Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)
Open TigerLinks
 

Post Reply 
Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
Author Message
heyradio Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 422
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 39
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #21
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
Yeah, I've been saying for a long time that we Tiger fans should be rooting for playoff expansion far harder than -- while a nice dream -- conference realignment. Having a legit shot at playoffs every year will level the playing field far more than consolidating power.
12-12-2025 11:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Eagleonpar Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,308
Joined: May 2018
Reputation: 540
I Root For: UOFM
Location:
Post: #22
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 11:32 AM)heyradio Wrote:  Yeah, I've been saying for a long time that we Tiger fans should be rooting for playoff expansion far harder than -- while a nice dream -- conference realignment. Having a legit shot at playoffs every year will level the playing field far more than consolidating power.

We can forget about conference realignment. That ship sank when they turned down the 250 million
12-12-2025 12:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Claw Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,563
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1566
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Orangeville HELP!
Post: #23
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 11:09 AM)Eagleonpar Wrote:  Gotta make sure Dr Pepper and Allstate are happy

It has to play in Fansville.
12-12-2025 12:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fluke Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,657
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 81
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #24
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 10:19 AM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 09:20 AM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 07:20 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 05:12 PM)Keeper Wrote:  I like the idea the G5 proposes for a 5 + 11. This could still permit 2 G5 to be auto qualifiers, and possible at large selections if the American, the new PAC, and the Sun Belt continue to improve. I prefer 24 teams with 8 conference champs + 16, but the 5 + 11 is better that what they have this year.

I am hopeful that Tulane and ODU can get victories this year and increase the desire for a more inclusive college football environment. Just the idea of two tiers made me ill. the reality of it is downright sickening.

I'll be a fan of a 16 team playoff that features the following things:

1: P4 Conference champion will receive a first round bye (Indiana, Duke, Georgia, Texas Tech are those teams)
2: P4 Conference Championship runner-ups will receive a home playoff game (Ohio State, Virginia, Alabama, and BYU)
3: One spot for the Group of 5
4: 7 wild card teams

It'll force the hand to Notre Dame that they cannot receive a first round bye or a home playoff game because they're not in a conference. Only 1 Group of 5 team is needed (watching Tulane and JMU is going to get boring). It also forces teams to do well and be competitive, and have an incentive for making it to the conference championship game, and winning it. Therefore, the conference championship games will be exciting at the P4 level.
If college football is slowly becoming the NFL, and it is, then let's have a partial guarantee playoff system that can be won on the field (like it is in the NFL), then if you're a team that doesn't make it to the conference championship game, you're on the wild card spot, meaning you could very well be left off. If teams do their job, then they shouldn't have to worry about the wild card spot.

Don’t see why the runner ups should be guaranteed a home game or even a playoff spot for that matter. A third team from another conference or the g5 champ could easily be better than the 2nd place ACC team for instance. If Virginia didn’t choke this year it would have been a 7-6 Duke team as the runner up.

The point is to make the season and conference champ game matter, the outlier here, not the standard, is the ACC and Duke. The ACC needs to revamp their champ game requirements period, Duke should have never been within sniffing distance of a conference title. I think we can all safely say that if Duke was replaced with Miami then all of the champs and their runner-ups were deserving with VA being the weakest. And before you say it, they were ranked 17 and higher than any group of 5 so it's not like their inclusion would have been absurd, just means that JMU wouldn't make the cut and whoever is ranked 15 and 16 would be whining.

It’s not only about this year but other years. For instance when cincy made the 4 team playoff or Boise was ranked 6 or something a few years ago. They shouldn’t automatically be relegated to a bottom 8 seed.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 02:05 PM by Fluke.)
12-12-2025 02:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoDownSwinging Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 998
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 65
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #25
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 02:05 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:19 AM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 09:20 AM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 07:20 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 05:12 PM)Keeper Wrote:  I like the idea the G5 proposes for a 5 + 11. This could still permit 2 G5 to be auto qualifiers, and possible at large selections if the American, the new PAC, and the Sun Belt continue to improve. I prefer 24 teams with 8 conference champs + 16, but the 5 + 11 is better that what they have this year.

