RE: Conference Turmoil-PAC Dominoes: UTEP probable, others also to leave?
The only schools for which it makes sense to move to MWC are UTEP (already gone) and NMSU.
For everyone else, it becomes a balancing game between knowns and unknowns.
The current MWC is stronger than CUSA in football and (especially) basketball, but the MWC in 5 years likely won't have such a pronounced advantage. CUSA is weak as hell right now because we're full of recent and future FCS call-ups. We're basically where the Belt was about 5-10 years ago, just with marginally better basketball.
You CANNOT take the MWC's current TV deal and compare it with CUSA's and say, "The MWC would be a far better destination for any CUSA team." The MWC's next deal is 100% going to be worse than what they have now. CUSA's deal is ... let's say 90% ... going to be better than what we have now. So who will come out on top? No one at this point knows.
The MWC is still shopping for teams. If they get lucky and land NIU and Toledo, maybe this boosts their TV deal significantly. Or maybe it merely keeps it from tanking completely. It's not like either of those teams is a huge marketable asset on the same level as Boise State, who is out the door and not coming back.
And there's no guarantee those two teams are coming. Without them, Texas State, SHSU, La Tech, and/or some other Central or Eastern time zone team(s), the MWC is strictly a Mountain/Pacific commodity. It still has Air Force and (arguably) UNLV, but there are no other "big name" schools. It will command market value for a mid-tier G5 conference. Nothing more.
In basketball, while on paper, they may remain marginally stronger than CUSA, barring an influx of new, strong teams, they will absolutely fall from multi-bid status to single bid. This will be devastating to their NCAA revenue, once existing credits are used up. Boise is gone. SDSU is gone. Colorado State is gone. Gonzaga is off the table. There is no one they could realistically add (including the Montanas and Dakotas) to change this.
And this includes Toledo, Texas State, and (especially) NIU. Toledo and Texas State are mediocre teams at best. NIU is awful and would easily be the worst team in CUSA or any of the other "G5" conferences not named the MAC.
As for CUSA's future stability, yes, this has been a historically unstable conference. But FBS has been historically unstable, with lots of upward mobility changing things for every conference. Just look at where the teams who've left since 2005 have ended up (not including the non-football schools):
UCF, Cincy, Houston, TCU are all now in the Big XII.
Louisville and SMU are now in the ACC.
With the exception of the 3 who just moved to the Sun Belt, everyone else is in the American, which is a step up in football, basketball, and revenue.
Marshall, Southern Miss, and ODU were special cases. Each had their own reasons for the (mostly) lateral move to the Sun Belt, and they moved at a time when CUSA's future was unclear.
It's not like teams just come into CUSA, stay a year or so, then say, "THIS PLACE SUCKS! I'M OUTTA HERE!"
CUSA has been raided so often because it's historically been the source of the best teams.
Are we still "the source of the best teams" now? I dunno. Probably not. We still have some solid teams, but no one (including WKU and Liberty) is at a level where the American or some random Power conference would be licking its chops to poach them. The Sun Belt is a bit overcrowded now, and no one seems keen to leave. And the American has been so thoroughly poached that it's not an exciting choice for Power conferences either.
Heck, the 2PAC had to debate for a year whether it would be worth it just to add the top 4 teams from the MWC. That's how unattractive THOSE teams are.
All this means we're facing a period of *relative* stability. All that could change on a dime, of course, when the ACC teams are finally able to move, or if a big sweeping structural change comes to the Power level. But neither of those is guaranteed to happen (or at least guaranteed to impact CUSA).
We have an opportunity (while it lasts) to grow and strengthen ourselves. If we pull it off, great. If not, then yes, we will lose teams. But there aren't as many holes above us left to fill as there once were, just as there aren't as many sexy choices down at the FCS level as there once were.
If they're still getting pressure from the networks to add inventory, the MWC may end up having to invite NMSU. It's the only team left that's guaranteed to say yes.
But CUSA won't be forced to add replacement schools if/when that happens. And this means after next season, we won't have any transitional teams left in the conference. Everyone will be a full FBS member looking to improve itself. If all the newbies commit to that (and the old guard can recapture their past glory) then we will be in excellent shape when the time comes to negotiate our next TV deal. It won't take much to match or even exceed our fellow G5s. It's not like the network executives are sitting around thinking, "You know what our TV viewers really want? More AAC, MWC, and Sun Belt teams in prime time!" They'll simply match the best remaining inventory with the best teams they can get at the time. We just need to make sure we're in that conversation.
|