big 12)......but there is a lot at play in future expansion as cable numbers shrink, as the cost of adding members to some conferences becomes very very large, and as some conferences have gone to unequal payments, partial shares, and other things that would be best to resolve prior to considering new members

Totally agree on all 3 points, there are so many variables that none of us are thinking about or valuing properly that it's impossible to predict, the only thing certain is that we don't have an invite now and so maintaining status quo would reinforce the non-invite status, hence the investment.

To add to your points:
1. I agree there will be some tug of war going on internally at ESPN, but ultimately ESPN will do what's in its best interest and if that means moving properties to the SEC, they will do just that. It might come with an ACC sweetener, such has higher payout, more flexible terms, guaranteed tv windows, idk, but ESPN will have control over all of that and if their models point to it, they will not have any problem working out a deal to move product to the SEC.
2. I believe the ACC media agreement is for a set amount of teams, 15 (14 + ND), so dropping below that number would require the conference to add to stay at 15 unless ESPN opened the deal and allowed them to reduce inventory. More teams = more games, so the ACC has to fill it's obligations to ESPN, and that might mean invitations are required.
3. Cord cutting is definitely a factor in the valuations of these TV deals, and because the ACC's deal with ESPN is variable with ACCN success, cord cutting is front and center of their commissioner's minds (and ESPN's, who also receives revenue from the ACCN). That's why ESPN launched their own streaming platform. Really tough to pin down what # of subscribers ESPN Unlimited (which includes the ACCN) would be attributable to ACCN subscribers, as well as what profit they are able to maintain vs cable subscribers, but safe to say ESPN is maintaining and still growing the revenue side of things. How the ACCN payments will be affected, only time will tell.
06-03-2026 10:28 AM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #44
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 09:59 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 08:22 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:46 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:29 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:25 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  but he said it expires in 6 years not 10

and who knows what will happen with conference networks or media contracts in general in 10 years

True. So all a school can do its improve its position in the pecking order.

I am not arguing that a school should not do all they can to improve....I said before I would prefer USF in The Big 12 over uH especially now that USF is in the AAU and USF is investing in facilities......it would have been better for UCF and for WVU and Cincy recruiting wise and for exposure overall and for overall recruiting and it would have removed the over representation in Texas

I was just pointing out that 10 years is a meaningful longer period of time than 6 years especially when all, but the SEC will have a chance to go to market for a media deal possibly even 2 times relative to the ACC (or really even 3 if you are looking at the Big 10 and The Big 12 though I doubt the next Big 12 deal would be only 4 years or so)

You're right the ACC contract is to 2036. I think he misspoke but the fact remains the same - 6 years from now the ACC may be a member or two or even more less than they are now.

And to CB1 - all the facts and truth in the world will not fix envy. Not even the Memphis fans buy his post. He's in a league of his own.

I am not sure the ACC will be adding any teams mid contract there are a number of issues there

1. if the SEC is taking teams then ESPN is most likely involved.....if ESPN is involved there is an issue with ESPN acting in a way that harms the ACC that is also a business partner with the ACC and ESPN will at least need to keep the ACC contract the same even with fewer teams.....I am not sure it would put ESPN into a position of wanting the ACC to add teams especially when the answer from the ACC would be "pay full shares for new members plus make sure that Cal, Stanford, and SMU become full share"......if the ACC was to make any attempts at a demand I think it would be "pay full shares for the partial share three and then pay us all more". With 17 full members plus ND the ACC can be just fine losing 3 members or even 3 members and ND....hell they could lose 5 and ND and still be a 12 team conference

2. if the Big 10 acts then ESPN might not be involved, but I am not sure the answer for ESPN even if not involved would be to add teams vs. telling the ACC they can stay with the remaining teams and keep the same overall dollar amount of the contract thus freeing money to make Cal, Stanford, and SMU full share members

3. there is an issue that has been discussed by a FSU reporter that really looked into the numbers where the ACCn payout dropping as subscriber counts drop to the point where the growth of their payouts becomes very small and in about 5 years could be less than the Big 12 and if the Big 12 gets a good deal on the next one then the ACC would be below the Big 12 for a number of years. And that was using some conservative losses of subscriber numbers as overall cable subscriptions decline

again none of this is to say that USF should not act to place themselves in the best position possible or that I think what USF is doing is a bad idea (I wish they had done it a lot sooner so they would have caught the eye of The Big 12)......but there is a lot at play in future expansion as cable numbers shrink, as the cost of adding members to some conferences becomes very very large, and as some conferences have gone to unequal payments, partial shares, and other things that would be best to resolve prior to considering new members

As the poster above stated. If the ACC loses teams to BigTen or SEC, they will add schools even in mid contract, just as they did with Cal,Stanford and SMU. They must maintain a safe number so as to not take the risk of disbanding. Whoever they add won’t be coming at full value probably for the remaining of the contract, so it wouldn’t be a payment increase for ESPN. And more to protect or add to the carriage fees.

No one knows for sure what will happen,all a school can do is invest and try to make itself as attractive as possible for the next opportunity, that’s what USF is doing and I feel good are where we are and heading.
06-03-2026 11:23 AM
Find all posts by this user
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #45
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Welcome back, MSU.

MSU does bring up some good points but in all honesty, as long as things are being paid for it really doesn’t matter where the money comes from (provided that it’s legal).