I am hopeful that Tulane and ODU can get victories this year and increase the desire for a more inclusive college football environment. Just the idea of two tiers made me ill. the reality of it is downright sickening.

I'll be a fan of a 16 team playoff that features the following things:

1: P4 Conference champion will receive a first round bye (Indiana, Duke, Georgia, Texas Tech are those teams)
2: P4 Conference Championship runner-ups will receive a home playoff game (Ohio State, Virginia, Alabama, and BYU)
3: One spot for the Group of 5
4: 7 wild card teams

It'll force the hand to Notre Dame that they cannot receive a first round bye or a home playoff game because they're not in a conference. Only 1 Group of 5 team is needed (watching Tulane and JMU is going to get boring). It also forces teams to do well and be competitive, and have an incentive for making it to the conference championship game, and winning it. Therefore, the conference championship games will be exciting at the P4 level.
If college football is slowly becoming the NFL, and it is, then let's have a partial guarantee playoff system that can be won on the field (like it is in the NFL), then if you're a team that doesn't make it to the conference championship game, you're on the wild card spot, meaning you could very well be left off. If teams do their job, then they shouldn't have to worry about the wild card spot.

Don’t see why the runner ups should be guaranteed a home game or even a playoff spot for that matter. A third team from another conference or the g5 champ could easily be better than the 2nd place ACC team for instance. If Virginia didn’t choke this year it would have been a 7-6 Duke team as the runner up.

The point is to make the season and conference champ game matter, the outlier here, not the standard, is the ACC and Duke. The ACC needs to revamp their champ game requirements period, Duke should have never been within sniffing distance of a conference title. I think we can all safely say that if Duke was replaced with Miami then all of the champs and their runner-ups were deserving with VA being the weakest. And before you say it, they were ranked 17 and higher than any group of 5 so it's not like their inclusion would have been absurd, just means that JMU wouldn't make the cut and whoever is ranked 15 and 16 would be whining.

It’s not only about this year but other years. For instance when cincy made the 4 team playoff or Boise was ranked 6 or something a few years ago. They shouldn’t automatically be relegated to a bottom 8 seed.

Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.
12-12-2025 04:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Keeper Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
Post: #26
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-11-2025 06:09 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote:  A larger playoff only makes sense for several reasons.

1. It's great sports viewing for all college football fans, which translates into more broadcast revenues across the board.

2. Allows more bubble teams into the mix, thus keeping the Power Conferences (and maybe Notre Dame) happy, too.

16 teams is a no-brainer, and I think 24 would be even better (assuming the Top 8 would enjoy first round byes).

Especially if the top 8 are conference champions and have home games. That really makes the regular season ever more interesting, and keeps CCGs in play.
12-12-2025 08:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Keeper Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
Post: #27
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-11-2025 07:20 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 05:12 PM)Keeper Wrote:  I like the idea the G5 proposes for a 5 + 11. This could still permit 2 G5 to be auto qualifiers, and possible at large selections if the American, the new PAC, and the Sun Belt continue to improve. I prefer 24 teams with 8 conference champs + 16, but the 5 + 11 is better that what they have this year.

I am hopeful that Tulane and ODU can get victories this year and increase the desire for a more inclusive college football environment. Just the idea of two tiers made me ill. the reality of it is downright sickening.

