bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-21-2025 11:07 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-21-2025 10:38 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-21-2025 10:16 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-21-2025 06:27 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (11-21-2025 06:08 PM)quo vadis Wrote: I've never liked the ACC deal. IMO, the five game commitment was and is too high a price to pay to park Olympic sports in the ACC and share in their lame bowl lineup.
Should have parked our other sports with the new Big East and signed independent bowl deals. Yes, neither would be as good as in the ACC and the money would be less, but IMO again, five games was too high a price and still is.
With the move to nine conference games, wouldn't late-season games be more difficult to schedule, even for Notre Dame? I ask this in all sincerity.
I don't run things at Notre Dame, but I've been doing a lot of thinking about how Notre Dame should handle the football schedule.
First, given their issues with the Big Ten, I'd approach Michigan and USC about going independent in football, with a loose partnership that included round robin scheduling and maybe one or two non-playoff bowl bids. If they agreed, schedule would consist of the following:
Annual games: Navy, Clemson, Michigan, USC
I'd schedule one game per year with each of the following pairs of teams. Preferably it would be a two on/two off format for each, with one team from each pair on the schedule and the other off in any given year: Boston College/Pitt, Florida State/Miami, Michigan State/Purdue and Ohio State/Penn State.
One game per year similar to the above, but involving three teams on a two on/four off basis: UConn/Syracuse/Stanford. UConn as a concession for joining the Big East. For Syracuse, I'd want to keep a basketball and lacrosse game (and possibly have them join the Big East as an affiliate member for lacrosse) and football would be the concession for that. Stanford would be useful as a filler on the schedule especially for rivalry week.
Remaining games would be flexible on the schedule.
To me that provides a good geographic mix, a good mix between permanent opponents and variety in the schedule, and a good mix between maintaining long-term rivalries and creating new ones, all without sacrificing schedule quality. And maybe I'm naive, but it seems that there are a number of candidates for late season games within that group.
Quote:If the five game annual requirement is "too high a price" why wouldn't ND just leave the conference now, pay the exit fee and go on about their business? I assume that their exit fee would be less due their partial-membership status.
As I understand it, there are three provisions applicable to ND
Exit fee: This is the same for all ACC members, including ND.
Grant of rights: The value of the GoR varies by member. ND's GoR does not include football, so it is worth less than the GoR of, for example, Florida State, Miami or Clemson. From what I have heard, ND's GoR without football is worth roughly the same as Wake Forest's GoR with football.
Contractual provision: ND signed a contract with the ACC not to join any other conference for football. I presume that potential damages could be huge if ND were to join a P2 conference. But if ND left the ACC and joined the Big East, that would not trigger a breach of this contract.
Importantly, I have not seen the GoR agreement. But if the tweet is correct, ND likely would sue on the way out, claim that they are breaking the agreement for cause and that they owe no money as a result. Likely that would settle for ND paying a discounted amount to leave.
Aren't you guys making over $20m a year from the ACC "partial" membership? It's very nearly a half share in payout, plus you have a good home for all of your non-FB sports. Why would you walk away from that much money? BC some ACC social media accounts are pumping up the ACC football team against a non-ACC football team? This feels like faux rage, a true tempest in a teapot if ever there was one.
I honestly don't know what ND's *official* reaction to this is -- they're notoriously tight-lipped about such things. But if the comment in the podcast is correct, ND would hurt its future credibility with the ACC unless it is at least prepared to walk And justify the ACC's actions if that makes you feel better (even though they may have violated their own GoR), but this is the sort of thing that tends to erode trust.
With respect to the ACC portion of the schedule, the objection was never to playing any ACC teams. The objection was that playing an average of five games per year was excessive. With respect to the CFP, there has been a lot of argument here that ND's SoS is too weak. Without question, the ACC portion of the schedule has been a drag on ND's SoS, especially when you consider that three of the six ACC opponents on ND's schedule (Boston College, Syracuse and Stanford) are ineligible for a bowl game.
As for the money, we all know that ND could make more money from media rights sources than they currently do by joining the Big Ten, yet they don't do that. There are multiple sources of revenue for ND, and the ACC payout is just one source. In ND's case, at least, people here tend to greatly underestimate the importance and amount of alumni contributions. This event, and ND's reaction to it, are the sort of things that tend to influence alumni donations.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not advocating for you guys to join the B1G. I’m actually quite happy to sit back and passively send good vibes your way while you guys chart your own course. I simply think that decision to spurn the B1G is justified in part by how close you are able to get to a full B1G share with your lucrative NBC deal combined with ~ a half ACC share. Take out that $20m+ from the ACC, and all of a sudden, the B1G or even SEC looks a whole lot more attractive. If Independence is as important to you guys as I think it is, the ACC deal you have right now is just about perfect. If the price of that ACC deal comes with a few social media posts supporting Miami football over ND football, then I think you can live with that.
(This post was last modified: 11-22-2025 02:19 PM by bryanw1995.)
|
|