USF absolutely benefits from have an enrollment of over 36K undergrads and over 10K grad students. If they are willing to finance things via student fees, more power to them.

Time will tell if things pay off for the Bulls in the long run.
06-03-2026 11:29 AM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #46
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 11:29 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  Welcome back, MSU.

MSU does bring up some good points but in all honesty, as long as things are being paid for it really doesn’t matter where the money comes from (provided that it’s legal).

USF absolutely benefits from have an enrollment of over 36K undergrads and over 10K grad students. If they are willing to finance things via student fees, more power to them.

Time will tell if things pay off for the Bulls in the long run.

Thanks Ned,

Therein lies the crux. As long as things are getting paid for...

We're talking about a financial shell game involving cooking the numbers at the last minute, increasing revenue projections by $15M+ out of thin air when the interest rate suddenly hiked, which their own State Bond Director clearly points out in his memorandum. Everything relies on a highly speculative, extreme best case scenario requiring "dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources" per J. Ben Watkins III. Revenue sources that are incredibly volatile and unreliable, including donations and ticket revenue.

It's not neutral when he calls out, "USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided" or "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated." Does, "the material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo" indicate great confidence?

You're a business owner and this is decidedly not neutral language, coming from a State administrator. Don't get me wrong, I want every program in the conference to be successful, but this is administrative malfeasance and a risky and dangerous, highly leveraged gamble at best. Any fluctuation has massive and broad implications for the University as a whole, and the blast radius won't be contained within the athletic department. That's the issue.
06-03-2026 12:06 PM
Find all posts by this user
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #47
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 12:06 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 11:29 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  Welcome back, MSU.

MSU does bring up some good points but in all honesty, as long as things are being paid for it really doesn’t matter where the money comes from (provided that it’s legal).

USF absolutely benefits from have an enrollment of over 36K undergrads and over 10K grad students. If they are willing to finance things via student fees, more power to them.

Time will tell if things pay off for the Bulls in the long run.

Thanks Ned,

Therein lies the crux. As long as things are getting paid for...

We're talking about a financial shell game involving cooking the numbers at the last minute, increasing revenue projections by $15M+ out of thin air when the interest rate suddenly hiked, which their own State Bond Director clearly points out in his memorandum. Everything relies on a highly speculative, extreme best case scenario requiring "dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources" per J. Ben Watkins III. Revenue sources that are incredibly volatile and unreliable, including donations and ticket revenue.

It's not neutral when he calls out, "USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided" or "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated." Does, "the material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo" indicate great confidence?

You're a business owner and this is decidedly not neutral language, coming from a State administrator. Don't get me wrong, I want every program in the conference to be successful, but this is administrative malfeasance and a risky and dangerous, highly leveraged gamble at best. Any fluctuation has massive and broad implications for the University as a whole, and the blast radius won't be contained within the athletic department. That's the issue.

Now you’ve got me curious. I’ll dig into things later.

Either way, I sincerely hope things work out for them (and Memphis).
06-03-2026 12:21 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #48
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 12:21 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:06 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 11:29 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  Welcome back, MSU.

MSU does bring up some good points but in all honesty, as long as things are being paid for it really doesn’t matter where the money comes from (provided that it’s legal).

USF absolutely benefits from have an enrollment of over 36K undergrads and over 10K grad students. If they are willing to finance things via student fees, more power to them.

Time will tell if things pay off for the Bulls in the long run.

Thanks Ned,

Therein lies the crux. As long as things are getting paid for...

We're talking about a financial shell game involving cooking the numbers at the last minute, increasing revenue projections by $15M+ out of thin air when the interest rate suddenly hiked, which their own State Bond Director clearly points out in his memorandum. Everything relies on a highly speculative, extreme best case scenario requiring "dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources" per J. Ben Watkins III. Revenue sources that are incredibly volatile and unreliable, including donations and ticket revenue.

It's not neutral when he calls out, "USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided" or "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated." Does, "the material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo" indicate great confidence?

You're a business owner and this is decidedly not neutral language, coming from a State administrator. Don't get me wrong, I want every program in the conference to be successful, but this is administrative malfeasance and a risky and dangerous, highly leveraged gamble at best. Any fluctuation has massive and broad implications for the University as a whole, and the blast radius won't be contained within the athletic department. That's the issue.

Now you’ve got me curious. I’ll dig into things later.

Either way, I sincerely hope things work out for them (and Memphis).

Don't take my word for it...

(06-02-2026 03:09 PM)msu35 Wrote:  https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ndum-2.pdf

STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF BOND FINANCE

MEMORANDUM

To: Board of Governors
From: J. Ben Watkins III
Date: September 5, 2023
Re: University of South Florida Stadium Project

USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided. The indicative interest rate on the Truist Loan has increased by 1.5%, from 5.5% to 7%, to account for a potential increase in the financing cost. Truist quoted an indicative rate as of August 14, 2023 of 6.68%. The actual interest rate will be set immediately prior to the loan closing based on prevailing interest rates at the time. USF also significantly increased the projected revenues expected to be generated from stadium operations based on the consultant's feasibility report. Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project. The increase in revenues is attributable primarily to ticket sales ($2.3 million), priority seating donations ($3.1 million), premium seating donations ($5.3 million), advertising ($1.0 million), and naming rights ($2.5 million). Combining the impact of the increased debt service of approximately $2.2 million per year with the increased revenues of $15.2 million results in a positive impact on the projected debt service coverage ratio for the Project.