I'll be a fan of a 16 team playoff that features the following things:

1: P4 Conference champion will receive a first round bye (Indiana, Duke, Georgia, Texas Tech are those teams)
2: P4 Conference Championship runner-ups will receive a home playoff game (Ohio State, Virginia, Alabama, and BYU)
3: One spot for the Group of 5
4: 7 wild card teams

It'll force the hand to Notre Dame that they cannot receive a first round bye or a home playoff game because they're not in a conference. Only 1 Group of 5 team is needed (watching Tulane and JMU is going to get boring). It also forces teams to do well and be competitive, and have an incentive for making it to the conference championship game, and winning it. Therefore, the conference championship games will be exciting at the P4 level.
If college football is slowly becoming the NFL, and it is, then let's have a partial guarantee playoff system that can be won on the field (like it is in the NFL), then if you're a team that doesn't make it to the conference championship game, you're on the wild card spot, meaning you could very well be left off. If teams do their job, then they shouldn't have to worry about the wild card spot.

You sir are an elitist who has no interest in making college football more competitive. By only rewarding those at the top and not encouraging the aspirational by giving the opportunity to be successful you are calling for a P2 2nd2 all the rest divide. That is sickening and frankly un-American.
12-12-2025 08:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Keeper Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
Post: #28
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
[quote='heyradio' pid='20474520' dateline='1765557172']
Yeah, I've been saying for a long time that we Tiger fans should be rooting for playoff expansion far harder than -- while a nice dream -- conference realignment. Having a legit shot at playoffs every year will level the playing field far more than consolidating power.


Exactly the preversion of college football has come from the top (SEC primarily). Inclusion and opportunity is what made the United States the Greatest nation on earth for 75 of my years. Those same two values could bring back college football, and not make it all about the top 3 or 4 of 2 conferences. There are 130 teams in 10 conferences in d1. If eight of those conference champions get a second round home game; teams like Arkansas, South Carolina, Missouri, Illinois, Iowa, Wisconsin, and many others might rethink their allegiances and television contracts might come back to the more equitable level they were before the SEC went to 12 teams and began the Conference Championship Game cycle. College football was never the greatest game, but it could once again become great and not some exercise in futility for over 100 team's fans.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 08:34 PM by Keeper.)
12-12-2025 08:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fluke Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,657
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 81
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #29
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 04:35 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 02:05 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:19 AM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 09:20 AM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 07:20 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  I'll be a fan of a 16 team playoff that features the following things:

1: P4 Conference champion will receive a first round bye (Indiana, Duke, Georgia, Texas Tech are those teams)
2: P4 Conference Championship runner-ups will receive a home playoff game (Ohio State, Virginia, Alabama, and BYU)
3: One spot for the Group of 5
4: 7 wild card teams

It'll force the hand to Notre Dame that they cannot receive a first round bye or a home playoff game because they're not in a conference. Only 1 Group of 5 team is needed (watching Tulane and JMU is going to get boring). It also forces teams to do well and be competitive, and have an incentive for making it to the conference championship game, and winning it. Therefore, the conference championship games will be exciting at the P4 level.
If college football is slowly becoming the NFL, and it is, then let's have a partial guarantee playoff system that can be won on the field (like it is in the NFL), then if you're a team that doesn't make it to the conference championship game, you're on the wild card spot, meaning you could very well be left off. If teams do their job, then they shouldn't have to worry about the wild card spot.

Don’t see why the runner ups should be guaranteed a home game or even a playoff spot for that matter. A third team from another conference or the g5 champ could easily be better than the 2nd place ACC team for instance. If Virginia didn’t choke this year it would have been a 7-6 Duke team as the runner up.

The point is to make the season and conference champ game matter, the outlier here, not the standard, is the ACC and Duke. The ACC needs to revamp their champ game requirements period, Duke should have never been within sniffing distance of a conference title. I think we can all safely say that if Duke was replaced with Miami then all of the champs and their runner-ups were deserving with VA being the weakest. And before you say it, they were ranked 17 and higher than any group of 5 so it's not like their inclusion would have been absurd, just means that JMU wouldn't make the cut and whoever is ranked 15 and 16 would be whining.

It’s not only about this year but other years. For instance when cincy made the 4 team playoff or Boise was ranked 6 or something a few years ago. They shouldn’t automatically be relegated to a bottom 8 seed.

Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.

Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 09:03 PM by Fluke.)
12-12-2025 08:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Lord2FLI Away
Peanut Vendor
*

Posts: 4,779
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 561
I Root For: The End
Location:
Post: #30
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 04:35 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 02:05 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:19 AM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 09:20 AM)Fluke Wrote:  Don’t see why the runner ups should be guaranteed a home game or even a playoff spot for that matter. A third team from another conference or the g5 champ could easily be better than the 2nd place ACC team for instance. If Virginia didn’t choke this year it would have been a 7-6 Duke team as the runner up.

The point is to make the season and conference champ game matter, the outlier here, not the standard, is the ACC and Duke. The ACC needs to revamp their champ game requirements period, Duke should have never been within sniffing distance of a conference title. I think we can all safely say that if Duke was replaced with Miami then all of the champs and their runner-ups were deserving with VA being the weakest. And before you say it, they were ranked 17 and higher than any group of 5 so it's not like their inclusion would have been absurd, just means that JMU wouldn't make the cut and whoever is ranked 15 and 16 would be whining.

It’s not only about this year but other years. For instance when cincy made the 4 team playoff or Boise was ranked 6 or something a few years ago. They shouldn’t automatically be relegated to a bottom 8 seed.

Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.

Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.
12-12-2025 10:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Atlanta Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
Post: #31
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
Develop a 2-tiered tournament with top 4 ranked conference champs plus the top ranked at large school getting a bye & a spot in the 12 team final tier with remaining FBS conference champs (7) plus top 7 ranked remaining at large teams as an initial tier playing an early round with winners filling out the 12 team final tier. No FBS conferences are left out & plenty of at large opportunity. Do away with the committee & set these rankings via a set of computer analysis.
(This post was last modified: 12-13-2025 07:54 AM by Atlanta.)
12-12-2025 11:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fluke Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,657
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 81
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #32
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 04:35 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 02:05 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:19 AM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  The point is to make the season and conference champ game matter, the outlier here, not the standard, is the ACC and Duke. The ACC needs to revamp their champ game requirements period, Duke should have never been within sniffing distance of a conference title. I think we can all safely say that if Duke was replaced with Miami then all of the champs and their runner-ups were deserving with VA being the weakest. And before you say it, they were ranked 17 and higher than any group of 5 so it's not like their inclusion would have been absurd, just means that JMU wouldn't make the cut and whoever is ranked 15 and 16 would be whining.

It’s not only about this year but other years. For instance when cincy made the 4 team playoff or Boise was ranked 6 or something a few years ago. They shouldn’t automatically be relegated to a bottom 8 seed.

Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.

Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.
12-12-2025 11:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoDownSwinging Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 998
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 65
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #33
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 11:49 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 04:35 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 02:05 PM)Fluke Wrote:  It’s not only about this year but other years. For instance when cincy made the 4 team playoff or Boise was ranked 6 or something a few years ago. They shouldn’t automatically be relegated to a bottom 8 seed.

Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.

Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.

I want to go back to my original statement and make a correction. You can't have a 16 team playoff with 4 teams earning a bye, unless there's a play-in for seeds 13-16.

So, I would like to adjust my original statement. The Power 4 conference champions should be seeds 1-4. Runner-up will be seeds 5-8. The only way the Group of 5 champion can host a playoff game would be if their resume is better than one of the runner-ups resume, and if that's the case, they'll be in seeds 5-8. So, you have potentially 5 teams battling for 4 spots. Seeds 9-16 are the G5/Wild card teams.

Now, I can understand why people would make an argument of why the 3rd or 4th best SEC team is better than the Runner-up in the in the ACC or Big 12. However, I still believe we need to incentivize making it to the conference championship game at the Power 4 level.
12-13-2025 11:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Keeper Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
Post: #34
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-13-2025 11:59 AM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 11:49 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 04:35 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.

Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.

I want to go back to my original statement and make a correction. You can't have a 16 team playoff with 4 teams earning a bye, unless there's a play-in for seeds 13-16.

