XLance
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,155
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
|
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-27-2025 07:23 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-26-2025 01:12 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote: LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.
A few points to consider here:
1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)
2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.
3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.
4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.
5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.
6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.
Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.
Regarding point 6.
You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.
Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.
It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.
I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.
That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.
ND is getting almost a half share of the ACC, over $20m per year for the past 2 years. It is no exaggeration to say that this agreement has kept you guys out of the clutches of the B1G, and it has every potential to continue doing so in the future. Is 5 games really too great a price for that? Those 5 games also help you guys fill out your schedule, generally against teams that aren't going to be much of a threat to the Irish.
I think that the deal is a huge win-win. It's great for ND b/c it helps keep their revenues competitive with the P2, and it's also great for the ACC b/c they have a Top Brand that is far more interested in holding the Conference together than in splitting for greener pastures.
This little tiff about some ACC social media posts is a huge nothing burger.
Hold on, Bryan. Haven't you been on ND about SoS? If you're going to do that and be intellectually honest, you have to admit that the ACC obligation is a drag on that SoS, especially as things currently stand. Three of the six ACC teams on our schedule won't even be bowl-eligible this year, and a fourth (NC State) didn't get to bowl eligibility until last weekend. And another ACC team on our schedule (Pitt) is the Rodney Dangerfield of FBS even though they've had a decent season (and yes, I'm aware that I'm dating myself with that reference).
I'm also aware that there are other weak teams on our schedule this year that aren't in the ACC. Those games, however, are scheduled out years in advance, and it's impossible to know how good those teams will be when we actually play them. Arkansas and Purdue both have played well below their historical norms this season (by contrast, Texas A&M has played better than their historical norm).
And by no means am I saying don't ever schedule any ACC team ever again. We've had historically significant series with a number of ACC programs. And as a practical matter, I'm aware that it's impossible for ND to fill its entire schedule with P2 opponents short of joining one of the P2 as a full member. In a more perfect world, however, we'd be dealing with individual ACC members rather than with the conference for football scheduling. In a world that is slightly less perfect than that, but more perfect than the one we have, our obligation to the ACC would only be four games per year, or dare I say it, three games per year. What does a four game per year obligation give ND that a five game per year obligation does not? More margin for error when it comes to scheduling, without necessarily sacrificing SoS.
In any event, the agreement between ND and the ACC will, by its very terms, come to an end in the relatively near future, unless some type of extension is negotiated. I would expect that ND will look to renegotiate its football game obligation to the ACC when negotiations on an extension take place.
That's just like the ACC games. Those games have been scheduled out until 2036 since Notre Dame signed the contract with the ACC.
It was impossible to know about Notre Dame's ACC opponents this year as well.
|
|