The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources. Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates. The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo. The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment.

cc: Raymond Rodrigues, Chancellor, Board of Governors
Kevin Pichard, Director, Finance and Facilities, Board of Governors
Fell Stubbs, University Treasurer and Associate Vice President, University of South Florida
Executive Director, USF Financing Corporation

State Board of Administration | 1801 Hermitage Boulevard, Suite 200 | Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Office (850) 488-4782 | Fax (850) 413-1315 | Website: http://www.sbafla.com/bondfinance
06-03-2026 12:32 PM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #49
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 10:28 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 09:59 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 08:22 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:46 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:29 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  True. So all a school can do its improve its position in the pecking order.

I am not arguing that a school should not do all they can to improve....I said before I would prefer USF in The Big 12 over uH especially now that USF is in the AAU and USF is investing in facilities......it would have been better for UCF and for WVU and Cincy recruiting wise and for exposure overall and for overall recruiting and it would have removed the over representation in Texas

I was just pointing out that 10 years is a meaningful longer period of time than 6 years especially when all, but the SEC will have a chance to go to market for a media deal possibly even 2 times relative to the ACC (or really even 3 if you are looking at the Big 10 and The Big 12 though I doubt the next Big 12 deal would be only 4 years or so)

You're right the ACC contract is to 2036. I think he misspoke but the fact remains the same - 6 years from now the ACC may be a member or two or even more less than they are now.

And to CB1 - all the facts and truth in the world will not fix envy. Not even the Memphis fans buy his post. He's in a league of his own.

I am not sure the ACC will be adding any teams mid contract there are a number of issues there

1. if the SEC is taking teams then ESPN is most likely involved.....if ESPN is involved there is an issue with ESPN acting in a way that harms the ACC that is also a business partner with the ACC and ESPN will at least need to keep the ACC contract the same even with fewer teams.....I am not sure it would put ESPN into a position of wanting the ACC to add teams especially when the answer from the ACC would be "pay full shares for new members plus make sure that Cal, Stanford, and SMU become full share"......if the ACC was to make any attempts at a demand I think it would be "pay full shares for the partial share three and then pay us all more". With 17 full members plus ND the ACC can be just fine losing 3 members or even 3 members and ND....hell they could lose 5 and ND and still be a 12 team conference

2. if the Big 10 acts then ESPN might not be involved, but I am not sure the answer for ESPN even if not involved would be to add teams vs. telling the ACC they can stay with the remaining teams and keep the same overall dollar amount of the contract thus freeing money to make Cal, Stanford, and SMU full share members

3. there is an issue that has been discussed by a FSU reporter that really looked into the numbers where the ACCn payout dropping as subscriber counts drop to the point where the growth of their payouts becomes very small and in about 5 years could be less than the Big 12 and if the Big 12 gets a good deal on the next one then the ACC would be below the Big 12 for a number of years. And that was using some conservative losses of subscriber numbers as overall cable subscriptions decline

again none of this is to say that USF should not act to place themselves in the best position possible or that I think what USF is doing is a bad idea (I wish they had done it a lot sooner so they would have caught the eye of The Big 12)......but there is a lot at play in future expansion as cable numbers shrink, as the cost of adding members to some conferences becomes very very large, and as some conferences have gone to unequal payments, partial shares, and other things that would be best to resolve prior to considering new members

Totally agree on all 3 points, there are so many variables that none of us are thinking about or valuing properly that it's impossible to predict, the only thing certain is that we don't have an invite now and so maintaining status quo would reinforce the non-invite status, hence the investment.

To add to your points:
1. I agree there will be some tug of war going on internally at ESPN, but ultimately ESPN will do what's in its best interest and if that means moving properties to the SEC, they will do just that. It might come with an ACC sweetener, such has higher payout, more flexible terms, guaranteed tv windows, idk, but ESPN will have control over all of that and if their models point to it, they will not have any problem working out a deal to move product to the SEC.
2. I believe the ACC media agreement is for a set amount of teams, 15 (14 + ND), so dropping below that number would require the conference to add to stay at 15 unless ESPN opened the deal and allowed them to reduce inventory. More teams = more games, so the ACC has to fill it's obligations to ESPN, and that might mean invitations are required.
3. Cord cutting is definitely a factor in the valuations of these TV deals, and because the ACC's deal with ESPN is variable with ACCN success, cord cutting is front and center of their commissioner's minds (and ESPN's, who also receives revenue from the ACCN). That's why ESPN launched their own streaming platform. Really tough to pin down what # of subscribers ESPN Unlimited (which includes the ACCN) would be attributable to ACCN subscribers, as well as what profit they are able to maintain vs cable subscribers, but safe to say ESPN is maintaining and still growing the revenue side of things. How the ACCN payments will be affected, only time will tell.

