(01-04-2021 01:44 PM)bullet Wrote: Don't try to read people's minds. You aren't good at it.
I think the basketball tournament is too big. It is 68 out of 350 schools. Nearly 20%.
An 8 team football tourney is 8 out of 130. 6.1%. I think 16 would be too big unless you include all 10 conference champs. And I really don't think all conferences really belong in it.
I am not trying to read minds so to speak. But you simply cannot fit a round peg into a square hole.
Frankly part of the reason that this is so great is that there is a human element to all of it. People love arguing about stuff - especially sports. The publicity is a wet dream for marketing attention.
Again, you seem to have a rise in your pants over the fact that the "committee process" is shady. That is because the odd man out always has a legitimate argument why they should be included instead of the last man in. I watch the Basketball Selection show every year and it is the same thing. The major difference is that they have auto bids but the simple fact is that there is enough room to fit all the conference champs in AND and the teams who are good enough to be there as well. Even with 68 teams the teams on the bubble complain they got screwed.
Football does not have that luxury. There is a finite ceiling as to how many teams you can add to a tournament format and not kill 18-22 year old kids
and keep the regular season meaningful
and not last longer than the NFL season all at the same time. These are still college students.
You will always have outliers regardless of the system. In the human model, TCU a few years back - should have been in the final 4. This year if you use auto bids Oregon is in and they should not be.
Unless you have a 16 team football tournament you are not going to be able to satisfy the vast majority. Anything less than 16 has to omit all FBS conference champs as auto-bids. At least with 16 you have 6 wild cards who will normally be filled out by the remainder of the top 8 ranked teams who are not already in.
I am not arguing against an 8 team tournament, just the methodology by which the participants are chosen. I think 8 is a perfect number. You should be able to weed in the really good team with an outlier loss and reward a team like Cincy who earned a shot AND not let a team in who had no right being there (Oregon).