RE: Portal update
We talk so much about who has left and why and is it Hammock’s fault and does he know what he is doing...So I thought it would be interesting to see a side by side comparison of the positions from the point where Hammock came in after the 2018 season vs. where the roster is right now. Here it is…
QB Then
Childers
Graham
Hall
Ant. Thompson
Wright
QB Now
Lombardi
Fletcher
Rod. Thompson
Hampton
Cassens
Eval: It's extremely likely that there are 3 QB's now that are better than Childers, who was head and shoulders above the rest of his group.
RB Then
Harbison
Nettles
Rowells
Valentine
Jad. Huff
Doke
RB Now
Waylee
Collins
Ducker
Brown
Bolden
Lawson
Gordon
Beiber
Solomon
Eval: The speed the current group has far surpasses the prior group, but we also haven't seen any of them step up and be quite the short yardage bulldozer that Harbison was.
FB Then
Bostad
FB Now
Ratkovich
Bostad
Eval: There really was no FB used in recent years before Hammock and the lone from then is still here now, but Ratkovich if used properly can add a huge dimension for this team as an NFL level FB/H-back. Especially helpful if you look ahead at the TE groups.
TE Then
Brinkman
Crawford
Harmston
Lersch
Brown
DeHaan
Soraghan
Thrower
TE Now
Soraghan
DeHaan
Novotny
Kosin
Mallette
Eval: The TE spot is a total shell compared to what it was. As mentioned above, I expect Ratkovich to be used a lot as an H-Back to offset this, but they have to really hope that Novotny and/or Kosin turn out to be something.
WR Then
Tears
Robinson
Wesley
Tucker
Kokosioulis
Pollack
Mitchell
Segobiano
Brummet
WR Now
Richie
Tucker
Rudolph
Toure
McCray
Travis
Howard
Dozier
Urwiler
Battle
Sikma
Lipscomb
Brueckner
Kelley
Eval: Give me the current group any day and twice on Sundays (Hello Mr. Richie). This is not even close! Robinson is an addition by subtraction since he was a handless black hole and Richie is better than the first group combined on his own. When you don't even have to mention a guy who was an All American as a KR as a true freshman, you know it is on an entirely different level.
OL Then
Veloz
Perez
Patten
Olsen
Cox
Roberts
Hawn
Potter
Webster
Warner
Gueths
Dassow
Schlee
Rozulmowski
Reeves
OL Now
Patten
Cox
Potter
Zschernitz
Champe
Lippe
Engstrand
Rios
Pitcel
Buss
Webster
Vicula
Thompson
Wilty
Hoth
Pinnick
Mackinnon
Schooley
Beyer
Eval: This one is hard for several reasons. 1) Cox, Potter & Patten as holdovers have obviously improved with experience and age. 2) Most of the current group we have not seen yet. That being said, considering what we have seen out of Champe & Zschernitz, and the sheer size of a lot of the guys we haven't seen, as well as the larger number of the group as a whole, I'm of the opinion that the current group will compare really well if we look back in a few more years.
DT Then
Heflin
Kramer
Griffen
Kelly
LeRoy
Hughes
Webster
DT Now
Ester
Griffen
Taylor
Hugunin
Jordan
Haberman
Ontengco
Eval: 2018 group wins easily here. Ester, Griffen and Taylor are good players, but they are not yet at a comparable level to Heflin, LeRoy, Kelley and Kramer. Check back in a few years and it could be a different story, but for now the prior group wins.
DE Then
Lorbeck
Wynne
Denton
Kennedy
Wright
DE Now
Thomas
Oppung
O’Malley
Mattox
Davis
Jennings
Johnson
Williams
Rempel
Brunner
Waskow
Wilson
Eval: Another tough one because the current group is very young and mostly unseen. I think it would be an endless debate between Lorbeck and Wynne vs. Oppong and O'Malley, but the second group are freshmen who have played 6 games thus far...If any of this current group develops at all, that would make it a pretty easy decision.
LB Then
Jones-Davis
Deveaux Jr.
Pugh
Cole
Labus
Gay
Bonds
Gregory
Parker
Harmon
Jennings
LB Now
Pugh
Deveaux Jr.
Cole
Rayner
Rattin
Jackson
Tewes
Kopp
Gay
Appolon
Asuquo
Whitsey
Hamm
Nelson-Douglas
King
Hernandez
Harmon
Parker
Dominguez
Redmond
Eval: 3 of the top 4 are the same guys. Jones-Davis was great, but Rayner is a stud as well. Rattin/Labus are very similar players. Jackson looked decent in his short stints and he is still just learning the position and getting stronger. I've been watching Asuquo down here in TX since he committed and he is GOOD. This is likely going to be a strength of this team going forward just as it has been in the recent past.
Safety Then
Williams
Foster
Smith
Thomas
Earl
Ross
Covington
Safety Now
Hansen
Lafayette
Brown
Dolphin
Ross
Earl
Laffin
Hoffmann
Eval: Lafayette has the potential to be better than Williams, Foster and Smith but he has to actually do get there. The rest of the current group are a serious question mark if they can get to the level of those three guys. Like DT, this is a spot that they really need to have something in these young guys or it is going to be major trouble.
CB Then
Haney
McKie
March
Hall
Harris
Todd
Walker
Rivera
CB Now
Thomas
Gandy
McGee
March
Rogers
Prophete
McGarrell
Kalomo
Byrd
Myles
Jammeh
Lambert
Lacey
Eval: I thought Haney, McKie and Walker all had a lot of potential when they arrived at NIU. Haney and McKie really struggled before they left, but they were young. Walker looked good in his one game before getting hurt. Really these are both groups that are nothing but equal question marks. Bad then and bad now, both with potential to grow. We know how it turned out for most of the first group, they aren't here anymore. The current group needs to pan out much better considering how many CB's have left under Hammock.
Special Teams
Richardson & Ference are the same so really all there is to say is they have gotten better and older and their potential replacements are on the roster in Woodill & Foley. Rudolph is the best returner we have had since TommyLee Lewis. I expect all the speed of the last two classes to be a big benefit on special teams in the future.
|