the issue with losing teams to the SEC (and thus the other full ESPN P level property) is ESPN will be paying a great deal more money for teams/content they already own

so that makes it that much harder for them to offer more favorable slots to the ACC because ESPN will be taking teams from the ACC (content they own), paying a lot more for it......and thus they need to maximize the return on that higher pay by placing that content in the best slots possible along with all of the other very high priced ACC content

which means there is no room for the ACC to get better slots and in fact the ACC will probably be losing their "better slots" mostly because they teams that were most likely going to play in those slots will be leaving

if the Big 10 is taking teams I think ESPN can still tell the ACC "well hey there went the teams that used to take the best slots now the rest of you have a better chance at getting them" and again I think the best offer money wise would be "keep the contract the same with fewer teams and remember we did this for you next round of negotiations"

with streaming ESPN sucks at it and in fact sucks at it worse that bootleg streamers in Latvia or Madagascar or wherever they are located.....they suck so bad at it they should fire their entire IT staff (or the people left over from when disney took over infoseek)

and it is going to be a lot harder in the future to value what portion of content that any entity brings to a streaming service especially with contracts that were written around a single network and the subscribers to it....plus it will depend if it is a full package of all disney/espn content or if it is groups of packages of disney/espn content
as for disbanding.....I think disney will face issues of they are trying to cram everything on everyone all in one $25 a month bundle....of course their answer to that could be "well ok no ACCn and no SECn and it cost you $23 a month".....but then do the conferences accept that valuation.....the next negotiations are going to have to center on pricing as a stand alone product, pricing in a bundle, and discounts for certain bundles and what share the conference networks get for that.....then disney/espn has to try and sell all that crap to the streaming services because even if they do try and go it alone there is no chance they are going to go it alone and not try and still get in with other streaming services and all the more so since they own 100% of hulu and paid a ton of money for that

as far as needing to add members or needing to be at 15 or having concerns with not being a viable conference.....I think at this point ESPN would just assume they lose some members some how some way because ESPN is full to the gills with "content" and does not have room for all of it as it is....I am not sure they want to see the best teams go to the Big 10 nor do they necessarily want to may more just to move them to the SEC, but I think if you could hear them talk they would wish a couple of programs would just "drop athletics" and go away or drop football anc concentrate on other things

and Cal, Stanford, and SMU were not added for any fear of being a viable conference they were added because they were willing to take very little money for a long period of time which the other teams could use to make Clemson and FSU happy for a short period of time

with the need for making FSU and Clemson gone the other teams just need to worry about how to try and make Cal, Stanford, and SMU whole and MAYBE get a little more money each and I think that adding partial share members would be a last resort and probably something that ESPN would not really even be interested in unless they can find a way that the numbers make sense for ESPN

I think ESPN and the ACC would both be happier with "keep the money the same for fewer members and lets talk again at the end of the contract"
06-03-2026 05:07 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #50
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 05:07 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 10:28 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 09:59 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 08:22 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 04:46 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  I am not arguing that a school should not do all they can to improve....I said before I would prefer USF in The Big 12 over uH especially now that USF is in the AAU and USF is investing in facilities......it would have been better for UCF and for WVU and Cincy recruiting wise and for exposure overall and for overall recruiting and it would have removed the over representation in Texas

I was just pointing out that 10 years is a meaningful longer period of time than 6 years especially when all, but the SEC will have a chance to go to market for a media deal possibly even 2 times relative to the ACC (or really even 3 if you are looking at the Big 10 and The Big 12 though I doubt the next Big 12 deal would be only 4 years or so)

You're right the ACC contract is to 2036. I think he misspoke but the fact remains the same - 6 years from now the ACC may be a member or two or even more less than they are now.

And to CB1 - all the facts and truth in the world will not fix envy. Not even the Memphis fans buy his post. He's in a league of his own.

I am not sure the ACC will be adding any teams mid contract there are a number of issues there

1. if the SEC is taking teams then ESPN is most likely involved.....if ESPN is involved there is an issue with ESPN acting in a way that harms the ACC that is also a business partner with the ACC and ESPN will at least need to keep the ACC contract the same even with fewer teams.....I am not sure it would put ESPN into a position of wanting the ACC to add teams especially when the answer from the ACC would be "pay full shares for new members plus make sure that Cal, Stanford, and SMU become full share"......if the ACC was to make any attempts at a demand I think it would be "pay full shares for the partial share three and then pay us all more". With 17 full members plus ND the ACC can be just fine losing 3 members or even 3 members and ND....hell they could lose 5 and ND and still be a 12 team conference

2. if the Big 10 acts then ESPN might not be involved, but I am not sure the answer for ESPN even if not involved would be to add teams vs. telling the ACC they can stay with the remaining teams and keep the same overall dollar amount of the contract thus freeing money to make Cal, Stanford, and SMU full share members

3. there is an issue that has been discussed by a FSU reporter that really looked into the numbers where the ACCn payout dropping as subscriber counts drop to the point where the growth of their payouts becomes very small and in about 5 years could be less than the Big 12 and if the Big 12 gets a good deal on the next one then the ACC would be below the Big 12 for a number of years. And that was using some conservative losses of subscriber numbers as overall cable subscriptions decline

again none of this is to say that USF should not act to place themselves in the best position possible or that I think what USF is doing is a bad idea (I wish they had done it a lot sooner so they would have caught the eye of The Big 12)......but there is a lot at play in future expansion as cable numbers shrink, as the cost of adding members to some conferences becomes very very large, and as some conferences have gone to unequal payments, partial shares, and other things that would be best to resolve prior to considering new members

Totally agree on all 3 points, there are so many variables that none of us are thinking about or valuing properly that it's impossible to predict, the only thing certain is that we don't have an invite now and so maintaining status quo would reinforce the non-invite status, hence the investment.

