First: 16 teams
Second: seed top eight conference champions
Third: seed the eight at large invitees
Fourth: All first round games at the home field of the conference
champions with 20% of seats available to visiting opponent (home team keeps all proceeds from ticket sales)
Fifth: The last 7 games played at neutral sites.
Sixth: Maintain this system for a minimum of 5 years to allow everyone
to come around to realize this is the most equitable system and
is the one that should have always been in place.
that has been my desire for a while. It makes too much sense, so it'll never be used.
(05-12-2022 03:22 PM)Keeper Wrote: [ -> ]First: 16 teams
Second: seed top eight conference champions
Third: seed the eight at large invitees
Fourth: All first round games at the home field of the conference
champions with 20% of seats available to visiting opponent (home team keeps all proceeds from ticket sales)
Fifth: The last 7 games played at neutral sites.
Sixth: Maintain this system for a minimum of 5 years to allow everyone
to come around to realize this is the most equitable system and
is the one that should have always been in place.
Love it. Will never happen as the "Big Boys" want no part in giving schools like us a chance to compete at that level.
Some posters should not be allowed to start new threads
Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
(05-15-2022 12:41 PM)macgar32 Wrote: [ -> ]Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
Yep-its fair---Georgia should not of lost 2 --and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game--they should have just played better---plus the fixed/fake/rigged rankings are ALWAYS SKEWED in the big boys favor anyway
(05-17-2022 11:26 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ] (05-15-2022 12:41 PM)macgar32 Wrote: [ -> ]Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
Yep-its fair---Georgia should not of lost 2 --and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game--they should have just played better---plus the fixed/fake/rigged rankings are ALWAYS SKEWED in the big boys favor anyway
I guess everyone has an opinion
(05-17-2022 11:26 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ] (05-15-2022 12:41 PM)macgar32 Wrote: [ -> ]Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
Yep-its fair---Georgia should not of lost 2 --and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game--they should have just played better---plus the fixed/fake/rigged rankings are ALWAYS SKEWED in the big boys favor anyway
Agreed, I would go so far as to say no 2 loss team should be in playoffs period, no matter how good the “experts” want to tell us how much they pass the eye test or look good on paper…..if they are fortunate enough to make playoffs they absolutely deserve to be on road regardless of opponent…..but 2 losses should make them Play the B10 or another P4 champ.
(05-17-2022 11:26 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ] (05-15-2022 12:41 PM)macgar32 Wrote: [ -> ]Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
Yep-its fair---Georgia should not of lost 2 --and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game--they should have just played better---plus the fixed/fake/rigged rankings are ALWAYS SKEWED in the big boys favor anyway
Georgia had 1 loss to #3 Alabama and went into the playoff ranked #3 in the country.
Georgia
12-1
1 loss to Alabama, 12-1 and ranked #3 in the country
#3 in the country entering the playoff
Beat 4 ranked teams
Utah State
10-3
Lost to 7-5 Boise at home by 24
Lost to 6-6 Wyoming at home by 27
Lost to 10-3 BYU at home by 14
Your position is that 1 loss Georgia (the eventual national champion btw) did NOT deserve a home game, but 3 blowout loss Utah State DID deserve a home game?
Because Georgia did NOT play well enough to deserve a home game, but Utah State, DID?
I kind of like the idea that if you don’t win your conference, you get a road game. Make Conference Champs really mean something. The P5 already has all the money and the best of everything else. The polls will make sure they can advance more than one team to the tourney. Once the teams are set though, forget the pollsters. I think this would have an impact on recruiting for all the other conferences and I think that would be a great thing. And being a great thing for all the non-P5 tams/conferences would be the reason none of this will ever happen.
(05-18-2022 02:52 PM)Browning Hall Wrote: [ -> ]I kind of like the idea that if you don’t win your conference, you get a road game. Make Conference Champs really mean something. The P5 already has all the money and the best of everything else. The polls will make sure they can advance more than one team to the tourney. Once the teams are set though, forget the pollsters. I think this would have an impact on recruiting for all the other conferences and I think that would be a great thing. And being a great thing for all the non-P5 tams/conferences would be the reason none of this will ever happen.
^^THIS^^--yep-----and the sec/power 5 bootlickers are already pushing back -laughing at (KEEPERS) model
(05-18-2022 03:26 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ]^^THIS^^--yep-----and the sec/power 5 bootlickers are already pushing back -laughing at (KEEPERS) model
It's foolhardly to make light of someones dreams.
(05-18-2022 12:56 PM)Stammers Wrote: [ -> ] (05-17-2022 11:26 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ] (05-15-2022 12:41 PM)macgar32 Wrote: [ -> ]Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
Yep-its fair---Georgia should not of lost 2 --and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game--they should have just played better---plus the fixed/fake/rigged rankings are ALWAYS SKEWED in the big boys favor anyway
Georgia had 1 loss to #3 Alabama and went into the playoff ranked #3 in the country.
Georgia
12-1
1 loss to Alabama, 12-1 and ranked #3 in the country
#3 in the country entering the playoff
Beat 4 ranked teams
Utah State
10-3
Lost to 7-5 Boise at home by 24
Lost to 6-6 Wyoming at home by 27
Lost to 10-3 BYU at home by 14
Your position is that 1 loss Georgia (the eventual national champion btw) did NOT deserve a home game, but 3 blowout loss Utah State DID deserve a home game?
Because Georgia did NOT play well enough to deserve a home game, but Utah State, DID?
If the NCAA controlled college football, this would have a chance. However, the top conferences control college football, so no way this ever happens.
I will add, that if every conference champ got a guaranteed bid and a home game, that would be the end of conference championship games.
Thus ... no more Lulu & Junior!
https://www.luluandjunior.com/
(05-18-2022 02:01 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ] (05-18-2022 12:56 PM)Stammers Wrote: [ -> ] (05-17-2022 11:26 PM)jsw3ent Wrote: [ -> ] (05-15-2022 12:41 PM)macgar32 Wrote: [ -> ]Is it fair...
That 2 loss Georgia ranked in the top 5 should have to play at the Cusa home field
Yep-its fair---Georgia should not of lost 2 --and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game--they should have just played better---plus the fixed/fake/rigged rankings are ALWAYS SKEWED in the big boys favor anyway
Georgia had 1 loss to #3 Alabama and went into the playoff ranked #3 in the country.
Georgia
12-1
1 loss to Alabama, 12-1 and ranked #3 in the country
#3 in the country entering the playoff
Beat 4 ranked teams
Utah State
10-3
Lost to 7-5 Boise at home by 24
Lost to 6-6 Wyoming at home by 27
Lost to 10-3 BYU at home by 14
Your position is that 1 loss Georgia (the eventual national champion btw) did NOT deserve a home game, but 3 blowout loss Utah State DID deserve a home game?
Because Georgia did NOT play well enough to deserve a home game, but Utah State, DID?
Based on the OP'S (KEEPER) idea on what the playoffs should be ------absolutely ----Georgia would have known the rules and criteria ---they should have played better and won their conference if they wanted to host a home game !
They played better than every single school in the country except two. Utah State would have been 4-9 playing their schedule. If it was the NCAA basketball tournament, it would have been a #11 seed playing a home game against a #1 seed. Super fair.
Everyone gets a trophy.