Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
Author Message
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #41
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved
02-16-2026 03:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #42
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 03:44 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved

When we moved up to FBS we had an FCS national championship in recent memory (1998), and had just spent most of the decade+ after that making the playoffs and winning games, including making it to another national championship game (against the App State team that upset Michigan earlier in the season). Don Brown's first stint was the winningest 5 years in program history, and it didn't include winning the championship (his team lost it).

The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while. How to properly make the transition was done about as poorly as it possibly could have gone. Even keeping Don Brown those last two years of FCS would have set us up better for FBS success in the MAC. He left specifically because he was told the team wouldn't be going FBS (according to a family member of his that I know), and then 2 years later after a horrible coach ruined the team and the depth, they made the decision to go.
02-16-2026 04:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #43
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 04:05 PM)e-parade Wrote:  When we moved up to FBS we had an FCS national championship in recent memory (1998), and had just spent most of the decade+ after that making the playoffs and winning games, including making it to another national championship game (against the App State team that upset Michigan earlier in the season). Don Brown's first stint was the winningest 5 years in program history, and it didn't include winning the championship (his team lost it).

The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while. How to properly make the transition was done about as poorly as it possibly could have gone. Even keeping Don Brown those last two years of FCS would have set us up better for FBS success in the MAC. He left specifically because he was told the team wouldn't be going FBS (according to a family member of his that I know), and then 2 years later after a horrible coach ruined the team and the depth, they made the decision to go.


So your football program got hot after your basketball program went down?

I agree that its tough for any non Power school to have both hot at the same time
02-16-2026 04:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #44
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 03:44 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved

The argument you are trying to make drop down FB to support BB is so much easier to make when the BB is good.

Ball State hasn't had a good enough BB program I think to make that calculation. Akron is the best example the MAC has and with declining enrollment has to make some decisions.
02-16-2026 04:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #45
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 04:52 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:44 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved

The argument you are trying to make drop down FB to support BB is so much easier to make when the BB is good.

Ball State hasn't had a good enough BB program I think to make that calculation. Akron is the best example the MAC has and with declining enrollment has to make some decisions.

I have said over and over again, dropping down to FCS doesn't help matters

Minimal expense reduction for massive revenue reduction - on top of the conference affiliation issue
02-16-2026 05:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #46
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 05:00 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:52 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:44 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved

The argument you are trying to make drop down FB to support BB is so much easier to make when the BB is good.

Ball State hasn't had a good enough BB program I think to make that calculation. Akron is the best example the MAC has and with declining enrollment has to make some decisions.

I have said over and over again, dropping down to FCS doesn't help matters

Minimal expense reduction for massive revenue reduction - on top of the conference affiliation issue

Conference affliation issue isn't a problem for everyone in the MAC.

Most of the NIL in a FB conference has to be directed to FB so if you don't have FB you can spend in BB.

Yes a you will lose revenues/donations by not having FB so the BB must be really good to make it worthwhile.
02-16-2026 05:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #47
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 04:18 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:05 PM)e-parade Wrote:  When we moved up to FBS we had an FCS national championship in recent memory (1998), and had just spent most of the decade+ after that making the playoffs and winning games, including making it to another national championship game (against the App State team that upset Michigan earlier in the season). Don Brown's first stint was the winningest 5 years in program history, and it didn't include winning the championship (his team lost it).

The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while. How to properly make the transition was done about as poorly as it possibly could have gone. Even keeping Don Brown those last two years of FCS would have set us up better for FBS success in the MAC. He left specifically because he was told the team wouldn't be going FBS (according to a family member of his that I know), and then 2 years later after a horrible coach ruined the team and the depth, they made the decision to go.


So your football program got hot after your basketball program went down?

I agree that its tough for any non Power school to have both hot at the same time

Yup, that's unfortunately how the timing worked out. Just so happened that the football started to get hot shortly after Cal left.
02-16-2026 05:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
chargeradio Offline
Jesus is Lord
*

Posts: 8,783
Joined: Mar 2007
Reputation: 243
I Root For: Alabama
Location:
Post: #48
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 11:40 AM)Cyniclone Wrote:  If enough schools were to show interest in moving down, could the MAC stand up an FCS football conference while maintaining the FBS conference for all sports? Here, the MAC would remain intact as an FBS conference, but some members like Akron and Kent State could be MAC FCS members while belonging to MAC FBS league in all other sports.
That would require a minimum of 14 members between both levels of football, and the football-only members like Sacramento State wouldn't count towards the minimum eight required for FBS.

