(05-05-2026 07:46 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Of course if CUSA Waits three to four years another good candidate may develop.
This is where "waiting" creates a new wrinkle.
Everyone -- EVERYONE -- is expecting the P4 to do something in the next few years to set themselves apart. The AFCA's recommendations this week will only hasten that. (I don't think too many people are naive enough to believe the G6 will be included in an expanded playoff, except as possible at-large bids.)
Meanwhile, the ACC is still counting down the days on its current media deal. Here's what we know about that:
- ESPN picked up the option to continue the current media deal until 2036. It was previously set to expire next year, in 2027.
- As part of the settlement, Clemson and FSU obtained performance-based concessions which will drive more revenue to teams which drive more viewership. But the ACC still lags FAR behind the other P4s in revenue.
- Another concession in favor of Clemson and FSU was a steep reduction in GoR penalties if they leave the ACC after 2031.
- This means the next Realignment Apocalypse is likely no more than five years away, not ten.
Meanwhile, here's when everyone else's media deals expire:
- CUSA - 2027
- MAC - 2027
- Big Ten - 2030
- SBC - 2031
- MWC - 2031 and 2032 (separate deals with multiple partners)
- PAC - 2031
- Big XII - 2031
- AAC - 2032
- SEC - 2034
So what does this tell us?
CUSA
could add Tarleton and another school to get to 12 heading into media negotiations. But are ANY of the available prospects that valuable to ESPN, FOX, CBS, or anyone else?
CUSA
could sign a long-term deal including another big GoR penalty to secure our membership well past 2032. But this could put us in a bad position (think ACC) once everyone else's deals are renegotiated.
...OR...
CUSA could negotiate a more short-term deal, involving only the ten current members, which takes us to 2031.
Such a deal would expire in the middle of the Realignment Apocalypse.
While it's a gamble, it could work in our benefit. As the world of FBS heaves and trembles from the force of all the tectonic shifting, we'll get a very clear idea of who the haves and have-nots are, and what we should realistically expect from any media deal, given our strength and ratings history.
And we'll know by then if expansion must include only FCS members or if we suddenly find ourselves in position to poach from the FBS. (Right now, that's not terribly realistic. But the 2031 landscape could look very different.)
The key question is, although adding numbers for "padding" may appear to be the "safe" thing to do, if crazy things happen and conferences above us begin poaching, would the addition of Tarleton or SFA or SDSU or ISU be enough to stop any of that from affecting CUSA?
I believe the answer is no.
So rather than add now, unless Tarleton et al are just so incredibly valuable to the networks that they force our hand, I believe we'll stand pat at 10 until 2031.
Our next media deal (2027) will be designed only to get us to that point.
Sometimes it pays to be reactive rather than proactive. This is one of those times.