To add to your points:
1. I agree there will be some tug of war going on internally at ESPN, but ultimately ESPN will do what's in its best interest and if that means moving properties to the SEC, they will do just that. It might come with an ACC sweetener, such has higher payout, more flexible terms, guaranteed tv windows, idk, but ESPN will have control over all of that and if their models point to it, they will not have any problem working out a deal to move product to the SEC.
2. I believe the ACC media agreement is for a set amount of teams, 15 (14 + ND), so dropping below that number would require the conference to add to stay at 15 unless ESPN opened the deal and allowed them to reduce inventory. More teams = more games, so the ACC has to fill it's obligations to ESPN, and that might mean invitations are required.
3. Cord cutting is definitely a factor in the valuations of these TV deals, and because the ACC's deal with ESPN is variable with ACCN success, cord cutting is front and center of their commissioner's minds (and ESPN's, who also receives revenue from the ACCN). That's why ESPN launched their own streaming platform. Really tough to pin down what # of subscribers ESPN Unlimited (which includes the ACCN) would be attributable to ACCN subscribers, as well as what profit they are able to maintain vs cable subscribers, but safe to say ESPN is maintaining and still growing the revenue side of things. How the ACCN payments will be affected, only time will tell.

the issue with losing teams to the SEC (and thus the other full ESPN P level property) is ESPN will be paying a great deal more money for teams/content they already own

so that makes it that much harder for them to offer more favorable slots to the ACC because ESPN will be taking teams from the ACC (content they own), paying a lot more for it......and thus they need to maximize the return on that higher pay by placing that content in the best slots possible along with all of the other very high priced ACC content

which means there is no room for the ACC to get better slots and in fact the ACC will probably be losing their "better slots" mostly because they teams that were most likely going to play in those slots will be leaving

if the Big 10 is taking teams I think ESPN can still tell the ACC "well hey there went the teams that used to take the best slots now the rest of you have a better chance at getting them" and again I think the best offer money wise would be "keep the contract the same with fewer teams and remember we did this for you next round of negotiations"

with streaming ESPN sucks at it and in fact sucks at it worse that bootleg streamers in Latvia or Madagascar or wherever they are located.....they suck so bad at it they should fire their entire IT staff (or the people left over from when disney took over infoseek)

and it is going to be a lot harder in the future to value what portion of content that any entity brings to a streaming service especially with contracts that were written around a single network and the subscribers to it....plus it will depend if it is a full package of all disney/espn content or if it is groups of packages of disney/espn content
as for disbanding.....I think disney will face issues of they are trying to cram everything on everyone all in one $25 a month bundle....of course their answer to that could be "well ok no ACCn and no SECn and it cost you $23 a month".....but then do the conferences accept that valuation.....the next negotiations are going to have to center on pricing as a stand alone product, pricing in a bundle, and discounts for certain bundles and what share the conference networks get for that.....then disney/espn has to try and sell all that crap to the streaming services because even if they do try and go it alone there is no chance they are going to go it alone and not try and still get in with other streaming services and all the more so since they own 100% of hulu and paid a ton of money for that

as far as needing to add members or needing to be at 15 or having concerns with not being a viable conference.....I think at this point ESPN would just assume they lose some members some how some way because ESPN is full to the gills with "content" and does not have room for all of it as it is....I am not sure they want to see the best teams go to the Big 10 nor do they necessarily want to may more just to move them to the SEC, but I think if you could hear them talk they would wish a couple of programs would just "drop athletics" and go away or drop football anc concentrate on other things

and Cal, Stanford, and SMU were not added for any fear of being a viable conference they were added because they were willing to take very little money for a long period of time which the other teams could use to make Clemson and FSU happy for a short period of time

with the need for making FSU and Clemson gone the other teams just need to worry about how to try and make Cal, Stanford, and SMU whole and MAYBE get a little more money each and I think that adding partial share members would be a last resort and probably something that ESPN would not really even be interested in unless they can find a way that the numbers make sense for ESPN

I think ESPN and the ACC would both be happier with "keep the money the same for fewer members and lets talk again at the end of the contract"

Might agree with you with the ACC staying as put and keeping money. But the reality that they also added the Cal/Stanford to make sure they would have numbers still available to continue should they had lost teams to the P2 has been collaborated before.

As I keep saying all our schools could do is try to end in best spot possible, whether in a depleted ACC or elsewhere.
06-03-2026 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user
ultraviolet Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,424
Joined: Jan 2004
Reputation: 516
I Root For: ECU
Location:
Post: #51
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
I have a hard time believing FSU is really as desirable to a P2 conference as many claim. Same for Clemson. UNC and UVa are far more valuable to a B10 or SEC.
06-03-2026 06:03 PM
Find all posts by this user
ghostofclt! Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 13,828
Joined: Oct 2018
Reputation: 8226
I Root For: Charlotte
Location: n/a
Post: #52
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
clt wouldn't bet on the acc being around too much longer. they aren't even paying rent for their offices in Charlotte
06-03-2026 07:03 PM
Find all posts by this user
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #53
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 08:55 AM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 08:42 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 11:51 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-02-2026 08:30 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  USF is an AAU institution. They fit the profile of the ACC, if a spot were to open up. That is the most obvious and important metric for an athletic department.

