LexColonel
Special Teams

Posts: 563
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 45
I Root For: EKU, Louisville, NAVY
Location: Lexington
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-13-2023 04:01 PM)freshtop Wrote: (07-13-2023 03:32 PM)LexColonel Wrote: (07-13-2023 01:52 PM)whupemall Wrote: (07-13-2023 09:59 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: alphabetical--
THE BEST SIX:
Chatty
Delaware
EKU
Missouri St.
SFA
Tarleton
My personal top two are EKU and SFA. I think everyone here knows the plusses and minuses of both. All I'll add is that, in both cases, they bring existing strong rivalries with them, and that's more important than people seem to realize (or at least be willing to admit) when it comes to a conference identity. SFA is the stronger of the two athletically across the board, but EKU is far ahead of them in both FBS readiness and fan support (in football and basketball).
Delaware and MoSt - These are similar adds. They expand the footprint slightly, and don't have much in the way of existing relationships with any current CUSA members, but both bring some solid intangibles. Both are very strong in multiple sports (men's and women's) and Delaware, especially, brings a very strong fan base (nearly 17K football attendance in 2022). MoSt could work as an East or West addition, while Delaware would obviously be a far East addition. If UTEP/NMSU were to leave, or CUSA just decided to abandon divisions for good, both of these would have to be considered for invitations if the interest is mutual.
Chatty - Jax State and UTC had a nice, bitter rivalry going a few short years ago, and Chattanooga is a fun place to visit, or was the last time I made it up there with the family. I don't see them as a realistic add, though, unless UTEP/NMSU leave and CUSA refocuses on a tight, regional footprint. They don't have a really strong football fan base, even when the team is doing OK (<8K attendance in 2022). Men's hoops is really strong, and they're decent in softball. But they're really awful at a lot of other sports, and they don't sponsor baseball. They're not high on my list at all, but I would have absolutely no objections if they wound up in CUSA. I think they're happy enough in the SoCon they'll never leave, unless SoCon basketball just falls off a cliff or something.
Tarleton - I'm just going to sum this one up in one statement: I don't have enough information to form an opinion. Depending on whom you ask, they're either a bright shining prospect in a fast growing part of Texas, or they're a school in the middle of nowhere desperately trying to put lipstick on a pig. I'll let the league office do its due diligence here and hope they make the right decision either way.
I think this is a bit of stretch, especially in regard to football and men's basketball. Just a quick review, there was not much difference in last year's football teams, except that EKU won one more game than did SFA (includes a 7 overtime win over D1 MAC opponent, BGU). There are other games for comparison by not worth mention, but I believe show that EKU is at the very least equal to SFA.
Basketball: SFA: 19-13 last last year. EKU-23-14 (includes wins against now CUSA members, Jax State, KSU and LIberty). BTW, the entire team returns this year except one lost to graduation.
So, IF the two sports that are touted as most/only important are football and basketball, the statement that "SFA is stonger" is a bit misleading.
Probably means little in the scheme of moving to FBS, (although can't hurt), EKU's athletic director Matt Roan, was recently appointed to the NCAA Div 1 council.
Looking at the last 20 years for basketball.
Men's basketball:
EKU - 9 seasons over .500, 3 NCAA berths.
SFA - 18 seasons over .500, 5 NCAA berths.
In football, neither have had much to write home about the last 20 years.
EKU has 5 playoff appearances with an 0-5 record.
SFA has 4 playoff appearances with a 1-4 record.
EKU has had 13 seasons over .500 in the last 20.
SFA has has 8 seasons over .500 in the last 20.
In football I would give the edge to EKU. In basketball I think SFA has a good bit of separation. I think either would be a good candidate if we need to expand.
I did not say either were world beaters.. over and over again I’ve been told the “ past” means nothing. It’s like statistics, a change in parameters can always make one’s point. Just my opinion.
|
|