Even if there were such an interest among MAC members, FCS makes ZERO financial sense unless if you are going the Pioneer League route - and that really only works for private schools who charge much higher tuition. FCS has most of the expenses of FBS but a smaller fraction of the revenue.

FCS is going to die. The only question is when.
02-16-2026 06:08 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #49
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 06:08 PM)chargeradio Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 11:40 AM)Cyniclone Wrote:  If enough schools were to show interest in moving down, could the MAC stand up an FCS football conference while maintaining the FBS conference for all sports? Here, the MAC would remain intact as an FBS conference, but some members like Akron and Kent State could be MAC FCS members while belonging to MAC FBS league in all other sports.
That would require a minimum of 14 members between both levels of football, and the football-only members like Sacramento State wouldn't count towards the minimum eight required for FBS.

Even if there were such an interest among MAC members, FCS makes ZERO financial sense unless if you are going the Pioneer League route - and that really only works for private schools who charge much higher tuition. FCS has most of the expenses of FBS but a smaller fraction of the revenue.

FCS is going to die. The only question is when.

I'm not sure how FCS makes zero sense when it allows a program to direct the majority of its NIL toward BB.

That said FB is the bulk of the money for the typical mid major but if FB just isn't working out FCS is a potential effort to redirect resources but still field a FB program.
02-16-2026 06:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,889
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #50
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 01:24 PM)ZooMass84 Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 01:07 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 12:37 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 11:56 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  You can't bank on that. And I would bet $1 that without looking, you don't know who won the Horizon League last year.

If you can't make the economics of exposure work with Tuesday/Wednesday Night MACtion on ESPN, you're not going to make it work with half-empty arenas on ESPN-U

LOL I'm in NC so I'm not exactly in the Horizon leagues target region, but youre right I dont know without looking. Honest to goodness without looking I would guess Oakland....They have done well in the Horizon over the past few years and would be my final answer if this were a Who Wants to be a Millionaire

I think schools like Gonzaga and Big East/A10 schools would disagree with your assessment that if you cannot make FBS/FCS football work, you can't do well in basketball and make that a money maker. You can look at schools like Charlotte and ODU that use to be incredibly strong in basketball prior to adding football. Football diverted their already limited resources and their basketball programs suffered.

I don't think Gonzaga or Dayton or Saint Louis are relevant comparisons for the MAC basketball programs if they're dropping football and "putting resources into basketball". Loyola-Chicago is the unrealistic ceiling, Cleveland State is a much more realistic ceiling (4 20 win seasons in a row before this year). (But guess what? You can win 20 games a season in the MAC if you put resources into basketball.)


Quote:
Quote:Even things like increased home attendance and season ticket base from the move could be used to justify and even exceed that $3 savings gap

LOL no. Let's say you sell another 500 season tickets (which you won't) at $250 each. That's $75000.

OR you could just cut your next head coach's salary or the NIL budget by $100,000.

Quote:I mean if cost savings is the absolute primary concern than yes you are absolutely right. You are guaranteed to save money if you don't try. But most of these schools have made a decision to be D1 because they want to try.

Then they're not dropping down from FBS football.

Quote: And I believe that most struggling football schools would see a greater ROI on their athletic dollars by emphasizing another sport, basketball being the most obvious and highest profile.

That would support cutting a half-million dollars from the football budget to the basketball budget, sure. But the thread is talking about dropping from FBS.

You want to spend money on athletics because of (all the reasons that schools spend money on athletics), then you do that and you stay in the MAC. You want to save money because your administration decides that all of those reasons are horse manure, then you save money.

There's no third option where you do a Benjamin Button UMass, get rid of your FBS football program and then John Calipari and MArcus Camby show up and put you in the Final Four.
that has got to be the biggest fallacy out there: dropping football and "putting the cost savings into basketball etc." If that were true, then Boston University Hofstra Northeastern Idaho etc. would be going to Final Fours every year.