Maybe USF is waisting money, but they don’t seem to mind. I know I’m not concerned about their ability to field competitive teams next season.

First, AAU membership has little to do with clearing the initial bar. This will be predicated on corporate sponsorship support, real-world television metrics, overall financial health, and successful, desirable athletic programs. Once that hurdle is cleared, AAU affiliation absolutely can and oftentimes does help as a final filter, but it's certainly not the sole determining factor.

Regarding wasting money, I believe you're missing the point entirely. Let me explain using different terms. Think of USF's athletic department as the equivalent of someone (the athletic department) living at home with their parents (the university), taking out loans to finance a Corvette (the stadium) that they can't really afford. They're spending all of their money just to pay the note, so they have to pay for the fuel and insurance (operating budget) with their parents' credit card, promising to pay them back. Meanwhile, the insurance and fuel expenses are so high, the parents are having to tighten their belts too, impacting the entire household. Their only hope of getting out of this mess is resting on the small chance that their next scratch off card wins them a massive lottery payday (P4 invite).

Even if they do eventually get that lottery win, P4 revenue isn't a panacea. If it were, Iowa State and Cal wouldn't be in their current predicaments. Ever notice that even millionaires file for bankruptcy every day? The concept is very simple. Spend more than you make, and you're probably going broke. Hope that clarifies.

I agree location and market are important (in that argument, I’d take Tampa over Memphis). But, AAU status is still probably at the top of the ACC’s list. Remember, the B1G took Rutgers. They were certainly not the best athletic program available at the time.

Rutgers was a media market play. Yes, they needed to meet the B1G's academic standard, but the real value Rutgers brought was NYC.

lol Rutgers brings NYC…it’s not a college football city at all and Rutgers isn’t even in top 5 of the few that follow the sport up there.
06-03-2026 07:52 PM
Find all posts by this user
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #54
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 12:32 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:21 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:06 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 11:29 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  Welcome back, MSU.

MSU does bring up some good points but in all honesty, as long as things are being paid for it really doesn’t matter where the money comes from (provided that it’s legal).

USF absolutely benefits from have an enrollment of over 36K undergrads and over 10K grad students. If they are willing to finance things via student fees, more power to them.

Time will tell if things pay off for the Bulls in the long run.

Thanks Ned,

Therein lies the crux. As long as things are getting paid for...

We're talking about a financial shell game involving cooking the numbers at the last minute, increasing revenue projections by $15M+ out of thin air when the interest rate suddenly hiked, which their own State Bond Director clearly points out in his memorandum. Everything relies on a highly speculative, extreme best case scenario requiring "dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources" per J. Ben Watkins III. Revenue sources that are incredibly volatile and unreliable, including donations and ticket revenue.

It's not neutral when he calls out, "USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided" or "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated." Does, "the material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo" indicate great confidence?

You're a business owner and this is decidedly not neutral language, coming from a State administrator. Don't get me wrong, I want every program in the conference to be successful, but this is administrative malfeasance and a risky and dangerous, highly leveraged gamble at best. Any fluctuation has massive and broad implications for the University as a whole, and the blast radius won't be contained within the athletic department. That's the issue.

Now you’ve got me curious. I’ll dig into things later.

Either way, I sincerely hope things work out for them (and Memphis).

Don't take my word for it...

(06-02-2026 03:09 PM)msu35 Wrote:  https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ndum-2.pdf

STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF BOND FINANCE

MEMORANDUM

To: Board of Governors
From: J. Ben Watkins III
Date: September 5, 2023
Re: University of South Florida Stadium Project

USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided. The indicative interest rate on the Truist Loan has increased by 1.5%, from 5.5% to 7%, to account for a potential increase in the financing cost. Truist quoted an indicative rate as of August 14, 2023 of 6.68%. The actual interest rate will be set immediately prior to the loan closing based on prevailing interest rates at the time. USF also significantly increased the projected revenues expected to be generated from stadium operations based on the consultant's feasibility report. Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project. The increase in revenues is attributable primarily to ticket sales ($2.3 million), priority seating donations ($3.1 million), premium seating donations ($5.3 million), advertising ($1.0 million), and naming rights ($2.5 million). Combining the impact of the increased debt service of approximately $2.2 million per year with the increased revenues of $15.2 million results in a positive impact on the projected debt service coverage ratio for the Project.

The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources. Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates. The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo. The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment.

cc: Raymond Rodrigues, Chancellor, Board of Governors
Kevin Pichard, Director, Finance and Facilities, Board of Governors
Fell Stubbs, University Treasurer and Associate Vice President, University of South Florida
Executive Director, USF Financing Corporation

State Board of Administration | 1801 Hermitage Boulevard, Suite 200 | Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Office (850) 488-4782 | Fax (850) 413-1315 | Website: http://www.sbafla.com/bondfinance

So this is saying USF is paying for the stadium with their endowment money?
06-03-2026 08:01 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #55
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 08:01 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:32 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:21 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:06 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 11:29 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  Welcome back, MSU.

MSU does bring up some good points but in all honesty, as long as things are being paid for it really doesn’t matter where the money comes from (provided that it’s legal).

USF absolutely benefits from have an enrollment of over 36K undergrads and over 10K grad students. If they are willing to finance things via student fees, more power to them.

