(02-08-2021 04:16 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Not exactly sure why anyone would dislike a commercial calling for moderation and not political extremism but that’s where we are, I suppose.
I disliked it because it did a crappy job of "calling for moderation."
Nearly all of the images were of a rural lifestyle. How is that "inclusive" or "moderate?"
Putting a cowboy in Kansas was really odd. Kansas is mostly grain farmers, not ranchers. Farmers don't wear cowboy hats. Was the effeminate cowboy with earrings supposed to be a sign of inclusiveness?
*edit* - I had no idea that was supposed to be someone famous
And the script... the first 3-4 lines showed promise. But the rest was largely either pointless or divisive statements.
What "middle" is "between servant and citizen?" If the servant does not exist to serve the citizen, then he is, by definition, not a servant.
What "middle" is "between our freedom and our fear?" I roundly reject the idea that the two concepts are on the same continuum.
"Freedom is not just the property of the fortunate few; it belongs to us all." - Taken by itself, this is very true. But what does that have to do with anything else in the monologue? How does that explain the "middle" between fear and freedom?
"(The middle) is what connects us." - We are obviously not connected to each other by some geographical "middle." So he must be referring to a common language, culture, and core political beliefs. But liberals strongly disagree with this statement. And libertarians reject the idea as well, preferring to think of us as individuals.
"The very soil we stand on is common ground." - like much of the script, it's a vacuous statement that means nothing.
"We can make it to the mountaintop, through the desert... and we will cross this divide." - What divide is he speaking of? The divide between servant and citizen? The divide between our freedom and our fear? Or is he referring to a political divide? I disagree completely that finding a "middle ground" is something that can be accomplished by a quest. That sort of thinking is counterproductive to finding a solution.
The whole thing came off like a Madison Avenue exec was trying to preach to his idea of what Red America is like.