RE: @theDudeofWV is at it again. 2 of UCF/BYU/USF to the B12.
That $5.6M is all sports for UCF, and it's nice, but not close to enough for P5.
But let's put this in perspective with B12 schools ticket sales (from USAToday)
Texas = $72,457,216
Oklahoma = $42,142,811
West Virginia = $20,222,242
Oklahoma State = $19,679,074
Kansas = $18,957,247
Kansas State = $15,274,064
Iowa State = $14,260,192
Texas Tech = $11,970,439 // JRsec, are you really sure the SEC would consider them?
Baylor and TCU are private so do not report to the source used by USAToday.
Now the top G5 schools
Connecticut = $9,843,615 // Basketball (M & W) is most of this
Memphis = $8,804,547
Cincinnati = $7,420,821
Boise State = $7,378,826
East Carolina = $7,266,784
Houston = $6,551,591
South Florida = $6,071,874
Hawaii = $5,818,333
San Diego State = $5,809,058
New Mexico = $5,802,815
UNLV = $4,865,689
Central Florida = $4,458,254
Wyoming = $4,435,800
Colorado State = $4,231,475
BYU, Rice, Tulane, SMU are private and do not report to USAToday's source.
Nobody else topped $4m. There are some low P5, but these should not be considered the threshold, rather that these are "legacy" schools, falling below $12M in gate, who might not make the cut today were conferences forming again:
Texas Tech = $11,970,439
Georgia Tech = $11,756,425
Arizona State = $10,033,481 // I am sure they bounced back from this lower than normal number
Purdue = $9,222,191
Washington State = $7,656,362
Even so, if you take UConn out of the picture, as a school with exceptional Basketball ticket sales (Memphis, Cincy, New Mexico and SDSU also benefit from that), then only Washington State falls into the range of G5 schools. A similar gap exists in donations.
Texas = $46,019,194
Oklahoma = $45,504,839
West Virginia = $34,599,908
Texas Tech = $25,692,336 // makes up for weak gate
Kansas = $23,042,524 // this is way down, should bounce back $5-8M
Kansas State = $22,154,333
Iowa State = $17,551,225
Oklahoma State = $15,573,414
again there are some bottom P5 schools, everyone else is easily above $15M:
Minnesota = $14,018,855
Maryland = $12,281,532
Georgia Tech = $11,187,993
Oregon State = $9,785,111
Utah = $9,031,413 // unusual in that gate almost doubles donations
Washington State = $8,212,785
Rutgers = $8,125,201
Now the best G5 (number is fairly typical year to year if no comment):
East Carolina = $11,008,954 // surged up 4 years ago
Boise State = $10,328,892
Central Florida = $10,303,140 // surged up 4 years ago, more fluctuation than Houston
Houston = $9,923,994 // surged up 4 years ago, and seems to be holding at a higher level
New Mexico = $9,878,231
Fresno State = $9,601,295 // surged up 3 years ago with Tollner's hiring
Memphis = $9,279,348
San Diego State = $8,826,053
Air Force = $8,705,370
UNLV = $7,661,855
Wyoming = $7,577,090 // fluctuates from $4M to $8M
Connecticut = $5,666,522 // donations have dropped from $10-12M in the Big East days
Hawaii = $4,204,892
Cincinnati = $4,019,074
Colorado State = $3,740,779
South Florida = $2,566,098
Nobody else is above $4M, almost all of the rest of G5 below $3M. South Florida lacks a donation support (Fire the AD, snce his #1 job is fund raising), and I think that pretty much DQs them from B12 expansion. Really poor AI schools eliminated in the B12 Rose ceremony are up on this list (ECU, Boise State, Memphis, New Mexico, Fresno State, UNLV). Again BYU and other privates not reporting, so can't say.
Houston and Central Florida stand out here as being withing striking range of that $15M P5 expectation. They could probably grow into it (So could SDSU, but geography is against them). Not so Cincy and USF. BYU probably is already at the $15M "P5 level", based on their attendance (mentioned below). It's very apparent why UConn gave up on the American, their donations collapsed after the C7 split; if they bounce back to $12M range with Big East entry, the move will pay for itself in just 3 years.
Comments on Gate, Resources:
There is fluctuation in gate (less in donations), but the ranges are very much lower. We don't have readily accessible date from BYU, but football attendance is 56,000 and all the G5 are below 40,000 (mostly around 30-34K), and BYU also gets 14,000 Basketball fans per game. If the ratio of ticket sales to seats in butts is similar then BYU is probably netting well north of $10M in gate (conservatively -- I'd guess closer to $15M than to $10M). There is no doubt donations are a good bit higher there as well -- those with good attendance have good donation levels as well. None of the others is within striking range of the P5 expectation for gate.
From a resource level, regardless of metric, BYU looks like a P5 school, none of the other aspirants for the B12 looks like a P5 school. Certainly some bump would come from moving up, but it would likely take over a decade to get on even standing with the little-8 for those schools with the most growth potential. BYU is the only one ready to go. Houston and UCF have P5 potential. (I'd say the same for New Mexico, Fresno State, Memphis, Boise State and ECU, except AI and location kill them as choices; all need to invest heavily in the school over the athletic department to boost AI before seeking P5 membership -- this is why they did not get a Rose from the B12 in 2016.)
Conclusion
Texas, if they stay (which I think is likely until the LHN runs out in 2031) would be the ultimate decider on whether any school is taken by the B12 to replace Oklahoma. The Florida schools may have the market value, but they are otherwise not acceptable to Texas. Others are even less acceptable to Texas (and probably also with other B12 schools). It pretty much comes down to Texas say thumbs up or down on BYU. Nobody else makes sense. Frankly they might even say no on BYU for travel and T9 concerns.
Note: the resources, support and institutional standing point at three more "next up" after BYU; SDSU (too far west for B12 consideration), Houston and UCF (trajectory is right for these two, base not yet enough for P5). I put these more in the aspirational category. I can't see Texas accepting an aspirational school. But once they leve they would be high on the B12 list.
|