Time will tell if things pay off for the Bulls in the long run.

Thanks Ned,

Therein lies the crux. As long as things are getting paid for...

We're talking about a financial shell game involving cooking the numbers at the last minute, increasing revenue projections by $15M+ out of thin air when the interest rate suddenly hiked, which their own State Bond Director clearly points out in his memorandum. Everything relies on a highly speculative, extreme best case scenario requiring "dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources" per J. Ben Watkins III. Revenue sources that are incredibly volatile and unreliable, including donations and ticket revenue.

It's not neutral when he calls out, "USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided" or "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated." Does, "the material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo" indicate great confidence?

You're a business owner and this is decidedly not neutral language, coming from a State administrator. Don't get me wrong, I want every program in the conference to be successful, but this is administrative malfeasance and a risky and dangerous, highly leveraged gamble at best. Any fluctuation has massive and broad implications for the University as a whole, and the blast radius won't be contained within the athletic department. That's the issue.

Now you’ve got me curious. I’ll dig into things later.

Either way, I sincerely hope things work out for them (and Memphis).

Don't take my word for it...

(06-02-2026 03:09 PM)msu35 Wrote:  https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ndum-2.pdf

STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF BOND FINANCE

MEMORANDUM

To: Board of Governors
From: J. Ben Watkins III
Date: September 5, 2023
Re: University of South Florida Stadium Project

USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided. The indicative interest rate on the Truist Loan has increased by 1.5%, from 5.5% to 7%, to account for a potential increase in the financing cost. Truist quoted an indicative rate as of August 14, 2023 of 6.68%. The actual interest rate will be set immediately prior to the loan closing based on prevailing interest rates at the time. USF also significantly increased the projected revenues expected to be generated from stadium operations based on the consultant's feasibility report. Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project. The increase in revenues is attributable primarily to ticket sales ($2.3 million), priority seating donations ($3.1 million), premium seating donations ($5.3 million), advertising ($1.0 million), and naming rights ($2.5 million). Combining the impact of the increased debt service of approximately $2.2 million per year with the increased revenues of $15.2 million results in a positive impact on the projected debt service coverage ratio for the Project.

The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources. Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates. The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo. The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment.

cc: Raymond Rodrigues, Chancellor, Board of Governors
Kevin Pichard, Director, Finance and Facilities, Board of Governors
Fell Stubbs, University Treasurer and Associate Vice President, University of South Florida
Executive Director, USF Financing Corporation

State Board of Administration | 1801 Hermitage Boulevard, Suite 200 | Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Office (850) 488-4782 | Fax (850) 413-1315 | Website: http://www.sbafla.com/bondfinance

So this is saying USF is paying for the stadium with their endowment money?

Not true.
06-03-2026 08:07 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #56
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 08:07 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 08:01 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:32 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:21 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 12:06 PM)msu35 Wrote:  Thanks Ned,

Therein lies the crux. As long as things are getting paid for...

We're talking about a financial shell game involving cooking the numbers at the last minute, increasing revenue projections by $15M+ out of thin air when the interest rate suddenly hiked, which their own State Bond Director clearly points out in his memorandum. Everything relies on a highly speculative, extreme best case scenario requiring "dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources" per J. Ben Watkins III. Revenue sources that are incredibly volatile and unreliable, including donations and ticket revenue.

It's not neutral when he calls out, "USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided" or "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated." Does, "the material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo" indicate great confidence?

You're a business owner and this is decidedly not neutral language, coming from a State administrator. Don't get me wrong, I want every program in the conference to be successful, but this is administrative malfeasance and a risky and dangerous, highly leveraged gamble at best. Any fluctuation has massive and broad implications for the University as a whole, and the blast radius won't be contained within the athletic department. That's the issue.

Now you’ve got me curious. I’ll dig into things later.

Either way, I sincerely hope things work out for them (and Memphis).

Don't take my word for it...

(06-02-2026 03:09 PM)msu35 Wrote:  https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ndum-2.pdf

STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF BOND FINANCE

MEMORANDUM

To: Board of Governors
From: J. Ben Watkins III
Date: September 5, 2023
Re: University of South Florida Stadium Project

USF has submitted revised projections that are materially different than originally provided. The indicative interest rate on the Truist Loan has increased by 1.5%, from 5.5% to 7%, to account for a potential increase in the financing cost. Truist quoted an indicative rate as of August 14, 2023 of 6.68%. The actual interest rate will be set immediately prior to the loan closing based on prevailing interest rates at the time. USF also significantly increased the projected revenues expected to be generated from stadium operations based on the consultant's feasibility report. Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project. The increase in revenues is attributable primarily to ticket sales ($2.3 million), priority seating donations ($3.1 million), premium seating donations ($5.3 million), advertising ($1.0 million), and naming rights ($2.5 million). Combining the impact of the increased debt service of approximately $2.2 million per year with the increased revenues of $15.2 million results in a positive impact on the projected debt service coverage ratio for the Project.

The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources. Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates. The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts outlined in the initial memo. The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment.

cc: Raymond Rodrigues, Chancellor, Board of Governors
Kevin Pichard, Director, Finance and Facilities, Board of Governors
Fell Stubbs, University Treasurer and Associate Vice President, University of South Florida
Executive Director, USF Financing Corporation

State Board of Administration | 1801 Hermitage Boulevard, Suite 200 | Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Office (850) 488-4782 | Fax (850) 413-1315 | Website: http://www.sbafla.com/bondfinance

So this is saying USF is paying for the stadium with their endowment money?

