(08-20-2023 11:27 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (08-20-2023 10:43 PM)JRsec Wrote: (08-20-2023 10:35 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Not sure how trustworthy the source is, but my gut feeling has been that UNC and/or NC State would eventually change their vote and let Stanford and Cal into the ACC.
And what motive would you ascribe to such a change of heart?
No motive or change of heart. I’ve been saying that for the past few days.
To use a comparison of today’s ACC with the Big 12 in 2010, FSU is Nebraska (ready to figure out any way to get out), while UNC is Texas (keeping options open, but still would rather control their own conference). UNC isn’t 2021 Texas yet where they’re resigned that they need to move.
NC State is almost a perfect corollary to Texas Tech - they’re relying on being bonded with big brother, but that may not be a reliable plan for the long-term. NC State has to look at scenarios to ensure that the ACC doesn’t just completely meltdown like the Pac-12 did in the face of defections.
FSU and Clemson aren’t budging on their votes, but I see UNC and NC State as having different motivations and could be swayed.
I find that a reasonable take. We'll see what happens with FSU and Clemson, they take 24.7% of the value of the ACC with them if they go, or about 2% more than USC and UCLA took out of the PAC 12. That will destabilize things to a degree. What the ACC has potentially going for them is that your assessment of North Carolina's desire to leave is dead on I believe.
They've talked with the SEC to keep options open, then voted no initially on these additions to buy some time for Clemson and FSU to think things through. They realize what decision is ahead of them if FSU and Clemson do leave. And their questions will be, "If we stay and focus on basketball and academics, will we have enough to fund the myriad of sports we offer when football goes pay for play? Will we have enough football revenue in a devalued ACC to keep it all afloat? What happens when Miami and Virginia Tech want to leave as well? Do we keep N.C. State with us or let them leave to maximize football revenue? How will the football donors Mack Brown has energized respond to this decision?
Face it Frank once you are past those 4 football first schools most of the rest of the ACC would have more reason to stay together than they would to go. Perhaps Louisville bails, but B.C., Pitt, Syracuse, Virginia, UNC, Duke, Wake Forest, Georgia Tech, Cal and Stanford would have a good deal in common.
Their next question would be, "Will Notre Dame stick around?" My gut feeling is no, because they wanted the football first schools to stay in the ACC in 2011.
I think they know they are safe to play along with this to see how it will work for a few years. The SEC is like their Motel 6, "We'll leave the lights on!" I suspect the Big 10 would as well.
In the meantime, Stanford and Cal would serve as good cover for Florida State and Clemson to go. If Viriginia Tech and Miami stick around perhaps the Irish will as well. The inventory would be the same, the time slots more varied, and rough value of the conference schools top to bottom closer than ever.
It will be one of the more fascinating experiments in all of realignment if this is indeed what UNC decides to do.
BTW: I hate this new spell checker which anticipates the words I want to use. You reread what you have written, and the damned thing has changed your "no" to "now" because that is what it anticipated, and you didn't see it while typing. I'd love to get my hands on the developer that came up with this annoying innovation.