(05-18-2024 08:16 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (05-17-2024 11:53 PM)epasnoopy Wrote: Albany, Stony Brook, Maine, and these other schools people keep mentioning like they are somehow close are just as far if not further from schools like NIU, WMU, and CMU than North Dakota St.
NDSU is 9 hours from NIU. Albany is 13 hours. Stony Brook is 14 hours. South Dakota St is 8.5 hrs.
NDSU is 11.5 hours from WMU. Albany is 10.5 hours. Stony Brook is 12 hours. South Dakota St is 11 hours.
NDSU is 14 hours from CMU. Stony Brook is 12.5 hours. South Dakota St is the just under 13 hours.
Yes, geography does work like that ... schools are in east coast states are farther from NIU, WMU, and CMU and ... even setting aside 2025 member UMass ... schools that lies west of Minnesota are farther from Buffalo, Kent State, Akron, and Ohio.
(Though at 9.5 hours with passports, Albany can be notably closer to CMU, which I presume is why the CMU comparison included Stony Brook but not Albany.)
So looking at the schools in the middle, NDSU is 13.5 hrs from Miami, 13 hours from Bowling Green/Toledo/EMU.
Albany is 9 hours from EMU (8.5hrs w/passports), 8.5 hours from Bowling Green / Toledo, 10.5 hours from Miami.
And it's not as if North and South Dakota are small population states with a single flagship University each ... it is four main Universities in the Dakotas: USD, SDSU, UND, NDSU. Indeed, for the best students in North Dakota, the de-facto flagship is the University of Minnesota, through in-state tuition reciprocity between Minnesota and North Dakota.
I drafted about the same post, but since you did, I cut that. Will just add what else I wrote ...
If NDSU and SDSU were closer west and a bit south they'd be in the MWC -- they seem to have most everything else going for them -- but they're not. There are some Montana schools in between, and the MWC isn't after them either. Sorry for them, but geography does matter to two of the mid-major conferences. CUSA (trying to be a "little AAC?") apparently doesn't give a damn, but the Sun Belt and MAC do. And it seems the far-flung MWC does not want to further fling itself.
IMO, those who "like" NDSU look at how
wonderful it would be to have them since they're
so good at football. But
why should the other schools pay higher costs for how good they are? Travel costs include
all sports.
And SDSU too? What about North Dakota and South Dakota? When someone changed conferences, within a couple years they all did. That's how all four ended up in the MVFC and Summit. This ain't Washington-Washington St., Oregon-Oregon St. here. These are small-population states with small-town influence a huge factor.
Yes, UMass is way out East. But they have terrific potential in the top sports, a great location, solid academics and a willingness to put some $ into it. (So is URI, apparently.)
Illinois State would fill a gap in the West, and 1-2 somebodies are needed to fill the gap in the East. Think "bus league" for most members for most sports.
All that said, the current choices are not world-beaters. BUT the MAC has some time to spend.