So, I would like to adjust my original statement. The Power 4 conference champions should be seeds 1-4. Runner-up will be seeds 5-8. The only way the Group of 5 champion can host a playoff game would be if their resume is better than one of the runner-ups resume, and if that's the case, they'll be in seeds 5-8. So, you have potentially 5 teams battling for 4 spots. Seeds 9-16 are the G5/Wild card teams.

Now, I can understand why people would make an argument of why the 3rd or 4th best SEC team is better than the Runner-up in the in the ACC or Big 12. However, I still believe we need to incentivize making it to the conference championship game at the Power 4 level.

You continue you elitist recommendations. Every conference championship needs to be incentivized and included in a championship playoff just as is done with basketball and every other NCAA sport.
The exclusion of these champions is what has led to this destructive system in football. Clearly you are not a Tiger fan. So which P4 conference do you favor.
By the way in your system there would be 124 teams battling for 4 spots and all of the P4 teams would receive preferential treatment. You and so many of your ilk have no concept of fair play.
(This post was last modified: 12-13-2025 12:55 PM by Keeper.)
12-13-2025 12:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoDownSwinging Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 998
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 65
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #35
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-13-2025 12:51 PM)Keeper Wrote:  
(12-13-2025 11:59 AM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 11:49 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.

I want to go back to my original statement and make a correction. You can't have a 16 team playoff with 4 teams earning a bye, unless there's a play-in for seeds 13-16.

So, I would like to adjust my original statement. The Power 4 conference champions should be seeds 1-4. Runner-up will be seeds 5-8. The only way the Group of 5 champion can host a playoff game would be if their resume is better than one of the runner-ups resume, and if that's the case, they'll be in seeds 5-8. So, you have potentially 5 teams battling for 4 spots. Seeds 9-16 are the G5/Wild card teams.

Now, I can understand why people would make an argument of why the 3rd or 4th best SEC team is better than the Runner-up in the in the ACC or Big 12. However, I still believe we need to incentivize making it to the conference championship game at the Power 4 level.

You continue you elitist recommendations. Every conference championship needs to be incentivized and included in a championship playoff just as is done with basketball and every other NCAA sport.
The exclusion of these champions is what has led to this destructive system in football. Clearly you are not a Tiger fan. So which P4 conference do you favor.
By the way in your system there would be 124 teams battling for 4 spots and all of the P4 teams would receive preferential treatment. You and so many of your ilk have no concept of fair play.

Why are you here? I thought you moved to Fayetteville?

I hate it to break it to you but Sun Belt, CUSA, and MAC teams aren't beating anyone in the top 16. We're basically waisting time. Western Michigan won the MAC championship game, and they were shutout by Illinois and lost by 17 to 4-8 Michigan State. Kennesaw State won the CUSA, and they couldn't score 10+ points to Wake Forest, and lost by 45 points to Indiana. No one wants to see those games when College Football is competing for ratings. It's a bad product. You're just finding an easy way for the Tigers to make it to the playoffs without necessarily earning the right. They're in good company because if they win the American, there's a 60% chance to make it to the playoff because the American is better than the Mountain West.
There's a mismatch from a physicality standpoint when it comes to football between SEC and Sun Belt players. That's just reality.
12-13-2025 01:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3rdgenerationtiger Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,430
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 471
I Root For: Tigers & Bears
Location: The Airport
Post: #36
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-12-2025 08:19 PM)Keeper Wrote:  [quote='heyradio' pid='20474520' dateline='1765557172']
Yeah, I've been saying for a long time that we Tiger fans should be rooting for playoff expansion far harder than -- while a nice dream -- conference realignment. Having a legit shot at playoffs every year will level the playing field far more than consolidating power.