Its simple math. Having FBS limits what you can spend on basketball. Dropping fb doesn't mean you will be successful in basketball, but it increases the chance you don't end up 9-21 for the season.
02-16-2026 07:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,889
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #51
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 05:00 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:52 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 03:44 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved

The argument you are trying to make drop down FB to support BB is so much easier to make when the BB is good.

Ball State hasn't had a good enough BB program I think to make that calculation. Akron is the best example the MAC has and with declining enrollment has to make some decisions.

I have said over and over again, dropping down to FCS doesn't help matters

Minimal expense reduction for massive revenue reduction - on top of the conference affiliation issue

Ultimately, you do spend a lot less on facilities and coaching staffs. But, of course, the bigger reduction is completely eliminating it and dropping to 14 sports from the 16 required in FBS.
02-16-2026 07:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Offline
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #52
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 07:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 01:24 PM)ZooMass84 Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 01:07 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 12:37 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 11:56 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  You can't bank on that. And I would bet $1 that without looking, you don't know who won the Horizon League last year.

If you can't make the economics of exposure work with Tuesday/Wednesday Night MACtion on ESPN, you're not going to make it work with half-empty arenas on ESPN-U

LOL I'm in NC so I'm not exactly in the Horizon leagues target region, but youre right I dont know without looking. Honest to goodness without looking I would guess Oakland....They have done well in the Horizon over the past few years and would be my final answer if this were a Who Wants to be a Millionaire

I think schools like Gonzaga and Big East/A10 schools would disagree with your assessment that if you cannot make FBS/FCS football work, you can't do well in basketball and make that a money maker. You can look at schools like Charlotte and ODU that use to be incredibly strong in basketball prior to adding football. Football diverted their already limited resources and their basketball programs suffered.

I don't think Gonzaga or Dayton or Saint Louis are relevant comparisons for the MAC basketball programs if they're dropping football and "putting resources into basketball". Loyola-Chicago is the unrealistic ceiling, Cleveland State is a much more realistic ceiling (4 20 win seasons in a row before this year). (But guess what? You can win 20 games a season in the MAC if you put resources into basketball.)


Quote:
Quote:Even things like increased home attendance and season ticket base from the move could be used to justify and even exceed that $3 savings gap

LOL no. Let's say you sell another 500 season tickets (which you won't) at $250 each. That's $75000.

OR you could just cut your next head coach's salary or the NIL budget by $100,000.

Quote:I mean if cost savings is the absolute primary concern than yes you are absolutely right. You are guaranteed to save money if you don't try. But most of these schools have made a decision to be D1 because they want to try.

Then they're not dropping down from FBS football.

Quote: And I believe that most struggling football schools would see a greater ROI on their athletic dollars by emphasizing another sport, basketball being the most obvious and highest profile.

That would support cutting a half-million dollars from the football budget to the basketball budget, sure. But the thread is talking about dropping from FBS.

You want to spend money on athletics because of (all the reasons that schools spend money on athletics), then you do that and you stay in the MAC. You want to save money because your administration decides that all of those reasons are horse manure, then you save money.

There's no third option where you do a Benjamin Button UMass, get rid of your FBS football program and then John Calipari and MArcus Camby show up and put you in the Final Four.
that has got to be the biggest fallacy out there: dropping football and "putting the cost savings into basketball etc." If that were true, then Boston University Hofstra Northeastern Idaho etc. would be going to Final Fours every year.

Its simple math. Having FBS limits what you can spend on basketball. Dropping fb doesn't mean you will be successful in basketball, but it increases the chance you don't end up 9-21 for the season.

The revenue delta between being 9-21 and 21-9 isn't much.
02-16-2026 07:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Offline
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #53
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 07:53 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 05:00 PM)solohawks Wrote:  I have said over and over again, dropping down to FCS doesn't help matters

Minimal expense reduction for massive revenue reduction - on top of the conference affiliation issue

Ultimately, you do spend a lot less on facilities and coaching staffs. But, of course, the bigger reduction is completely eliminating it and dropping to 14 sports from the 16 required in FBS.

Yup. If you're going to drop down to save money, go ahead and maximize the cost savings, assuming that the revenue is close enough to zero that it doesn't matter.
02-16-2026 08:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #54
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
Again I think the math has changed with NIL.

Before it might of been FBS or drop the FB program. Now it might make sense to keep the program at FCS where you can cut costs but still have the benefits of a FB team for alumni engagement while putting the focus on BB with NIL spending.