Not true.

This is the absolute pinnacle of message board cope smoking. The official link to the actual PDF is staring you directly in the face. Hmmm...is the director right or a random, highly confused USF fan on a message board right?

It's not by accident that J. Ben Watkins III, the Director of the State of Florida Division of Bond Finance, chose those very specific words. Clearly you're in total denial. The state literally caught USF cooking the books in real-time to force the stadium approval through, and Mr. Watkins made it public record that he identified the discrepancies. To put it into perspective, this is the equivalent of someone getting turned down for a mortgage because the interest rates changed and the payments were too high, so they resubmit their application with a sudden and mysterious 300% income bump out of thin air by fabricating some side hustle based on hypothetical earnings.

The objective reality:
  • $15.2M Shell Game: The second the bank interest rate hiked from 5.5% to 7% (adding $2.2 million a year in pure debt service), USF magically "found" $15.2 million in brand-new annual stadium revenue out of nowhere. USF literally typed a higher number into the spreadsheet to make the debt coverage ratio look legal.
  • "Eliminated Conservatism": Do you understand what that even means? The state director wrote that whatever financial safety net or conservatism that USF claimed to have was totally eliminated. The entire project is now wholly dependent on highly speculative, best-case-scenario revenue goals to even cover the "note."
  • Target on the Endowment: The director explicitly warned that because the debt is secured by gross athletic revenues, any failure to meet these incredibly hyper-aggressive revenue estimates will "necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

This is actually happening right now. Because USF is over-leveraged on this stadium gamble, their direct athletic contributions actually decreased by 18.11% in FY25. To keep the entire athletic department from sinking under the weight of this crushing debt, the USF Board of Trustees literally had to approve a $22.5 million internal university loan funded by the university's investment gains just to bail out athletics. They are unambiguously doing exactly what the state warned they would have to do: raid the university coffers to bail out athletics.

By claiming it's "not true" that the endowment is at risk, you are literally calling the State of Florida's chief bond administrator a liar to protect your own feelings, and ignoring cold, objective reality.

Keep struggling at checkers. Receipts:

USF BOT's finance committee makes way for millions for Athletics expenditures for the next fiscal year
Quote:The BOT approved an internal loan of up to $22.5 million and a $16 million increase in student-athlete revenue sharing payments for the 2026-27 fiscal year.

USF revises NCAA report after 'overlooked' opt-in error, posts $2.3 million operating net income
Quote:On the other hand, contributions - including donations from individuals, companies, associations and more - decreased by 18.11%.
06-03-2026 09:19 PM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #57
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment
06-03-2026 10:36 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #58
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment

Correct. Nothing is being taken from the endowment.

USF was not getting much revenue from playing at RJS
No money from concessions nor parking
No money from suites at RJS
No money from advertising at the stadium
They were being charged a fee for tickets sold

All the above will now be available as extra revenue in new stadium and we are not even accounting naming rights for the stadium.

In addition to this, you will also bring in later the Fletcher District which will also bring extra revenue and more events to the stadium.

Already the University is close to finalizing deal with the Tampa Bay Authority to help bring events and run events there.

I know for some of the haters on this board, trying to bash others when they are moving forward it’s a way to hide their insecurities.

USF will continue moving forward and hopefully some of posters on this board will get a chance to go to a game at our new stadium.
(This post was last modified: 06-03-2026 11:01 PM by Cubanbull1.)
06-03-2026 11:01 PM
Find all posts by this user
owl at the moon Offline
Eastern Screech Owl
*

Posts: 21,692
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3099
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
Post: #59
Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Did you say “naming rights”?

Imma start a gofundme.

Let’s all chip in to call it msu35 stajium
06-03-2026 11:09 PM
Find all posts by this user
owl at the moon Offline
Eastern Screech Owl
*

Posts: 21,692
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3099
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
Post: #60
Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Side note on the ACC, Todge alluded to this but when Cal, Stanford, and SMU joined up the ACC was able to exercise their pro rata clause to increase their total media deal by 17/14ths. That $$ of course does not distribute directly to the new schools who of course are on partial (or less) deals. It helps fund the performance payouts that kept fsu Clemson & co. appeased for now with the cash flow sitiation.

The ESPN deal still allows the ACC one more pro rata addition. So the ACC doesn’t even need to lose anyone to consider adding one more attractive up-and-comer from THE AMERICAN or the Big12 or any of the other g8 that look interesting. Bring USF (or Memphis, or Marshall) in on an smu deal, and espn will contractually up the ante in the fsu performance fund.

Won’t hold my breath on this scenario as I’m sure a bit of eyebrow raising already happened on the last +3 especially the ponies, so I really don’t think ACC adds an 18th (unless one of us make say back to back CFP runs including winning at least one playoff game)

And that one of us happened to also be AAU, and have a nice new stajium or major upgrades in works.

USF, Tulane, Rice, Buffalo is your short list.
Kansas would politely take the phone calls, but of course they’re not headed over.
06-03-2026 11:24 PM
Find all posts by this user
Thread Closed 




User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.