Exactly the preversion of college football has come from the top (SEC primarily). Inclusion and opportunity is what made the United States the Greatest nation on earth for 75 of my years. Those same two values could bring back college football, and not make it all about the top 3 or 4 of 2 conferences. There are 130 teams in 10 conferences in d1. If eight of those conference champions get a second round home game; teams like Arkansas, South Carolina, Missouri, Illinois, Iowa, Wisconsin, and many others might rethink their allegiances and television contracts might come back to the more equitable level they were before the SEC went to 12 teams and began the Conference Championship Game cycle. College football was never the greatest game, but it could once again become great and not some exercise in futility for over 100 team's fans.

If it wasn’t so great, why do sports programmers shell out billions for the broadcasting rights?
(This post was last modified: 12-13-2025 11:05 PM by 3rdgenerationtiger.)
12-13-2025 10:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Tiger87 Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #37
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-13-2025 11:59 AM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 11:49 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 04:35 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  Boise State lost by 17 to Penn State, and Cincinnati lost by 21 to Alabama.
If you believe Memphis is going to host a playoff game as a Group of 5 member, then I got some bad news for you. I just don't believe that'll ever happen in the playoff era (G5 team to host a playoff game), so we need to move forward to something that can guarantee in some way for teams that earn it. I don't think Memphis will be in the P4 until the 2028-2030 season the earliest.

Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.

I want to go back to my original statement and make a correction. You can't have a 16 team playoff with 4 teams earning a bye, unless there's a play-in for seeds 13-16.

So, I would like to adjust my original statement. The Power 4 conference champions should be seeds 1-4. Runner-up will be seeds 5-8. The only way the Group of 5 champion can host a playoff game would be if their resume is better than one of the runner-ups resume, and if that's the case, they'll be in seeds 5-8. So, you have potentially 5 teams battling for 4 spots. Seeds 9-16 are the G5/Wild card teams.

Now, I can understand why people would make an argument of why the 3rd or 4th best SEC team is better than the Runner-up in the in the ACC or Big 12. However, I still believe we need to incentivize making it to the conference championship game at the Power 4 level.

I don't think the P4 champs deserve auto-seeding 1-4. The incentive is already there - win the conference champ get an auto bid. They don't deserve the top 4 seeds automatically. Plus the B10 and the $EC will not go for that.

And the runners-up definitely don't deserve an auto-bid - much less seeds 5-8. Again, BIG and SEC will not go for it. Win the conference championship if you want a bid. Otherwise, have a really good non-con and reg season.

Basically, keep the system the way it is, just add 4 more at large bids. Seeding by the committee - just like other NCAA tourneys.
12-15-2025 04:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DDrum1961 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,878
Joined: Jan 2007
Reputation: 104
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Bartlett
Post: #38
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
If they keep adding to the number of teams, you will eventually eliminate the Conference Championship games or reduce the number of regular season games… The total number of games has to have a limit for both safety and quality of play …
12-15-2025 09:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Keeper Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
Post: #39
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-13-2025 01:34 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-13-2025 12:51 PM)Keeper Wrote:  
(12-13-2025 11:59 AM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 11:49 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.

I want to go back to my original statement and make a correction. You can't have a 16 team playoff with 4 teams earning a bye, unless there's a play-in for seeds 13-16.

So, I would like to adjust my original statement. The Power 4 conference champions should be seeds 1-4. Runner-up will be seeds 5-8. The only way the Group of 5 champion can host a playoff game would be if their resume is better than one of the runner-ups resume, and if that's the case, they'll be in seeds 5-8. So, you have potentially 5 teams battling for 4 spots. Seeds 9-16 are the G5/Wild card teams.

Now, I can understand why people would make an argument of why the 3rd or 4th best SEC team is better than the Runner-up in the in the ACC or Big 12. However, I still believe we need to incentivize making it to the conference championship game at the Power 4 level.

You continue you elitist recommendations. Every conference championship needs to be incentivized and included in a championship playoff just as is done with basketball and every other NCAA sport.
The exclusion of these champions is what has led to this destructive system in football. Clearly you are not a Tiger fan. So which P4 conference do you favor.
By the way in your system there would be 124 teams battling for 4 spots and all of the P4 teams would receive preferential treatment. You and so many of your ilk have no concept of fair play.