For South Dakota St it might be who cares about BB? For Illinois St it might be let's stay in the MVC and concentrate on BB.

The hybrid situation in conferences like the MVC is a problem when half of your conference doesn't have FB while the other half does. The Summit is heading in this direction too.
02-16-2026 08:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JSchmack Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,220
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 385
I Root For: St. Bonaventure
Location:
Post: #55
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 04:05 PM)e-parade Wrote:  The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while.

The idea that UMass "sacrificed" basketball for football is just nuts to me.

I don't know if it's an age/timing thing of UMass being REALLY GOOD in the 1990s when the internet went from "what's that?" to "we all have it and talk sports on message boards now" but the expectations/perception of UMass basketball have just not matched reality.

UMass without Calipari/Leaman as head coach is .473 over 60 seasons listed in Sports-Reference.

Post Calipari, pre FBS (1997-2011) - .513 win percentage
Post FBS announcement (2011-pres) - .516 win percentage

That's not "Sacrificing basketball." That's just what UMass IS.

And I mean no disrespect to my former A-10 brethren. I'm an honest pragmatist -- and in the same boat as Bona fans discuss moving on from Mark Schmidt!
02-17-2026 01:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #56
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-17-2026 01:41 PM)JSchmack Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:05 PM)e-parade Wrote:  The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while.

The idea that UMass "sacrificed" basketball for football is just nuts to me.

I don't know if it's an age/timing thing of UMass being REALLY GOOD in the 1990s when the internet went from "what's that?" to "we all have it and talk sports on message boards now" but the expectations/perception of UMass basketball have just not matched reality.

UMass without Calipari/Leaman as head coach is .473 over 60 seasons listed in Sports-Reference.

Post Calipari, pre FBS (1997-2011) - .513 win percentage
Post FBS announcement (2011-pres) - .516 win percentage

That's not "Sacrificing basketball." That's just what UMass IS.

And I mean no disrespect to my former A-10 brethren. I'm an honest pragmatist -- and in the same boat as Bona fans discuss moving on from Mark Schmidt!

From 1960-2011, UMass football had a winning percentage of ~.600. The 90s really did a number on the perception of UMass sports.
02-17-2026 01:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Sitting bull Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,514
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 144
I Root For: W&M
Location:
Post: #57
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-16-2026 03:44 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 02:47 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  When UMass joined the MAC, they hadn't been to the NCAA's in over 10 years. That's the reality.

It takes decades, not years, to build a program that can command national attention. You look at the best possible outcome, Gonzaga or UCF. Instead, look at the 75th percentile outcome. Memphis or South Florida or Fresno State or Northern Illinois football, or St Mary's or George Mason basketball.

If you were playing College President simulator, would you downgrade Ball State football to be Indiana State so that Ball State basketball could be George Mason?

It would be dropping football completely not downgrading to FCS so dropping down to FCS to pursue a better basketball program would be foolish.

Again there is no real substantial savings in dropping from FBS to FCS, significant costs still exists but the revenues shrink substantially.

As to your question, I will rephrase, would I drop football at Ball State to try and become George Mason? It would really depend on the financial commitment of my boosters and what they prefer. I know UNCW is better off not trying to do football...our basketball and baseball would be no where near as financially supported if we had to worry about football.

Look at the CAA schools, the ones that do not have to worry about football (UNCW, Charleston, Hofstra) tend to be doing much better than the ones that do in the area of basketball.

So if Ball State wanted to become a basketball power, yes I would encourage the dropping of football as I believe it would make the goal much much easier. They would have to be ok with being in the Horizon or ideally the MVC and have that resolved

From a W&M perspective, we could never beat ODU in basketball, men or women, until they got a football program. Since then, we are disappointed if we don’t beat them. We both play football and I would say per capita (considering student and alumni involvement), our FCS football program is as or more popular than their Sun Belt program.

I remember back in the 70s when there was a group at W&M that wanted to dissolve football so our basketball program could be “like Georgetown”. Thankfully, that mindset was defeated and we put fresh support behind our football program that remains the key revenue producer in the athletic department by far. There’s just no guarantee that giving up one sport leads to prominence in another.

As far as the CAA, you left out W&M that will be in the top half, maybe in the top four, by year end. We have football but swept UNCW and beat Hofstra in our only match-up. Towson, who also plays football, went 16-2 and regular season champs last year.
02-17-2026 02:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #58
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
I just don’t understand the clamor of a lot of people to want to see schools downgrade. No one wants to move down from the P4 to G6. Similarly, no one wants to move down from the FBS to FCS. Since 2000, only one FBS school has chosen to move down to FCS: Idaho. All other movement has been entirely in the other direction of FCS to FBS. The latest two FBS schools - North Dakota State and Sacramento State - are paying massive premiums and even foregoing future conference revenue simply to move up.

I can at least understand moving from Division I to Division III or dropping football entirely if it’s a pure matter of cost. Tinkering around the margins by moving from FBS to FCS when the CFP exists, though, really makes little sense, particularly when any FCS schools of value have either left to move up to FBS or trying to find ways to do so.

Academia is not a normal industry. Prestige and grouping yourself with the highest level set of peers possible - whether it’s in academics or athletics - is the whole name of the game. The whole argument that a school would be better off and more competitive at a lower level virtually always falls on deaf ears: leaders and donors want to hear that they’re associated with and competing against the best of the best.
(This post was last modified: 02-17-2026 02:15 PM by Frank the Tank.)
02-17-2026 02:11 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,349
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 958
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #59
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-17-2026 01:41 PM)JSchmack Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:05 PM)e-parade Wrote:  The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while.

The idea that UMass "sacrificed" basketball for football is just nuts to me.

I don't know if it's an age/timing thing of UMass being REALLY GOOD in the 1990s when the internet went from "what's that?" to "we all have it and talk sports on message boards now" but the expectations/perception of UMass basketball have just not matched reality.

UMass without Calipari/Leaman as head coach is .473 over 60 seasons listed in Sports-Reference.

Post Calipari, pre FBS (1997-2011) - .513 win percentage
Post FBS announcement (2011-pres) - .516 win percentage

That's not "Sacrificing basketball." That's just what UMass IS.

And I mean no disrespect to my former A-10 brethren. I'm an honest pragmatist -- and in the same boat as Bona fans discuss moving on from Mark Schmidt!
The MAC is clearly a worse league than the A-10 for UMass hoops. Worse history, usually worse kenpom, no drivable away games, no rivals or shared history, worse for recruiting and, and maybe this us just because I live in PA, a worse BB tv deal that will remove them from every bar I attend.
(This post was last modified: 02-17-2026 02:12 PM by The Beaver.)
02-17-2026 02:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #60
RE: MAC schools potentially dropping to FCS
(02-17-2026 02:12 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(02-17-2026 01:41 PM)JSchmack Wrote:  
(02-16-2026 04:05 PM)e-parade Wrote:  The decision wasn't "sacrifice basketball for football" it was "make the most of our football team and strike the iron when hot" - our basketball team hadn't been to the NCAA since the same year UMass football won the national championship (1998). One team was busy having the best run it ever had while the other was struggling.

The decision was the right one, but that was unfortunately the last right decision the department made for a while.

The idea that UMass "sacrificed" basketball for football is just nuts to me.

I don't know if it's an age/timing thing of UMass being REALLY GOOD in the 1990s when the internet went from "what's that?" to "we all have it and talk sports on message boards now" but the expectations/perception of UMass basketball have just not matched reality.

UMass without Calipari/Leaman as head coach is .473 over 60 seasons listed in Sports-Reference.

Post Calipari, pre FBS (1997-2011) - .513 win percentage
Post FBS announcement (2011-pres) - .516 win percentage

That's not "Sacrificing basketball." That's just what UMass IS.

And I mean no disrespect to my former A-10 brethren. I'm an honest pragmatist -- and in the same boat as Bona fans discuss moving on from Mark Schmidt!
The MAC is clearly a worse league than the A-10 for UMass hoops. Worse history, usually worse kenpom, no drivable away games, no rivals or shared history, worse for recruiting and, and maybe this us just because I live in PA, a worse BB tv deal that will remove them from every bar I attend.

Did you ever get UMass games at bars you attended before we went to the MAC? Honest question there.

I saw UMass Hockey at bars more often than Basketball by a wide margin. Struggling to even think of times when I saw A10 games on TV. I did catch part of a UMass basketball game at a bar this season though, but that wasn't during MAC play.
02-17-2026 02:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.