Why are you here? I thought you moved to Fayetteville?

I hate it to break it to you but Sun Belt, CUSA, and MAC teams aren't beating anyone in the top 16. We're basically waisting time. Western Michigan won the MAC championship game, and they were shutout by Illinois and lost by 17 to 4-8 Michigan State. Kennesaw State won the CUSA, and they couldn't score 10+ points to Wake Forest, and lost by 45 points to Indiana. No one wants to see those games when College Football is competing for ratings. It's a bad product. You're just finding an easy way for the Tigers to make it to the playoffs without necessarily earning the right. They're in good company because if they win the American, there's a 60% chance to make it to the playoff because the American is better than the Mountain West.
There's a mismatch from a physicality standpoint when it comes to football between SEC and Sun Belt players. That's just reality.

They are not beating those teams because the prevision you so passionately prefer is stacking the deck. The games being played would syphon money from your conference and would make it possible for G6 conferences to compete. Allowing the P4 to have all but 1 team is the tournament is like giving billionaires a tax break while imposing punitive sales taxes on the rest of us(tariffs are sales taxes on consumer goods). Knowing your perversion you can probably find an excellent reason for that also.
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2025 04:13 AM by Keeper.)
12-16-2025 04:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Keeper Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
Post: #40
RE: Good chance of a 16 team CFP next season
(12-15-2025 04:45 PM)Tiger87 Wrote:  
(12-13-2025 11:59 AM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 11:49 PM)Fluke Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 10:25 PM)Lord2FLI Wrote:  
(12-12-2025 08:51 PM)Fluke Wrote:  Yes cincy played #1 because they were #4. That has nothing to do with whether they would have beaten one of the lower ranked teams. In fact the #1 almost always dominated the #4 by that much or more. Huge difference from that and playing the 8 seed at home. They had already beat #8 and #16 that year. You are cherry picking and saying well the g5 got dominated so didn’t deserve it when the same thing happened to most p5 teams.

The margin of victory during the four team era for that game was
2015: 20
2016: 17
2017: 18
2018: 11 #4 Alabama won.
2019: 35
2020: 17
2021: 21
2022: 1
2023: 7

I think I understand, you're issue isn't so much that the runner-ups are included, but about where they are seeded.

Exactly. I just don’t think they should be guaranteed a protected seed.

I want to go back to my original statement and make a correction. You can't have a 16 team playoff with 4 teams earning a bye, unless there's a play-in for seeds 13-16.

So, I would like to adjust my original statement. The Power 4 conference champions should be seeds 1-4. Runner-up will be seeds 5-8. The only way the Group of 5 champion can host a playoff game would be if their resume is better than one of the runner-ups resume, and if that's the case, they'll be in seeds 5-8. So, you have potentially 5 teams battling for 4 spots. Seeds 9-16 are the G5/Wild card teams.

Now, I can understand why people would make an argument of why the 3rd or 4th best SEC team is better than the Runner-up in the in the ACC or Big 12. However, I still believe we need to incentivize making it to the conference championship game at the Power 4 level.

I don't think the P4 champs deserve auto-seeding 1-4. The incentive is already there - win the conference champ get an auto bid. They don't deserve the top 4 seeds automatically. Plus the B10 and the $EC will not go for that.

And the runners-up definitely don't deserve an auto-bid - much less seeds 5-8. Again, BIG and SEC will not go for it. Win the conference championship if you want a bid. Otherwise, have a really good non-con and reg season.

Basically, keep the system the way it is, just add 4 more at large bids. Seeding by the committee - just like other NCAA tourneys.


The football tournament is not like any other NCAA tourney. Because in all the other tourney's all conference champions are included and usually have a home game in the tournament.
12-16-2025 04:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.
MemphisTigers.org is the number one message board for Memphis Tigers sports.